doaba/maja/malwa
dr dre · 22 Jul 2006
why dont some sikhs marry from other areas ie malwa and doaba?
Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton
ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥
dr dre · 22 Jul 2006
why dont some sikhs marry from other areas ie malwa and doaba?innit dude · 22 Jul 2006
majhas and doabs do intermarry sometimes. malwais maybe unheard but i have heard of some malwa majha marriages nowdays. But arrangd its true there is a divide. Happned to me 3 months ago, one of our family friends from malwa was going to sangrur for a trip, and wanted to find me a bride from there, when he introduced me to his other friend. The first question his friend asked whether i am from their zila or from outside. When our family friend said i am from outside ( rural guriy bara pind to be exact) the other mans face changed, but the family friend cut in and said we should not even think about such things about this side that side. With myself i am not too worried, but i have experienced it a few times, and i think we will change things ouside as a lot of us are now migrating outside. We do not have the hang ups like our fathers did.S Singh · 22 Jul 2006
These things should not matter. If people want to feel different based on geographical locations, then that is there choice. In 1 or 2 generations, these differences will be all gone.Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 23 Jul 2006
Author: S Singh Date: 07-22-06 09:12 These things should not matter. If people want to feel different based on geographical locations, then that is there choice. In 1 or 2 generations, these differences will be all gone. ??????????????????????? I sure hope so....have been hearing the same thing for four generations already...from majha doaba malwa we now have malaysain singaporean aussie canadian yogi and american goray afro american kenyan tarkahn ravidassia jatt sikhs etcRandip Singh Johal · 23 Jul 2006
These things DO matter. At the end of the day while according to Sikhism everyone is free to marry whom they want regardless of caste,religious,racial,creed differences it is not mandatory to marry someone of a different creed,race,religion,caste. The choice still comes down to parents. The Gurus themselves married only into their Khatri caste. If there are Jatts who only want to marry into Jatts then that's fine. If they are particular about marrying into Malwa or Doaba only then that's fine too. These types of things only apply in cases where the marriage is arranged with parents having the final say. Parents want the best for their children. Reasons for them wanting to marry only amongst the same caste or their region include: If a Jatt married a Tharkan. What would their families have in common to talk about? One would talk about living in the pind, farming, warriorism while the other would talk about carpentry. If a Doabia married a Malwai everytime the Malwai said 'jwaak' the Doabia wouldn't know what he's talking about. Everytime the Doabia said 'paji' instead of bhy (22) the Malwai would be thrown off. There are other differences between Malwa,Majha and Doaba besides dialects. Malwa and Majha have good landholdings amongst Jatts while Doaba has small landholdings regardless of caste. Doaba is a region where everyone is just getting ready to leave for abroad if they already haven't left. The Majha region is also a lot more religiously conservative then either Malwa or Doaba.PTE SINGH · 24 Jul 2006
Thats just down to personal choice, not any sort of irrational predjudice and nor is it cultural taboo to marry some one from a different area. Many people in the UK choose not to marry people from up north or vice versa, simply because therr are cultural differences and the impracticality of traveling, this is also the case in Punjab. Malwais do things differntly to those from Doaba, they speak differently and have different customs. Each to their own i sayHarcharan Singh · 24 Jul 2006
"If a Jatt married a Tharkan. What would their families have in common to talk about? One would talk about living in the pind, farming, warriorism while the other would talk about carpentry." Randip Ji, With all due respect you should refrain from making such silly, ignorent and childish comments. That is like saying if we take "caste" out of the equation, what would Jatt and a Tarkhan have to talk about? What did the Panj Pyare have in common to talk about, were they not from 5 different castes? In the UK today, I know many "Jatt" who are now mistry, in fact most of the immigrants that come here end up labouring for building firms. There are also many that have set up their own carpentry, plumbing, electrician and building businesses. Same way I know of many "Tarkhan" who own land and manage commercial crop production in Punjab. Both live pinds and Sher, so not sure why you mentioned this difference. This is a Sikh website, Admin, usual are letting anti-gurmat posts through even though they are now supposed to have strict team and processes. What would different castes have to talk about? Their ego based differences. What would Khalsa have to talk about, their ONE caste bestowed by Dasmai Patshaah, Warriorism, Kirtan, Simran, Shaheediyan, Dasvandh, Nishkaam Seva, Politics, Shaster Vidya, Gurpurb, Santhia, Kathaa, Sikh personalities, unity of mankind, Janam Sakhiyan, improving, contributing to and sponsoring Sikh education, other religions (comparively).......I think you get the message. You are right, people are free to make their choices, but the underlying factor for a decision should be "is the other family Gurmukh", not "is the family our jaath paath, Pind, ecomomic status"... Obviously this applies to "SIKHS", caste loving Punjabis are free to do what they like. Vaheguru.avtar ghuman · 24 Jul 2006
why has caste entered this topic? it has nothing to do with a malwa and doaba majha. Its not a uqestion of rights of choice. Its a question of whether one is a sikh, following the definitive of a learner sikh, a sikh learner disciple of his guru . Whether that sikh is following akhal takhats divine order on the issue, what gurmat states, what sikh history and its instituitions hold and the very creation of khalsa and the commands given by guru gobind singh rehetname. Guru gobind singh was born outside punjab, in bihar patna sahib, where did guru jies wife come from? It certainly is not mandatory to marry a person of a differenmt descent , but it is also not mandatory to marry someone of the same occupational caste, race either or to be told/coerced persuaded to by elders. The choice lies with the individual, and today as more and more divorces take place in the arranged and love marriages people are choosing whats best for themselves. Parents i am sorry to say do not always know what is best, especially if those parents are not even following the basics of rehat. However the best guidance one can have on such issue would be the panj piare, sadh sangat ( true sadh sangat) and sri guru granth sahib ji. If one took it the way randip singh ji says then we are virtually from all over the shot both as sikhs and if one is todays version of a jatt that too. Early day sikhs came from far and near, afghanistan, delhi, kabul, sirsa, rajistan, hariana, lahore and malwa. people evolve constantly whether one was a jatt washerman, canadian american midlander londoner. My rishta has been organised by the saadh sangat, i am a train driver, she is a global banker, i am in london she is from new york though she is a different caste that was not even considered or asked for by either side. yes it is a personal choice to marry wherever one wants works both ways.kaur · 24 Jul 2006
lets hold a survey amongst kaurs and singhs of the world the naujwan peeri. ask rehtwale gurmukhs if they would consider the caste of their prospective spouse. and ibet you they would not if they are serious about sikhi.Nav Singh · 24 Jul 2006
"If a Jatt married a Tharkan. What would their families have in common to talk about?" If a Chinese person married a white American what would their families have to talk about? If an African-American married a Latino what would their families have to talk about? What a ridiculous objection. Newsflash for Mr. Johal: people from different backgrounds do get married and their families have a lot to talk about.Randip Singh Johal · 24 Jul 2006
Newsflash Nav Singh: The topic is about Sikhs not about Chinese, Blacks and Whites getting married. People are free to marry whomever they want. There are also those who trust their parents enough to have them arrange their marriage. The parents have full rights to marry their kids to whom they feel is a good match. Everyone wants the best for their kids. They are not obligated to cross regional (majha,doaba,malwa),caste,creed,racial,religious boundries in doing so. It is perfectly alright for them to have a preference to only marry amongst their own kind (different subcaste/gotra of course). This does not go against Sikhism. The Gurus themselves only married amongst Khatris. That is our shining example.singh · 25 Jul 2006
ok here goes my family are not from a big high class. and we come from punjab with marital links spanning doabe ludhiana patiala (malwuah) delhi jammu dehra doon rishikesh and jodhpur. We are the same religion and the marriages get on very well. Language at first is a minor barrier, this however requires both sides adjusting a little, and where say the majority speak a doabi dialect the ludhiana speaker will slowly pick up and fit in and speak whatever the others say. In dehra doon they are punjabi speakers, but with a hint of hindi, again my father is from dd married my mother from doab and both moved to uk, he surrounded by doabs speaks doab. Its no big deal, both sides just fit in around each other. The in laws get on very well, as both sides adjust to eacvh other with respect. Its a different world when people just do not care where you are born, from city or from a rural outset, relatives embracing from different areas its a feel that not many in the world get to share, and its beautiful amongst sikhs. Its like a fluid thing, we make efforts with each other and out of thousands of rishtedars in england alone i can only think of one divorce and that too a devious punjabi fellow who married for entry purpose.singh · 25 Jul 2006
its not always about trust either randip singh ji. People nowdays just wish to make their own choices, others through friends, others relatives and some with family . We have the right and more options to choose from. Most of the time even parents will do their background checks if say a friend introduces us to another person and parents are chilled. It does not mean if the parent does not fix us they are against, they can be happy when they are happy with the other family. But we do have a problem where people venture out of religion, what do you expect with the dark ugly side of punjabi culture? Parents who drink smoke eat meat believe in paatjaatpoona, treat their son different from their daughter, do not read gurbani as their guru guide and do not look after the spiritual health of themselves or their children are not in a position of right to make a life choice for another human being as their choice will be based upon individual matt as opposed to guru jis matt. Drinking intoxicats the senses, meat increases lust and ego, caste increases humai which in turn leaves one stuck in maya more, and gender bashing inflicts a life of hell more so on a female. It is a good deed to raise a person on this earth, ultimatly god is the giver. God is the taker. However raising a child does not mean we go and marry our son to a chunni wearer wagainst his wishes when he wants dastaar, or a daughter to a drinker. There are parameters between sikhi and punjabi culture. Parents can only act in the best interests of their offspring when they first give up vices that reduce their clarity and vision to a cloud of maya. When they think out of the punjab box and apply sikhi, this will water the seeds of the future. The seeds will thus bloom, and maybe no more divorce cases. Most parents want whats best for their child so they nowday let them choose. But there are some parent who make wrong choices for their own family pride and honour. Let me tell you my best friends sister was looking to marry. Her parents found it hard because she had back pain. Then she got older, the father said she must marry in caste come what may. The girl had soul search, decided to wear from patka to dastaar. The father in desperate measure set her up with a mona from india. As time progresedd mona demanded she take off dastaar she did. It did not work out, but the things people will do for this honour can complicate issues with gurmat. Some work out some do not. but facts common sense and increased independance mean we have the choice to make qualified decisions based on our understandings, and these increase further with sikhi. Punjabiat is good, but where it conflicts it is not good. Yes guru jis married within sodhis and bedis, theres nothing wrong to marry who you want. Guru sahib also created the khalsa, enshrined equality, and hukams have been passed on the marriage issue through akhal takhat. In my opinion if sikhs really followed gurmat to the real, there would be no culture clashes just sikhs everywhere enjoining together. To make differences s to fuel ego. Ego is number one dushman. Shoes seva will help us cleanse our minds from haumai bhai sahib. where you live?Satnam · 26 Jul 2006
This is same like Ireland, Scotland and England. Majority of them are white and christians but they have diffrent styles and habbits. Majha , Doaba , Malwa people are punjabi, same race, color, but diffrent styles and habbits. If people from these areas are Amritdhari , then they will have lot of things common as commmon Guru,Religion, food, habbit of Naam Jap and Nitnem etc. These people will have least diffrences. For Non amritdhari, they can have diffrent Gurus,Religion, Food, Hobbies etc. So these people can have diffrences. Any way in general, Majha people are famous for being warriors. Doaba People are Famous for being well educated ,smart and well organized people. Malwa area was backward since there was not much water in the earth and people were poor, but Guru Gobind Singh jee gave blessing to Malwa by remaining most of their life time in Malwa and created lots of Gursikhs, Sant Mahapurakhs in this area. Malwa is also famous for creating lots of jathedars and Akali leaders. To me all Majha, Malwa and Doaba people are cool.kichkeh boli paow · 28 Jul 2006
human nature when humans have a rough ride in life they stick together content respect each other and fight together for each other when they get everything on a plate the time and energy to devote to development gets misguided and make differences. ask those malwa doaba majha people who live life on the rough edge if this matters to them? ask shaheed sikh parivars if this matters to them what regionm a fellow sikh came from? through bhai sahib randhir singhs jis writings try to gather up through bhai sahibs thought on paper how he would have felt about this. Seek guru gobind singh jis grace and understanding upon this born in bihar come to punjab, his panj piare from different parts of india his disciples from all over. seek the understanding of great sikhs from past and those with kamaiya around us. You will see the more gian sikhs have the more they are attund to God and see things vry different from us. People with no or less kamaiya do not have gian upon acceptance and thus border themselves off from each other, this is relevant to most punjabis abstaining from sikhi. They will have this small amount of respect for sikhs but they refuse to follow the message. Until you follow the message you will not be able to taste its sweetness. This is a sikh website not a punjabi one. We maybe majority punjabi sikhs but practically speaking when the rd is one path its fine when the rd splits off into sikhi and punjabi history and culture what way would a sikh choose? if the sikh chooses the punjabi rd will it aid his or her journey to sach khand? will it help us reach higher to the next level? will it increase truth on earth?J.A.T.T · 28 Jul 2006
I am sorry to say this, but I think this whole issue is stupid! It's like saying a person from New York wouldn't marry someone from Detroit because how they speak English even though they’re from the east coast and live in a same country.all 4 1 · 31 Jul 2006
a sikh is not bound or limited by region country or tribe. He is a universal spirit. The differences sikhs have amongst themselves are purely their own weaknesses, inability to adapt to the environment around them whilst upholding gurmat. They can sacrifice their hair, khalsa intitiation and history yet they cannot part with their biases and divisions. egos has outlived their spiritual nature. sikhs are stuck in a backward culture pit that does not evolve, sikhi allows the mechanisim to evolve around kaal whilst staying in its complete prsitine form and glory. Loosers will never want to feel change understand it or change for the better. The sikh religion is for the better, in 1699 the khattris and brahmins once refused to take amrit as their lower caste counterparts would have became equal and became lost. Today we are like those brahmins in 1699 who walked away and build walls cutting from other human beings. This is most ironic amongst sikhs when we share the same history culture and goals ahead.