Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

should or should not a sikh do this

should or should not a sikh do this

**** · 14 Sep 2006

vaheguru ji ka khalsa vaheguru ji ki fateh ji There is something i have been thinking about from the past few days. If you, some how, associate with or other people, who have faith in god however, are not very religious and participate in manmat stuff i.e. eat meat, alcohol, cut hair etc... If someone like as such ever asks for a sikh to do a prayer for them like path in turns for their betterment, their sukh, that could be anything work related, health etc... What should or should not a sikh do. The problem is, if your helping them less their problems, they would only continue carrying on with their daily manmat acts. If it's work they will persue consuming meat and alcohol with the barkat (profits/earnings)and if its their health the same applies. I don't mean to sound harsh or anything in regards to my comments. But please do contribute with your thoughts too. Guru Tegh Bhadur ji gave his life away for the betterment of hindus on the request of the kashmiri pandits. They obviously practised many rituals opposite to gurmat. Yet didn't do as the above. There are probably more things to put in perspective than what i have just mentioned. This is why i ask sangat to give their views. vaheguru ji ka khalsa vaheguru ji ki fatehji

Re: should or should not a sikh do this

Dalbiri · 14 Sep 2006

All amritdharis should keep the story of Guru Gobind Singh Ji and Bhai Joga (I think that was his name). When Bhai Joga went to do "manmat" things, in this case seeing a prostitute, Guru Gobind Singh Ji prevented him. Importantly, afterwards he did not disown him for his weakness. If you do not have love for your fellow Sikh brothers and sisters despite their weaknesses than are you may be in danger of using your spirituality or amrit as a ego enhancer rather than an ego destroyer. What I mean by this is using it make yourself better than others hence my use of the term ego-enhancer. What would you prefer in your above example, that he loses his health and suffers or has more problems? Does that seem Sikhlike to you? Maybe if you did pray for him and added an extra bit to ask that he move closer to Sikhi as well, it would be better? Just food for thought Bhai ji, no disrespect whatsoever intended. Its just some thoughts that came into my mind also.

Re: should or should not a sikh do this

Harinder Singh · 15 Sep 2006

<> So true. There are many many sikhs involved in manmukh activities who can be made gursikhs. Baba Jarnail Singh Ji khalsa was so good in it because he had power of word.

Re: should or should not a sikh do this

Khalsa Kaur · 15 Sep 2006

SSA to all, Please visit www.thelivingtreasure.org discussion forum. You will find reply of your querries. Gurbani teaches you to be a good human being and this is what our first Guru taught. Khalsa Kar [%sig%]

Re: should or should not a sikh do this

singh5 · 15 Sep 2006

I know that many Gursikhs have said that doing ardaas for other people without any vichaar on who they are and what they're doing is a bad idea and takes your kamaiee. Personally I think that if you've said to someone you'll pray for them you've given your word and you should do it. Keeping your bachan is important. My suggestion is that if you want to help someone then the best thing is to do a japji sahib and then ardaas that Guru Sahib help that person "gurmat anusaar" or according to Gurmat.

Re: should or should not a sikh do this

**** · 15 Sep 2006

"I know that many Gursikhs have said that doing ardaas for other people without any vichaar on who they are and what they're doing is a bad idea and takes your kamaiee. Personally I think that if you've said to someone you'll pray for them you've given your word and you should do it. Keeping your bachan is important. My suggestion is that if you want to help someone then the best thing is to do a japji sahib and then ardaas that Guru Sahib help that person "gurmat anusaar" or according to Gurmat." Dhanvad for confirming that. That is exactly what i had in mind.

Re: should or should not a sikh do this

Dalbiri · 15 Sep 2006

Sorry, I sort of took it for granted that at least some words would be exchanged about moving towards to a better lifestyle to the person. Not in a condescending way but with pyaar, humilty and pure intentions. People most definitely shouldn't doing ardaas for people for petty things like it was some magic incantation that will fulfil your wishes. Better still to tell them to lead as good a life as they can and pray for strength to face their challenges.