Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Spiritual but Not Religious?

Spiritual but Not Religious?

pssandhu_99 · 14 Sep 2006

Is there some thing called 'Spiritual but not religious '? I read it many times and heard too ..when people and sad to say some times mostly Sikhs too give evidence of this to feel escapism to easy way of life than the protocols advised by Gurus.

Re: Spiritual but Not Religious?

vaheguru1 · 15 Sep 2006

vaheguru, wow your post really made me think..the differences between being religious and being "spiritual". its true that sikhi is described as being a spritual path as oppose to a religous one...and i actualy have to agree with this statement, but not in the way that "sikhs" have used it as an easy way out. a religion is characteristic of having to follow certain rituals.. now youve mentioned protocols that have been advised by the gurus and i dont think these fit into the bracket of rituals..or religion. isnt it true that the reason gurunanakdevji said that there is no hindu or musalman...that he wanted to abolish the idea that "religion and rituals" is the path to god. i think the protocols advised by the gurus are to help us ont he path of spiritualism.no? and isnt the gurus "religion", actualy the religion of "no religion"...if you get what i mean in gurbani guruji says sagalae karam dhharam jug sodhhae || I have studied the religions and rituals of all the ages. bin naavai eihu man n prabodhhae || Without the Name, this mind is not awakened. and sagal mathaa(n)th kaeval har naam || The essence of all religion is the Lord's Name alone. maharaj says karam dhharam sabh ba(n)dhhanaa paap pu(n)n sanaba(n)dhh || Rituals and religions are all just entanglements; bad and good are bound up with them. i dont know if im totally of track here but it would be interesting to know what other gursikhs think sorry for any mistakes.....

Re: Spiritual but Not Religious?

Lakhvir Singh · 15 Sep 2006

The 'protocol' word is not appropriate in its use with the Guru's instructions. The word 'protocol', according to the dictionary is "diplomatic formality, precedence, and etiquette" – too formal. Sikhi is a way of life. So, in my humble opinion, the matter of this discussion could be rephrased to: 'Is the way of the Guru (Gurmat) a way of religion or of spirituality?' I consider myself a complete moorakh, lacking wisdom or any knowledge to lay claims on whether I should be religious or spiritual. Guru Nanak started a new way of life, a life that was attached to the Name and Praise of Akaal Purakh. That's how simple Sikhi can be defined. Sikhi, as instructed by our Gurus, is the way of the Guru and I couldn't categorise Sikhi as either spiritual or religion. I only understand it as the way my Guru has selected for me to help me merge into my Divine Husband Lord. [%sig%]

Re: Spiritual but Not Religious?

baba jee · 15 Sep 2006

"spiritual but not religious" is the worst excuse for athiesm i have ever heard. all the gorae these days, "im spiritual but im not religious" it means they get high and like to feel like they are accomplishing some sort of spiritualism and want to make excuses for amoral behaviour by forgetting about moralistic religion and then feeling like they are somewhere when all they did was pump chemicals into their brain.. another form is the yoga ones who just sit in silence and clear their mind and call this meditation, it is a form of meditation, but again, it is personal and does not effect any spiritual realm or getting to god.

Re: Spiritual but Not Religious?

**** · 15 Sep 2006

Veerji baba jee pls could you explain one thing. Why is you more or less always have to show yourself or portray yourself through writing as a very defensive type of personality. One is only trying to have a conversation amongst sangat and read their views but you just seem to always exagurate on your lines of opinion. Veerji this is not me trying to throw harsh words in your face. But please ponder upon it.

Re: Spiritual but Not Religious?

SomeSingh · 15 Sep 2006

imo, it's the exact same thing. In Sikhi, we call it dharm, there is no separate word for the two as far as i'm aware. unfortunately, manmat has creeped into other religions. this karmkhand is passed of as religion, but it is just ritualism. that is why ppl see the two as different. i see it as more of a matter of terminology than anything else. although sometimes it's a matter of a seroius lack of understanding, or just an excuse to not follow dharm.

Re: Spiritual but Not Religious?

dattaswami · 16 Sep 2006

Religion Vs Spirituality Every Religion in this world wants you to get rid of bad qualities at least from today for the admission into that religion which is practically impossible. The reason is that these bad qualities were grown like hills for the past millions of births. This small human life is insufficient even to move them, not to speak of removing them. People can control the bad qualities to some extent by their efforts. These bad qualities are frequently sparking in the minds of even the most pious sages. If one says that he is good and he is devoid of all the bad qualities, it only cheating others, which in turn is cheating oneself. Due to this practically impossible condition, for the religious admission, people have developed allergy towards any religion because the eligibility for admission is impractical. The religious preachers have confused the whole situation by fusing religion and spiritualism. Religion is the context of GOD to establish peace and justice in this world. In this context, you must control your bad qualities so that you will not disturb the peace and justice and will not harm any good person in this world. If you disturb the world by your bad qualities, God will punish you. But, in this context, it is sufficient if you control the bad qualities since you cannot remove them. The Religion ends here. Some religions strictly end here without any spiritualism. The spiritualism is the context in which you have to make efforts to reach God. In this context, you need not even control your bad qualities because, God has no personal objection towards your bad qualities. These bad qualities cannot be obstacles in any manner in this context. Moreover, when you turn these bad qualities towards the God, they become your helpers. Any quality whether good or bad, is created by God only to help you in reaching Him. If you realize the original aim of all these qualities, good or bad, why should you control these qualities, which are with you as a helper? No fool controls his helpers. So, any quality when involved in spiritualism is used for its original aim, it becomes a good quality. So all your qualities become good in spiritualism and you need not put any effort to remove or even control them. When the qualities are not used for their original purpose, they become bad qualities. Therefore, whatever qualities turned towards the world, are bad qualities. In this spiritualism, there is no need of any effort even to control these bad qualities. Then, for what, our effort should be made? Our effort should be concentrated to achieve “Bhakthi” which is the love on God. “Bhakthi” is achieved and is grown by the knowledge of God. For example, you came to know that Bombay City exists. This is the knowledge of existence of Bombay. By this you want to see Bombay. As you know the details of Bombay more and more, your desire to see the city becomes more and more. Knowing details about the Bombay City is again the further knowledge. So, knowledge is directly proportional to desire. First Rukmini heard that there is Lord Krishna on this earth. As she heard more and more about Lord Krishna from Sage Narada, her love on Krishna increased enormously. Narada means he who gives knowledge. Therefore, ‘Jnana”(knowledge) generates and develops “Bhakthi (devotion)”. Due to Bhakthi, the Lord is attained. Gita says the same ‘ONLY BY BHAKTHI I AM ATTAINED’ (‘Bhaktya………’). In the spiritual path all your effort must be concentrated in acquiring the knowledge of God day by day. Once this knowledge based Bhakthi (devotion) is achieved, your qualities good or bad are immaterial. Whatever may be the vessel, the drink in it is important. The value paid in a hotel is for the drink only. If you have taken a cup of coffee, you are paying the cost of the coffee only whether the cup is made of glass or metal. Similarly, God gives value only for your Bhakthi and not for your quality. I will give a beautiful example here. “Sabari” is with good qualities and offered fruits to the Lord Rama who is Vishnu. A hunter called “Kannappa” gave flesh to the Lord Siva. Sabari reached the ‘World of Vishnu and Kannappa reached the World of Shiva”. Both have reached the same Lord because Veda says, “Shiva is Narayana”. Both of them have been given the similar value by the Lord because in both cases, the intensity of the devotion is the same as both gave even their food without eating. Therefore, this proves clearly that the Lord has no objection for your bad qualities. Hence, all the effort should be only to achieve and increase the intensity of love devotion or Bhakthi on God. It is not necessary to bother about your qualities that are inherent coming from millions of births. They are the born qualities. The tail of the dog is curved. Any effort cannot make it straight. By force, we can keep it straight but it has not become straight. Similarly you can control your bad qualities for not disturbing peace of the world by some force. When you come to God, you come in your natural state because you can deceive the world showing that your banded tail is straight but not the God. Whether the river comes in straight path or curved path, the ocean receives only the water with equality. Similarly, God receives your love irrespective of your quality. He received “Sabari” and ‘Kannappa” equally. Sabari with good qualities and Kannappa with bad qualities reached the same Lord, as their devotion is of same intensity. A piece of gold is wrapped in an old cloth. A stone is wrapped with a metallic foil. Which has more total value? Similarly, the love with high intensity covered even by a bad quality has more total value than the love with lesser intensity covered by a good quality. When the blood flew from the eye of the Lord, the Priest who is a person with good qualities is trying to apply the medicine. But, his devotion is less. In the same situation, “Kannappa” plucked his eyes and donated to the Lord. Kannappa is a person with bad qualities but his devotion is the highest. Devotion is the highest good quality. Now let us evaluate the total cost of the priest and Kannappa. The devotion in Kannappa is +100. The bad qualities in Kannappa are –10. The total cost is +90. The priest with good qualities is +10. The devotion in him is +20. The total cost is +30. So, of the two who is good? Obviously it is Kannappa. Gita says, that, “Even the worst is best by Bhakthi” (Api chet….). Therefore, what is the eligibility for the admission into our religion of Guru Datta? The eligibility is that you should be a living being. Even animals and birds are eligible to reach God irrespective of their qualities. Even serpent, spider and the elephant got salvation in Sri Kala Hasthi. The serpent has all bad qualities. God did not insist the serpent to get rid of all the bad qualities. Even if God says, the serpent is unable to understand put the efforts. When such a serpent is eligible, why not a man? All the people are depressed and dejected with the eligibility conditions stipulated by various religions. For example if an Institution stipulates the eligibility condition as that one should remove his head and come, nobody can be admitted. Similarly the religions stipulate the removal of all the bad qualities, which is impossible. Only a temporary control is possible which is necessary for you to live in this world with peace. This control is possible. In our religion also we are stipulating this condition, which is possible. So, in our Datta religion, the eligibility condition is that if your bad qualities do not disturb the world, the Lord has no personal objection to them and you need not even control them. Moreover, they will help you in spiritualism. How to turn the bad qualities towards God and make them helpers in reaching the God? There are six bad qualities that are inherent in any living being since millions of births. They are Lust (kama), Anger (krodha), Greediness (Lobha), ego (mada), Blind attraction (Moha) and Jealousy (Matsarya). Anger, greediness, ego and jealousy come under Rajas quality. Lust and blind attraction come under Tamas quality. I give you an example to divert your bad qualities towards the Lord, which can be used as powerful vehicles. Example:- Love in cinema songs can be diverted to the Lord by little change in words. Then, the powerful tune that created sweet feelings in you is now a powerful vehicle to make you to reach the Lord. A film song ‘Churaliya Tumne ……’) instead of ‘Sanam’ replace the word with ‘Hare’. All the sweetness of your mind is now on the Lord Krishna (Vishnu). See how a person, mad after cinema songs become a powerful devotee in his own way without any change! You can sing this as your prayer for which you need not put any effort by force. Your worship should be natural and spontaneous, which alone can be true. Anil Antony