Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Bend It Like Beckham

Bend It Like Beckham

shere punjab · 07 Sep 2006

I had just watched the movie for the first time today, Its about a sikh family yet the movie doesn't do a to good of a job for the sikh image and believe it does more harm then any good I was just wondering what everyone elses views are about the movie

Re: Bend It Like Beckham

Kirtan Lover · 07 Sep 2006

I agree... but then what more do you accept from Gurinder Chadda... It reinforces positively ... go and do as you want... your parent will come round to the idea .. or get used to it.

Re: Bend It Like Beckham

kharkoo · 07 Sep 2006

The film bored me!

Re: Bend It Like Beckham

Dalbiri · 07 Sep 2006

Gurinder Chaddha, the muj, probably didn't get any attention from Sikh guys and resents it. Apparently she is married to a half white-half Japanese dude. The film made me sick, typical crap that westerners promote. Nearly had a fight with a gora in the cinema when it came out, harami was making puking noises when that girl and white boy were kissing. Then he started saying "take that off, it looks silly" when her dad came on screen with a pagh on. Then again have you noticed how those that marry into the west are given a career boast, i.e. Daljit Dhaliwal, Nirpal Dhaliwal, G. Chadha. I think they want to encourage this by making them prominent role models for the rest of us.

Re: Bend It Like Beckham

Lakhvir Singh · 07 Sep 2006

We cannot expect such films to be the voice of Sikhs. For the film-maker and audience, it is nothing more than a subject to entertain. I guess not everyone is as passionate as the others about the faith they profess and portray. The biggest missionary is the self – now there's the power. [%sig%]

Re: Bend It Like Beckham

capone · 07 Sep 2006

i think we are contradicting ourselves as sikhs by ridiculing the director, about sikhi of all things. if shes married to a chinese person thats her own decision, and comments such as her not getting attention from sikh guys shows little understanding of sikhi. as sikhs, we need to be a more constructive in situations like this if we are to make change or any gain. Or else, its [i]ourselves[/i] who are making sikhs look even worse then the people we are criticizing

Re: Bend It Like Beckham

Dalbiri · 07 Sep 2006

I've always said that Sikhs need to grasp and master media such as film simply because this, in this day and age, is the most effective communication medium. We need it not only to teach others about us but also teach our own about their heritage seeing as many to lazy to pick up a book. I think we are getting there, slowly slowly. We can maybe study the Jews and see how they have managed to exert such a strong presence in such media despite being a small community like us.

Re: Bend It Like Beckham

livingforwaheguru · 09 Sep 2006

i agree with dalbiri

Re: Bend It Like Beckham

**** · 09 Sep 2006

never mind the people in the movie being made fun of. How much good are so called sikhs doing when physically showing themselves in cinema theaters. For the rest of the public were making a mockery out of ourselves by sitting in that crowd.

Re: Bend It Like Beckham

Dalbiri · 09 Sep 2006

"For the rest of the public were making a mockery out of ourselves by sitting in that crowd." If you are refering to my post ****, don't worry. I was ready to slap that guy about but his mouth miraculously shut when I went near him. I went to the cinema because my young cousin wanted to watch the film. It was pretty much one of the first films to be made with a strong Sikh presence so I was interested to watch it myself, little did I know about Chadha's agenda. And I didn't just let nazi white boy say that crap without saying stuff back, which I know is not a particularly good thing but at least it let people know all Sikhs are not cowardly hippy types, all sant and zero sipahi, no anakh. Even as I left the screen, some of the other members of the audience (not the white ones but the black people), smiled at me in a friendly way, I think they could understand.

Re: Bend It Like Beckham

Dalbiri · 09 Sep 2006

Chadha's other film (Pride and Prejudice I think) had Aiswariya Rai singing about her gora boyfriend with the Harmandir Sahib in the background of the shot. That is going to far I think. I've seen it before, disgruntled Sikh girls attacking their own roots through media with the support of arty morons, who encourage that type of stuff. How different is that from a Sikh girl throwing her kara in a bin and defaming the Sikh Gurus on stage like at a hUT conference. That Bhatti play (Behzti) can be seen in the same light. Look how much unneccesary hoo-ha that caused. What I think basically happens is that some crafty people of other races make naieve idiots attack their own culture and reward them for it by giving them career boosts.

Re: Bend It Like Beckham

shere punjab · 11 Sep 2006

how can anyone in the caste of bend it like beckam or the producer Chadha call themselves sikhs when they make a movie thats spose to represent sikhs then act like a bunch of morans on screen.

Re: Bend It Like Beckham

shere punjab · 11 Sep 2006

Why havn't any of the sikhs in the uk done anything to bring up the humilation this movie put on sikhs.

Re: Bend It Like Beckham

shere punjab · 11 Sep 2006

How can anyone involved in that movie call them selves a sikh after insulting us the way they did.

Re: Bend It Like Beckham

Kirtan Lover · 12 Sep 2006

the same was for her fil bhaji on the beach .. the first file she made.

Re: Bend It Like Beckham

Dalbiri · 14 Sep 2006

What about the fact that such things do actually happen. We can't deny that and trying to hide issues were what caused these types of problems in the first place, in my opinion. It wouldn't do to have riots everytime someone from a Sikh background creates what seems to be anti-panthic material. Better still we should ask why they have created it in the first place. What things in our society makes our own people reject their own heritage and actually attack it. Usually it is either another culture gaining a FULL influence in their mind or some deep seated resentment from some perceived (real or unreal) mistreatment at the hands of their own people. That liberals will encourage distent is something we should take for granted but we should be very careful to be an inclusive, understanding and caring community. This would result in such things not taking place. Shere Punjab, Sikhs in the U.K. have a world of issues that they have to deal with already and it isn't like they don't protest when things go too far (i.e. Behzti). You lot want to read a book called Tourism by Nirpal Dhaliwal, which is a best seller. If you think those films were bad, this would make your head explode. Again, we don't want to get fundamentalist and perhaps a little freedom is in order. We need more reaching out, not anger to my mind. We have to capture the hearts of youth whilst they are young. I meet lots of people disgruntled at the Sikh community because of caste, patriarchy, hypocrisy and a general pervasive supercillious attitude that many Sikhs have. But once we have real love for our own people in our hearts and can be forgiving and compassionate they will learn to love their roots.

Re: Bend It Like Beckham

Damandeep Singh · 19 Sep 2006

Totally right Veer ji [%sig%]

Re: Bend It Like Beckham

Heart · 21 Sep 2006

Vahegurujeekakhalsa Vahegurujeekeefateh I personally thought the movie had its main conflict and resolvement. However, i thought the way they presented a 'sikh' family was not right. A sikh of the guru would never induldge of wine other than the wine of love eraptured from naam. A sikh of the guru would never become involved with lust. It could have been made better than it was.. anyways. [%sig%]

Re: Bend It Like Beckham

SomeSingh · 22 Sep 2006

the family was very much like many punjabi families today. only the cultural stuff was exaggerated in this film. that's the version of sikhi that these people claim to believe in. they have no idea what true sikhi is. it's just something that forms the backgrounds in their lives, in a distorted way.

Re: Bend It Like Beckham

Dalbiri · 23 Sep 2006

Is it just me being paranoid or are goray trying to erode Sikh identity through media? I notice how they love to promote anti-Sikh former Sikhs. The only other accepted visible Sikh personality I see on TV is that big Scottish guy, Bhupinder Kohli. I think he is the acceptable face of Sikhs for these people, you know, friendly, non-controversial like a "giant teddy bear" as one girl put it.

Re: Bend It Like Beckham

A Singh · 27 Sep 2006

Well from concept point of view the film was good, especially if we talk about the father and daughter relationship. In fact it was very well portrayed. But coming the presenting the Sikh culture it sounds to be distorted with Punjabi culture. As a film maker Gurinder Chaddha tries to play safe here, in other to make the film acceptable to Punjabi masses. I feel that people from the Sikh community should try to take more such initiatives in the correct deception of the Sikh image. Or else the damage to the coming generation will be severe.

Re: Bend It Like Beckham

shere punjab · 16 Oct 2006

I do not understand why she would use a sikh family and claim they represent sikhism in the movie when she could not be further from the truth.