Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Reforms at Sri Darbar Sahib Amritsar?

Reforms at Sri Darbar Sahib Amritsar?

singh5 · 18 Sep 2006

This is a sensitive topic and my intentions are not to idley criticize. 1) Ardaas and Jaikara: In every Gurdwara Sahib I know of, ardaas is preceeded by "too(n) thakur..." and then is proceeded by the dohiraa and a jaikaraa. Why are these not done at Darbar Sahib? Some people say this is the "maryada" there but who created this maryada? I don't think it was Guru Sahib? It seems like the old mahant maryada. I think it's a shame that "Raj Karega Khalsa..." isn't recited at Darbar Sahib. Another argument is that while Akal Takhat Sahib is Miri, Darbar Sahib is Piri and that's why these things aren't done there. But as we know, Miri and Piri are not separated or segregated in Sikhi so why here? 2) Who can do seva: I don't want to rake up an old issue but I find it odd that a mona can lift the palki sahib but not a Gursikh bibi? Once again people rely on 'maryada' but who made this maryada? 3) Degh: why do we tolerate the [i]selling[/i] of degh? Why is it that any smoker/drinker or anyone else can handle the degh and carry it to the sevadaars and they can then distribute it to the general sangat? Akal Takhat Sahib was asked whether non-Sikhs can do degh seva and they replied that it was not acceptable. But here non-Sikhs can handle the degh and no one questions it? 4) Langar: like the degh seva, the preparation of langar is done by paid sevadaars. I believe it is also written on a sign outside the langar that this seva is reserved for amritdharis. So why is it that when 'special guests' come, they do photo-ops while doing this seva? I have seen photos of movie actresses and politicians making rotis. What do they know of the maryada? A side note is that the sevadaars themselves often don't know or care about maryada. A Singh who does seva at the langar (as a paid employee) told me that all the employees are amritdhari but many don't even do ishnaan in the morning before coming to the seva, let alone nitnem. These are just my observations and I could be wrong. We often hold out Darbar Sahib as an ideal and that is a good thing, but we sould not let this stop us from bringing about necessary changes where they are needed.

Re: Reforms at Sri Darbar Sahib Amritsar?

Kulbir Singh · 18 Sep 2006

Excellent points. Its about time the old mahant maryada mentioned in points 1 and 2 be abolished and Gurmat Maryada be established. [%sig%]

Re: Reforms at Sri Darbar Sahib Amritsar?

Balpreet Singh · 19 Sep 2006

Pictures like this (Jack Straw) are taken by celebrities quite often. I find it quite inappropriate.

Re: Reforms at Sri Darbar Sahib Amritsar?

Kulbir Singh · 19 Sep 2006

Such langar cannot be classified as "Guru ka Langar". [%sig%]

Re: Reforms at Sri Darbar Sahib Amritsar?

Jaspalkaur · 19 Sep 2006

Out of the majority of sikh population world wide, there would only be a handfull of people to talk against this. As majority of "Amrithdharis" don't have anything against it. Quite often, even Jathas like AKJ, when commandments are given to abhilakis the panj piyar don't even give it the slightest importance to give hukam of only eating from amrithdharis. Well mostly, in some places they may do. I personally don't really like to catagories sikhs as 'jathas' because the hukam is one. We can learn what is right or wrong from guru maharaj and his gursikhs i.e. Rehitnamas.

Re: Reforms at Sri Darbar Sahib Amritsar?

Ravjeet Singh · 26 Sep 2006

I have just returned from Amritsar and would have to agree with these points. Is it true that degh in the morning comes from Baba Sham Singh Dera which is located just out side Darbar Sahib? Another point I found was filming in Sri Harmandir Sahib by Etc Panjabi. During the time of filming so many people go and they spend ages standing staring at the camera. While I was there I found little fights between the SGPC sevadaars and sangats who wanted to sit behind the raagi singhs it was so closte to getting physical at times. Before rehraas the paath when Raagi Singhs sing har jug jug bhagath .... the granthi singhs tell everyone to be quite, no one else but raagi singhs must be herd. Is this some kind of maryada I have no knowledge of? With regards to your points of degh and langar I have to agree I think in todays day and age it is very dangerous. There are many other points such as the selling of Chandoha Sahibs of Sri Darbar Sahib by certain Singhs who read Bani at amrit vela. There are many things I herd about with regards to corruption, and even things more extreme which are very disheartening.

Re: Reforms at Sri Darbar Sahib Amritsar?

gupt sinner · 27 Sep 2006

if you look at corruption and negatives thats all you see bhai sahib. just takes the good points, take your laha. the Degh is made in darbar sahib