the importance of Raag
seek the truth · 05 Feb 2007
Vaheguru ji ka khalsa Vahegurujikifateh
I wanted to ask.
it seems to me that everyone wants to try to live in the way the guru's hundreds of years ago...wear what they wore, eat from the utensils they ate from, eat and drink what they did...
we want to preserve the lareedar saroop of guru granth sahib ji...
we want to try and change as little as possible....
yet.
somehow...raag gets left out of the equation.
Yes its true that what is important is the pyaar in which one sings kirtan..but it all comes down to respect..and simply...if guru sahib wrote the gurugranthsahibji in raag, then why do we find it so difficult to abide by this?
If Raag wasnt important then gurusahib wouldnt have bothered. the akj youth theese days want to live how gurusahib did in their times..wear bana, eat from sarabloh, keep lareedar saroop, but when it comes to raag, which is explcitly written in guru granthsahibji, they seem to ignore it. Additionally, even guru sahibs kirtaneea sata and balwand used to sing in raag.
at all the akj and other programes, there are no youths who seem to have made the effort to sing raag, rather, they make an effort to sing other things just to impress sangat.
we say its too hard, we have to learn this and that...but we make this effort for keeping sarabloh and bibek.
I think raag should be sung at rhensbais as much as it can be.what does the sangat think? i know i myself really enjoy the kirtan thats done in rhensbais, maybe the tune and beat i dont know...but if the tune and th ebeat of kirtan shouldnt matter, then why dont we do raag kirtan? or atleast try?
Vaheguru ji ka khalsa Vaheguru ji ki fateh
The importance of Raag
Harcharan Singh · 05 Feb 2007
Vaheguru ji ka Khalsa Vaheguru ji ki Fateh,
This topic has been brought up many times here.
Bhai Kulbir Singh Ji has previously said that Tapoban Sahib were discussing the topic of raag on an on-going basis, as to pursuing it at Gurdwara Sahib or letting "Raagis" come and perform kirtan at Gurdwara Sahib.
Bhai Balpreet Singh Ji (Tapoban Sahib) has acknowledged at Khalsa Camp UK that kirtan should be done be done in raag .
It would be hugely inspiring and uniting for the panth if AKJ could add this most important Guru Ji da hukum to their already great efforts of keeping Guru Ji's rehit, hukum and cultural traditions alive.
Maybe my aforementioned veers could update sangat on any movement (or lack of) on Tapoban Sahib's stance on this?
Many sections of the Panth are becoming educated as to the anand and meaning of using Nirdareth Raag and the beauty and pleasure of using Guru Ji's beautiful gifted saaj, it would be such a shame if AKJ got left behind in this hugely important part of our Guru's cure for our diseased mind.
Kirtan is the one main aspect that "can" unite our now diverse panth, no one can change or argue against the basis of the whole format of Maharaj or the hukum before every shabad (exc Japji Sahib).
If one wants to hear our Guru sahiban speaking, hear their true emotion, feel the correct interpretation of the shabad, then the nirdareth raag provides the tone behind the voice for our Guru sahiban, their is no way we can misinterpret their words.
Naam abyaas is key to true kirtan, but so is following our Guru's hukum.
Please don't let this turn into a debate about misunderstood concepts re raag kirtan like singing long sur and long alaaps, elements which raagi's overley influenced by Indian classical have brought into Kirtan and by which the majority of the non-raag educated panth judge Guru Ji's kirtan.
We also knowthe sharda and nimrata are core.
It's not a matter of judging Guru Ji's kirtan by a few Raagis who may have given raag a bad name, the key is to learn the real kirtan maryada our selves and then implement it as it should be done - i.e. Gurmat Sangat, not Indian Classical.
Truth is that 90% of raagis, don't sing in Nirdareth raag or follow kirtan maryada i.e. using rahao as the chorus etc.
There is still a lot of work and research to be done, but if sangat doesn't agree with what they have experienced that doesn't mean the whole concept is wrong, and we should write it off, it is our duty to find the correct maryada and learn, use and promote it.
Raag is not that hard to learn, once you know the key rules, with daily practice, sangat can be singing and composing in a very short time. The quality, presentation and skill is obviously like anything else, will come with practice and time, but at least your love and commitment to Guru will be 100% from the start! This is not to say that those who don't do nirdareth raag do not have 100% love, it's just a matter of opportunity and education in most cases, both of which have now pretty much reached all corners of the Earth! The only other bar, is cultural change, which no one really likes, it's difficult to come out of the habit of a lifetime, or do something different to what our idols/role models did.
But as in all things Sikh, the only role model we should place above and above all others, is dhan dhan Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji Maharaj and try and practice and preserve, that which was done by our pyare Guru Sahiban.
Vaheguru
[%sig%]
Re: the importance of Raag
Khalsaspirit · 05 Feb 2007
Waheguru ji ka khalsa
Waheguru ji ki fateh
Good to hear again that at least some Sikhs are recognizing the contribution of great Sikhs to Sikh panth for keeping the pristine tat Rehat of Sikhs. At same time I have seen this question from few ones like above that Akhand Kirtani Jatha is not following the nirdarat raag when they do kirtan, and the complaints are made in such a way for example as above written and they give the impression that Jatha is against Raag. Although I am not talking on behalf of Jatha but as per my experience with the jatha their most Kirtani Singh/Singhnia are well aware about raags and infact do kirtan in raags although not strictly in raags at certain stage of kirtan atmospheric level. But posing them on internet that they do not know how to do kirtan is a childish thinking. With whatever intension some one does this is very clear either they want to improve the parchar by jatha by solely with raag kirtan or they are jealous of some thing with jatha and Guru knows what ever the case is. But the suggestions were well taken already since last 50 years or so. If Sikh panth is reviving the kirtan style then it also a good sign for progress of Sikhi and be a part of it. It is easy to say and post comments but do not follow whatever they him or her self says and it is not going to help any one. Before commenting on any role model, be a role model first. Do the nirdarat raag kirtan in sharda and pyaar continually and once you reach on certain avastha of Naam then others will follow you as well so do not have to bang on others because of ignorance or hate. Jatha Singhs/Singhnia forever supports the raag kirtan but at the same time do not just lost in sangeet only.
I will request this forum sangat please do not mix topics together as one above did and brought Raagmala in to this topic which already out of Raag itself. He/She mentioned
“Let say if you read and it is not bani it make no difference you have read extra but what if this is bani (and it is) then what will you answere to gurushahib”
And FYI, Guru piyare jio you are true it is bani and it is bani of MADAVNAL KAM KANLDA of the poet AALAM but it is not Gurbani.
Waheguru ji ka khalsa
Waheguru ji ki fateh
[%sig%]
Re: the importance of Raag
Khalsaspirit · 05 Feb 2007
Waheguru ji ka khalsa
Waheguru ji ki fateh
Guru piyare jio
Nice to hear that you go to listen Kirtan to revive our wandering mind. Rather starting any discussion I would suggest that let's start keeping our
Amrit vela as strictly as possible. I can assume that at least you follow the Sikh Rehat Maryada. So let's be a more Sikh of Guru Sahib. If you go to reinsabai to listen to kirtan just concentrate on Gurbani and its mood.
Do more n more Naam japp in Amrit vela avoid such discussions for another year or so and see after a year worth of Naam japp at Amrit vela still your mind wants any discussion on this then do more strict amrit vela and also
Concentrate more n more in Ardas you do after Nitnem. Especially second last tuk
"Sayee piyare mail jina milayan tera naam chit avay"
Waheguru ji ka khalsa
Waheguru ji ki fateh
[%sig%]