< Female Punj Piyare >
Jagroop Singh · 01 May 2004
Vahiguru ji ka khalsa, Vahiguru ji ki fateh!
Sadh Sangat Jio,
From various Sikhs, i have received various viewpoints regarding the following question:
- Can female Gursikhs do Seva as one of the Punj Piyare i.e. giving Amrit?
If you think they should/shouldn't/are not allowed according to Gurmat, please provide evidence of your reasoning/GurBani.
Thanks.
Vahiguru ji ka khalsa, Vahiguru ji ki fateh!
Re: < Female Punj Piyare >
Panth Says Yes · 01 May 2004
Sat Sri Akal:
Panthic Rehat Maryada says yes. It is the hukam of the Panth. Period and end of story.
Re: < Female Punj Piyare >
the real maha moorakh · 03 May 2004
>>Mkhalsa - Guru asked for 5 heads...he did not ask a gender specific question, caste, age, nationality etc.<<<
If guru ji did not ask a gender specific question, than why are we asking it today? Although physically a women is different from a man, there is no difference between their atmaas. and the physical body of the panj pyaarey of today is different from the oroginal panj pyaarey, whether they are male or female. so if you want o use this argument, make sure every panj pyaarey are physically the same as the original panj,. and then your argument will be valid.
If this seems like a leftist modern point of view, then your argument seems like a muslim/hindu/punjabi culture influenced view.
Re: < Female Punj Piyare >
Niranjan Singh · 04 May 2004
uK SiNgH :
I along with many other Sikhs have taken Amrit where one of the Panch was a Singhni. Do you consider us to be Sikhs ? If not, then what are we ?
Are you saying that you are you a better Sikh than us because you had 'male' Panj Piyarays, and we didn't ? Or are you a better Sikh because of your Rahini-Behanee ?
The Panj represent the Spirit and Body of Guru Gobind Singh Ji (eg: "Khalsa Mero Roop Hai Khaas, Khalsay Mai Hao Kaor Nivaas")
Where does it say that Guru Gobind Singh Ji only resides in males, and where does it say than females are NOT Khalsa ?
Why are dera dwellers so afraid of a female Khalsa ?
Will it take another Mai Bhag Kaur to liberate you out from these Sanaatan-Masand phobias ?
Re: < Female Punj Piyare >
kar kirpaa sab rayN thheevaa(n · 04 May 2004
M4A1
you say why was Mata Bhag Kaur never...
hmm
why was Baba Deep Singh never?
why was Bhai Mani Singh never?
why was Bhai Nand Lal never?
hmm...
your question is irrelevant.
Re: < Female Punj Piyare >
Jagroop Singh · 07 May 2004
Vahiguru ji ka khalsa, Vahiguru ji ki fateh!
uk Singh wrote "This desire to make warriors out of Khalsa women is one of the bigger problems we face".
Please explain why this is a problem.
Dhan Siree Guru Granth Sahib Jee!
Re: < Female Punj Piyare >
Ek Sikh Punjaban · 07 May 2004
Yes i think that women should be able to be Punj Piyare. I says so in the panth. One of our Guru's said that women are very important.
Re: < Female Punj Piyare >
vaheguroo~vaheguroo · 07 May 2004
yehh, i knew that baba jarnail singh jee didnt agree with singhnees in the punj, but why?? can someone post why he didnt agree with this??
Re: < Female Punj Piyare >
Jagroop Singh · 09 May 2004
Vahiguru ji ka khalsa, Vahiguru ji ki fateh!
UK Singh wrote: "Feminism is not much about ‘equality’ as it is about altering the balance of power. The feminist want the power and seeking ‘equality’ is merely a camouflage".
Dear Veer Ji, you're reading of feminism is seriously limited and generalised. As i am sure you are aware, it's not quite as simple as that...i won't cut and paste lots off stuff off the internet - that would certainly waste time.
UK Singh wrote: "And so are the cries of ‘oppression’ that the feminists and other post modernist liberals make".
i don't see why you are bringing postmodernism into it - what's your point here...are you trying to point to some sort of change, re: feminism, between the modernist era and what some now refer to as the contemporary postmodernist era...perhaps you are; it's just not very clear at all though.
UK Singh wrote: "The Guru promises full spiritual equality to men and women, but nowhere in Sikhi would you hear anyone say – the Sikh revolution really wants to transfer the societal setup from patriarchy to matriarchy, or transfer the ‘power’ to women".
Again, you are alluding to a very convenient (for your argument that is) yet completely limited concept of feminism. As i am sure you are aware, not all feminists over the last 80 years were the kind of 'anarchists' that you paint them out to be...again, i do not wish to point to the obvious and digress as a result.
UK Singh wrote: "As you do know, the status of women in Sikhi is radically different from pretty much all other ‘civilized’ realms of religion, the ancient Stone Age matriarchal tribes excepted of course. The Guru exalted the status of women from the causers of the ‘original sin’ (Genesis), ,‘one-half of man’ (Quran) or ‘witch/Maya’(Hindu milieu) to the ‘honour of man’(Guru Hargobind Sahib) and the ‘creator of kings’(Guru Nanak Dev Ji)".
This part of your post is absolutely excellent; this shows you have perhaps even unintentionally grasped what Guru Sahib was doing; the practice of Burquah (full length head/face/bodylegs veil) was so strongly set against what Sikhi was about that 3rd Nanak Sahib would not even allow women who wore it to attend Sangat! Now that is a SERIOUSLY STRONG STATEMENT that Guru Sahib made! You can call it whatever you like by the way...the action speaks louder than any words.
UK Singh wrote: "Women seeking power is a deviation from the normal feminine behaviour and against the basis of natural way in which heterosexual relations function. Man commands the power, and women nurture and submit, ensuring a compatible relationship. There is nothing bad about this setup; howsoever politically incorrect it might sound. That’s how the genetics has made men and women. Fighting against the Will of Vaheguru can’t take us far, thought it can certainly begin the decay of society as we see all around ourselves".
Nurture and submit - what like Mai Bhago...i gues if you were right that particular historical happening would read: "and she stayed quiet as the men decided not to follow Guru Sahib into battle; she scolded herself for even thinking she should say something and quietly proceeded to wash the dishes and sweep the floor - as every good woman should". i think Veer MKhalsa Jee has succinctly relegated your argument. As for inferring that it is this imbalance of gender power-relatations that has caused 'the decay of society'...you seriously need to do some flower-arranging or something to get in touch with your feminine side Veer Ji! Your point is so limited that to be honest what can be said in reply aside from the following: that is absolute nonsense!
UK Singh wrote: "Finally, the basic question that needs to be asked is this- if women don’t share ‘equal power’ with men, does it make them oppressed? Probably in the feminist worldview, but not in an objectivist rational order".
Objectivist-rational order; Veer Ji, as Veer MKhalsa Jee did, i am going to 'assume too much' here and declare that much of the terminology you use in your post is in fact for the purposes of intentionally mystifying what you are putting across. i feel as though you have yet to learn that the intellect is limited...for instance, what if i was to begin a thread called 'the nature of objectivism' and was to argue there is no such thing as objectivism...me and you could carry the debate on for aeons and aeons and no progress would be made. Always remember that Guru Sahib is more than just a philosopher...the philospher tries to ascertain Truth from an objective position whilst Guru Sahib is actually part and parcel of the Truth...subjectivism and objectivism do not apply here. As Sikhs, this is what we try to achieve by living and breathing Siree Guru Granth Sahib Jee.
UK Singh wrote: "Feminism is all about transforming patriarchy into something that is less than desirable and I’m not too keen on seeing that happen in the realm of Sikhi".
Guru Sahib sees patriarchy as unnatural...just as He sees matriarchy as unnatural...Natural is about balance, ying and yang, equilibrium. This is where your arguments fall flat on their face. You are effectively saying that patriarchy is natural, correct, positive etc. What you fail to do is quote Siree Guru Sahib in support of your attitudes...i accept every quote from Siree Guru Sahib that has been put forward to challenge your views as my support.
Dhan Siree Guru Granth Sahib Jee!
Re: < Female Punj Piyare >
guru da dass · 10 May 2004
Waheguruji ka Khalsa Waheguruji ki Fateh
I have been monitoring this thread and to me it raises even more questions. If a person puts their heart and soul into Sikhi and follow rehet in every way then wherein lies the difference between any member of the Khalsa?
If liberation from oppression is a core value of the Khalsa then why are we looking for excuses to bar full participation by women in the activities of the Khalsa Panth? This seems to be a disturbing trend. I know women who are taught not to and do not perform their Nitnem when they are menstruating. In certain groups women are barred from paticipating in Akhand Path because they menstruate and because of a taught aversion towards women because they wear salvar or pyjamee (it does not seem to matter if rehet states that one has to take full shower and wear clean clothing before doing a rol)
Is is inherently right to deny voice and participation in Panthic activities solely based on gender? That is at least 50% of the Panth.
I think the Gurus would disagree with you when by the time of Guru Gobind Singh 40% of Sikh missionaries were women. Have we not taken a step back in Gurujee's mission itself? Who is to say they did not officiate in ALL duties requiring Panthic attention as well?
It is one thing to SAY one does not discriminate but it is ACTIONS that speak louder and clearer. A Sikh must be one in thought, speach and action. When one excludes an entire section of the Khalsa for reason of race, occupation, caste or gender from participation in religious or Panthic matters we are no longer following Gurujee's Hukam...we are discriminating and becoming the oppressors the Gurus so vigorously fought!
I have taken amrit when 2 women were in Panj Peeyarey, and the Darban was also a woman. It was a truly Chardhikala Amrit Sanchaar that occured and a tremendous amount of kirpa occured there. I suppose you are going to say I was hallucinating or making it up. Then I CHALLENGE you to meet me and tell this to my face! I took amrit 21 years ago jee. Amrit has begun a process that continues to turn my life on its head.
That anyone champions human rights and gives a voice and a role to the disenfrenchised and the underrepresented champions the Guru's cause. The Gurus brought light and nudged the conscience of the whole world. Why as Sikhs would we want to step back from this glorious heritage and apply shackles within our own Khalsa Panth?
By the way one of the Sikhs who has left this world was also a woman who was an inspiring role model for other young women and young men. She was learning Gatka, was an infectious budding leader, and was blossoming into a fine strong Gursikh. Do we not need people like this? Is building strong leaders and getting EVERYONE involved in whatever talent and capacity not in our Panth's best interest!! Or are we going to fall victims to our narrow insecurities and prejudices??
Waheguruji ka Khalsa Waheguruji ki Fateh
[%sig%]
Re: < Female Punj Piyare >
want to know now pleasee · 11 May 2004
I know that DAMDAMI TAKSAAL is 100% against this.
Re: < Female Punj Piyare >
Rashminder Singh Oz · 11 May 2004
thanx guru da daas ji
i agree with u, 100% correct........ i wish people should start accepting the fact that bibian can do all sewaas what singhs can do.
i myself want a baby girl after i get married, i want her to be parcharak in her coming future, i will try my best to make her best parcharak for spreading guru ji's message about dastaar for bibian , make her good kathakaar and kirtanee
may guru bless me with such a daughter
come on gursikhon lets change our mentality.............. there is no sex difference in terms of gurmat rehit maryadaa.
chardikalaaaaaaaaaaaaaa
waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh
Re: < Female Punj Piyare >
guru da dass · 11 May 2004
Waheguruji ka Khalsa Waheguruji ki Fateh
To tell you the truth I don't really care if the Taksal is against this or not. I am no less a Sikh then any of them. I f they don't like it that is their problem. I am sick and tired of this oppressive discrimination in so many shades under the guise of gurmat against 50% of the Sikh panth.The soul wears the body of the Akal Purakh's choosing and it is our narrow point of view that locks us into patterns or discrimination. Gurujee is without vair and is a lot more fair then many groups out there. The heck with them!!