Forum
How to improve sikh and hindu relations
How to improve sikh and hindu relations
shere punjab · 15 Oct 2006
I know their bin many problems between sikh and the indian government in the past but i was wondering why are their sikhs who have hate for hindus when are gurus sacirficed themselves to protect them, and what would be strategies to bring the two community's closer rather then have them divide further apart. We have to understand their was wrong things done to eachother from both sides and im pretty sure the indian government does not represent the hindu people. I know it's a really small minority of sikhs who hates hindus but why so much hate towards all of the hindu people when the indian government was responsible for attacking sikhs and operation bluestar was planned by sikh's example is KS brar and the punjabi police were mostly sikhs and kps gill was a sikh, i know these guy's arn't real sikhs but their not hindus either.
Re: How to improve sikh and hindu relations
A Singh · 16 Oct 2006
First of all Gurus never fought for any community as such the way the present time hard liners try to project.
There are many people apart from Hindus belonging to other faiths, have written excellent books or articles on Sikh faith, History, Lives of Gurus, etc. They should be honured by the highest SIKH religious authority.
Once there are people from other faiths speaking in favour of the Sikh religion most of these RSS related activities can be controlled. Plus one should remember majority Indians do not favour such hard liners.
Re: How to improve sikh and hindu relations
Harinder Singh · 17 Oct 2006
I feel the word hindu is wrongly used. There are crores of hindus in India who are in much worse condition than sikhs in their so called own country. Its only the small percentage of brahminical hindu who is anti sikh. The problem is that the remainder hindu is brainwashed by this brahminical hindu. This brahmanical hindu has no principals, no morals and can fall to any level, can break all the world records of lying and deceiving. In order to improve hindu sikh relations this brahminical hindu has to be taken care of. I feel the day remainder hindu understands the kartootan of brahminical hindu , they will start becoming sikhs. But the remainder hindu has to do it fast as the future is really dim and scary. I personally feel that this brahminical hindu might be the worst form of human creation of God.
KHALISTAN ZINDABAD
RAJ KAREGA KHALSA
Re: How to improve sikh and hindu relations
Harinder Singh · 17 Oct 2006
Just to add, this brahaminical hindu is the same hindu who started wearing green clothes and eating halal meat in order to impress the muslim rulers. This brahamanical hindu is the same hindu who attacked Guru Gobind Singh time and again.
Re: How to improve sikh and hindu relations
shere punjab · 17 Oct 2006
Many hindus im am friends with are bhamins and don't believe in hurting sikhism or anything, they respect sikhs and don't see us differently, I know in the hindu community in india their is a small percentage of hindus who are hurting sikhs by making claims that they are hindus and even going on to try converting us but they are small numbers so why do many sikhs who support khalistan believe the whole entire hindu population or bhamin population needs to be wiped out.
Re: How to improve sikh and hindu relations
Harinder Singh · 17 Oct 2006
By brahmanical hindu, I meant a person who exploits the masses by either using religion or politics. I dint mean a random hindu born in a brahmin family. Many brahmins in punjab villages are very good and share good relations with sikhs.
Sikhi brreaks the shackles of such relgious and political exploaitation and hence has been attacked by brahminical hindu for the last 500 years.
Radhaswamis, Sacha Sauda,Ashutosh and some pseudo sikh "saints" and "brahamgyanis" will also come in the league of this brahminical hindu. There are many khalistanis who are sadly filled with anger and hatred and then there are others for whom khalistan issue is just a very good time pass. A naam abhiyaaasi rehitavaan gursikh khalistani will never wipe out anybody and will only fight either in defence or for kirpa and welfare. Moreover, this brahamical hindu is going to be wiped out by his own bad karma.
"Paapi ke maarne ko paap mahaballi hai"
Re: How to improve sikh and hindu relations
dogra · 23 Oct 2006
Shere Punkab, ur words are not lone voice, many people who do not have hate, know th real situation People are people at the end of the day.
The scarifices of the Gurus wil never be forgotten and their example will shine through the dark clouds of hate to bring the full realisation of humanity.
Re: How to improve sikh and hindu relations
Seeker of the Truth · 23 Oct 2006
I thought Sikhs and Hindus were cool with each other? I heard these people marry each other a lot and visit each other's temples. I am shock to hear that Sikhs and Hindus don't like each other. You people (Sikhs and Hindus) need to chill out.
Re: How to improve sikh and hindu relations
fresno sikh · 23 Oct 2006
SSAKAL
Just today at work a hindu doctor asked me that who was Guru Nanak's Guru (since I do irk him as a sikh). I said in Aardas written by Guru Gobind Singh ji up to 1st 9 patsahis say Pratham Bhaguti simar kae(Bhaguti means steel power God) Guru Nanak lae Dhiya. GOD was Guru Nanak's Guru.Also in Sidh Gosht Baba says to sidhs" Sabad Guru Surat Dhun Chela". Also validated by Guru Gobind singh ji. "Jo prabh ko mil chaye hai kogh sabadh(Guru Granth sahib(sabadh)) mei ley".He was wanting to say sant kabir was his Guru and since kabir was a hindu so was he. If Hindus stop play mind games with sikhs the relations will improve by themselves.
Re: How to improve sikh and hindu relations
Harjas Kaur · 24 Oct 2006
"why do many sikhs who support khalistan believe the whole entire hindu population or bhamin population needs to be wiped out."
If this is so, why are all the genocidal attacks in recent history, and forced and deceitful assimilation tactics committed by Hindutva fanatics trying to eliminate Sikhi? I think you have your facts backward. It isn't Sikhi trying to wipe out millions of Hindu's, but Hindu's sure doing a job trying to wipe out Sikhi. Sikh militants are in survival mode.
[%sig%]
Re: How to improve sikh and hindu relations
fresno sikh · 24 Oct 2006
SSAKAL
Kabeer was a believer in one GOD regardless of him being a Muslim or Hindu. That's why his Bani is in Guru Granth Sahib along with other saints.
This is the essence of Guru Granth sahib and sikh believe. But to get technical on the surface Bhagat kabir ji's Guru was Ramanand. Kabir ji laid down on the path during amrit vela which Ramanand travelled everyday to take a bath. Due to being dark ouside Ramanand hit kabir while walking and said wake up Ram ke Bande bol ram. But I do agree that the doctor is an ignorant prick.
Re: How to improve sikh and hindu relations
Harinder Singh · 24 Oct 2006
I have had one of my professors trying to convince me that Sri Guru Nanak Dev Ji was a vishnu avatar and meditated on "raam". Then there are some professors who always ask whether I have some relation with their hero supercop KP"S" Gill as my surname is also Gill(though I have ripped of my surname recently). I am yet to meet a punjabi or delhi hindu who critisizes operation bluestar or shows sympathy for mass murder of sikh youth in fake encounters.
I really used to get angry but now I pity such people. Basically sikhs are too good for such a group of people and I feel that muslims have got the right "dose" for them.
Bhul chukk maaf
Khalistan Zindabad
Re: How to improve sikh and hindu relations
Harinder Singh · 24 Oct 2006
<>
Basically we sikhs have a slave mentality. We want to please the world by telling that Guru Granth Sahib contains writings of hindus and muslims.
Gurbani has clearly mentioned that Guru Nanak is the only Satguru and without Satguru no one has met God. Hence all the bhagats must be sikhs of Guru Nanak. But do we believe this ? No. We want to make the world happy. I am ashamed to be part of such a slave punjabi community. I have never understood why Waheguru came and started sikhi with such an undeserving bunch of people.
Re: How to improve sikh and hindu relations
fresno sikh · 24 Oct 2006
Veer Harjinder Singh Ji
I dont think we or me in particulary have a slave mentality to say that Guru Granth Sahib Ji has bani of Hindu muslim Bhagats. I know we cannot be doormats to the world religions. But as sikhs we have to be aware of us and others religions and people around us. "Hindu Anna Turku Kana Dono whicho Gyani sayana" Be a Gyani and one with be at peace with themself.
I fully believe Whaeguru himself came in his sargun saroop as Guru Nanak and is the Guru of Kalyug and Whaeguru is the Gurumantar. His vision is perfect and superseeds all. Also in Rehras sahib it says "Mein Na ganesheo pratham manaya kishan, Bishan kabho na dhiyao" it is quiet clear to a sikh if he is a nitnemi that his full faith is Gurus and Whaeguru himself and does not rest on the 33 carores dieties. It is hard to find gursikhs in this kalyug like you who have such passion for sikhi.
Re: How to improve sikh and hindu relations
Harinder Singh · 24 Oct 2006
Dear Veer
Guru Granth Sahib ji tells about 1 Satguru and 1 Naam. If Bhai Sahib Kabeer Ji's guru was Bhai Ramanand Ji , it means that there are multiple Satgurus and multiple Naams in Sri Guru Granth Sahib which is not true.
Bani says "sabh tey vadda satgurr nanak". If you carefully see this tukk, you will notice that both satgurr and nanak have "aunkarrs" in the end.So this tukk means that "Satguru Nanak is the greatest of all" and DOES NOT mean "O nanak, satgur is the greatest of all".
Then there is another tukk "satgurr bajhunn gurr nahin koi nigurre ka hai nau burra". This is pretty clear. It means that "Other than the Satguru there is no other Guru and a person without Guru has a bad reputation".
Hence its pretty clear that Satguru Nanak is the greatest of all and Satguru Nanak is the only Guru and rest all are dehdhari pakhandis.
This will automatically mean that all the bhagats were sikhs of Guru Nanak Dev Ji.
Dont believe the historians. Historians make mistakes, historians lie delibrately, historians are bought by the governments.May be 500 years from now people will quote from the present RSS historians that Guru Nanak Dev Ji was a krishna bhagat and Guru Gobind Singh Ji worshiped Durga.
Re: How to improve sikh and hindu relations
shere punjab · 25 Oct 2006
Many of my hindu friends are against operation bluestar and kps gill, i have told them everything that has happened and they agree with me that it was wrong and is the indian governments fault and that the RSS has to be stopped from doing what they are doing, and i know many hindus who respect sacirfices made by sikhs and go to sikh gudwara to pay their respects.
Re: How to improve sikh and hindu relations
Seeker of the Truth · 25 Oct 2006
Most Hindus I met claim Baba Jarnail Singh was a terrorist and they supported the attacks on harmandir sahib and in fact, Hindus in Punjab celebrated and start giving out sweets with each other when they heard the Indian army attacked Harmandir sahib and other gurdwaras.
Re: How to improve sikh and hindu relations
Harinder Singh · 25 Oct 2006
There are loads of hindus that come to gurdwaras. But then very very small section of them come to listen Gurbani. For most its just a ritual. In the evening they will first go to a temple and bow to a stond idol(representing their god) and then they will come to Gurdwara and bow to Sri Guru Granth Sahib. Then there are loads of hindus who come to gurdwaras only to have food. Gurdwaras like Bangla Sahib, Sees Ganj Sahib are full of poor hindus trying to fill their bellies. In fact they run and push when the call for "langar" is made. Sorry to say but Gurdwaras like Bangla Sahib are used by some hindus as a place to have nice evening walk or a nice bath in the sarovar or even for dating etc.
Re: How to improve sikh and hindu relations
Harinder Singh · 27 Oct 2006
<>
Thats true. What I meant was that hindus coming to our gurdwaras is not a sign of some hindu sikh unity etc. Infact, if you wear round dastaar, open beard, kirpan on the outside, lots of hindus look at you with fear and suspicion(thanks to the brahamanical media of India). Plus the sardar jokes have spoiled it all. I personally can never forgive indians for what they do to young sikh boys in schools and colleges. These jokes make young sikh boys feel as if they are inferior and foolish and hence suffer from low self esteem.
Re: How to improve sikh and hindu relations
Harinder Singh · 27 Oct 2006
<>
I feel that people in subcontinent especially india have degenerated the maximum. Its really tough to teach them the way of Satguru Nanak(unless one has become a brahamgyani). They want short and lazy way outs like feeding poor, visiting sacred places, licking the stinky feet of fake saints etc.
Plus Guru Nanak Dev Ji told that "truth is high, but higher still is truthful living" and in a corrupt country like India it will be tough to find people who live truthful lives. I see almost everyone around me as corrupt and hypocrite in some form or the other.
Sikhi needs to be spread to the west as India is the worst place on this planet to live a free, honest and spiritual life. Sikhi deserves better people than indians and punjabis.
Re: How to improve sikh and hindu relations
Man Singh · 27 Oct 2006
Mutual respect is the only way to improve relations.
Live and let live is the only way to do that.
Killers of great Gurus are of course playing a special role in creating rift between these two brothers behind the scene.
Choice is ours if we get in trapp or kick out the dividers
Re: How to improve sikh and hindu relations
fresno sikh · 27 Oct 2006
Just be aware after partition hindus raised the slogan Hindi Hindu Hindustan
against the formation of punjabi suba not khalistan. Punjab which was already 1/3 of the punjab was futher divided into Haryana and Himachal pardesh. Also hindus tried to say that punjabi (grumukhi) is not even a language. We cannot trust these people again in any circumstances.
But no use crying over spilled milk now.
Re: How to improve sikh and hindu relations
Man Singh · 28 Oct 2006
fresno sikh,
you are right and I can never justify the wrongs of those who raised slogalsn mentioned by you.
But what surprises me is that you are angry on those who divided 1/3 remaining Punjab into haryana and Himachal.
Do you have same level of anger with those who captured reaming 2/3rd and virtually kicked us out from that land of ours where our history is hiding in every particle.
Haryana and Himachal even today provide 100% freedom and equal rights to all communities and God willing can be integrated again to Punjab. Even whole India is being ruled by a Sikh today.
can you even Imagine of a Sikh being a chief Mionister of captured Punjab on Pakistani side.
What I feel today is that we have forgot our 2/3rd Punjab altogather and are querlling with our own brothers.
Think about it and decide who is enemy no 1?
Don'nt blame operation blue star and 84 riots on poor Hindus as these two crimes were very clearly committed by people loyal to a lady who licked the feet of Muslims all through her life in the name of `secularism'.
Let's opne our eyes and minds.
In my opinion, Sikhs can win any part of India even today anytime. More diffcult is getting Lahore back. have we ever thought of that?
Never? Because we have accepted permanent defeat on that front and we have none else to show our bravery other then poor Hindus befooled by `secular' toxication.
Choice is ours if we cntinue fighting among ourselves or plan to liberate the capital of Sikh empire Lahore.
Re: How to improve sikh and hindu relations
fresno sikh · 28 Oct 2006
SSAKAL
Man Singh
I dont know who the enemy is or was Tara singh, Nehru, Gandhi..........
But I do have a teary feeling when I see the Guru Shrines in pakistan in ruins where my Guru's and great sikhs spend their lives and we have to kneel in front of the Bhaman Govt of India for the visas to a land which we once ruled. I am tired of seeing the same saga played over and over with the sikhs both in East and West. But my deep sincere regards to all the well wishers of the khalsa panth who give so much inspiration to each other.
Re: How to improve sikh and hindu relations
shere punjab · 29 Oct 2006
Not all hindus support INDIRA GANDHI or the RSS so trying to paint a whole community with the same brush is useless, their were hindus who did hide sikhs in their homes during the riots of 84 and many hindus who were equally hurt by operation bluestar, but we have to remember KPS Gill was not a hindu KS BRAR and RANJIT SINGH the men who planned operation bluestar were not hindus these men were so called sikhs, and the punjab police many of which wear turbons and grow out their beards calling themselves sikhs were not hindus. Why CONGRESS winning elections in our own homeland sikhs vote for them.
Re: How to improve sikh and hindu relations
Sitara · 30 Oct 2006
There are no problems between Hindus and Sikhs just people on the internet get over excited about things...sometimes we take things personally and that clouds our judgement.
They are Sikhs and Hindus that say nasty things about each others religion on the net but I don't think they mean it...if they met each other in person they would probably get on very well. We just need to chill for a bit thats all, life is too short
[%sig%]
Re: How to improve sikh and hindu relations
Sitara · 30 Oct 2006
"I really used to get angry but now I pity such people. Basically sikhs are too good for such a group of people and I feel that muslims have got the right "dose" for them."
Thank you for your kind words, I will now respect Sikhs even more after reading this comment.
Re: How to improve sikh and hindu relations
Harinder Singh · 30 Oct 2006
<>
Dear Sitara
I am not a saint nor a brahamgyani. I am very much a kalyugi jeev. I have absolutely no sympathy for people who support operation bluestar, praise indira gandhi, respect KP"S" Gill and there are loads of hindus who do that.
You see many sikhs getting angry over hindus but then its pretty much natural after all that has happened to sikhs.Remember all sikhs are not saints.
Imagine you save a girl getting raped and afterwards the same girl stabbs u in the back. HOw will u feel?
Same has happened with the sikhs.
It is due to such bad karma that indians have been getting the muslim dose time and again. I see this muslim dose has started again and is going to get stronger in the future.
Re: How to improve sikh and hindu relations
Man Singh · 30 Oct 2006
frensco Sikh sat Sri Akal ji.
I am with you on all the issues raised by you accept one : ie calling Indian government as `bhaman government'.
In indepenedent India is any community that suffered most are the Brahmins. Their traditional occupation has been eliminated, they were traditionally landless. Their situation is almost equal to SC/ST's on economic front. SC/ST's get reservation but Brammins not .
Yes around 10,000 Brahmins families aroudn India are landlords who associated with foreign invaders and became jamindars.
These Jamindars were the people who created whole havoc on weaker sections of scoiety.
Unfortunately 5 crore brahmins are suffering economically psychologically and emotionally due to wrong doing of these Landlords and of course ingnorance of all of us.
Do you feel nehru was having even a single quality a Brahmin is supposed to have? he was a brownsaheb.
Let's see ourselves and not get away by propganda.
I come from rural area and I have seen poor landless Brahmins boys suffering even fro food.
In south India Brahmins are surviving for Rs 300(US $ 6 only ) per month as salary from temple.
Real cause of suffering is Nehruvian Secularism and non violence which becomes violent from time to time against follwers of Indian religions and pampers those who always denigrated civilisational values originated from soil of India.
Re: How to improve sikh and hindu relations
Sitara · 30 Oct 2006
<>
I would feel bad, but I wouldn't start hating the girl's mother, father, brother, sister, cousins, village, town, community, district etc etc
Re: How to improve sikh and hindu relations
Harinder Singh · 30 Oct 2006
<>
What if the girl's mother,father, brother sister etc are silent or even supportive of girl's action ?
Now you will say that hindus are themselves helpless under a corrupt government and corrup judiciary. But then why the same silent hindus break their silence and start to hate sikhs when they demand khalistan.
If hindus cant assist sikhs getting justice in India, why dislike them for demanding self rule?
Can India dare to attack mecca the way they attacked Sri Darbar Sahib?
First you attack Sri Darbar Sahib, you kill innocent sikhs in mobs in 84,then you kill a generation of sikh youth in fake encounters, , then you deny them justice for 22 years, then you term the same sikhs as aatankkvaadi, terrorist, traitors when they demand khalistan, and then you ask why sikhs have developed hatred for india. Balle ne tuhade.
Re: How to improve sikh and hindu relations
Sitara · 31 Oct 2006
Harinder,
Chill out mate..do some paath. You are obviously getting angry and over emotional. OK Hindus are very bad and ungrateful..leh I have said it, khush?
Re: How to improve sikh and hindu relations
Man Singh · 31 Oct 2006
Harinder Singh Ji,
That's where the error of judgement lies. You blame Hindus for the sins of congress which is gang of mao, Mrax, macauley and Mohammed.
Hindus also demanded their most secred place of worship i.e Sri ramjanam Bhumi you know what happened? Mulayam Singh Yadav opened fire on them. You know how many people killed there? Nobody know because no news was allowed to come out?
Yes you are right. India being ruled by gangs of Mao, Marx macaulkey and Mohammed can never attack mecca. Thye can'nt even storm a hazratbal dargah where Muslim terrorists were hiding.
In place of that they released around 40 Muslim terrorists for daughter of Mufti Mohammed said?
Sikhs always sacrificed their lives to defend civilisational values from soil of India.
Muslims always ridiculed and attacked the same values.
But 24% Muslims were given 28% of land while sikhs were declared terrorists for the same demands. Of course some Sikhs misused that movement and killed many innocent Hindus.
Almost all big Hindu tempels even today are controlled bu government and the money collected is diverted to Haz Subdisy or to christian NGO's to convert Hindus.
What I mean to say is that Hindus are also eqauly suffering under these foreign ideologies of Mao, Marx Macauley and Mohammed.
These 4 M's are here to elimintae the civilisational values originated from soil of India.
It is due to their propaganda why Sikhs are cutting their hair and loosing selg pride in Sikhi. They are not allowing our mionds to think beyond Bollywood, Bhangra and Biriyani.
I don'nt think Hindus who are under attack from all sides have any say in running Indian affairs. recent example is serving meat on har Ki Pauri haridwar by Mulayam singh yadav to Muslim iftar party.
India is virtually a Islamic state today where Hindus have minimum rights even less then Sikhs. Therefore by blaming Hindus fro everything we are trying to demonise the victim and protecting the real culprits ie followers of Mao, Marx, macaulkey and Mohammed.
Re: How to improve sikh and hindu relations
Harinder Singh · 31 Oct 2006
You put the entire blame on congress.
Even the BJP/RSS respect KP"S" gill and call the sikh freedom fighters as terrorists. Traitors like barnala are made governors, be it be congress or bjp at the centre.
Also can u explain why the entire indian nation voted for rajiv gandhi after indira was sent to hell ?
Re: How to improve sikh and hindu relations
Man Singh · 31 Oct 2006
Yes unfortunately what you said is true.
I feel its brainwashing through media that has made gangs of mao marx macauley and Mohammed trapp the soul of India.
BJP is noway different then congress.
RSS I have seen during my university days preaching teachings of Great Gurus and expressing great respect for them in their Shakhas in the campus.
I attended one propgram of theirs where their pracharak gave an exteremely brilliant lecture on the uniqueness of sacrifice of Guru Govind Singh Ji maharaaj. lecture was so emotional and philosophical togather that till date even in Guru Dwara I never met such speaker.
His vibrating quotations `sawa lakh te ek ladau' & `hall paranda lilla ghoda' even today inspires my heart.
KPS Gill episode I am not much aware if RSS ever glorified him but during struggle period in punjab of course RSS calmed down anger of Hindus against Sikhs by propgating a theory that nails and flesh can never be separated though some scraches may cause some bleedings.
In the era when innocent people were being killed by stopping buses, and Guru's Vesh was being misused by some miscreants, maintaing harmony between these two brotherly communities was definitely a great job.
My feeling is always that `togather we stand devided we fall'.
Khalasa was never meant for Punjab. In association with Hindu organisations like RSS we can spread Khalasa around the globe. If we stick to a Punjab centered Khalasa, I fear, may blunt the its sword.
Guru Gobind Singh maharaj was not born in Punjab nor did he die there.
Even tamil naadu got his follwoers and so weer in far places like Assam due to Guru Teg Bahadur's prachar of sikhi there.
Today Sikhs are giving a sort of impression as if non Punjabi Sikhs are simply Not Sikhs and their participation in Hindu festivals stripps them of sikhi.
In Europe and North America Sikhs are participating in Christian New Year parties, halloveen and many otehr festivals. Sikhs are celebrating birth days and marrioage anniversaries in pure christian ways. Does it make them lesser Sikhs?
Then how come Sikhs in India if participating in festivals of their felow Hindus can be branded as Non Sikhs?
In a Multicultural world today Sikhs are living in almost every country and have to respect and mix up with all cutures and religions of the world. The same way others also participate in Sikh festivals while maintaing their identities.
Hindus are also part of humanity and deserve the same treatment as we give to Christians and others. being the root of our culture and religion of which we are fruits and flowers, Hinduism deserve a bit more then what we are ready to give to Christians and Muslims.
To make Khalasa global we should involve and intercat with everybody and anybody including Hindus. This will ensure our growth.
Re: How to improve sikh and hindu relations
shere punjab · 31 Oct 2006
why do sikhs vote for congress in the punjab.
Re: How to improve sikh and hindu relations
Harinder Singh · 31 Oct 2006
RSS has recently been exposed for spreading wrong and derogatory information about the sikh faith. They have made the Guru form of God i e. Guru Gobind Singh Ji,the owner of crores of universes into a patriot of a piece of land i e. india. They also believe the Guru form of God worshipped krishna and ram.
Basically the RSS dudes are afraid of the muslims and hence want sardars on their side. But the type of derogatary information that they are spreading, no sikh of the guru will be on their side.
ISI wants to turn sikhs against hindus and RSS type hindutva groups want to make sikhs worshippers of their bharat mata and slaugter muslims.
Both are enemies of the sikh panth and both are going to be ruined in the future.
KHALISTAN ZINDABAD
Re: How to improve sikh and hindu relations
Man Singh · 01 Nov 2006
Yes Harinder Singh ji. You are quite right in your analysis.
Now question left to Sikhs today is to decide either to move alone (ekala Chalo re) or associate with lesser evil?
RSS, ISI and congress these three options are there in the market out of which I feel congress is the biggest eveil as it is like a snake in grass and mesmerises people by sweet poisonous pills.
ISI is effective only because gaddar and namakharam congress is there sucking blood of Indians.
I still feel that RSS desperate to win Sikh's confidence can mend its ways if its mistakes are highlighted by Sikh leadership.
If they want to inspire their youth in the name of great Gurus and propagate their sacrifices with whatever motives they have, they are still lesser evil.
I feel RSS should be educated about true nature of Sikhism and their association with Sikhs can make whole India as `khalasa'.
Punjab oriented Sikhism closed in Punjabi language not only isolates non Punjabi Sikhs from the faith, but also blocks its further growth.
Choice is ours. Flexible grows, while rigid breaks down.
Kindly allow me to appreciate your analysis of attitude of ISI, RSS and Congress towards sikhs .
Re: How to improve sikh and hindu relations
Harinder Singh · 01 Nov 2006
<>
We are never alone as we have Waheguru on our side. But the key here is rehit. If we dont keep rehit we will loose and if we keep rehit we will be unbeatable.
Just one strong khalsa in the form of Bhai Jarnail Singh Khalsa shook the entire indian nation and the GOI were left with no option but to get him killed by some way or the other.
Imagine what will happen if our kaum is full of rehitvaan gursikhs.
Dont trust anything coming from the mouth of BJP or Congress. They are the biggest liars human race has ever produced. They will commit a genocide operation and call it operation shanti(peace).
This world is just a play of all powerful Waheguru and the khalsa raj is inevitable.The poor manmukhs are going to be burnt by the fire of maya.
"jaisee aggan uddar meh, taisee bahar maya".
RAJ KAREGA KHALSA
Re: How to improve sikh and hindu relations
manmitchera · 09 Nov 2006
when Guru Nanak Dev Ji met Kabeer Ji, He was almost forty years old and Kabeer was almost 110 years old. One note readers must make is that when this meeting took place Guru Nanak Dev Ji had already received the revelation from God when He was 30. This shows that Guru Nanak Dev Ji had been commanded by God to preach the truth.
[%sig%]
Re: How to improve sikh and hindu relations
vikramjit singh randhawa · 15 Nov 2006
veer harinder singh jee
1)I totally agree with you,sikhs have slave mentality.sikhs are totally selfish these days and have nothing to do with religion.I only listen frm them is,saanu tey koi kuj nahi kehnda. we are happy at our home so no need to do anything.Thts disgusting mentality.
2)There were sikhs like bhagat singh, beant singh, satwant singh ,sant jarnail singh and then follow population of million sikhs who dont even want to remember their sacrifice.Sikhs call them terrorists themselves.
3)Everybody in sikh religion puts their own interest first.I really want to ask every sikh what they learned frm Sahib Sri Guru Gobind Singh.Guru Gobind singh jee ne khazaney dee parwah nahi keetee,apnee maa dee parwah nahi keetee,apne pitaa dee parwah nahi keetee,sahibzaadiya baare nahi sochiya.Ajj sikhaan nu bahut pyaare ne bache gharbaar,sikhism nu kee horiha asee kee laina.you cant look upon guru sahib even as Guru Sahib said "jab je chaley wipran ke reet mai naa chaloo inki parteet".sikh kaum apne shaheedan nu pulgayee.
4)Gurudwara sahib vich aashique chaldee.Young munde kurhee ehee karan jaandhey.
Re: How to improve sikh and hindu relations
aanjan · 16 Nov 2006
Man Singh ji
Did Sikh Gurus go out and seek support NO. Cause our support is Akalpurakh and a Sikh is nirbhau by doing bhagti of nirbhau
Is RSS and Shiv Sena Same or different in your opinion?
Re: How to improve sikh and hindu relations
Harinder Singh · 16 Nov 2006
Dear Veer Vikramjit Singh Ji
Wahegurujeekakhalsa Wahegurujeekeefateh
Current state of sikhs show that they never deserved to be sikhs. Having said that I feel there are quite a few people who have guru kirpa too. In this dark age of kaliyuga, u cant expect everyone to be a gursikh.
It always take a few to bring a revolution. There were only 40 odd singhs who took on the indian army in 84, there were only 40 muktas who took on mughal faujan at chamkaur sahib. Even today, there are charrdikala souls in sikh panth and in the future these souls will start to show their power.
Sikhi comes from the creator, so what do we have to fear. Its the manmukhs who should be fearing as they are going to loose both here and hereafter
Re: How to improve sikh and hindu relations
Man Singh · 16 Nov 2006
anjaan ji, first of all whom you call Sikh gurus are Gurus for the humanity and if Sikhs claim a monopoly on them and their great teachings it is sort of narrowing and reducing their status. Of course Gurus were part of Akal Purakh and they do not need anybody's support to perform their designated task in this material world.
Of course pandits from kashmir came to Gurus and pleaded for safety and Gurus gracefully did that.
Today again when Hindus are in troble, they look at sikhs but I feels sikhs of today are not capable of doing that.
Then Hindus formed just tried fro alternatives. RSS is one of them. RSS is a social organisation busy in integrating the all people following religions of Indian origin.
I can see RSS guys are propgating teachings of great Gurus alla around the world more then Sikhs. Of course their interpretation may be different then those of Sikhs but I don'nt see any thing wrong in it if they use Gurus' teachings to build up confidence among Hindus in a scenerio when Sikhs have started acting as enemies to Hindus in many cases and infected with separatist virus injected in them by enemies of Indian civilisation. Yes Anjan ji, truth is this only.
Shiv Sena and BJP are the political parties and purely working for their self interests.
if you study the plans of Muslims and christians for next 1000 years, you will realise the danger ahead.(See project Joshua 2 in the internet aas a sample).
Let's not be emotional. let's remember what happened in 1947 when around half a million Hindus/Sikhs were kicked out , killed , converted and raped.
we read stories of Hindu Sikh women even today who are living a Muslims in pakistan today and theor families back in India.
When question of security comes in emotions doesn'nt work. Secular goondas of congress loyal to a women of no religion Indira gandhi killed 2000 sikhs and we all balmed it on `Hindus'? Why? becasue we were moved by propganda of mao, marx macauley and Mohammed.
My stand is again the same. RSS may be India centric and there is nothing wrong in it. But it is introducing Sikhism in disguise from kashmir to kanya Kumari and from Gujraat to Assam. RSS is popolarising Guru's teaching in interior tribal villages in cewntral India.
Sikhs never did that detailed work. In place of supporting RSS and correcting it if they are wrong somewhere in their interpretation of Guru's teachings, Sikhs are doing just leg pulling.
This truth was explined to me once in Pant Nagar University by Sardar Gajendra Singh who was a friend of a RSS worker otherwise I also might be abusing RSS today like many of our fellow Sikhs.
Thanks to RSS for sprwading Gurus'names at least even among 50 Million tribals of India.
United we stand and divided we fall. It happened in 1947, it may repeat again anywhera nd anytime.
enemies of Indian civilisation of course might be smiling at our fingh among ourselves.
Re: How to improve sikh and hindu relations
shere punjab · 18 Feb 2007
i personally hate people who support rss bjp and hindutva anything hindutva because their just destroying the teachings of sikhism and converting sikhs in the punjab to hindus their destroying our faith. But not all hindus are bad and i don't think sikhs should blame all hindus in india as it's probably like 9% of hindus that are enemy's to sikhs but muslims i don't think country's like pakistana and muslims care about sikhs since their religion calls any religion besides islam the religion of the devil.
Re: How to improve sikh and hindu relations
A Singh · 20 Feb 2007
No one would have objection with organisations like RSS propagating teachings of Sikh Guru provided they are correct. But the irony is that they are distorting Sikh history very severely. They will not be successfull in the long run.
On the other there are many Non Sikhs (Hindus, Muslims, Christains, etc)who practice the Gurus teachings perfectly plus continue to follow there own faith.
RSS and Congress are same , only the approach is different. The aim is same the elimination of Sikh Panth complete. One does to elimination of the Sikh community what haven't in the 80s and 90s and the other does through confusing the Sikh youth.
Over the years the elimination of Sikhs have happen in a very systemic and planned manner.
Right from 1950s to 1970s no major industry and educational institutions were set up in Punjab, terming it as a border state. Sikhs leaving Punjab start migration to Western countries in search of better employment. This happen in the 60s and 70s.
Distribution of drugs among the rural Sikh youth was intensified. This was also Congress sponsered.
In the early 80s there were several cases of disappearance of the Sikh youth.
In the mid and late 80s many Sikhs were killed in the name of terriosm by the Punjab Police and Para Military Forces like CRPF who were particularly Amritdharis.
These were done by the Congress Government.
From 1986 onwards the RSS involvement in the form of Rashtriya Sikh Sangathan (RSS) starts to promote Hindu-Sikh unity. Parallely the brutality of Security forces on innocent people continues.
Gradually cases of Sikhs cutting hair increase, the youth gets confused. At this point the RSS intensifies its anti Sikh propaganda terming Sikh Gurus as worshipers of Hindu Dieties. Their propaganda was maximum when the Akali-BJP government was in power in Punjab.
These are all pre planned designs of Hindu Hardliners much proir to independence to eliminate the Sikh community completely from the Indian soil. Earlier they were Congress bakts now they are BJP / RSS bakts.
Congress and BJP / RSS are 2 sides of the same coin.
Re: How to improve sikh and hindu relations
Harsimranjit · 20 Feb 2007
Listen to what you are saying Dude!
"the indian government does not represent the hindu people. I know it's a really small minority of sikhs who hates hindus but why so much hate towards all of the hindu people when the indian government was responsible for attacking sikhs"
India boasts itself to be the world's largest Democracy
The Indian people put the government into power
Even after indira was busted up after 84, rajiv gandhi came into power
he stayed successively in power by landslide victories....
... he very much reflected the hindu majorities' view...
allowed panjab to be flooded...
..allowed the delhi riots to occur... and even after such... he remained in power.
..so your statement is clearly flawed. dont just hate the hindu government, hate the hindu voters
[%sig%]
Re: How to improve sikh and hindu relations
Man Singh · 20 Feb 2007
Indira gandhi was a women of no religion or a Muslims in you analyse theoretically being undivorced wife of Pheroz Khan.
Those who attacked Sikh in 1984 were loyal to such lady and it is foolish to call them Hindus.
Yes Hindus are under trap of 4 gangs in India. these gangs are Mao, Marx, macauley(Secular) and Mohammed. Therefore it is these gang members that voted congress to power.
Poor Hindus whose temples have been captured by government, whose saintly people are harrassed every now and then by the government, whose pilgriumage is being taxed by the government while giving subsidy to haz pilgrimage, stand nowhere in Indian power equaltion.
Hindus are left helpless even by Sikhs today the very Panth who took sword to bring justice to all communnities including Hindus.
have you ever thought why all 68 teerthas mentioned even in Sri Guru Granth saheb, are in bad shape? Because Hindus are still slave to gangs of mao, marx, macauley and Mohammed.
If Sikhs als associate with these gang members against Hindus, I am sure it is like killing again a dead society.
Sikhism was the only hope for Hindus. Now they also have run away from path of righteousness and have associated gangs of enemies of India civilisation, Hindus have left nothing but bearing the blame for every eveil in India as propgated by media controlled by gangs of Mao, marx macauley and mohammed.
But one thing is sure, once Hindusim dies, sikhism will be next target of attack by these gangs of non Indian ideologies. Just wait and watch.
Solution lies in unity. Let's educate RSS guys about true teachings of Gurus so that they can correct their ways. Thier strong Network of course can be used for propgation of Khalasa as they are almost half khalasa already.
Re: How to improve sikh and hindu relations
dogra · 24 Feb 2007
" your statement is clearly flawed. dont just hate the hindu government, hate the hindu voters
"
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Hate hate hate, yes, what a wonderful emotion, to have to hold, to embrace, what a way to teach the kids. Hate id path to destruction of ones soul.
What Hindu government?? Where r people being forced or slyly into Hinduism?
When u vote, what is the basis of your vote, is it your persinal economic circumstance?
Indira Government is dead, as is Rajivs, Indira dauighter in law put Manmohan Singh in the prime position, if there was a master plan, would u put the person whose faith u want to weaken in the top power position, Do u think Pakistan will ever have a nonmuslim PM, or Chief of the army?
Re: How to improve sikh and hindu relations
A Singh · 26 Feb 2007
The present Chief Justice of Pakistan is a non muslim.
Re: How to improve sikh and hindu relations
Man Singh · 26 Feb 2007
who told you? A.Singhji?
It was for one day when as acting chief justice when real chief justive was away or undergoing some surgery.
Here is the list:
Temporal Order Name of Chief Justice From To
1 Justice Sir Abdul Rashid Abdur Rashid (Chief Justice, Federal Court)
07 June 1949 29 June 1954
2 Justice Muhammad Munir (Chief Justice, Federal Court) 29 June1954 02 May 1960
3 Justice Muhammad Shahabuddin 03 May 1960 12 May 1960
4 Justice A. R. Cornelius 13 May 1960 29 February 1968
5 Justice S. A. Rahman 01 March 1968 03 June 1968
6 Justice Fazal Akbar 04 June 1968 17 November 1968
7 Justice Hamoodur Rahman 18 November 1968 31 October 1975
8 Justice Muhammad Yaqub Ali 01 November 1975 22 September 1977
9 Justice S. Anwarul Haq 23 September 1977 25 March 1981
10 Justice Mohammad Haleem 23 March 1981 31 December 1989
11 Justice Muhammad Afzal Zullah 01 January 1990 18 April 1993
12 Justice Dr. Nasim Hasan Shah 17 April 1993 14 April 1994
13 Justice Sajjad Ali Shah 05 June 1994 02 December 1997
14 Justice Ajmal Mian 23 December 1997 30 June 1999
15 Justice Saeeduzzaman Siddiqui 01 July 1999 26 January 2000
16 Justice Irshad Hasan Khan 26 January 2000 06 January 2002
17 Justice Bashir Jehangiri 07 January 2002 31 January 2002
18 Justice Sheikh Riaz Ahmad 01 February 2002 31 December 2003
19 Justice Nazim Hussain Siddiqui 31 December 2003 29 June 2005
20 Justice Iftikhar Muhammad Chaudhry 30 June 2005 Incumbent
AR Cornelius was a British guy who took Pakistani citizenship and People suspect that he accepted to convert to islam to become a Judge.
Yousuf Yohana criter recently converted to become Captain.
I worked in malaysia and have seen many people virtually forced to convert of they want propmotion or high position in government. Muslims are merely 48% in malayisa thogh officially they claim to be 52 % by tempering the statistics data.
Let's not act like Dhimmi.
We are living in a free world now and sjould have courage to call right as right and wrong as wrong.
I strongly feel that in Indian constitution has minimum rights for `Hindus' and let's help them get rid of this nonsense of secularism that equates `killers', invaders and protectors of the civilisational values.
Hindu temples are captured by secular governments, temple money is being for haz subsify while Hindu pilgrimage is taxed by government.
In recent Kumbh Mela government of India spent around 360 crore Rupees and earned around 1000 crores in terms of space rental, taxation and tourism.
So sad to see. 68 teerath has beed mentioned in Gurbaani as well and are lying in shamles due to mental and constitutional enslavement of Hindus.
The only way is either all Hindus convert to Sikhism or Hindus and Sikhs get united to downplay the designs of associates of `Jehangir' and `Aurangjeb'.
Re: How to improve sikh and hindu relations
A Singh · 26 Feb 2007
http://www.rediff.com/news/2006/feb/14inter1.htm
'The law is equal for everyone in Pakistan'
February 14, 2006
Last week when Justice Rana Bhagwandas, acting chief justice of the Pakistan supreme court, crossed into India along with his brother judge, Justice Khalil-ur-Rehman Ramdev, on a private visit, he expected his trip to go unnoticed.
"How did you find out our whereabouts?" he asked Senior Associate Editor Onkar Singh when Onkar caught up with the two judges at the Punjab Bhavan in Chandigarh.
Justice Bhagwandas is the senior-most judge in the Pakistan supreme court after the present chief justice. According to Pakistan's constitution, the senior-most judge holds charge for the chief justice in the latter's absence.
Justice Bhagwandas, who was born in Sind, confesses he is not much of a cricket buff but applauds whenever Pakistan registers a win against India.
How has been your experience so far during your India visit?
I have come on a private visit with my brother judge Khalil-ur-Rehman Ramdev. I came to India once before, in 2005.
Any difference between the two visits?
I do not think it would be proper to compare the two visits because when I was here last time I did not visit Punjab and Haryana. Last time I went to Delhi, Lucknow, Gurgaon and Indore. This is a leisure trip full of recreation and excitement.
How has been the experience so far?
It is a nice experience, impressive and appealing. Because there is a lot of love and affection amongst the people who we met during this visit right from the moment we walked across the Wagah checkpost.
There is sincerity of purpose, respect for each other combined with love and affection. That is a great thing. It has been a wonderful experience.
You are the first acting chief justice of Pakistan from a minority community. How does it feel?
For me it makes me no difference because I treat it (his position) as a sacred trust. It is the virtue of God, the Parmatma, the creator to do justice and we as judges merely act as his agents. I always seek guidance from the creator so that we do not make a wrong judgment.
We act without favour or fear, ill will or affection. For me it makes no difference.
Before me there have been distinguished judges from the minority community who have held this esteemed post. We had Justice A R Cornelius, who was the chief justice of Pakistan for eight long years, from 1960 to 1968.
Our constitution commands that in the event of the absence of the chief justice or his inability to perform his functions the president shall appoint the senior-most judge to act as the acting chief justice. That is why I get an opportunity whenever our chief justice goes abroad.
What is the status of minorities in Pakistan? Do they get justice?
There is no problem. The law is equal for everyone. It provides for equal treatment and equal protection.
Do you have stringent laws to deal with crime like rape?
Pakistan has already enacted such laws. The question is only of the implementation of that law. If proper and definitive evidence comes on record then people who indulge in such heinous crimes are duly punished. But if there is inadequate evidence then the courts cannot convict them.
We have stringent laws to deal with terrorism and laws that deal with other heinous crimes under the Pakistan Penal Code.
Are you as a judge concerned about the honour killings in Pakistan?
Not just a judge but every Pakistani is deeply concerned that there should be no honour killings. A person cannot be allowed to take the law into his hands and commit a murder of a sister or a wife or a sister-in-law on the ground that she is living an immoral life or is suspected to have illicit relations with someone else.
Every Pakistani citizen is concerned about it. The law does not recognise the so-called honour killings. The Pakistani supreme court does not approve of such heinous crimes. We have modified the law and the offender is given capital punishment for the murder of a woman to protect the honour of a family or community. The supreme court is not sympathetic on this account.
Have you intervened in such matters on your own?
Yes, many times. And whenever we have done so it has given us a tremendous sense of satisfaction.
Rashid Junior, then captain of the Pakistan hockey team, once told us an airhostess refused to give him water when the team lost to India.
(Laughs) This must be a rare incident and the airhostess may have been worked up. I have little interest in cricket. People are crazy about cricket and we feel happy when our country wins. The names of Hanif Mohammad, Imran Khan, Shoaib Akhtar all come to my mind once I think about cricket. These are legends of Pakistani cricket.
Sachin Tendulkar is a big name in Indian cricket and he is one of the finest batsmen the world has ever produced. When Sehwag scored 309 during his last tour to Pakistan, his innings was highlighted by the media. I never have had the occasion of meeting them because we as judges have to be isolated.
Do you encourage Public Interest Litigation?
In Pakistan we have imposed heavy penalties on persons filing frivolous litigation in the name of Public Interest. But that does not mean what we do not entertain PILs. They are part of the judicial system. If some person pro bono publico takes up the cause of the general public and if it is a genuine cause and if it involves violation of fundamental rights then the courts must act and they do act.
Do Pakistani courts also have a backlog of cases?
That is the part of the judicial system. There are two factors for that. One is the growing population and the second is loss of our values.
When we downgrade our standards, crimes do take place. A majority of the cases relate to property disputes. Unless we reform ourselves and create awareness amongst ourselves, respect truth and observe sanctity for the law, this backlog is not going to end.
On our part, we try our best to minimise litigation by disposing off frivolous litigation and imposing heavy costs. We also dismiss false cases summarily. We should raise the quality of our values and infrastructure of our judicial system and imposition of heavy costs at all levels to bring down the backlog.
Re: How to improve sikh and hindu relations
Sarab loh jee dee sadaa racchiaa hamn · 26 Feb 2007
Man Singh, i m just curious... are u a Hindu?
Re: How to improve sikh and hindu relations
Man Singh · 27 Feb 2007
I belongs to a small village in Ghaziabad district in Utter Pradesh. Its name is Kusaidi. People of this village belive that once Guru Nanak Dev Ji Maharaj visited this village and they follow his teachings as per their understanding.
Being almost in the interior most, mainstream Sikhi of today hardly reached here. You can decide now in whcih category you want to put me.
For me yes I am a Hindu and yes I am a sikh as well. Does it make a difference?
Jehangir , in his tujuk e jehangiri wrote Guru Arjan Dev Ji.
I feel people like us are bridge between modern distorted definition of definition of Hindu and Sikh.
You decide what I am and what I am not. I feel Hindusim is humanism and Sikhsim being `Khalasa' is purest form of Hindusim as Islam being the latest in Judaism-Christianity - Islam series.
Any further doubt please feel free to contact me at [address removed]?
Re: How to improve sikh and hindu relations
Man Singh · 27 Feb 2007
Are you sure A.Singh.
I belive there is islamic law for Muslims and old Bristish law for the rest of population.
I request you to read the Pakistan Human rights report and certain incidences in karachi itself in which minor non Muslim girls are kidnapped, beatedn and forced to confess to convert to islam and Shariyat court sanctioning such marriages of minor girls to elderly Mullas engaged in terror activities.
here is report from pakistani reprot of human rights commisison
http://www.hrcp-web.org/fact_list.cfm#An%20HRCP%20fact-finding%20team%20visited%20Islamkot%20in%20January%202007%20to%20look%20into%20the%20case%20where%20a%20teacher%20allegedly%20abducted%20and%20forcefully%20converted%20a%20Hindu%20girl%20to%20Islam%20before%20marrying%20her.
Reality is that our attitude is that of a typical Dhimmi and we spend more energy on defending the culprits rather then defending the victims.
This dhimmitude is the root of the problem and almost all followers of religions of India origin Hindus, Sikhs etc are infected by this dhimmitude.
My apology for any offence.
Re: How to improve sikh and hindu relations
dogra · 02 Mar 2007
http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/world/south_asia/6367773.stm
Losing faith
Mukhi Aishwar Lal agrees that Hindus in Sindh are still afraid.
Garish Kumar's grieving father, Saspal, wants justice
They are frightened to move outside freely. Some even put themselves under a self-imposed curfew after 2000 hours a few months ago.
"No-one is targeting the minorities," argues Kishanchand Parwani, Advisor for Minorities' Affairs to the Sindh Government.
But he admits that, although the minorities are supposed to be equal citizens according to the constitution, the reality is different. He accepts that they feel like second class citizens.
Garish Kumar's father, Saspal Das, still retains faith in the system: "I will fight till I get justice for my son."
But many Hindu families who stayed in Pakistan after partition have already lost faith and migrated to India
Re: How to improve sikh and hindu relations
shere punjab · 03 Mar 2007
man singh its alright if you want to consider yourself half sikh and half hindu long as you don't support rss or anything but i don't think sikhism is the purest form of hinduism personally i believe it has nothing to do with hinduism and sikhism is a seperate faith i really don't believe people can be following two religions at once since each religion conterdicts the other one but i don't want to offend you and still find it awsome that you practise some of the principles of sikhism. Have you ever considered becoming 100% sikh.