Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Raagmalaa during amrit sanchar

Raagmalaa during amrit sanchar

talikhaak · 24 Jan 2007

Vaheguru ji ka khalsa, Vaheguru ji ki fateh! During an amritsanchaar do Jatha singhs tell the abhilakhee's not to beleive in raagmaala/read raag maala? Thanks! Vaheguru ji ka khalsa, Vaheguru ji ki fateh!

Re: Raagmalaa during amrit sanchar

singh5 · 24 Jan 2007

In every amrit sinchaar I've seen organized by Akhand Kirtani Jatha, it has never been ordered not to read Ragmala. If the issue comes up the Punj Pyaaray explicitly say that while they believe that Ragmala is not bani, there is no hukam from them and each Gursikh is free to make up their own mind. They also usually mention that we are to respect the opposite opinion and not feel animosity. It has never been a hukam to not read ragmala.

Re: Raagmalaa during amrit sanchar

maha_moorakh · 24 Jan 2007

if you are unsure ask the panj pyare wether it is bani or not [%sig%]

Re: Raagmalaa during amrit sanchar

k Singh · 25 Jan 2007

it is a shame other jathebandees do not have the same common sense. Some sants and taksals say you must read raagmala in amrit sanchaars. They put their own views and pretend it is Gurus hukam.

Re: Raagmalaa during amrit sanchar

123 · 25 Jan 2007

this question was raised during my amrit sanchar and the panj very clearly sed that as AKHAL TAKHT sahib had issued no hukamnama it was up 2 the individual becos the bogh of an akhand path for example can be done at the salok mahal 5 after the mundavni OR the reader can go on reading raagmala. I just want to reiterate that akhal takht sahib has no definite view and has issued a hukamnama saying that absolutely no one may write/print a saroop which doesnt contain the ragmala [%sig%]

Re: Raagmalaa during amrit sanchar

Bazzer · 26 Jan 2007

It seems to me to be crazy not to have a stance on Raag Mala by the panj pyaray. It is obviously bani so should/must be read at bhog time. The panj pyaray should not sit on the fence, Raag mala should be read, full stop.

Re: Raagmalaa during amrit sanchar

Khalsaspirit · 26 Jan 2007

Waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh, On basis of Gurmat principle many Gursikhs try to avoid any arguments of RAAGMALA in General public. But it seems like the beginners in Sikhi do not dare to avoid this as this issue is been the Sikh panth’s one of the divisive one so every Gursikh with avastha try to avoid this. But whenever some one touch this sensitive issue in general public we always ask them that aside from verbal hearing from some one if you any documented proof or any research on Raagmala proving it is a Gurbani bring it to Sri Akal Takhat Sahib and if your research clearly proved over the research made that it is not Gurbani then all the Sikh panth will recite the Raagmala. Other wise do not waste your time ans sangat's valuable time by just fooling with it just based on rumors or some one said it or this sant says it is bani etc etc so far none of the sant has shown any proof for it only spread stories which finally found to be faked. As just recently in past two decades a baba ji faked the story of a panthik Shaheed Singh and known to be this baba ji was very much respected by panth. So khalsa jio be serious do not just rely some personalities to decide and prove that any bani is Gurbani. Really take the darshan of Sri Guru Granth sahib ji when I say 'really darshan' means read the each word as acceptance of GURU Sahib from "Ik Oankar to Nanak Naam milay tan jivan" and then read so called any bani you think of is Gurbani then come to any conclusion. Do not make up or give any decision on any panthik issue just from top of your head based on ego, jealous or ignorance. Be a Sikh of Guru sahib not to a sant or any other dehdhari. Guru Mehar karay one day will come when every one will accept the Guru Sahib’s hukam on this issue too. Till then pray for your chardi kala because with your chardi kala panth will in chardi kala otherwise wastage of time bottom line this life span and read it if you like it or do not. Do not play politics on this issue and I am really telling you this politics is killing you and your panth. To be honest not against any sant who do sewa for panth on Gurmat principle not to bulid up a dera. But in past century at large seems like later one is the case. "Sub mein ravia akooy soee" Waheguru ji ka khalsa, Waheguru ji ki fateh [%sig%]

Re: Raagmalaa during amrit sanchar

Manjot Singh Khalsa · 26 Jan 2007

Bazzer, Panj Pyare cannot go overriding decisions by the Guru Panth! This is manmat and the panj inserting their own personal agendas into the amrit sanchar. The panj should do what 123 posted.

Re: Raagmalaa during amrit sanchar

maha_moorakh · 27 Jan 2007

panj pyare is satguru [%sig%]

Re: Raagmalaa during amrit sanchar

CSJ · 05 Feb 2007

" Do not make up or give any decision on any panthik issue just from top of your head based on ego, jealous or ignorance. Be a Sikh of Guru sahib not to a sant or any other dehdhari. Guru Mehar karay one day will come when every one will accept the Guru Sahib’s hukam on this issue too." I like to be a sikh of guru sahib not sant or any body else. Is'nt in akj you dont belive in sants but isnt it is same thing as you call bhai and doing the same thing just a word diffrence. Means follow every word like in and othere deras. Dont get me wrong I have respect for bhai sahib. But I like to be sikh of GURU sahib not to anybody else. [%sig%]