Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

reading or listening nitnem

reading or listening nitnem

sarbloh · 18 Jul 2006

Wahegurujeekakhalsa Wahegurujeekeefateh Does one need to read the 5 banis of the nitnem or can one just listen through a player or a computer? In case of Naam,one needs to japp and then listen.But can the same be said of gurbani?Does reading and listening gives more benefit that just listening?? Wahegurujeekakhalsa Wahegurujeekeefateh

Re: reading or listening nitnem

singh · 18 Jul 2006

both are the exact saem, as long as you hear it in your mind. we must also follow them (manniye)

Re: reading or listening nitnem

sarbloh · 22 Jul 2006

Anyone else?

Re: reading or listening nitnem

........ · 23 Jul 2006

fatehjee, i think reading and listening has a big benefit as you know how to pronounce the the panj baniya better, because the audio may be clear. yeh in a way they do both seem the same dont they? its a difficult question really. fatehjee

Re: reading or listening nitnem

Gurpreet Singh · 23 Jul 2006

I believe there is much more laha for the average person if they say and then listen to themselves.

Re: reading or listening nitnem

Gurpreet Singh · 23 Jul 2006

http://thepanthicotpreka.blogspot.com/2006/07/clarification-from-earlier-comment.html Clarification From an Earlier Comment 'Suntay Puneet, Kehtay Pavit' Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa, Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh, A while back someone on the blog made a comment that 'Suntay Puneet, Kehtay Pavit' from Anand Sahib means that we can just listen to bani inside of reciting it. I had posted the opposite. I have done some research on 'Suntay Puneet, Kehtay Pavit', and I disagree with the person that says we can just listen to bani. Let me first start of with a katha I heard. Limited knowledge is a very dangerous thing. If we just look at bani with our limited scop it is very easy to take the wrong arth (meaning) from it. For example, someone is told to dig a hole at a certain spot in order to get water. The person digs and digs, he digs 4 feet under the earth and gives up. He returns angry to the person who told him to dig, and says why did you tell me to dig there, there is no water. But little does this person know, the water is not 4 feet under the earth, it is 15 feet under the earth, he just didn't go deep enough. In the same way most of us don't go deep enough into gurbani, to get the proper arth, we just take watever first comes into our mind, in order to make bani fit our preconvieved notions. Now back to 'Suntay Puneet, Kahtey Pavit'. 'Suntay Puneet' does not mean that you become 'puneet' by listening to an mp3 recording of your nitnem. 'Suntay Puneet' means that you become 'puneet' by listening, meaning applying to yourself what you recite each morning in your nitnem. Another example I was given while trying to look deeper into this tuk was, 'pavitar pavitar pavitar puneet' from Sukhmani Sahib. One arth of this could be, 3 times Pavitar is 1 time Puneet. So from 'Suntay Puneet, Kehtay Pavit' ... When you recite bani with you mouth you are 1 time pavit, but when you recite bani with your mouth, and than you listen to it, you apply it to yourself and act on it, than you are 3 times pavit. In conclusion, listening to a mp3 recording of bani is good. But there is nothing like reciting bani with your mouth, and than listening to what you have said with your own ears, and than acting upon it in your daily life. If I have made any mistakes in this translation, I ask for forgiveness, as I am not perfect, nor am I someone worthy of asking arths of bani from. Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa, Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh

Re: reading or listening nitnem

Satnam · 24 Jul 2006

sunathae puneeth kehathae pavith sathigur rehiaa bharapoorae || Puneeth is bigger than pavith, that means listening is more powerfull than reading. We should do both at same time, read with tongue and listen with our ears, so we get pavith and puneet both at same time. Pure are those who speak, and pure are those who listen; those who enshrine it within their minds are pure. Says Nanak, listen to the Ambrosial Naam and become holy; you were created only to hear the Truth. ||37||

Re: reading or listening nitnem

.......................... · 24 Jul 2006

Vaheguru ji ka khalsa Vaheguru ji ki fateh , saad sangat ji i think that both reading and listening to nitnem are both fine as long as you concentrate on either one. Just remember keep japping naam. VAHEGURU!!! Vaheguru ji ka khalsa Vaheguru ji ki fateh

Re: reading or listening nitnem

5vikaari-no amritvela manmukh · 25 Jul 2006

I use to do this, the reason why I stopped was because I knew it was my mind that was being too damn lazy, and since I had it memorized I would just walk around and do my nitnem but words were coming out of my mouth but I only picked up a line or two and its message, I know its hard, but you have to control your mind and make it sit at one place because its like a kutte dee pooch, that wags and we as its master have to own it and not let it run you around with a leash. When I use to listen on the computer I found myself logging onto this forum and others to see what was happening and the gurbani was playing on the back of my mind, chalo rehat wise I think its better to sit at one place ik man ik chit and recite gurbani. My two cents/