Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Caste, Hindu, Muslims and Banda Singh Bahadur

Caste, Hindu, Muslims and Banda Singh Bahadur

Dalbiri · 05 Sep 2006

This is from a manuscript completed in 1734 by Mohammad Shafi Warid. ------------------------------------------ After the death and defeat of Wazir Khan (who oversaw the execution of the two younger sahibzaaday) and the sack of Sirhind. Sirhind became the seat of that evil sect, they sent forces to the surrounding tracts and destroyed the families of those who had not bent their heads in obedience to them from older times. Whether Muslim or Hindu, everyone who was not enrolled amongst his followers was put to the sword by those cruel men. Since the cruelty of that man (Banda) has been mentioned by this truthful pen, it is meet some lines are written about his habits and manners...After the slaying of Wazir Khan he laid down that of Hindu or Muslims, whoever became enrolled amongst his Sikhs, should be of one body and take their meal together so that the distinction in honour between the lowly and well-born was entirely removed and all achieved mutual unison, acting together. A sweeper of spittle sat with a raja of great status, and they felt no hostility to each other. He (Banda) thus initiated numerous innovations and strange practices and put them to effect.. WJKK WJKF

Re: Caste, Hindu, Muslims and Banda Singh Bahadur

Dalbiri · 06 Sep 2006

This is from page 161 of "Sikh History from Persian Sources" Edited by J.S.Grewal and Irfan Habib. Grewal is a GOI guy, so it is unlikely to be "concocted" to suit the Khalistan agenda. In fact the publication costs for the book were met by the Anandpur Sahib Foundation, and Department of Culture, Goverment of India, as clearly stated on the opening pages of the book. In fact the Indian History Congress are actually respensible for initiating the project so you can forget the Khalistani bogeymen theory. Whilst we are on the topic Chandra, recently you posted a long extract in the form of an English translation from Khafi Khan's Persian manuscript. You also added a link to a very interesting site with translations of Persian works claiming that the work was there, when I looked I couldn't find it. Could you resolve this please.

Re: Caste, Hindu, Muslims and Banda Singh Bahadur

Dalbiri · 06 Sep 2006

Chandra, here is another extract from the above mentioned source. This time it's Khafi Khan talking about Banda Singh. The manuscript was completed in 1731. --------------------------------- (Siege of Lohgarh) The wretched chief of that sect (Banda) accompanied by his error tending, doomed followers, whom wealth seeking as well as deep faith had bound to that eternally misled one, incited and encouraged his followers to fight and resist with such fables and inducements as that whoever is killed in this battle will without delay in the very form, whether bearded or beardless, in which he dies, return and attain further progress in the stages of worldly life. Those persons who regarded the statement of their spiritual leader and chief in the matter of transmigration of souls (which is condemned by all scripture believing God praying faiths) as absolutely proved, lent their ears in agreement. Coming out of the fort with all alarcity, enthusiam and inclination, they raised the cry of "Fateh Darshan" and "Sacha Padshah" at the time of battle, and like insects threw themselves madly and bravely upon the fire of artillery and the edge of the sword and the tips of arrows and spears. They launched such rank shaking assaults on imperial entrenchments, and every day many were killed. Some Muslims also earned the eternal merit of martyrdom. Although from the lower castes of Hindus, countless people like ants and locusts had gathered around him (Banda) and lost no time in getting killed or coming to battle for his sake, yet they did not harm such Hindus of high status as Khatris of the Punjab, who were colluding in the plans and designs of that rebel (Banda), or Jats famous for their bravery, who were supporting and joining the army of that doomed one. All remaining Hindus, along with Muslims they regarded as deserving to be killed. To all observers of military conflicts it is apparent that in most armies, among two ot three thousand horsemen, if there are one or two hundred who are brave and loyal to the extent of sacrificing their lives, this becomes the cause of the honour and victory of that army. In contrast was this wretched sect, which despite most of them being foot soldiers, there was hardly anyone amonst them, either horse or foot, who did not consider being killed in the path of their spiritual leader (murshid) as his own greatest wish and aspiration. This reason and their greed for wealth, precious goods and jewels, which came to their hand through plunder, became a fresh factor for the success and triumph of those beggardly, doomed men. Ordinary people of little faith attributed it to magic and sorcery practised by that sect.

Re: Caste, Hindu, Muslims and Banda Singh Bahadur

santbirsingh · 07 Sep 2006

just how does the quote about Shaheed Baba Banda Singh Bahadur suppport a "khalistani agenda", and what does that mean exactly?

Re: Caste, Hindu, Muslims and Banda Singh Bahadur

Ek_singh · 07 Sep 2006

Persian sources are nothing but bashing of Baba Banda Singh Bhadhur as they wanted to defame his personality. All these rumours to defame this great Khalsa were spread with a help of Tat Khalsa. You can read more at http://www.sikhnet.com/sikhnet/discussion.nsf/SearchView/3D91C4436C8A1DC78725702B005CA157!OpenDocument [%sig%]

Re: Caste, Hindu, Muslims and Banda Singh Bahadur

Dalbiri · 08 Sep 2006

Ek Singh, I read that link, I think that it was poorly presented and not very convincing. I wholeheartedly agree that many Persian accounts will naturally be biased against Banda or Sikhs in general but to discount all of their contents as false is wrong. They are still valuable sources of information reagrding Sikh history although a discriminative eye must be used to analyse them.