Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

right or wrng saroop??very confused

right or wrng saroop??very confused

*paapi* · 30 Aug 2006

fatheh jee i went to meet a gursikh today and a conversation about particular saroops started..and basically the main issue was weither lareevaar or padh shedh saroop where correct.. now to my current belief and understanding i dont see there to be any difference in the format... but in the conversation with this particual singh he stated there isnt no difference because our guru jee's light is in the "shabad" not the format... there was also an issue beacuse bhai randhir singh jee stated that lareevaar was incorrect...but then the argument of this could be that bhai sahib jees book quoted gurbani which was written in padh shedh format and if it was incorrrect then why where these books alowed to be printed because these books where printed in bhai sahibs time.... i have also heard of some singhs not mutha teaking before a padh shed saroop because they see this saroop as not in gurbani.... padh shed saroop is when the gurbani is split up to read...dont we split up the words wen we recite gurbani??its not like we say all in one breathe so ow does the splitting on guru jees angs differ from the splitting in recitation i hope someone can give me the history or facts on this topic fatheh jee bhul chuk maaf [%sig%]

Re: right or wrng saroop??very confused

Kulbir Singh · 31 Aug 2006

Paapi jeeo, ---------------- now to my current belief and understanding i dont see there to be any difference in the format... but in the conversation with this particual singh he stated there isnt no difference because our guru jee's light is in the "shabad" not the format... --------------- Shabad is our Guru. This is why Padd-chhed saroop is not acceptable. Padd-chhed saroop does not have all Gurbani. It does not have Shabad Guru in its fullest form. It’s got other than Gurbani. Let me explain: Following pankiti can be done padd-chhed two ways: Itey kookar haur begana, bhaunka iss tann taayee|| And Itey Kook, rahau begana, bhaunka ss tann tayee|| Only one of the above is correct. Only one of the above is Gurbani. The other is not Gurbani. We don’t know which one it is. If Padd-chhed saroop has the wrong one, then it’s missing Gurbani and hence it cannot be Satguru. If "itay kookar Hau Begana" is Gurbani and Padd chhed has "Itey kook rahu begana" then its missing Gurbani. Hence it cannot be Guru for lacking Gurbani. In case of laridaar, if the paathi does it wrong, we can blame the paathi but in case padd-chhed has the wrong split of words, then it’s the mistake of the saroop thereby disqualifying it to be Satguru. There are 500 big differences of paaths and hundreds and hundreds of small differences of paaths. Pad-chhed saroops are not shudh and don’t contain a lot of baani. For this reason they cannot be called Satguru. Still you should respect them and we do respect them but we don’t consider them to be Guru. ----------------- there was also an issue beacuse bhai randhir singh jee stated that lareevaar was incorrect... ------------- Add to this list – Sant Gurbachan Singh Bhindranwale, Sant Jwala Singh Harkhowal and Sant Ishar Singh Rarewale. There are numerous other Gursikhs who were opposed to Padd chhed. --------------- but then the argument of this could be that bhai sahib jees book quoted gurbani which was written in padh shedh format and if it was incorrrect then why where these books alowed to be printed because these books where printed in bhai sahibs time.... ----------------- Two wrongs don’t make a right. If Bhai Sahib’s books contain padd chhed baani, it does not mean that Padd chhed saroop is okay. ------------------ padh shed saroop is when the gurbani is split up to read...dont we split up the words wen we recite gurbani??its not like we say all in one breathe so ow does the splitting on guru jees angs differ from the splitting in recitation ---------------- Doing padd chhed would be okay if one can do it correctly. The problem is that no one can do the Padd chhed correctly. The current padd chhed saroop has hundreds of pad-chhed (split of words) related mistakes, thereby not qualifying this saroop to be our Guru. [%sig%]

Re: right or wrng saroop??very confused

**** · 31 Aug 2006

veerji As you know majority of sikhs in the panth unfortunately have and do participate in the amrith sinchar where our true guru saroop is not in parkash. A thought and question comes to mind. As we have heard that when receiveing Naam Drihr many abhilakis start japping naam beyond control with so much raas. This happens even when the panj piyare are not fully rehitvaan themselves i.e. not bibekis. What happenes to those gursikhs who have reached hight states of spirituality, without taking amrith in presence of Laridaar saroop. Will they be given a place in Dargha. Also i strongly wish all panj piyare were bibekis. When i took Naam Drihr i was given amrith again without parkash of laridaar saroop and no hukam was given to stop eating from outside. Even one of the panj piyare i know ate from outside.

Re: right or wrng saroop??very confused

singh5 · 31 Aug 2006

I think that it would be foolish for a human to answer the question "Will they be given a place in Dargha". I can't answer whether I will be given a place in Dargha let alone whether others will. That having been said, I think we all know what the correct maryada is. The correct maryada for amrit sinchaar is with parkaash of laridaar saroop. The abhilakhis expect that the punj pyaare are following Gurmat maryada when they pesh and if there is dhill in them or they do something wrong, there is no doubt that they will be accountable for it. So what can people do who did not have laridaar saroop parkaash in their amrit sinchaar? I think thats a personal question they have to answer for themselves. There's a voice in your head and all of our heads and we need to listen to it. What does it think? Take a hukumnama from Guru Sahib. I know some Gursikhs have gone to amrit sinchaars where laridaar is parkaash and explained that pad-chhed was used in their amrit sinchaar and I know others who have not taken this step. I think it's a very personal matter and we should do what we think is right and what Guru Sahib wants of us.

Re: right or wrng saroop??very confused

*paapi* · 31 Aug 2006

fatheh jee thanku 4 ur reply veer kulbir singh jee.. u stated nobody can read padh shed saroop correctly...mistakes cud also be made during the recitation of the lareevaar saroop... similarily with the exmples u stated... the gursikh reciting lareevar cud easily make the mistake is placin the spaces in the wrong place... so wouldnt padh shed saroop be a benefit in this matter? ....bhul chuk maaf... [%sig%]

Re: right or wrng saroop??very confused

singh5 · 31 Aug 2006

The difference is that if someone makes a mistake when reading from laridaar saroop, the mistake is the reader's own. If the mistake is actually in the saroop, then the mistake is the saroop's which doesn't make any sense because Guru Sahib cannot be wrong. If there is one saroop that splits Kookrahau as kookar hau and the other as kook rahau then which saroop is "right". By default the other has to be "wrong". So you see how this is a very big problem? If someone took the bani of Guru SAhib and re-arranged it by Guru as opposed to by raag, would that be acceptable? Why? They say that the bani will still be the same right? But the fact is that we dont' have any authority or right to alter Guru Sahib in any way. If we break the words according to our own intelligence there can be so many mistakes and after all, Guru Sahib didnt' want it this way otherwise he would have done it himself.

Re: right or wrng saroop??very confused

E · 02 Sep 2006

yes kulbir singh what you say makes sense, pad chedh changes the meaning / changes gurbani therefore i agree 100% to print pad ched birs is manmat, lareevar is the correct form but even in a lareevar saroop there are mistakes with laga mantra, which potentially change the meaning of gurbani i would therefore hesitate before i can say with 100% confidence pad ched is not satguru i would need more evidence

Re: right or wrng saroop??very confused

SomeSingh · 02 Sep 2006

giani takhur singh (patiala) once said that sikhs should metha tek even to a padd ched saroop. It's a sin to not do so.

Re: right or wrng saroop??very confused

**** · 03 Sep 2006

i believe it is correct to metha tek to shabad even it is pad ched. Except we cannot say it is in our full guru saroop because of the differences mention in the above posts.

Re: right or wrng saroop??very confused

raj · 08 Sep 2006

as ppl have stated that pad ched saroops are incorrect...but then guru granth sahib jee would be very difficult to read...i mean each shabd is joint then hw would a person be able to tell how to pronounce or say each word?...sorry i dnt know much about this as ive never dicussed this with anyone....