Re: right or wrng saroop??very confused
Kulbir Singh · 31 Aug 2006
Paapi jeeo,
----------------
now to my current belief and understanding i dont see there to be any difference in the format...
but in the conversation with this particual singh he stated there isnt no difference because our guru jee's light is in the "shabad" not the format...
---------------
Shabad is our Guru. This is why Padd-chhed saroop is not acceptable. Padd-chhed saroop does not have all Gurbani. It does not have Shabad Guru in its fullest form. It’s got other than Gurbani. Let me explain:
Following pankiti can be done padd-chhed two ways:
Itey kookar haur begana, bhaunka iss tann taayee||
And
Itey Kook, rahau begana, bhaunka ss tann tayee||
Only one of the above is correct. Only one of the above is Gurbani. The other is not Gurbani. We don’t know which one it is. If Padd-chhed saroop has the wrong one, then it’s missing Gurbani and hence it cannot be Satguru. If "itay kookar Hau Begana" is Gurbani and Padd chhed has "Itey kook rahu begana" then its missing Gurbani. Hence it cannot be Guru for lacking Gurbani.
In case of laridaar, if the paathi does it wrong, we can blame the paathi but in case padd-chhed has the wrong split of words, then it’s the mistake of the saroop thereby disqualifying it to be Satguru.
There are 500 big differences of paaths and hundreds and hundreds of small differences of paaths. Pad-chhed saroops are not shudh and don’t contain a lot of baani. For this reason they cannot be called Satguru. Still you should respect them and we do respect them but we don’t consider them to be Guru.
-----------------
there was also an issue beacuse bhai randhir singh jee stated that lareevaar was incorrect...
-------------
Add to this list – Sant Gurbachan Singh Bhindranwale, Sant Jwala Singh Harkhowal and Sant Ishar Singh Rarewale. There are numerous other Gursikhs who were opposed to Padd chhed.
---------------
but then the argument of this could be that bhai sahib jees book quoted gurbani which was written in padh shedh format and if it was incorrrect then why where these books alowed to be printed because these books where printed in bhai sahibs time....
-----------------
Two wrongs don’t make a right. If Bhai Sahib’s books contain padd chhed baani, it does not mean that Padd chhed saroop is okay.
------------------
padh shed saroop is when the gurbani is split up to read...dont we split up the words wen we recite gurbani??its not like we say all in one breathe so ow does the splitting on guru jees angs differ from the splitting in recitation
----------------
Doing padd chhed would be okay if one can do it correctly. The problem is that no one can do the Padd chhed correctly. The current padd chhed saroop has hundreds of pad-chhed (split of words) related mistakes, thereby not qualifying this saroop to be our Guru.
[%sig%]