Re: confused
Seeker of the Truth · 04 Sep 2006
I am NOT an AKJ/Tapoban Sikh, but here's the link that I think will answer your question:
http://www.tapoban.org/langar.htm
Re: confused
Balpreet Singh · 07 Sep 2006
The question is not of higher or lower. The question is not of "outcasts". The question is only of Guru Sahib's hukam and working to enhance spiritual jeevan.
Bibek (eating food cooked in sarbloh by amritdharis reciting naam/bani) is an essential rehit. Just the way amrit was prepared by the punj pyaaray, a Gursikh tries to replicate this with every meal. The vibration given by the sarbloh and the naam helps jap more naam.
The original maryada for langar was that everyone eats together but the food is prepared according to bibek and seva is done by bibeki Gursikhs. Later this has been changed. Does it appeal to the mind to think that people who drink/smoke or fornicate are doing langar seva and preparing the food? This person may eat in the langar and is given as much respect as any one else, but they do not qualify for this seva.
Most of us agree that degh seva should only be done by amritdharis. We all agree that amrit sinchaar seva is certainly restricted to amritdharis. Is this discrimination? No. It's just the reality that the person who is capable of the seva should do it. These Gursikhs have naam vibration from amrit and thus they qualify. If an "amritdhari" does not keep any rehit or jap naam then they too don't qualify for langar or degh seva.
It's about enhancing jeevan, not discriminating.
Re: confused
Balpreet Singh · 07 Sep 2006
...,
Your post is an excellent example in support of keeping bibek.
If food is food then certainly the delicacies offered by Malik Bhago (the rich man not a King though) would have been nutritionally superior to the food prepared by Bhai Lalo. Certainly then, if Bibek doesn't matter, Guru Sahib should've eaten the better food.
But here it has been illustrated that the person cooking the food does make a difference. If the person cooking is immoral then that food is unacceptable. Do you know who cooks your food if you go to a restaurant? It could be a criminal or someone completely without morals. Unfortunately at our Gurdwaras, we have no checks on who prepares the food anymore. Smokers and drinkers are welcome to help cook.
But as the story you posted illustrates, Bhai Lalo (a Sikh of Guru Sahib incidentally and directly addressed by some Shabads of Guru Nanak) made simple food with bani and naam and that was approved but the food of Malik Bhago was not accepted regardless of how tasty or nutritious it would have been.