Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Taksali questions

Taksali questions

HSingh · 19 Jul 2006

waheguroo ji ka khalsa waheguroo ji ki fateh! Daas was talking to a veerji who belongs to the damdami taksal. and he asked me that "when you (jathe wale) do saas giraas naam jaap why do you jump around and move your heads, isnt this the same like dancing and beadhbi of guru sahib." daas said that its not in our hands what we do during this time "jio too chalawe tiv chalai suamee" its all in his hands we are just puppets. daas also said that i will do more khoj because i only know a little. Then he also asked that when you do naam jaap why are non amritdharis not allowed to participate. So daas is asking his brothers and sisters for their opinion. [%sig%]

Re: Taksali questions

HSingh · 19 Jul 2006

anyone

Re: Taksali questions

S Singh · 19 Jul 2006

Saas Giraas Simran is not just a Jatha thing. Saas Giraas Simran was the method also used by other great Sikh mystics such as Sant Attar Singh Mastuanaywalay, Sant Ishar Singh Jee Raraywalay. Furthermore, Saas Giraas is also mentioned in some puraatan rehetnamay such as Prem Sumarag Granth.

Re: Taksali questions

singh · 19 Jul 2006

I would say for sure that our Taksali Veers would see Jatha Singhs as crazy people. The Bhagats in Gurbani have talked about how their Naam Simran makes them look like madmen to others, but only the true Naam Abhiasee knows what it tastes like. Our Taksali Veers do more Abhias on Gurbani and less Naam Jaap. For this reason, they may not experience the effect of Naam. I encourage all Taksali Veers to Get Naam Drirta and make your lifetime fruitful. On the 2nd question, how can those who have not traded their head for Naam join in Naam Abhiaas? Until we have received blessing of Amrit, we are not in the slightest able to Jap Naam. Naam is given as a gift to us by Guru Ji - it is not just assumed. Only once you have the gift of Naam from guru Ji will you be able to Jap this Naam. Sometimes I am amazed how Taksalis Veers manage to not understand such concepts given how much Gurbani they read. This is all very clearly written in Gurbani many times over. Hope this helps to some degree.

Re: Taksali questions

singh · 19 Jul 2006

ssingh you missed the point...dont get defensive...the guy didnt say that it was wrong, just asked why AKJ's move a lot when they do simran...he didnt attack the simran...

Re: Taksali questions

:-) · 19 Jul 2006

Firstly, panj piaray STRICTLY give hukam not to do saas giraas in sangat who have not had naam drirh. Secondly regarding, the jumping around, etc......if one does saas giraas as taught by the panj piaaray, then no such extreme movements occur. In fact, saas giraas is a way of doing naam abhiyaas in so much sehaj...one's body may vibrate, however for one to jump around is not correct. You only have to listen carefully and watch the panj piaray's in order to follow their bachan...the rest will follow.

Re: Taksali questions

HSingh · 20 Jul 2006

Veerg "S Singh" the guy asked that why do you people nodd your heads is it not the same as dancing. and he also asked that why are non-amritdharis not allowed to participate. [%sig%]

Re: Taksali questions

anon · 20 Jul 2006

bhai sahib not all saas giraasi's nod there heads or "bop", alot of people do it on purpose, alot of people dont even knw they are doing it. alot of people make small movements alot of people go over the top. important thing is we dont know how they are feeling, they could sooo absorbed in naam and cant help it. even das cant help sometimes tho the movements are only minor. what you will notice is that the real sants are very absorbed in naam and they dnt make a single movement! they are oblivious to the environment, you can speak or touch them and they will not know of it. they are really in chardi kala. but tis not a jatha thing, to say all akjers "dance" is wrong cos they dont. das believes small movements are ok, its natural tho eventually alot of these movements will just stop automatically as you progress. non amritdharis do not know saas giraas, if they heard saas giraas they would not understnd it and would most likely get freaked out. besides only panj pyareh in amrit sanchar can teach saas giraas and no1 can go n teach someone sitting in darbar sahib how to do it, just so they can join in or understand what is going on. the saas giraas ideally should not be shown in public purely for the reason that other will freak out and it will effect their concentration. all mahapurshs regardless of jatha are gifted with saas giraas, waheguru himself blesses them. some people just have like a kick start if you like.

Re: Taksali questions

S Singh · 20 Jul 2006

The nodding of the head from side to side is not part of Saas Giraas Simran. I think what your friends are refering to is the way some AKJ youths swing there heads during kirtan dhuni. I beleive that trend was started during SDO's time and has now become part of the Jatha culture. Personally I dont agree with it because I dont think that the method to Japping Naam is swinging ones head from side to side.

Re: Taksali questions

singh · 21 Jul 2006

well if thres a non-amrirtdary singh, wouldn't him doing saas giras bring him closer to sikhi and make him want to take amrit? before i took amrit i did saas giras and it made me into a better person (i believe) and made me want to take amrit. if we do not allow non-amritdarys to join us in this amazing expereince, what will bring them into sikhi and what will make them take amrit?

Re: Taksali questions

Taksali Singh · 21 Jul 2006

These questions seem very odd coming from a "taksali". A major misconception is that only Akj wale Singhs/Singhnia do saas giraas. Infact, this technique is used across the sikhi spectrum. Even many Taksali Singhs use this technique. Also, the second question seems even more "odd" coming from someone claiming to be a Taksali. Taksalis have no prohibition on doing simran/naam abhiyaas with non-amritdharis. Simran is acceptable to be done with people having the same mindset of prema-bhagati (loving devotion). Also keep in mind sangat ji, one person claiming to be 'taksali' does not by default represent all of taksal. There are many youth out there who don't understand all that Taksal believes in, but still consider themselves taksali. They aren't wrong, but their views can't be viewed as strictly 'taksali'.

Re: Taksali questions

... · 21 Jul 2006

Theres fanatics all over the place. In my opinion you should not force anything on anyone. For example when I was younger, I went to a temple where the granthi was literally crying after a katha vachak did katha at that temple. I don't think it should be that hardcord; and that in my opinion is not what religion should be about.