Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

What should A GURSIKH do?

What should A GURSIKH do?

TAT · 05 Sep 2006

I will present you with 3 scenarios, plz tell me what you think a Gursikh would do in these situations. What stays the same in evryone is that you are a Singh or Singhnee walking down the street and you are carrying a sharp, fully usable, 9" kirpan under your clothes. Scenario A: As you are walking, you are approached by a large group of unknown strangers, they tell you to give them your money and your phone. They are all unamred, however seem to be of considerable strenght. What do you, as a Gursikh do? Scenario B:Same as scenario A, however instead of a group of people, it is only one person, however is much stronger than you. Scenario C:This time, the mugger is armed with a knife, and he is not afraid to use it. Also, plz do mention whether your answers would be different if u were wearing a different size of kirpan, possibly smaller, 5"-7" etc. or bigger like 1 foot.

Re: What should A GURSIKH do?

Kirtan Lover · 06 Sep 2006

Give then your money your phone... and walk away then tell the police! I would NOT use my kirpan, unless my life or anothers was at threat.

Re: What should A GURSIKH do?

**** · 06 Sep 2006

Instinctively i think many gursikhs may not want to give in to a situation like that. I suppose you would refuse. If such people are not willing to give up through talking they will obviously start causing physical violence and if serious harm is to be caused upon yourself then maybe i don't know, you never know you could end up using it. Maybe other gursikhs have better to say. I too would like to read some more views.

Re: What should A GURSIKH do?

Dalbiri · 06 Sep 2006

What is the point of carrying a kirpan and letting people walk all over you?? Forget the kirpan if that is your issue, pick up something else you can use and smack them over the head with it a few times until they learn not to disrespect Sikhs like that. I had a friend who has a pagh but isn't religious at all (he trims beard). On some quite street a big guy came over to him and told him to empty his pockets, that guy had a knife. X grabbed his hand and stuck the blade in the guys thigh, then punched him in his face a few times. But he is a pretty strong dude (although he doesn't look it). Sometimes he uses his sulaee (needle that he uses to put his hair in his pagh), in emergency situations like that. Isn't a Sikh who is scared to fight, like that khota with a tiger skin on him in the sakhi. You shouldn't even wear bana if you can't knock out a few teeth in my opinion. Put it in context, when Guru Gobind Singh Ji made the Khalsa, he was looking for fighters not hippies.

Re: What should A GURSIKH do?

singh13 · 07 Sep 2006

lol funny but such a true reply "dalbiri" we should b doing more on a personal basis to become fighters and not just b hippies :D

Re: What should A GURSIKH do?

Simple Singhani · 08 Sep 2006

yh thats true. We are meant to be saint soldiers... but another thing we should not do is knock everyone out! haha. shouldn't we know when to be a saint and when to be a soldier? Try your best not to knock the guy i say.. but if things start getting ugly.. what else can u do? If i were in that position i would try to fight with fists and everything first.. rather than reach straight for my kirpan. bhull chuk maaf vaheguroo jee ka khalsa vaheguroo jee kee fateh Simple singhani

Re: What should A GURSIKH do?

SomeSingh · 09 Sep 2006

even if you have a kirpan, are in good shape, and are well trained in its use, you could still be seriously injured in a fight even if the opponent only has basic or no training in weapons. even a not very deep wound can be serious depending on where it goes in. why risk your life for pieces of coloured paper? if they don't have a weapon (they may have one under clothes) it's still a dangerous situation. ultimately, the choice is up to you.

Re: What should A GURSIKH do?

Dalbiri · 09 Sep 2006

Author: SomeSingh Date: 09-09-06 14:57 even if you have a kirpan, are in good shape, and are well trained in its use, you could still be seriously injured in a fight even if the opponent only has basic or no training in weapons. even a not very deep wound can be serious depending on where it goes in. why risk your life for pieces of coloured paper? if they don't have a weapon (they may have one under clothes) it's still a dangerous situation. ultimately, the choice is up to you. -------------------------- Whatever else cowardly behaviour is not part of Sikhi. I'm just saying that if we are meant to be sant-sipahi and we can't handle little altercations, then what good would we be in lifes greater battles. In the past Sikhs managed to avoid alot of trouble by building a great reputation for themselves as warriors. They made moghuls and Afghans fearful of entering Panjab such was their reputation. We maybe need to build something like that up again? Just a thought. I think Sikh reluctance to face up to challenges as such is partially responsible for alot of our issues. Like Muslims blatantly targeting Sikh girls to convert in the U.K., not long ago they would not dare to even try this but because the sipahi side of Sikhi being played down they now feel confident enough to do this. This is what I think anyways.

Re: What should A GURSIKH do?

SomeSingh · 10 Sep 2006

I think Sikh reluctance to face up to challenges as such is partially responsible for alot of our issues. Like Muslims blatantly targeting Sikh girls to convert in the U.K., not long ago they would not dare to even try this but because the sipahi side of Sikhi being played down they now feel confident enough to do this. --------------------- I agree. We should definitely face up to challenges. I am not advocating cowardice, nor am I advocating running from challenges. But when it comes to a matter of fighting armed thugs for a few dollars, there may be no point. We should not avoid khas challenges, but this example is just a minor thing that imo has little to do with sikhi. But I definitely am not advocating cowardice.