Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Gujarat clubs Jains, Buddhists with Hindus

Gujarat clubs Jains, Buddhists with Hindus

Mehtab Singh · 20 Sep 2006

http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/articleshow/2007934.cms?headline=Gujarat~clubs~Jains,~Buddhists~with~Hindus GANDHINAGAR: For three years, the Narendra Modi government sat over a Bill seeking to regulate religious conversions, even after it was passed by the Assembly and had the governor’s consent. Nothing came in the way of the law, apart from the chief minister’s own inhibitions to figure exactly how he could further consolidate his image as the Hindutva mascot. Finally, on Tuesday, the Gujarat Assembly passed the Gujarat Freedom of Religion Bill (Amendment) Bill, 2006, with the amendment, coming after three years of conflicting legal opinion being balanced with political and ideological motives. Amid protests by an outnumbered Opposition, the Bill went through, along with an important newly added clause which clubs Jains and Buddhists with Hindus, in the same manner as Shias and Sunnis on one hand and Protestants and Catholics on the other. It virtually means conversions between Jains and Hindus, Buddhists and Jains, and Hindus and Buddhists can happen easily, without government’s permission. More importantly, a Hindu who decides to become a Buddhist, would not be called a convert. Ditto for a Protestant seeking to become a Catholic, or vice versa, and a Sunni becoming a Shia or vice versa. The curbs are on crossing the faith-lines between Hinduism, Christianity and Islam. Surprisingly, Sikhs are not even mentioned in the draft. But if a Hindu wants to become Christian — the main target for Modi — the district magistrate has to be informed first. Christian community leaders are livid that the law is now on the verge of being enforced. "The Bill is extremely draconian and unconstitutional," said Jesuit-activist Father Cedric Prakash, Minister for state for home Amit Shah, who introduced the Bill, said Jainism and Buddhism were "construed as parts of Hinduism". During the discussion on the Bill, an appeal was made by a hardline BJP MLA and former state for home Gordhan Zadaphia, to also club Sikhs with Hindus. It is learnt that the government had indeed toyed with the idea of describing Sikhs as "part of the Hindu family", but dropped the proposal fearing protests. Shah refused to comment on the issue. Arguing that the amendment would not stand legal scrutiny, leader of opposition Arjun Modhvadia said: "Buddhism was given the status of a separate religion by the National Commission for Minorities Act, 1992. As for Jains, they were given the same status by a division bench of the SC in 2004." [%sig%]

Re: Gujarat clubs Jains, Buddhists with Hindus

Seeker of the Truth · 20 Sep 2006

Why can these people leave other religions alone? This is such a dumb bill!

Re: Gujarat clubs Jains, Buddhists with Hindus

S Singh · 20 Sep 2006

Maybe Sikhs should also be thinking about introducing a similar bill in Punjab against the Radhaswami cult which is converting thousands of Sikhs out of Sikhi.

Re: Gujarat clubs Jains, Buddhists with Hindus

Dalbiri · 20 Sep 2006

Where is Chandra? Explain this please. In an earlier post you said this stuff doesn't happen.

Re: Gujarat clubs Jains, Buddhists with Hindus

shere punjab · 21 Sep 2006

whats the Radhaswami cult.

Re: Gujarat clubs Jains, Buddhists with Hindus

Dalbiri · 21 Sep 2006

Still, it is Hindu interference in other religions.

Re: Gujarat clubs Jains, Buddhists with Hindus

Seeker of the Truth · 21 Sep 2006

It's a good thing that Modi left out Sikhs. Oh man, I could picture mad protests all over the world if Modi added Sikhs to his little bill. [%sig%]

Re: Gujarat clubs Jains, Buddhists with Hindus

Sitara · 21 Sep 2006

Dalbiri Jains are closer to Hindus than Sikhs are. In many Gujarati communities you can't distinguish between Jains and Hindus. Even though both Sikhi and Jainism is critical of Hindus, I have more respect for Jains since they argue in a respectful manner unlike many of the Sikhs (who call our rishis morons).

Re: Gujarat clubs Jains, Buddhists with Hindus

S Singh · 21 Sep 2006

Sitara, which Sikh called the Rishis as 'morons'? But I do agree with you that some Sikhs do get a little disrespectful to Hindus and vice versa. Both need to learn some mutual respect and debate in a civilized manner without getting insulting. But still I have yet to come across a Sikhs who called the Rishis as morons.

Re: Gujarat clubs Jains, Buddhists with Hindus

Mehtab Singh · 21 Sep 2006

From what I saw on TV with regard to this latest development, a Buddhist leader is already opposing this bill. Some more taken from http://www.tribuneindia.com/2006/20060921/nation.htm#18 "....[i]Chairman of the All- India Confederation of SC/ST Organisations Udit Raj termed the Bill as a “retrograde step” and would affect the secular fabric of the country. He condemned the clubbing of Buddhists and Jains with Hindus and said there would be widespread protests all over India and that Buddhists and Jains would never accept such a situation[/i]." [%sig%]

Re: Gujarat clubs Jains, Buddhists with Hindus

Dalbiri · 21 Sep 2006

The real for all this is that education is spreading and people have awoken to the lack of rationality and logic of Hinduism. Hinduism doesn't do well in the face of modern thinking, so before everyone jumps ships, clever Hindus are making it difficult to leave. It's like the Berlin wall, you may stop people for a while, soon those walls will come tumbling down.

Re: Gujarat clubs Jains, Buddhists with Hindus

Seeker of the Truth · 21 Sep 2006

<<>> That is so true. This also may explain why a lot of Hindu extremists like to try to convince people that Sikhi is another sect of their religion

Re: Gujarat clubs Jains, Buddhists with Hindus

Sitara · 22 Sep 2006

<> Is that why so many Scientists, Scholars and Philosophers had a very high regard for Hinduism...You just seem to look for any excuse to bash Hinduism

Re: Gujarat clubs Jains, Buddhists with Hindus

Dalbiri · 22 Sep 2006

Abrahmics can only think in terms of tribal ideas & concepts like herds, sheeps, your side and my side etc. This is not spirituality but mob mentality where thousands of blinds club togather and assure each other that they have sight. ------------------------------------------------------------- Yeah yeah, like Hindus weren't slaves in their own country for centuries.....maybe if you learned to club together yourselves we wouldn't have had every Afghan, Moghul and Persian walking in and walking away with the women and wealth. How do you explain this nonsense. When you have to put legislation in to try and stop people converting to other faiths that is a very sorry time indeed.

Re: Gujarat clubs Jains, Buddhists with Hindus

S Singh · 23 Sep 2006

I think that modern day Hinduism may have some very unnecessary rituals which were added during the age of Kaliyug. The original Vedic Dharm which we read about in the Puraan and Mahbharat was good. People back then were much more moral and ethical. The Vedic people in the previous Yugs would spend only the first half of their lives in worldly affairs while the later half they would spent doing Bhagti leaving the world aside. Kingdoms were ruled based on Dharm. Even Bhagats like Dhru and Prahlad lived in the previous Yugs. When wars occurred, civilians were never harmed by the Kshatriyas. This is unheard of even in today’s standards. Corruption of the Vedic Dharm started when Kaliyug started. Vedic Dharm began deviating away from its original pristine form. But even then, Hindu society had high moral and ethics. Degeneration in Hindu society really started when the Muslims invaded India. Hindus living under Muslim occupation began imitating their Muslim rulers. They began lying and cheating like the Muslims. [%sig%]

Re: Gujarat clubs Jains, Buddhists with Hindus

Dalbiri · 23 Sep 2006

Corruption of the Vedic Dharm started when Kaliyug started. Vedic Dharm began deviating away from its original pristine form. But even then, Hindu society had high moral and ethics. Degeneration in Hindu society really started when the Muslims invaded India. Hindus living under Muslim occupation began imitating their Muslim rulers. They began lying and cheating like the Muslims ---------------------------------- Not at all, I read a Hindu account long ago that said in the face of continual defeat at the hands of Islam many Hindus swallowed their pride and became cowardly and syncophantic servants of the Muslim rulers. That is why so many of them were employed by the Moghuls, even when Moghul policy was destroying their temples and taking their women openly from them. They had to do this to survive and this helped shape the national character but luckily for them Angreezis secured them a homeland before they left India and now they experiencing freedom, which they probably couldn't have managed to secure for themselves. You can see this character still in existence in the U.K. where Sikhs and even Pakis would and will fight racist goray in riots, even if they were the police (i.e. Southall in 80's and Bradford more recently). Whereas no Hindu is conspicuous in such frontlining. And then they have the front to make films like "proud to be Indian" which is fictional bullcrap. And what are you talking about. The fundamentals of Hinduism has Gods that sexually frolic with gopis, try to strip girls naked, chop off their own genitalia, run off with women, betray each other and turn against each other, where are the morals in such tales? And the treatment of Shudras and Dalits as enshrined in the religion is disgusting. If we can condemn aparteid and slavery, we should do the same with this which really is no different.

Re: Gujarat clubs Jains, Buddhists with Hindus

Harinder Singh · 23 Sep 2006

One motive of this bill is to stop christian missionaries from converting hindus. Well, the disgraceful activities of these missionaries shud be stopped as these missionaries are buying the conscience of people with money. Secondly, this bill also indicates the current situation of poor hindus who are ready to sell their conscious very easily. The corrupt indian system thats been in practice for 60 years is one of main factors for this moral degenration of people. Thirdly, this bill states budhists and jains as hindus which is very wrong. I feel the hindus have dug a big hole for themselves. Crores of hindus stood for people like Indira Gandhi, admired killers like KP"s"Gill, remained silent during the mass murder of sikhs in 80's and 90's, cracked jokes at sikhs as their time pass and hence have distanced themselves from sikhs, may be forever. The muslims, the christian missionaries and the corrupt hindu ministers are going to eat them now.

Re: Gujarat clubs Jains, Buddhists with Hindus

S Singh · 23 Sep 2006

Dalbiri Jee, I think that if you want to read about authentic Vedic Dharm you need look at what is written in the Upanishads or the Bhagwat Geeta which is essence of Vedic thought. I don’t think that current Hindus have lived up to their heritage. Living under foreign rule for a thousand years first under the Muslims and then under the British has destroyed the moral and ethical character of this society. Now under the rule of Congress party and BJP, the Hindu society is further getting influenced by Kaliyug. Hindus need some Dharmi people to bring them back in line with Dharm.

Re: Gujarat clubs Jains, Buddhists with Hindus

Dalbiri · 23 Sep 2006

Manu wrote a law book which is basically the forefather to the aparteid system. How could a society not reject this outright? They must have seriously lost their dharam a long time ago. Note I'm not saying Sikhs are perfect and those that continue with Manu's caste crap should be castigated heavily. S Singh, Veer, I have some translations of Hindu thought as per Dasam Granth, do you think these are enough to acquaint me with vedic thought or is there more to it?

Re: Gujarat clubs Jains, Buddhists with Hindus

Harinder Singh · 23 Sep 2006

<< think that if you want to read about authentic Vedic Dharm you need look at what is written in the Upanishads or the Bhagwat Geeta which is essence of Vedic thought. I don’t think that current Hindus have lived up to their heritage.>> The word of Gita and Upanishads is still available, hindus are totally free to practice their religion now. Lots of parchar of Gita and Vedas is happening. There are TV channels dedicated for this. Why the word of Gita and Upanishads is not able to awaken the consiousness of hindus now?? How can theives and fraud ministers still continue to rule India?? How can muslim terrorists still continue to terrorise indians ? Why are 80 crore hindus afraid of muslims even now? Do you hear hindus cracking muslim jokes ? On the other hand sikh jokes are a routine for them. Sikhs were denenrated big time after 1850's but once word of Siri Guru Granth Sahib started ringing,there were revolutions and there were sacrifices. Why cant the word of Gita and Upanishads do the same for hindus now? Moreover they are not fighting forein ruleres. They only have to fight their own corrupt government in a highly gloablized and aware world.I have lived most of my 23 years of life in India and I have only seen corruption, selfishness, hypocricy, lying, injustice and cowardness.

Re: Gujarat clubs Jains, Buddhists with Hindus

S Singh · 25 Sep 2006

Dalbiri Jee, The Puraanic tales that are in Dasam Granth are stories of Devi/Devte. That is not philosophy. If you want to read their philosophy then read the Upanishads or the Bhagwat Geeta. There are no stories in those, only pure philosophy. I think that most Sikhs have been exposed to nationalist Dalit literature which is very Hindu phobic in nature. Even many Sikh writers are influenced by them. I’ve even seen some Sikh writers going to the extent of saying that vegetarianism is Brahmanism’s influence on Sikhs and so Sikhs should have no trouble eating meat because it is not against Sikhi. We do have some differences with the Hindus, but go to the extent of ridiculing everything Hindu (even the things in common with us) is just plain ridiculous. The Vedic society of the previous Yugs wasn’t all that bad. All the Bhagat we read about in Gurbani like Dhru, Pralad, Ganika were from those previous great eras, so are we now going to start ridiculing them as well? [%sig%]

Re: Gujarat clubs Jains, Buddhists with Hindus

S Singh · 25 Sep 2006

Harinder Singh Jee, Look at the Sikhs. We have been living under occupation for over 150 years. First under the British and now under the GOI. Sikhs of today are very different from the puraatan Sikhs. Most Sikhs today are hair cutters, rishwat-khoree, untruthful, Sharaab drinkers. Basically 150 years of occupation has turned most Sikhs into Sikhs who indulge into all the 4 Kurahits and 5 Vikaars. This is what 150 years of occupation has done to the Sikhs. Imagine what 1000 years would do to us. Well that’s what happened to the Hindus for 1000 years, and that’s why they are now the way they are.

Re: Gujarat clubs Jains, Buddhists with Hindus

Dalbiri · 25 Sep 2006

Basically 150 years of occupation has turned most Sikhs into Sikhs who indulge into all the 4 Kurahits and 5 Vikaars. ------------------------ This is too simplistic an argument. Sikhs were doing most of this under Maharara Ranjit Singh.

Re: Gujarat clubs Jains, Buddhists with Hindus

Harinder Singh · 25 Sep 2006

Dear S Singh Ji, Many of the bad habits that sikhs got into was during Ranjit "Singhs" rule when sikhs enjoyed sovereignity.It will be pretty unfair to say that degeneration of sikhs is only due to lack of self rule. Moreover in the last 150 years sikhs have launched fierce revolutions and wars. The latest one being 1984 when handful of armed sikhs stopped a nations army for 7 days and then sikhs assasinated a nations PM, a CM , an Army Chief and numerious other dushts. On the other hand, hindus have enjoyed religious freedom for the last 60 years but the indian society has only gone from bad to worse. There is corruption and injustice in almost every sphere of life but still hindus are quite,there is no revolution, no hindu spiritual leader willing to sacrifice himself to fight this out. Even after mass murder of sikh youth in India, one can still find devoted or rehitvaan sikh youth pretty easily in India but it will tough to find devoted staunch hindu youth. I study at a place where people from all over india come. I see devoted sikhs, devoted muslims but hardly see devoted young hindus. Isnt the word of Gita and upanashids powerful enough to awaken few hundred or thousand hindus among 80 crore and may be we can see some mini revolution or sacrifices?? Lacks of kashmiri brahmins who are knowledgable in vedas and Gita etc ran bare foot leaving their houses and properties. None of them fought or got shaheed.None of hindu swamis or spiritual leaders fought for them and attained shaheedi. If we assume that Gita or Upanishads are some special banis, how can a community with such spirtitual resources remain slave for 1000 years without giving much resistance. On the other hand, sikhs fought bravely against britishers, against pakistan in wars and lately against oppression of GOI and attained shaheedi in HUGE numbers.

Re: Gujarat clubs Jains, Buddhists with Hindus

Dalbiri · 25 Sep 2006

Are you going to castigate AKAL as well? ਆਪੇ ਦਸ ਅਠ ਵਰਨ ਉਪਾਇਅਨੁ ਆਪਿ ਬ੍ਰਹਮੁ ਆਪਿ ਰਾਜੁ ਲਇਆ ॥ He Himself created the people of the eighteen castes; God Himself acquired His domain. Or are you going to castigate your Abrahmic outlook and understand the scriptures in proper perspective?. ------------------------------------------- How can I castigate Akal?? Akal created all the people on the earth but caste is a man made thing, not from God but from man (and zulmi ones at that.) Let us by all means problematize Indian/Hindu society and let us work to remedy its flaws. -------------------------------------------------- Yep by going towards a Sikh direction perhaps? Which many Hindus seem to consider a downward step for some reason. But they are happy to have their daughters dancing around in a sequinned bra in a Bollywood film. Progress. "S Singh, Veer, I have some translations of Hindu thought as per Dasam Granth, do you think these are enough to acquaint me with vedic thought or is there more to it?" Here you go. That is why "Ignorance is Bliss". Why don't you start with Manusamriti itself?. --------------------------------------------------------------- I'm trying to understand. But we must also compare the real actions of the people as well as the literature or base of their society (goes for Sikhs as well). Look I don't hate Hindus, but if you don't start to reflect amongst yourselves REAL QUICK, we are all in trouble! Same can be said regarding certain practices in the panth.

Re: Gujarat clubs Jains, Buddhists with Hindus

shere punjab · 16 Oct 2006

that cheif minister of gujarat must be a dumb moran how you stop someone from following what religion they want, you can't stop someone from being a christian if their gonna follow christianity their gonna follow christiaity they can say their hindus yet follow christianity.