Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Why didn't all the Punjabis became Sikhs ?

Why didn't all the Punjabis became Sikhs ?

Sikhi · 21 Jul 2006

I always wonder this. We can not compare our faith with that of the others because Sikhi is "only" 300 years old. But wasn't it the faith of every punjabi to become a Sikh? The tharti of Punjab is that of the Guru Sahibaans. I think that if all the punjabis had become Sikhs, Pakistan wouldn't excist today. I think Punjab would be a seperate state.

Re: Why didn't all the Punjabis became Sikhs ?

**- · 22 Jul 2006

Becasue not everyone is a Robot. People have their own views and thoughts etc and therefore Sikhi is not for them. Punjab is not just the thatrti of the Guru Sahibaans but also many other peers/Rishis etc...You should not be so narrow minded and expect everyone to follow what u believe in...U are no different from a Fundo muslim

Re: Why didn't all the Punjabis became Sikhs ?

S Singh · 22 Jul 2006

The reason Sikhism did not spread all over Punjab is because Sikhs have faced severe persecution. To be a Sikh was considered a crime punishable by death. As a result the Sikhs never numbered more than 10-15% of the total population of Punjab. Furthermore, since the Sikhs were at a life and death struggle, they had absolutely no time to do Parchar to the masses and bring them into the Sikhs fold. Finally when the Sikhs stopped all foreign invasions, they began living a very worldly and materialistic life as opposed to a very spiritual life which they were living during the early Misl period. Sikh sardars began eating meat, watching Muslim dance girls for entertainment. For some strange reason, persecution makes Sikhs more spiritual and have more discipline in maryadha. Even though Sikhs started becoming more wordly during Raja Ranjit Singh's period, Sikhism did grow very much in Punjab. But unfortunately the new converts had all reverted back to either Islam or Hinduim when the British took over. So the Sikhs were again on the decline and eventually grew to an all time low of less than 10% of Punjab's total Population. The Sikh Sabha stopped this decline and brought back much of the Hindu population of central Punjab into the Sikh fold. But unfortunately the Singh Sabha was also contending with the Arya Samaj movement because of which Sikhs were unable to attract many of the Hindu Khatri's and Brahmans of Punjab who came under the influence of Arya Samaj. Currently most Sikhs are Monay (hair cutters). This Patit-puna has eroded much of Sikhism from the face of Punjab. Sikhs need parchar now more than ever. Fake Guru cults such as Radha Swamis, and Sant cults are making huge gains all over North India and in particular the Punjab at the expense of the Sikh Panth.

Re: Why didn't all the Punjabis became Sikhs ?

lakhi jungle never 4get · 22 Jul 2006

why dont all the supposed sikhs blessed with sikh families become sikhs first? you hear the struggles of early day sikhs coming from hindu families such as rajput princess sundri becoming a sikh and then dieing for her sikhi, and bijai singhs struggles with his hindu family. These stories tell us what those faced the pressure from their own families as well as the brunt of the moghuls. Today there are no moghuls, supposed sikhs from sikh families do not have family pressures to stick with hindu or muslim customs in theor families. So first we should ask ourselves whats wrong with us? then we should ask what can we do for the lost youth? pakistan punjab could have stayed a number of ways out of muslim hands but that would only dig us more holes when we blame each others shortfalls. The deeper the pit is for us, the longer the ladder gets to climb, now its a case of step 1 before step 10.

Re: Why didn't all the Punjabis became Sikhs ?

Dalbir · 22 Jul 2006

I think by the time Sikhi was born, half of the Punjab had converted to Islam. In any society there are conservatives who do not like change, this is represented by the Hindu Punjabis. Then there are those who sail in both ships and are unwilling to make a complete break from the past but in some way are attracted to the new thing, i.e. sanatanists. Only a few people really absorbed the radical message of Sikhi fully I guess and it is those Singhs we read about, who made our history by striking out bravely in a new direction.

Re: Why didn't all the Punjabis became Sikhs ?

sarbloh · 22 Jul 2006

Its all about karams.People in punjab or for that matter india dint deserve sikhi as a whole.It was just mauj or daya or Satguru Nanak to have come to this part of the globe to start the TRUE PANTH. I have lived most of my life in india and people here are so much engrossed in double standards,corruption,jealousy,selfishness,useless rituals,hypocrisy.People in this part of the globe are very low on conscious or zameer and hence dont/dint deserve to be sikhs.

Re: Why didn't all the Punjabis became Sikhs ?

Mokham · 23 Jul 2006

by the time of the rise of the Sikh Misls Punjab which was originally both Buddhist and Hindu had become about half Muslim The rise of the Misls also indirectly led to the rise fo tribalism and blood connections and politics Therefore we see the prevelance of certain castes amongst the Sikhs in Punjab and others amongst the Hindus More groups were absorbed during the time of Ranjit Singh and many who sat in both fences came under the fold during the British times although the divisions between Hindus and Sikhs have increased since this time in the last 100 odd years

Re: Why didn't all the Punjabis became Sikhs ?

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 23 Jul 2006

not necessary....heck even Guru nanak jis FAMILY didnt become SIKH..ONLY His Sister Bebe nanaki had full faith in him. No body else in His Village either..only Bhai mardana Ji... Gursikhi is the Way of LOVE..PREM..that cannot be forced, coerced..but must come from WITHIN..Jin PREM kiyo tin PRABH Paiyo... Even now some BORN SIKHS are LEAVING..and others born elsewhere are COMING IN.. what a "boring" world IF each and every of the 6 BILLION humans are all Banna wearing SIKHS...then "Ethiopian Sikhs" would be fighting "Somailan Sikhs"..and Ugandan Sikhs would be genoiciding Rawandan Sikhs...this si REALITY !!! Race/Economics/Politics over rides religion...any where and every where.. Exactly what Aurenga trieds to convice Guur teg Bahadur Ji...and Guru ji replied..NO instead of ONE.(ISLAM ONLY) .there will be THREE..Guru Khalsa panth...in aditon to islam and Hindus...Guru ji didnt say there will be ONLY KHALSA !!