Re: Hair on body can be cut or waxed?
Mohan Singh · 27 Apr 2004
No it cant.
Daya Singh Rehat Nama says no hair is to be removed. From ANYWHERE. I have read many other sources which say the same thing I will find later.
The UK Nihangs are attempting to pull in a wider target audience - of "Sikh" girls who dont have the love for the Guru to keep their full kesh, by making up this manmat. Just like they pull in the "Sikh" men who think drugs (Sukkha) are "cool" and dont want to give up meat.
Can you really imagine the Gurus wife cutting hair anywhere.
And I take offence to "unnattractive hair". Who says hair anywhere is unnattractive, why dont you go to the Barbers, perhaps a french crop would be more "attractive" for you.
Do not have any doubts on this part of the Rehat. It is a BUJJAR KUREHAT to remove any hair from anywhere on the body. There is no difference between head hair, beard hair, anywhere hair. Electrolysis, waxing, bleaching, whatever, is all BUJJAR KUREHAT and you will have to answer infront of Dharam Rai and go through 8.4 million life forms and torture at the hands of Yamdoots if as a Khalsa you neglect this vital part of Khalsa Roop.
People like to follow things which makes life easier for themselves. Do not delude yourself or help spread the UK Nihangs Manmat.
Apologies if I have offended anyone but I see Kesh as one of the most important external parts of Sikhi and for people to become lax in this Rehat, how can they have discipline in any Rehat.
Waheguru Ji Ki Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh.
Re: Hair on body can be cut or waxed?
Mohan Singh · 28 Apr 2004
This is to clear any doubts who have been misled on hair.
I am frankly not worried what the definition of Kesh is, how its defined in Mahan Kosh or Panth Prakash.
This is what Daya Singh Rehatnama has to say.
Those who undergo the tonsure ceremony, killers of daugters, followers of Dhir Mal, the masands, the followers of Ram Rai, or those who use colour prepared from red ochre or the kusumbha flower (since these both give red and as we know Rehat Maryada does not allow Red clothing) should all pay a tanakhah of a rupee and a quarter. (62)
*DO NOT CUT ANY OF YOUR BODY HAIR.* Cut your fingernails in such a way that they do not fall into your food and render it dirty. Wash your hands and feet and sit in a clean place to eat. In your earthern cooking square, cook over a wood fire (rather than a dung one - in the pinds they use poo for fuel). (63)
BTW....these numbers given are not part of the Rehatnama since it is written in prose not verse. The numbers have been added by WH McLeod so that when looking up lines they can easily be found. WH McLeod, who attempts to bash every angle of the Sikh Rehat and translates everything as harshly as possible to try and pull apart every detail, has admitted that body hair is not to be removed.
There are many, many other Rehatnamas and historical accounts that show that hair is not to be removed.
If Guru Gobind Singh did not want his daughters to be tested, why both wearing a keski, why bother keeping your head hair, why dont you just hide away and blend into western society completely. The path of a Gursikh is as thin as a hair and as sharp as a sword, it is not easy to get Mukti. Mukti is not given to every "Sikh".
I have already said alot and I feel I can say no more. Every Singhnee knows exactly what is right and wrong, it just depends on how far they want to take the excuses they make for such a tiny thing as hair. Imagine in Dharam Rais court if you waste 8.4 million life forms of pain and start the cycle all over again, because you were vain about your hair.
Waheguru Ji Ki Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh.
Re: Hair on body can be cut or waxed?
Mohan Singh · 28 Apr 2004
This a small request to "N30 Singh" Ji from Sikh*****ness.com forum who quoted my above comments on that website.
I would appreciate it if my comments were not on that website, sorry if I offend you, but I would rather that my comments or my name was not associated with that website if you do not mind. You may quote the Rehatnama on your own if you want. Please could you fulfill that one request for me. Thankyou.
Apologies
Waheguru Ji Ki Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh
Re: Hair on body can be cut or waxed?
princess of power · 28 Apr 2004
I hope this post does not get deleted.
I myself was as confused as "singhani" because I knew several akj ladies who were perfectly nice SAYING that we as women shouldn't remove out hair, but DOING the opposite. I was so confused as to why they would do this.
It is also glaringly obvious, we as asain women will have facial hair and lots of it, its not possible that we wouldn't, yet when we look around at the number of girls with keskis on but a smooth face, it does make me wonder.
Eventually there were too many hypocritical elements between what was said and what was done, and I am thankful that someone at least is being honest, its true, I don't think I look nice with a beard (being a woman) but I'm not saying other people think like me, and everyone sees differently, but for me, Sikhs that say what they mean a rarity, and its those I listen to.
Those that preach one thing and do another are not to be listened to as their words are lies.
Lets be honest now, how many people here honestly can say they do not know amritdhari girls that remove their facial hair??? Well, the guys wouldn't realise anyway, so this question is to the girls.
Re: Hair on body can be cut or waxed?
Mohan Singh · 28 Apr 2004
"??", The website I mentioned is the sole cause for all these problems about Kesh, Dastars, and whatnot being brought up in the first place in a bigger way than they have been before.
I do not want to be associated with it because I remember the Guru saying, do not go anywhere near or be associated with falsehood.
"Singhanee" Penji, I do not understand how the words of a non Amritdhari spiritually devoid moorakh such as myself can help a strong daughter of the Guru such as yourself. I can give you advice though, do not read message boards of so called "scholars" or such anti Gurmat propaganda that promotes such Manmat. Concentrate on yourself and do not be tempted by these shallow things. Keeping a small amount of natural Kesh is a tiny thing, compared to the immense amounts of paath and namsimran that a Sikh needs to do to achieve union with God.
Waheguru Ji Ki Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh
Re: Hair on body can be cut or waxed?
confused singh · 28 Apr 2004
singh -- you stated that those who cut their kes, will be given extra points down from dharam raj.
My question is for monas like myself, whats the use of staying in sikhi, if we are alway goign to get dissed. It's always monas getting dissed on sikh forums, like why not encourage monas to keep kesh. The more and more you badmouth people, saying they will be doomed, the more people will leave man, and serious. I have sharda in sikhi, even I know I am not a Sikh,even though all my relatives call me one. So if I die lets say, no matter what I did in life, I'll still be nailed for just cutting kesh. What happens if I have never had sangat of gursikhs my age, how come kesdhari brothers will say stuff over the net about monas, but never infront of their faces.?
Re: Hair on body can be cut or waxed?
singhsation · 29 Apr 2004
Dear Bhainjee -
While there are some punjabi/asian women with considerable facial hair, there are probably just as many who have next to no visible facial hair.
It's a matter of genetics.
Case in point: the women in my family don't tend to have much facial hair if any. my great-grandmother (amrit-dhari) suffered from arthritis in the knees and, as I kid, I used to massage her legs to ease her pain. she had absolutely no leg hair, no arm hair, and absolutely no facial hair.
My dad has next to no hair on his legs (literally looks like they've been waxed) but, in contrast, I do have hair on my legs. Genetics.
I have friends who have hairy chests and some with hairy backs as well while I don't. Genetics.
I feel proud of Gursikh sisters who have the strength to maintain their rehit when they do have facial hair, whether it is some or a lot. I can only imagine the fortitude these sisters have in maintaining their ideals.
The sad truth is, even Singhs and gursikh families, when looking for rishtay, will tend to shy away from Singhnian with lots of facial hair. Attractiveness is a factor when it comes to rishtay, even if it's the families who are making the rishtay.
A girl's family may look to physical attributes such as height and physique while the boy's family will look to physical attributes of attractiveness in the girl as well. It's hard to justify but it exists - almost all gursikh families are going to look at the prospective bride or grooms physical attributes. Should physical attributes play any part in gursikh relationships - ideally no but they do.
Some will say that we shouldn't consider physical hair on a gursikh girl when looking at rishtay because it is Guru ji's will for them to have that hair. But then, is it ok to look at gursikh boy's height or skin-color when making rishtay? Should it matter whether a Singhnee has a mustache or a Singh is only 5'2" tall? Ideally, the physical should not play a part but it does. I think most Singhnian know this - another reason I respect the Singhnian who maintain their rehit in the face of this pressure.
daas
princess of power wrote:
> It is also glaringly obvious, we as asain women will have
> facial hair and lots of it, its not possible that we wouldn't,
> yet when we look around at the number of girls with keskis on
> but a smooth face, it does make me wonder.
Re: Hair on body can be cut or waxed?
confused singh · 29 Apr 2004
singh veerji -- Thanks for your explanation. It cleared things up.
Re: Hair on body can be cut or waxed?
Mohan Singh · 29 Apr 2004
On the aforemented website where a discussing has being going on a few comments have been made about my original post.
"Last thing i want to see wahabis claiming oh If you got no kesh then there is no mukhti... lol.. what a joke..."
Here Bhai Sahib seems to have a problem believing that Bujjar Kurehats will result in being placed in the hands of the Yamdoots. I will answer to him, that if a Amritdhari Singhnee (or Singh) removes hair from any part of their body, then if they ask the Panj Pyare what they have done, the Panj will tell them, they have done a Bujjar Kurehat and they are now patits or "fallen ones". They are not Khalsa and have broken their Rehat seriously. If Bhai Sahib is telling me, that someone can achieve Mukti, after commiting a Bujjar Kurehat, then I am suprised. Why are we Khalsa Sikhs not smoking tobacco, committing adultery, if we can still get Mukti as a Kurehatee.
Mukti is not given out on a plate to everyone. Not only must we consider how Guru-centered someone is if they see no problem in doing a Kurehat, but also we must think, if someone disobeys the most fundamental Rehat their own Panj Pyare has told them, how can they be considered fit for liberation.
This may seem like "scare mongered" tactics, but I sincerely believe that the ramifications for doing one of the four Bujjar Kurehats is harsh. In the same way I would not expect to see a adultery or smoker achieve liberation.
Please could you give me Gurbani or Rehatnama quotes, to show that infringement on the most serious of ALL crimes in Sikhi, can still allow a person Mukti.
I also see that another member of that website, is claiming that this is a mistranslation. Bhai Sahib says:
"Well the thing is that the translation of that Rahitnama is actually false! That is what you get by translating Braj texts with modern Panjabi vocabulary!
That passage of the rahitnama in Braj translates as: Don't shave your hair (on the scalp) on the occasion of funerals (pind karam). Giving Rahitnamas in English alone is misleading. Give the gurmukhi text as well! "
Unfortunately you are wrong. In many other Rehatnamas, WH McLeod has translated lines as "hair on head". Infact he goes to certain lengths in parts of his book, to attempt to convince us that Kesh means head hair only. However it is clear from this line, that WH McLeod has translated it as all body hair. Why would McLeod who jumps at every moment to try and claim Kesh is head hair, mistranslate, considering he is incredibly knowledgable on all Indian languages?
Unfortunately it is a complete lie to claim the line is talking about funerals and head hair, when it clearly refers to body hair only. Every other translation of this Rehatnama, in Padams and Ashoks translations (and I am sure there are more I do not know of), give us exactly the same meaning.
There is no room for discussion on the meaning of this line.
Apologies if I have offended anyone.
Waheguru Ji Ki Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh
Re: Hair on body can be cut or waxed?
singhsation · 01 May 2004
>Honestly wrote:
> Next to no visible facial hair? To be honest, from the bottom
> of my heart, I've never seen an Amritdharee woman with no hair
> on her body or face, unless it's bleached and not noticble, or
> unless she got electrolysis done.
I wrote next to no visible facial hair - that is quite different than saying no facial hair. And it's true. All human beings, asian or otherwise, have facial hair - it just depends to what extent and how fine.
Some amritdhari women have a considerable amount of facial hair which is very visibile but I know of several amritdhari women who don't. I'm sure they must have some facial hair but it's just not very visible.
>
> My grandmother NOW also looks like she has no arm or leg hair -
> but that's because for her entire life, she never removed it,
> and most of her hair has fallen out now. (She's old). I'm
> talking about younger people.
Even with relatively younger people, this holds true. It's just genetics - some people are more prone to having facial and body hair than others.
I'm giving you personal examples becauase, well, I'm not in the habit of checking out people for body hair.
As I mentioned earlier, my great-grandmother had next to no body hair or any visible facial hair (menopause usually results in an increase in facial hair) but the same held true for my grandmother as well - she was old but not that old - I don't think 45 years old is that old.
It's not that different for guys - I'm sure you've seen guys with thick beards that go high onto the cheeks and other Singhs whose beards are not so expansive.
I have some friends with next to no chest hair and others with hairy chests and backs.
If someone automatically assumes that a bibi must have had elecotrolysis/waxing/whatever done because she has very little visible facial hair, then that person is making an ignorant and spiteful assumption.
Some things do indicate electrolysis or waxing such as the shape of the eyebrows but even then, there are some people with very fine eyebrows, and it would be foolhardy to be making negative and hurtful assumptions.
I have a friend, a devout gursikh, who has super fine eyebrow hair while her mother has almost no eyebrow hair.
These are differences due to genetics and outside of our control. I think every Sikh should accept what they have received as Guru ji da bhana and Guru ji's gift and leave it at that.
daas
Re: Hair on body can be cut or waxed?
princess of power · 01 May 2004
my point was ... your own ladies cannot keep this rehat, how can you expect to preach if you do not follow it yourself?
I deeply respect ladies who keep their hair everywhere, but I am tired of men who think they know everything bandying about words (as if their words matter an iota to a woman who has to look at herself and feel shame) and give ridiculous examples of prostitutes offering advice...
by the way, just because she is a prostitute doesn't mean her advice would not be worth taking, she is also created out of Vahegurus play, she is part of it, I as a Sikh have been taught by my Guru not to judge another....and what if that prostitute is the one that became brahmgiani by listening to the parrot repeating 'har har'? Would you refuse to take the advice of one such lucky soul because of what she used to be? but I digress.... the point is, there is something wrong here, either your own ladies who have taken amrit and according to you are commiting a 'bujjer karehit' (although I think otherwise) are unfaithful to their Guru and have little will power, or you might be wrong and it might be allowed.... who knows?