Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Amrit Shakna- all too easy?

Amrit Shakna- all too easy?

UK Singh · 23 Apr 2004

Do you guys think that it is becoming too easy for anyone to enter into the Khalsa Fold? Many take amrit because they may have overheard a Sant asking everyone in the Sangat to give their head to the Guru (not very realistic), become all religious for a short lived time due to a flash of inspiration by listening to Katha or they may have been forced to partake through peer pressure or parents. Unfortunately, people are not always prepared and have not sat any exams or tests to see of they are worthy of Amrit...including myself I might add! Due to people making the wrong decision or not having performed any amount of introspection, many end up trapped in a feeling of guilt if they cannot keep rehit. Other perform the ultimate sin of Kurehits, sufficient to nullify Amrit. Sant cheley and even some youth after Sikhi camps. When the security of Sangat disappears it is easy to fall back into bad habits. So the question arises...how can any new initiates prepare themselves and should the Panj Piyare set rigid tests for hopefuls before the Ultimate goal of giving a head?

Re: Amrit Shakna- all too easy?

kar kirpaa sab rayN thheevaa(n · 26 Apr 2004

VAAHEGUROOJEEKAAKHAALSAAVAAHEGUROOJEEKEEFATHEH!!! I wish somebody tested me when i took amrit. I toooootttttttaaaaaaallllllllyyyyy didn't deserve amrit. People ALMOST BEG others to take amrit. It's not worth it. You have to meet up to the standars or at least REALLY BE WILLING TO GIVE YOUR HEAD TO GURU GOBIND SINGH JI... It's not a joke. I think when I took amrit, I know I didn't take it as a joke - but I should have been more serious. anyway I totally think that at least the abhilaakhee shouldn't fool his/herself into thinking that just by putting 5 k's on you're ready The real ready is - Are you really honestly surely 100% ready to give your head to the Guru, that's it. No other test - nothing else, that's how simple it is. Can you give your head? anyway i talk to much bhul chuk maaf karnaa VAAHEGUROOJEEKAAKHAALSAAVAAHEGUROOJEEKEEFATHEH!!!

Re: Amrit Shakna- all too easy?

Mkhalsa · 26 Apr 2004

We need to go back to testing. We are all about quantity over quality now and if one jatha started doing hard testing over another jatha, that jathas numbers would dwindle because people would start saying things or trying to avoid that amrit sanchar which is totall kaljugy. We should make it stricter at least.

Re: Amrit Shakna- all too easy?

unknown... · 26 Apr 2004

WahegurjikakhalsaWahegurujikifateh I dnt think ne1 is worth amrit, cz amrit is something which we cannot judge da worth of. Guru ji makes us worthy of somthing by blessing us das all. u js need to walk one step towards Guru ji and Guru ji comes 100 steps fo dat 1 step. If ne1 has a feelin even to a small amount of becomin Gurus sikh den dey shud go for it and Guru will make dat person follow da rehit all u need is commitment. without commitment dere is no relationship whether dat be a relationship between Guru ji and a sikh or som otha kinda relationship. If u have love fo ur Guru den Guru ji will bless u wid amrit. I didnt kno much abt da rehit wen i took amrit, bt i was craving fo it so much and nw ive ben amritdari for 1 n half years nearly and m learnin each day and will till da day i pass out cz das wt sikhs do. and 1 day i want to become khalsa from sikh. WahegurujikakhalsaWahegurujikifateh

Re: Amrit Shakna- all too easy?

M4A1 · 26 Apr 2004

Yea, it would be cool if there was some sort of test like put the person into a freezing cold broiler room and leave them there for the day to do simran. If the person stayed inside all day then they would be allowed. Or have a person hung upside down from there feet for 5 hours doing simran. If the person stays like that, they would be allowed.

Re: Amrit Shakna- all too easy?

V Singh · 27 Apr 2004

GurFAteh You are very right, one SHOULD be tested. However don't you think this might lead to 'Haume'? If you feel that the Guru is EVERYTHING - You'd like to give ur LIFE for the Guru - the Guru is your EVERYTHING Your Ang Sang - You would fight and die for the Guru! Give ur LIFe foe the Guru then i think thats efficient, as if you get tested and 'notice' afterwards that you PASSED - might this not lead to 'Haumai'? bhull chukk maaf GurFAteh

Re: Amrit Shakna- all too easy?

Gurjeevan · 27 Apr 2004

It is all upto the Guru Ji who receives Amrit, not for us to say that peopel should be tested or not. Nobody deserves Amrit, as we are all Paapees.. Guru Ji bestows this gift to us.

Re: Amrit Shakna- all too easy?

Guru ka Singh · 27 Apr 2004

I agree with Gurjeevan, who are we to judge who does or does not deserve Amrit. It is all the Akal Purakh's Hukam. If we start pointing fingers at the Punj Pyaray then we are pointing fingers at Guru ji. If we accuse the Punj Pyaray for being weak, then we accuse the Guru ji of being weak. If an Amritdhari becomes a Kurheti, then it's the Akal Purakh's Hukum.

Re: Amrit Shakna- all too easy?

some Kaur · 27 Apr 2004

isn that what te peshis are for before the actual amrt sanchaar ceremony begins? Thats when the panj pyaarey assess whether the abjilakhees are ready for amrit or not. I heard that Bhai Fauja Singh had to get pesged like three or four times and was tested by the panj pyaarey before he got the daat of amrit. he had to actaully show the panj that he was able to sacrifice his life for amrit before they accepted him.

Re: Amrit Shakna- all too easy?

hmm · 27 Apr 2004

V singh's comments and Gurjeevan's comments both make sense. Same with everyone else's. I honestly feel, however, that we BEG people to take Amrit. I don't know if this is right. So many people do it for the wrong reasons, and so many people (like me) shouldn't be allowed to represent the Khalsa panth by taking Amrit. Like one example is how some girls get laser hair removal before taking amrit so that when they are amritdharee, they wont have any hair. Do people like this really deserve amrit? I don't know. I don't think it's fair.

Re: Amrit Shakna- all too easy?

UK Singh · 27 Apr 2004

Gurjeevan writes 'It is all upto the Guru Ji who receives Amrit, not for us to say that peopel should be tested or not. Nobody deserves Amrit, as we are all Paapees.. Guru Ji bestows this gift to us' When we are baptised, we join the Khalsa Fold (Akaal Purakh Ki Fauj). Logically speaking, anyone joining an army, whether it be in the past, present or future are tested. Do you realise the amount of training and preparation involved to join the Marines or the SAS. It is true that Cadets have to work their way up the ranks before joining the elite, but they are tested to the limit nonetheless. If they fail they walk. True to say we have many pious (Sant) folk in the Sikh community, but the majority of Sikhs we see are physically weak, obese and do not live upto the Sipahi model. Guru Sahib was obviously aware that just becoming a Sant was not enough! As MKhalsa stated, we need quality and not quantity. The Panj Piyare represent Guru Sahib, so they 'can' decide who takes amrit or not. During my Amrit Sanchaar, many children were turned away as they were deemed too young to take Amrit and understand the responsibilities involved... If anyone knows Singhs who perform Panj Piyariaan dhi Seva, please ask them their views..and post their replies here. Thanks for the feedback so far.

Re: Amrit Shakna- all too easy?

YAMDOOT · 27 Apr 2004

Any "Singhnee" who got laser hair removal before Amrit will, in my belief, be thrown down into Yampur for a little session with teh Yamdoots ;) WJKK WJKF

Re: Amrit Shakna- all too easy?

no one · 27 Apr 2004

>>>Any "Singhnee" who got laser hair removal before Amrit will, in my belief, be thrown down into Yampur for a little session with teh Yamdoots ;)<<< well, i hope you are right. Sometimes it doesn't seem that way

Re: Amrit Shakna- all too easy?

V Singh · 27 Apr 2004

'YAMDOT' arn't all sins removed after taking Amrit? so if a Women has DONE THAT MISTAKE - has learnted from it - and doesn't continue - does tha stll refer to your post? bhull chukk maaf GurFAteh

Re: Amrit Shakna- all too easy?

charan dhoor · 28 Apr 2004

Waheguruji ka Khalsa Waheguruji ki Fateh Such tests do nothing to improve one's spiritual life! Polar Pears live in the arctic and have not received salvation nor have bats that hang upside down their whole lives, and flamingos live standing in water on one leg for much of their lives and have not been delivered. Such similar images are replete in Gurbani and illustrate the futility of physical contortions, endurance tests and deprivations as a key to salvation. If anything they improve your haumain.Are we forgetting the lessons of Gurbani. Simran is the medicine that will in time erase haumain. Jee if someone comes forward in utter humility to the Guru's darbar then no test is needed.The Guru will give as He sees fit. Once one has received amrit it is like receiving a treasure. There is no way to predict how a person will turn out, what choices he or she will make how the treasure will be spent, invested or squandered. There is no hindsight in any of this. If in the darbar it is decided that a person needs more time to prepare.......and that sometimes is sometimes the case.....candidates have been know to have to complete something that will help them in their spiritual growth...and it usually helps a lot in that aspect of their spiritual life that needed to grow. Once they take amrit after that then they really take off. But you see not everyone's tasks to complete are the same. Everyone is different and no 2 people are at the same place spiritually.No 2 snowflakes are completely alike either. All of this is up to the Guru and He will speak His will as He sees fit in His darbar. dassan dass

Re: Amrit Shakna- all too easy?

M4A1 · 28 Apr 2004

I wasn't really serious with those tests. They did use to have tests a while ago. They use to splash cold water on the person and if they stopped simran, they were not given amrit.

Re: Amrit Shakna- all too easy?

?? · 28 Apr 2004

>>>>> They did use to have tests a while ago. They use to splash cold water on the person and if they stopped simran, they were not given amrit. >>>>> What??? First of all, how can someone without naam do simran? You do simran once you've gotten amrit not before. And 2ndly, what's being startled with cold water got to do with anything? If you dump a bucket of cold water on even the must dedicated candidate, I'm pretty sure they'd at least open an eye to see what the heck just happend. What jatha does this happen in???

Re: Amrit Shakna- all too easy?

p kaur · 28 Apr 2004

"charan dhoor", the panj pyare ARE the Guru, so they can judge whether someone will be commited enough to represent the Khalsa Panth when they take Amrit. I dont' mean tests like physical testing, I mean tests of the person's jeevani, their habits, finding out from other sangat what the reputation of that person is and whether they still do manmat, whatever.. "V Singh" - you proposed a really good point, but that's SO HARMFUL. If girls think that "when I take Amrit all my sins will be washed away" then they'll be even MORE eager to get permanent hair removal before taking Amrit, thinking that Guru jee wont care in the end. Then I bet the majority of Khalsa bibis will end up getting their hair removed before taking Amrit. That makes it so much harder for the bibis that truly want to follow rehat.

Re: Amrit Shakna- all too easy?

M4A1 · 28 Apr 2004

I heard that from someone doing katha. The bhai said that when he took amrit, they did those type of tests. He received amrit after failing a couple of previous attempts. He said they had to repeat gurmanter and a bucket of cold water was splashed on them. Those that kept repeating gurmanter were allowed to take amrit. It was not from any specific jatha, just 5 piarey.

Re: Amrit Shakna- all too easy?

s!nghn! · 28 Apr 2004

Even if a singhni permanetly removes hair before taking amrit, this past action will go along with her after taking amrit, where she will have to pay for what she did anyways in whatever manner Guru Ji pleases. In my opinion, there is no point in women removing hair BEFORE taking amrit and thinking that Guru Ji will still be pleased with them after they take amrit.

Re: Amrit Shakna- all too easy?

singhsation · 29 Apr 2004

I think it's foolish for any Sikh to get laser treatment before taking amrit but you've stated that this past action will go along with her after taking amrit. That is just an opinion which actually flys in the face of what we traditionally accept as the benefit of amrit. Amrit either wipes away your past deeds or it doesn't - I don't think we can now go and pick between those deeds which amrit is going to wipe clean and those which it isnt. With regards to testing, because taking amrit is too easy - what an absolutely RIDICULOUS idea. How can anyone judge Guru ji's grace on someone? How can any person deny the blessing of amrit? If the Panj Piare refuse someone, then they better do it with Guru ji" grace alone and not depend on background checks they've done and what they've heard from other people - people say a lot of incorrect, ignorant, and false things, either intentionally or unintentionally. And what do we do if the person wants to take amrit if they are denied? Should we set up an appeal process? Should we have some kind of amrit-tribunal? Maybe those denied amrit and those that denied them can present their evidence, have lawyers advocate for them and we can make our decisions that way. Ridiculous. They're are going to be those who adhere to rehit and those that don't - but Guru ji judges, them not us. The whole idea of testing for amrit is so elitist, it's rather sickening. daas s!nghn! wrote: > Even if a singhni permanetly removes hair before taking amrit, > this past action will go along with her after taking amrit, > where she will have to pay for what she did anyways in whatever > manner Guru Ji pleases. In my opinion, there is no point in > women removing hair BEFORE taking amrit and thinking that Guru > Ji will still be pleased with them after they take amrit.

Re: Amrit Shakna- all too easy?

Guru ka Singh · 29 Apr 2004

We can be so judgemental. How do we know who does or does not deserve Amrit? Everyone has the right to join the true path. No one deserves to be discriminated against. For me there was a big turning point in my life which directed me the Guru's path. For some people it might be the Katha done by a 'Sant' or a learned GurSikh. Sometimes one event or person can change your whole way of thinking. It's all Guruji's Hukam. 8 months ago I was cutting my hair, smoking, drinking and eating meat. Today I am an Amritdhari following the Guruji' path.