Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

confused

confused

lucky411 · 03 Sep 2006

I am not apart of the Sikh community, but I am currently working on a project on Sikhism. I was coming along fine until I came across a certain person who belong to your sect. He said some things that contridicted my research. He told me to visit this site, however i could not confirm what he had said. For example I read that about Guru Nanak Dev Ji, that equaility was very important to him. He sat amongst the poor and the outcasts of society and ate with them to show them that everyone was of equal status. The person i met doenst even eat langer at the Gurooduwara. He claims that he cannot eat food prepared by people who are not baptised. Can you please explain to me why that is? So I was just wonduring does your type of sect believe in the first Guru? Can you please help clear my confusion. Thank You FOr Your Time.

Re: confused

Seeker of the Truth · 04 Sep 2006

I am NOT an AKJ/Tapoban Sikh, but here's the link that I think will answer your question: http://www.tapoban.org/langar.htm

Re: confused

M B Singh · 05 Sep 2006

Sri Guru Nanak Dev Ji taught the humanity about equality, at every level; But this never means one has no reservations. You have to be different to make you glitter. [%sig%]

Re: confused

lucky411 · 06 Sep 2006

What do you mean by " this does not mean that one has no reservations" being different...does that mean putting yourself higher than others? YOu have to be different to make you glitter......so you don't let those lesser than you prepare your food? This does not seem like something Guru NAnak Dev ji would do....I hope not to offend, its just very confusing. Perhaps this is a new religion?

Re: confused

Dalbiri · 06 Sep 2006

lucky411 With all respect to AKJ and Taksali Singhs. I think you'll find that today Sikhs will generally go the Gurdwara and happily eat the langar that is prepared. I know most Gurdwaras generally do not turn anyone down who wants to help to do seva (obviously not if they are drunk with a cig hanging out their mouth though). I know many nonSikhs who have helped do such seva in Gurdwaras. Besides the vast majority of people who go to the Gurdwaras are not actually baptised. Please note I have nothing against the AKJ/Taksali rehat. I respect their adherance to sarbloh bibek rehat. In the early days of the Khalsa, Sikhs were hunted down and killed en mass and steel was given prominece by Guru Gobind Singh Ji who wanted to lift up people who had been oppressed for centuries. So symbolically steel is very important to many Sikhs, hence we wear a steel bangle on our wrists at all times, even people from Sikh backgrounds who are lax in follwing the code of conduct still generally do this, it is such a strong tradition (kutcha billay). Guru Gobing frequently referred to God as Sarbloh, or All-Steel. I think that the bibek tradition is very similar to the Jewish practice of "Kosher" And if any Sikh actually does these things to make themselves feel better than others, then this is their cross to bare. So don't worry about it.

Re: confused

... · 06 Sep 2006

that is sooo true these days sangat only eats out of amrit dharies hands..like monas are outcast. yeh there bad but there equal. the poeple that do that are showing off thier ego by saying they are higher. and that they wont eat out of someones hands who is not babtised.it does not nessecarily mean that person commits many sins. im sure everyone does reg. usually not purposly. this is my view. bull chuk maaf

Re: confused

Singhstah · 06 Sep 2006

hmm, school project, really? [%sig%]

Re: confused

Balpreet Singh · 07 Sep 2006

The question is not of higher or lower. The question is not of "outcasts". The question is only of Guru Sahib's hukam and working to enhance spiritual jeevan. Bibek (eating food cooked in sarbloh by amritdharis reciting naam/bani) is an essential rehit. Just the way amrit was prepared by the punj pyaaray, a Gursikh tries to replicate this with every meal. The vibration given by the sarbloh and the naam helps jap more naam. The original maryada for langar was that everyone eats together but the food is prepared according to bibek and seva is done by bibeki Gursikhs. Later this has been changed. Does it appeal to the mind to think that people who drink/smoke or fornicate are doing langar seva and preparing the food? This person may eat in the langar and is given as much respect as any one else, but they do not qualify for this seva. Most of us agree that degh seva should only be done by amritdharis. We all agree that amrit sinchaar seva is certainly restricted to amritdharis. Is this discrimination? No. It's just the reality that the person who is capable of the seva should do it. These Gursikhs have naam vibration from amrit and thus they qualify. If an "amritdhari" does not keep any rehit or jap naam then they too don't qualify for langar or degh seva. It's about enhancing jeevan, not discriminating.

Re: confused

... · 07 Sep 2006

There at Eminabad in the Punjab, lived in those times, a carpenter who used to make pegs of wood and other implements for the village. He lived in "pure poverty," as the Japanese would say. His life was simple, his needs were few, and he was happy. He was a disciple of the Master, but full of natural simplicity. READ THIS PART... Nanak went straight to his house and lived with him for days. He neglected the table of the king and preferred plain bread and water at the house of this man of God. The king sent for Nanak and asked, "Why do you refuse my bread and eat at the house of a low-caste though they say you are a Saint?" "Your bread is blood and his bread is milk," replied Guru Nanak.

Re: confused

Balpreet Singh · 07 Sep 2006

..., Your post is an excellent example in support of keeping bibek. If food is food then certainly the delicacies offered by Malik Bhago (the rich man not a King though) would have been nutritionally superior to the food prepared by Bhai Lalo. Certainly then, if Bibek doesn't matter, Guru Sahib should've eaten the better food. But here it has been illustrated that the person cooking the food does make a difference. If the person cooking is immoral then that food is unacceptable. Do you know who cooks your food if you go to a restaurant? It could be a criminal or someone completely without morals. Unfortunately at our Gurdwaras, we have no checks on who prepares the food anymore. Smokers and drinkers are welcome to help cook. But as the story you posted illustrates, Bhai Lalo (a Sikh of Guru Sahib incidentally and directly addressed by some Shabads of Guru Nanak) made simple food with bani and naam and that was approved but the food of Malik Bhago was not accepted regardless of how tasty or nutritious it would have been.

Re: confused

Dalbiri · 08 Sep 2006

What about a scenario where "drinkers, smokers and fornicators" (as someone put it), celebrated a childs birthday with an Akhand Path (as happens quite frequently) but the actual langar is cooked by bibekis, does this make it acceptable.

Re: confused

**** · 08 Sep 2006

"What about a scenario where "drinkers, smokers and fornicators" (as someone put it), celebrated a childs birthday with an Akhand Path (as happens quite frequently) but the actual langar is cooked by bibekis, does this make it acceptable." The story of Malik Bhago and Bhai Laloji also answers this question. The fact that the food bought from Malik Bhago was of corrupt finances (forcefully taking honest and harding working peoples wages) was the reason why blood came pouring from the roti. The person was corrupt therefore so was the money. If we are to accept food prepared by good means then it is of vast importance for the money to come from the right people aswell (who live and abide by hukam of vaheguru). Such people mentioned as above are too in debt to vaheguru by not following his given hukam of life, instead they are building sin upon sin by indulging in such actions. So how can it be wise to use finance coming from such people in Gurughar or for any other gursikhs. If we were to say that atleast he/she is not stealing therefore he/she is doing dasa noha di kamai. Then one thing we are not keeping in mind is that he/she is still doing kamai of bad karama with the same hands. So that does not balance out the needs for one to be able to do money or daswand seva, even if the person is doing dasa noha di kamai or not.

Re: confused

Ravinder · 08 Sep 2006

Lucky read a book called "Hidden Messages in Water" its proof of how positive and negative thinking has a detrimental effect on water. Good thoughts and words means the water created beautiful crytstals, bad thoughts and words meant the crystals were either non existent or deformed. Therefore, when one is Amritdhari who has created the food, he/she will in theory be thinking of God and put all their thoughts of love and compassion for God and good vibes into the food which will have a positive effect on the person consuming the food. Whereas if the person who prepared the food is say a meat eater, the negative effect of eating meat on the body (due to the animal's thoughts at its time of death) will affect the person preparing the food and in turn these negative vibes will then be transfered into the food being prepared and hence into the whoever consumes it.

Re: confused

Dalbiri · 09 Sep 2006

**** said: "So how can it be wise to use finance coming from such people in Gurughar or for any other gursikhs." That is so true but in reality we don't know where the money in the golak is coming from. I know for a fact that lots of the "respectable" members of the community do some seriously shifty stuff and they still make big donations.

Re: confused

SomeSingh · 09 Sep 2006

thoughts a person has while making food affect the food. teh food affects a person spiritually, giving a nudge or push towards a person's spirituality in the positive or negative direction. this is why sikhs try to exercises bibek or vivek - it is known as discerning wisdom. someone whose mind is poisoned is more likely to make food that is spiritually poisoning, someone whose mind is pure is more likely to make food that nudges a person towards spirituality. i've experienced this myself. eating food made by a very high spiritual level person made my concentration in meditation better. and vice versa. it also affects how much bad thoughts a person has. a person who is not sensitive to this stuff will probably not notice. I never noticed a long time ago. now i do. sensitiviity is built up over time. it is not a matter of who is bad or who is good, it is a matter of what is better for our spirituality.

Re: confused

**** · 10 Sep 2006

"That is so true but in reality we don't know where the money in the golak is coming from. I know for a fact that lots of the "respectable" members of the community do some seriously shifty stuff and they still make big donations." True. Therefore this is another one of the good reasons to keep bibek. There are rare gurughars who take precaution of this kind of stuff. If the running member/sevadars of the gurughar are bibeki then one doesn't need any other explanation.

Re: confused

M B Singh · 11 Sep 2006

All are equal; equal to participate in Guru's way of life. They need love , respect, services-------every thing we have; but we have something; given by GURU; given to us personally, out of HIS LOVE for us; we have to perserve that. We have reservations to keep that intact. All can sit with me; yet I am special. I am of GURU. I am taught to die for them; but not allow to let them dilute me. [%sig%]