Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Guru Nanak called a Devil on the BBC - Audio Now Available

Guru Nanak called a Devil on the BBC - Audio Now Available

q · 14 May 2004

On Tuesday 11th May 2004 on the BBC Asian Network programme, which Sonia Deol presented from 9am to 12.00. > >Guru Nanak, the first Guru of the Sikhs was called a devil. And other derogatory comments were made regarding the Sikh religion. > >After listening to the programme, it seems to me that this girl wasn’t even Sikh, she had no knowledge of Sikhi, which even a 5 year old would know. > >She had claimed that she was considering conversion to Islam, but it was obvious that she already regarded herself as a Muslim, as she frequently used the phase “we Muslims....” > >We therefore had on this show a Muslim girl insulting the Sikh religion live on the BBC. So this is where our taxes are going? > >And without jumping to conclusions, it seen quite obvious that she was in fact a Muslim, and was only on the show to insult Sikhs. And that the extremist views which she was allowed expressed live on air, are the same as those expressed by some banned Islamic organisation in the UK. > >So why was she allowed on this show? > >Surly the BBC would have some vetting procedure? > >This cannot be tolerated. > >Special thanks to www.shaheedkhalsa.com, for the recording and uploading of the programme > >Click on the links below to listen (right click to save as). > >Mp3 >Prelude to the show - Part 1 - http://www.shaheedkhalsa.com/part1.mp3 >Live Show - Part 2 - http://www.shaheedkhalsa.com/part2.mp3 >Closing comments - Part 3 - http://www.shaheedkhalsa.com/part3.mp3 > >Real Player >Full Programme >http://www.shaheedkhalsa.com/BBCAsianNetwork.rm > >Full Programme Streamed (to listen instantly) >http://www.shaheedkhalsa.com/BBCAsianNetwork.ram > >The BBC Asian Network are refusing to take our complaints now, and have refused to release a copy of the radio show > >People are always asking, “how can we do seva, “we want to get involved” etc > >## Act now. Please email the BBC direct to register you complaint. Use this form - ## http://www.bbc.co.uk/info/contactus/serious_form.shtml > >And call her live on her show too, see below for details. >Call Sonia on 08459 440445, >Text Sonia on 07786 202001 >Email Sonia at [address removed] > >We need to get thousands to responded to have a impact >

Re: Guru Nanak called a Devil on the BBC - Audio Now Available

S Singh · 14 May 2004

I don’t think anyone should blame Sonia Deol for what this Muslim said about Guru Nanak Dev Jee. Sonia immediately interrupted the Muslee and told her off.

Re: Guru Nanak called a Devil on the BBC - Audio Now Available

P.Singh · 14 May 2004

SONIA DEOL IS NOT TO BE BLAMED AT ALL!!

Re: Guru Nanak called a Devil on the BBC - Audio Now Available

Tarunjeet Singh · 17 May 2004

Vaheguru ji ka Khalsa Vaheguru ji ki fathe Dear brothers how can you say that she is not to blame??? All major radio stations operate with a 30 second delay, as soon as the comments where made by the muslim girl Sonia deol shoudl have took advatage of the delay and edited the broadcast rather than letting it go out to potentialy thousands of people listening. Then someone called in to complain against what the girl had said and Sonia defended her by saying that "it was keri's opinion" so it was OK to say that. So ask the question again is Soina to balme? Alot of peole are saying its's being blown out of proportion, I don't think so, if you are a Son or Daughter of Guru Nanak then you will feel pain when someone says soemthing hurtful about your father. if we as Sikhs are not willing to stand up for ourselves who else is??? Vaheguru ji ka Khalsa Vaheguru ji ki fathe

Re: Guru Nanak called a Devil on the BBC - Audio Now Available

manjit · 09 Jun 2004

sonia is not 2 b blamed at all tho. I have heard that they DO NOT HAVE A DELAY SYSTEM!!!!!!!!

Re: Guru Nanak called a Devil on the BBC - Audio Now Available

me · 09 Jun 2004

Well then you have heard WRONG you must be going deaf at such an early age. For shame...

Re: Guru Nanak called a Devil on the BBC - Audio Now Available

sikh_in_southall · 10 Jun 2004

look people enough has been said and done i.e complaints to bbc....let us be more vigilant in the future and now let this matter rest.......please don't take this the wrong way and think i don't love guru ji i do........but let us move on from here and address the biggest problem facing the panth.......the management of our guru ghar.....if we don't get rid of the old grandads who are wasting the sangats money on useless building exstentions very soon we will be closing guru ghars because the younger generation who have not be taught about sikh history and the lives of our gurus...just won't attend and some of them won't attend as they may have converted to other religions.......... in my opinion this is the single biggest threat facing the panth...........by the time these old men have spoken there last words and taken all the adulation for the gleaming new building the damage will already be done and we will be left picking up any pieces (thats if there will be any pieces to pick up!)....... this week here in southall (UK) we have had sant anoop singh and bhai balwinder singh rangila doing kirtan........on every occassion when they have done kirtan something or other has been wrong with the p.a system....and when one of the kirtanee has requested for either the mic to be turned up or the sound to be corrected......the granthi runs to the committee walla for permission to do anything with the mixing desk.......!and then someone comes along and starts fiddling and turning knobs randomly........some of you may think this is irrelevant but my point is that these people have a seige mentality and won't allow others to partake in sewa or offer advice on anything other than say what type of washing up liquid is needed in the kitchen.......... please forgive me if i have said anything wrong..........

Re: Guru Nanak called a Devil on the BBC - Audio Now Available

kaur · 10 Jun 2004

I can not believe this, of course she is to balme she should used the 30 second delay all radio's have this !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Re: Guru Nanak called a Devil on the BBC - Audio Now Available

manjit · 12 Jun 2004

well if they do have a 30 second delay system,they prove it!!!!!!!!!!

Re: Guru Nanak called a Devil on the BBC - Audio Now Available

Freedom of Speech · 12 Jun 2004

OMG ppl, others are allowd to state their views..... if this girl wanted to say it, then thats fair enuf, sonia, interrupted her and told her off, and on my behalf this was enough..... next thing, we gonna be like muslims, where if someone insults us, we are gonna want to kill them, or they insult our god, its blasphemy and well cut out their tongue.... ppl are allowed to say wat they want... we were given the opportunity to reply to our comments, and frankily thats fair enough.. although it wouldve been better if the person could actually spk descent english!!

Re: Guru Nanak called a Devil on the BBC - Audio Now Available

MS · 13 Jun 2004

>OMG ppl, others are allowd to state their views..... if this girl wanted to say it, then thats fair enuf, emmmm i dont think so, you belive its oka for someone to say something thats WRONG i.e. incorrect i.e. false, and hurtful for the intention of being hurtful. which it was right? sikhi may belive in fredom of speech however does not grant somone the right to be an ass! >next thing, we gonna be like muslims, where if someone insults us, we are gonna want to kill them, so somone calls or disrespects guroo sahib, i.e my father and you think i shouldnt give them at least a good wack accross their face for it? does that make sense that i ignore such disrespect to my faith, maybe the next time the indian govt attacks a gurdwara i help them out? >ppl are allowed to say wat they want not according to sikhi even the west does not recognise that as its illegal to deny the jewish holocost so in effect if you did, you could go prison for that. im quite suprised somone with a brain would say something to justify somone doing something wrong, and it is wrong what happened right? >we were given the opportunity to reply to our comments, or it would have been better to not have guroo sahib disrespected full stop, wouldnt that have been the better scenario?