Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Hawayein, the movie about 1984 riots

Hawayein, the movie about 1984 riots

shere punjab · 19 Sep 2006

I have yet to see this movie but i was wondering if sangat could give me their opinions about the movie.

Re: Hawayein, the movie about 1984 riots

Harinder Singh · 20 Sep 2006

first half is nice in the second half its the same propangda. Whole of the blame was put on Pakistan and sikh "terrorists". Any film released in India can never show complete reality as India is a pseudo democracy.

Re: Hawayein, the movie about 1984 riots

A Singh · 20 Sep 2006

Compared to Hawayein I found Maachis far more appealing. It put the blame on the Punjab Police for creation of terrorism. Indirectly of course blaming the Government for every thing. [%sig%]

Re: Hawayein, the movie about 1984 riots

shere punjab · 21 Sep 2006

I have finally gotton the oppurtunity to watch the movie, i believe it's a pretty good movie, i believe the director does his best trying to make the movie without any prejidice. What are your guy's opinion

Re: Hawayein, the movie about 1984 riots

shere punjab · 21 Sep 2006

I was hoping the sangat could tell me more about these movies.

Re: Hawayein, the movie about 1984 riots

S Singh · 22 Sep 2006

Maachis was more nearer to the truth than Hawayein. Any movie on this issue should be an art movie and not bollywood type commercial movie with all the dancing and songs.

Re: Hawayein, the movie about 1984 riots

A Singh · 24 Sep 2006

I am a fan of the film maker, writer & director of Maachis, Gulzar (Sampooran Singh). Gulzar himself is a Sikh and has the capablility to show the reality on screen. After the success of Maachis, he had indeed offered to make some thing of Sikh Gurus. Unfortunately our community sees such people with disgrace. In 1975 during the emergancy Gulzar had made a film called "Aandhi" which was a direct portraly of Indira Gandhi. The film was banned from screening but released later. Another film maker I admire is Dara Singh, for his contribution in Punjab films based on Sikh history, "Sawaa Lakh Se Ek Ladaaun" is a very well made film, but unfortunately banned by Akalis. [%sig%]

Re: Hawayein, the movie about 1984 riots

Pardeep Singh Bilga · 28 Sep 2006

Yes, agree that any film released in India will not be able to show the WHOLE truth.. but good on Babbu Maan and Amitoje Maan for having the guts to raise the issue at all. We see all the Panjabi singers jumping on the bandwagon of "Shaheed Bhagat Singh/Udham Singh" but when it comes to 1984 nobody will utter a word. They do show some good kharkoos in the film, as played by Babbu Maan and some others, however the film is let down by the demonisation of pro-khalistan militants and also gives the idea that ALL Sikh freedom fighters ONLY joined the battle because tey were forced, i.e. via police harassment- which isn't true at all, because many simply wanted to protect Sikhi from the corrupt and violent forces of that time. [%sig%]

Re: Hawayein, the movie about 1984 riots

sunnybondsingh · 28 Sep 2006

Sat Sri Akal Pardeep Sir, I want an something from you. You had a very great post. Can you please tell me , if not made like hawayein or maachis, how shud the movie on 84 events be? Please give a short story You would be helpfull, as i liked hawayein, but u didnt like it much (as i presume from your post), u have issues, so i want to know, how a director can show the truth and make the movie not a boring documentary... Bhul Chuk Muaf [%sig%]