Skip to content
ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥
Forum
Ekta Q
Ekta Q
Indy · 07 May 2003
How can Sikhs Sikhs unite under one banner, on one platform to fight injustice and prevent the assimilation of our religion by the Virus like Hindu India??
Don't you folks think that following ONE Rehat is the answer to ALL our problems??
Re: Ekta Q
Mkhalsa · 07 May 2003
> Don't you folks think that following ONE Rehat is the answer
> to ALL our problems??
Of course :)
Re: Ekta Q
sangh · 08 May 2003
isn't this what the singh sahba movement tried 2 accomplish in the early 1900's?
the only true way to unite i believe is by acceptance of all rehats rather then assimilation to one.
Re: Ekta Q
Indy · 09 May 2003
Of course? mmhhh...Are the Sikhs as they stand following 'One' Maryada at this current time?
Re: Ekta Q
Mkhalsa · 09 May 2003
I agreed with you veer jee, i didnt say its true..
but i like sanghs idea much better. We should all agree to disagree, otherwise the disagreements will lead to our downfall.
Re: Ekta Q
das · 10 May 2003
y is there fear of assimilation? what kind of assimilation do we sikhs fear?
i live in uk please enlighten me brothers and sisters..
Re: Ekta Q
mahakaal · 10 May 2003
i concur... if we can learn to accept our differences, the panth can achieve anything... at the moment, we are our own worst enemies!
Re: Ekta Q
Indy · 10 May 2003
Mahakaal certainly has the the right idea and has understood my initial post. Being at odds with each other due to distinct maryadas has not helped Sikhi one iota. External forces aside, Sikhs are their own worst enemies and have been now for some time.
Mind you, this is nothing new. Even at the time of Maharaja Ranjit Singh, the Misls were fighting each other over land. More recently some so called Sikhs have sold out by not requesting independence for Sikhs in '47.
What have we learnt from these history lessons? It would seem 'nil'!!
The Youth in the West seem to be taking after their forefathers in some respects. Different Jathebandhies preaching Sikhi from various angles does not help in the slightest.
Being in the West, you would have thought that the youth would have a democratic system in place. But we seem to taking the same Road as our forefathers. We still have people jumping on the Taksaal, Nihang, AKJ, and now even Udasi/Nirmala bandwagon. I'm not saying that we should not have specific groups as such. However, we should all be following Gurmat and not Manmat. ie Nihangs can teach us 'Shashtar Vidya', Nirmalas 'Sikh History, Taksaalis, 'Shudh Path and Gurbani Vichaar' and so on. As long as the Youth can take the lead and follow one Maryada, Sikhi will withstand and external forces such as RSS, Nakli Sants, GOI propaganda...I think you get the picture!
Re: Ekta Q
.. · 11 May 2003
the mool mantar says truth is eternal. no one can change it, not even the rss or goi. the moghuls british and ghandis tried they perished, sikhism is still alive.. all we need to do is screw our heads on..
if 24 million sikhs became nam japan bani reading guru ke sikh what can rss do?? in da old days the moghuls held swords at the throats of sikhs and tempted them with offers of intoxication, women, land.. today people forsake their dharm, cut their own hair with these hindi film trends, drink because they want to, and want statuses of wealth, theres no indian goi or rss holding a sword to the throat of a sikh today, (although their methods r more sly with the same aim as moghuls) those methods are not direct nowdays, so hence we as sikhs r responsible for our actions no one is forcing us to do anything.. its our people being weak, we have to recognise our internal situation and correct that and need massive parchar kicking off singh sabha style.. if not then whos gonna educate the youth??
Re: Ekta Q
mahakaal · 11 May 2003
i understand where u're coming from indy, but i dont think trying to brand everyone with the same barcode is the solution. everyone is different, with a different outlook on life. so trying to make everyone conform to one singular set of practices is bound to be met with a lot of dissention & resentment. that is basically what the powers that be in india are attempting to do... make everyone conform to a singular set of ideals... hindi, hindu, hindustan!!... rather than accepting the diversity & variety that exists within the cultures & religions that are present.
similarly, there is a lot of diversity within the panth... like u said there are the nihangs who know shaster vidya, the nirmalas who know sikh history & the taksalis who know shud path etc. each of these has their own separate & very different maryadas, but they all still hold their allegiances to sikhi. i think we should learn to accept each others rehats & look past our differences. we each have our own individual path to vaheguru, no two of us will ever walk the same path! :)
Re: Ekta Q
Indy · 12 May 2003
Knowledge in this information age is everything. The RSS or other external forces at play do need talwars held to any of the Sikhs. Have you been to Punjab recently? the dedhari guru's are growing at a phenomenal rate and have their derey set up in almost every Pind.
Parchaar is key. However, under circumstances where Sikhs have no comeback, even less under Hindu India than under the British what actions do you propose to bring Ekta to the Panth?? It's easy to point the finger at the Sikhs..do a certain degree we can blame the masses. Nevertheless most if not all of the blame lies with the self styled Sikh Leaders.
Radhasoamies attract huge numbers by offering homeless people free food and shelter to strengthen their cause. How often do you see Sikhs in the West approaching the homeless, carrying out charity work in an organised efficient manner...not even to convert, just to uphold the 'Vand Chakko' pricinple?
Obviously Sikhi is Akaal itself and will not dissapear of the face of the Earth. How that is related to Ekta in Sikhi and the current crisis we face is beyond me!
....actions speak louder than words.
===
Mahakaal Ji. Painting everyone with the same rehat could not be more different to the analogy you provided of Hindus trying to convert 'Anjaan' Sikhs into a whole new religious ideology. Hopefully, I won't need to expand on the differences between the two faiths.
Why do we as Sikhs need a distinct set of rules? Did Guru Gobind Singh Ji lay down separate rules for say the Akali Nihangs and the rest of the Sangat in 1699?
My simple point is that IF the Sikh Nation got it's acts together and stood one platform, gelled together by ONE Maryada, then many of the enemies we face try as they may, will think twice about trying to assimilate us.
A sub office of the Akal Takht in the West may also be beneficial.