Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Who constitutes 'Guru Ka Sikh'?

Who constitutes 'Guru Ka Sikh'?

Indy · 09 May 2003

Can someone advise if the following are considered Sikhs of the Guru? Bhai Nand Lal Goya, the Udasis, Nirmaley and Bhai Kanaiya. From my understanding none of the aforementioned recieved Pahul from Guru Sahib. Although Guru Ji respected them all. Guru Gobind Singh Ji himself started the Nirmaley....and the Udasis were initiated by Baba Siri Chand. Here in the UK some Singh's claim that these two sects were part of the Sikh Panth during the period of the Guru and widely accepted. Their contribution towards the preaching of Sikh doctrine and production of philosophical literature in Sanskrit, Braj, Hindi and Punjabi is considerable. Giani Gian Singh who wrote Panth Prakash was also a Nirmala. Some Nirmaley have been baptised. These guys are normally found on the way to Hemkunt Sahib.

Re: Who constitutes 'Guru Ka Sikh'?

kulpreetsingh · 09 May 2003

VAAHEGUROOJEEKAAKHAALSAA !!! VAAHEGUROOJEEKEEFATHEH !!! In his book, "Turban and Sword of the Sikhs: Essence of Sikhism," Bhai Tirlochan Singh provides photocopies of some actual hukamnamas from the mother of the sahibazadas, Mata Sundari Jee, The Hukamnama states the names of many people, an excerpt below: ... "Bhai Mal, Bhai Babu Rai, Bhai Chauna Mal, Bhai Daya Ram, Bhai Bagh Rai, Bhai Chatur Bhoj. You are all the Khaalsaa of Akaal Purakh, comprising the Patnaa sangat. The Guroo shall be your protector, contemplate the divine name Vaah Guru Vaah Guru. Your mortal life hall be morally and spiritually exhalted and felicitated." These were individuals who were Sikhs of Guru jee and had taken pahul (charn pahul) before Baisakhi. Clearly, a Khalsa is all that Bhai Nand Lal wrote in his poem "Khalsa Soee" and all that Guru Gobind Singh jee wrote in his bani. And clearly, the Sikhs of Guru Nanak through all the 9 Suroops were Khalsa. Mata Khivi was Khalsa. Bhai Gurdas was Khalsa. Baba Buddhaa Jee was Khalsa. Please, *please,* if anybody has information to the contrary please correct daas, but I think the only person who took khande-ke-pahul who had taken charn pahul from the Guru already, was Guru Gobind Singh, and that's because he was passing the physical Gurgadhee to the Punj Pyare. Guru jee makes this clear when he says "Khalsa mero roop hai khaas," and Bhai Nand Lal jee makes this clear when he says "Ik Sikh, Dho Sangat, Panj Parmeshar" (One is a Sikh, Two are Sangat, Five are the embodiment of the all-permeating Enlightener). I haven't read Bhai Santokh Singh jee or Giani Gian Singh jee's writings well enough to know what they say of Bhai Kannaiya jee and Bhai Nand Lal jee; but many historians say Bhai Nand Lal jee was a Singh - as even in the Amrit Keertan many of his hymns are written telling Sikhs to take pahul. If those two Sikhs did not take khande-ke-pahul they definately must have taken charn pahul. The udasees are not Khalsas or part of the Panth, to the best of my knowledge -- maybe somebody in the sangat could further elaborate on the rest of "Indy" jee's question as I don't have the wisdom. Stay in chardeekalaa always, VAAHEGUROOJEEKAAKHAALSAA !!! VAAHEGUROOJEEKEEFATHEH !!!

Re: Who constitutes 'Guru Ka Sikh'?

Kulbir Singh · 15 May 2003

Veer Kulpreet Singh jeeo, Please correct me if I am wrong but your assertion seems to be that the Sikhs who had taken charun pahul were not required to take amrit. Is this correct? Please verify. Guru Gobind Singh jee had taken Charun Pahul and he too took amrit from the Punj Pyaare. Then Bhai Ram Kuyer jee who was a Brahmgiyaani as per Sikh history too amrit. The saakhi goes as follows: One day Mata Gujree jee while doing paath at amritvela, asked her son Guru Gobind Singh jee if she could have darshan of a brahmgiyaani as described in the 8th Ashtpadi of Siri Sukhmani Sahib. Guru Sahib replied saying that the brahmgiyani Sikh would be at Siri Anandpur by noon that day. After saying this to Mata jee, Guru Sahib asked Ram Kuyer jee who lived at Lahore at that time, to come to Anandpur Sahib before noon. Now we all know that there were no phones or telegram system at that time. Guru Sahib sent him the hukam through aatma. Bhai Raam Kuyer jee heard the hukam of Guru Sahib from within and thought to himself that it was not possible to reach Siri Anandpur Sahib from Lahore using normal means, before noon. So he used his shakti and arrived at Siri Anandpur Sahib in a split second and met Mata jee. Such great gursikhs like Baba Ram Kuyer jee too had to take amrit. He took amrit and was named Gurbaksh Singh. This event is recorded in Sooraj Parkaash Granth and many other granths. If Gursikhs like Baba Raam Kuyer jee were not exempt from not taking amrit, who would have been? The reality is that everyone had to take amrit. I appeal Veer Balpreet Singh to post a historical reference whereby the Delhi sangat was divided in half over taking amrit. They were refusing to take amrit. By the way, Baba Raam Kuyer jee was the great grandson of Pooran Brahmgiyaani Baba Budda jee. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: Who constitutes 'Guru Ka Sikh'?

Manjit Singh · 15 May 2003

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa, Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh. If you believe that the Vaisakhi Smagam of 1699 is true, then the Khalsa(or Sikh) is one who do take amrit from Panj(not from so called Sants etc.). This is the only way Guru Sahib Ji told us to enter Sikhi. If someone like KalaAfgana or Nirmlas or Udassees adopts any other way to become a Sikh(Khalsa), he/she is a big time liar and I would say is cheating him/herself. As Guru Sahib ji says "Nigure Ka Hai Nauon Burraa", no one without amrit chhak can be a Sikh(Khalsa). So it doesn't matter who someone is (Udaasi, Nirmla or whoever), Amrit is the kassoutee (touchstone) to be Sikh(Khalsa). Manjit Singh

Re: Who constitutes 'Guru Ka Sikh'?

suraj · 16 May 2003

manjit singh veer can i ask u a question please if u dont mind? is it written anywhere that you have to take amrit?im a bit confused consdering most of asia people r either muslims and hindus how do we expect them to become amritdhari?

Re: Who constitutes 'Guru Ka Sikh'?

Singhnee · 16 May 2003

Waheguru jee kaa khalsa!! Waheguru jee kee fateh!! Dear Suraj jee, to be a sikh it's important to take amrit. Without amrit from punj no one can become a sikh.

Re: Who constitutes 'Guru Ka Sikh'?

Manjit Singh · 16 May 2003

>>>manjit singh veer can i ask u a question please if u dont mind? is it written anywhere that you have to take amrit?<<< Mr suraj Jee if you go through my posting again, I said that if you believe in what happened on Vaisaakhee of 1699, then amrit is necessary to be a sikh, if you don't believe in that wonderful happening then you can invent your own definition of a sikh. As for the concern if it is written anywhere: It has been documented by many author since then. For example: A letter written by Aurangjeb's Spy agent. Books written by many authors like Bhai Gurdaas Singh, Santokh Singh. Bhatt Vahian. RehitNamme written by Sikhs. >>>im a bit confused consdering most of asia people r either muslims and hindus how do we expect them to become amritdhari?<<< Even I am bit confused what are you trying to say here. I don't expect that a muslim or hindu should be amritdhari if they have to be muslim or hindu. But if someone wants to be a sikh then he/she has to take amrit. If you are saying that sikhs can be in more numbers if this condition of amrit is waived, the first thing is that no one has the right to waive it and say that amrit is not necessary and second Guru Gobind Singh Jee might have given amrit to Hill rulers (Paharhi Raje) who were at time ready to take amrit if they were allowed to keep the caste system and other such social evils. Shirimaan suraj jee I am sorry if that hurt your feelings but that is the truth I know. Manjit Singh

Re: Who constitutes 'Guru Ka Sikh'?

Balpreet Singh · 16 May 2003

All Sehajdhaarees and charan-pahulees in the time of Guru Gobind Singh jee were encouraged to receive Khanday Kee Paahul. Sainapati, a Kavi of Guru Gobind Singh jee, wrote Sree Guru Sobha which is dated in the early 1700s and is considered by all scholars to be an authentic contemporary account of Guru Saahib's life and the happenings of that time. One of the events he records with quite a bit of detail is the conflict between the Khalsa in Delhi and the Sehajdhaarees (he writes that they were mainly Khatree shop-owners). The Sehajdhaarees resisted becoming Khalsa because it would have required them to abandon their age-old custom of bhadun (shaving the head at ceremonial occassions). The result was a conflict in Delhi where the Khalsa's shops were boycotted by the Sehajdhaarees. I'll write more on this later when I have a copy of Guru Sobha with me. Another interesting account is found in Bhai Mani Singh jee's Giaan Ratnaavalee. In this, there is a conversation between the Sehajdhaaree/Charan Pahulee Sikhs and Guru Gobind Singh jee. The Charan Pahulees/Sehajdharees complain that the Khalsa is insisting they abandon their old practices and take on new Khalsa ones like Anand marriage, not feeding Brahmins at death etc. Guru Saahib encourages these Sikhs to slowly adopt the new practices but asks that their children be made Khalsa for sure. Thus, it's clear from historical sources that those who were Sikhs before Khanday Kee Paahul had to become Khalsa as well. Some resisted and there was conflict between the Khalsa and those who refused to take Khanday Kee Paahul and rejected it as unneccessary.

Re: Who constitutes 'Guru Ka Sikh'?

.. · 17 May 2003

does the guru granth sahib state u have to become amritdhari??

Re: Who constitutes 'Guru Ka Sikh'?

Kulbir Singh · 18 May 2003

Amrit of Khanda Baata is an initiation ceremony. Without doing this ceremony one cannot be a Sikh of Guru. During amrit sinchaar one formally adopts Guru Nanak as their Guru. As for reference in Gurbani with respect to amrit, all pankitis in Guru Granth Sahib jee that point to taking deekhiya, getting Naam from Guru, coming to Guru, adopting Guru, are references to one becoming an amritdhari. If not amrit chhak, what other way is there to adopt Guru Granth Sahib jee as your Guru? Sikhi is is not a jaat or race, that one is born into it. If one is a Caucasian, one is born a Caucasian and if one is of some jaat paat, one is born in it. But to become a Sikh, you cannot be a born Sikh. You adopt Sikhi and this adoption of Sikhi is amrit chhakna. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: Who constitutes 'Guru Ka Sikh'?

Indy · 19 May 2003

Some interesting responses have been posted. Kulbir Singh/Manjit Singh - How do we define Guru? In Gurbani, a few Bhagats have been called Gurmukh. These Bhagats were present way before Guru Ji himself. Now the question arises, why would Guru Ji call them Gurmukh? How can Nigure Ka Hai Nauon Burraa apply to these individuals whose Bani is included in the Guru Granth Sahib. Personally, I believe they were Sikhs then and now and will be in the future. Sikhi did not start during Guru Nanak Sahibs period. Sikhi is truth in itself and therefore is not restricted by time. Now this begs the question, can people who follow Sikhi in their everyday lives without actually knowing it, achieve Mukti? Concerning these Bhagats Gurbani asserts: As Gurmukh, Prahlaad meditated on the Lord, and was saved. gurmukh par-hilaad jap har gat paa-ee. As Gurmukh, Janak lovingly centered his consciousness on the Lord`s Name. gurmukh janak har naam liv laa-ee. As Gurmukh, Vashisht taught the Teachings of the Lord. gurmukh basist har updays sunaa-ee. Without the Guru, no one has found the Lord`s Name, O my Siblings of Destiny. bin gur har naam na kinai paa-i-aa mayray bhaa-ee. The Lord blesses the Gurmukh with devotion. ||13|| gurmukh har bhagat har aap lahaa-ee. ||13|| There are many examples where guru ji and bhagat expressed the same idea "Ram Kabira ek bhai hai/koi na skey pachhani" Ram and Kabir are one and nobody can find the difference. Guru Tegh Bahadur says the same thing "Nanak lean bhao Gobind seon jion pani sang pani." I am merged in God as water merges in water. There is no ego involved in the assertion of the Guru.

Re: Who constitutes 'Guru Ka Sikh'?

kulpreetsingh · 19 May 2003

Veer Kulbir Singh jee & Sadh Sangat, VAAHEGUROOJEEKAAKHAALSAA!!! VAAHEGUROOJEEKEEFATHEH !!! Just to clarify - and my apologies for taking so long to reply... ***vancouver smagam hit like a train of kirpaa... and sent me straight to swarag*** but i'm back and just to clarify - "pritham rehit yeh kar jaan khande-ke-pahul chhakay" i think the first rehit of sikhi is khande-ke-pahul however, the hukamnamas from mata sahib deva jee and mata sundri jee actually refer to the names of charan-pahaulee sikhs, without "singh" and call them "khalsa" (she actually says "you are the Khalsa of Akaal Purakh") it's in that book "Turban and Sword of the Sikhs: Essence of Sikhism," by Bhai Tirlochan Singh I am at the mercy of the sangat to explain this. I cannot assert anything on my own - because I have no knowledge. The best I can hope for is "tehel santhan kee sang saadhoo kaa" " hum bheekhakh baykhaaree thayray ... thoo nij path hai daathaa... hohu deiaal naam dhayho mangat jan ko... sadhaa raho rang raathaa" anaykaa galtheeaa dee khaymaa bakshnaa / please grant me forgiveness for the countless errors in my judgement VAAHEGUROOJEEKAAKHAALSAA !!! VAAHEGUROOJEEKEEFATHEH !!!

Re: Who constitutes 'Guru Ka Sikh'?

kulpreetsingh · 19 May 2003

Pyare "Indy" jee, VAAHEGUROOJEEKAAKHAALSAA!!! VAAHEGUROOJEEKEEFATHEH !!! The gurmantr that was given to Sikhs from the Guru is Vaaheguroo. "Vaaheguroo gurmantr hai jaap haumai kho-ay" - Bhai Gurdas jee Reciting it, all egotistic pride is lost. The gurmantr that bhagat kabeer jee got from his Guru, I think it was ramanand jee, was "Raam" bhagat kabeer jee's gurmantr was raam, he recited raam raam without fail, and was always devoted to his Guru. in the same way, Jesus was baptised by Joseph. in the same way, was the relationship between Krishna and his Sikhs, Buddha and his Sikhs, etc. This Gursikhee is "agam," "agochar," "gahar gambheer," "apaar," "ananth," "amrit" without match, without limit, far reaching, deep and profound, without a shore, without an end, without a death This Gursikhee is "khannion thikhee vaalon nikkee" sharper than the edge of a sword, thinner than a strand of hair This Gursikhee is "nirmolak heeraa," "ratan," "anayk roop nau nav nidh, this dhaa anth na jaee paaiaa" a priceless gem, a jewel, a diamond, the embodiment of countless beautiful essence of life - all the nine treasures and more, there is no limit to its praises This Gursikhee, this devotion, has lasted from time immemorial, but those who practiced it were "niaaray," "virlay," "iknaa" unique, extremely rare, one-of-a-kind, one-in-a-(VERY LARGE NUMBER) The Enlightener of the Universe is ONE, the True Enlightener, the Satguroo, and in this way we are all Sikhs of that Satguroo - that wonderous enlightener, Wahe... Guroo. However, the Sikhs of Guru Nanak in the Kal Yug are the Fauj of Akaal Purakh, blessed with the priceless gem of Gursikhee, the vast immortal nectar of Khande-ke-pahul, and the all-encompassing and liberating Naam. On top of this, the Sikh of Guru Nanak in the Kal Yug are blessed with dhur-kee-baanee, the guidance of all ages, by following which, even the most wretched soul would become pure. 'suntay puneet kahtay pavit satgur rahiaa bharpooray' And this purification comes from the true religion. Guru Nanak said himself "there is no hindu, nor a musalmaan" Does it sound pretensious, egotistical, proposterous for me to say all devotees of God are Sikhs? I wouldn't think so - but you're right pyare Indy jee, Sikhi has, does, and will always exceed the boundaries of the universe as long as Waaheguroo chooses. It is the relationship between the seeking soul, the enlightener soul, and the supreme soul. All three are one, and all three represent the universal Sikhi that is the true religion, which is the foundation of all worldly faiths. By practicing the teachings of the Guru - your Guru - so if you are a Sikh of Guru Nanak, be a proper one, if you are Hindu, be a proper Hindu, a Muslim a proper Muslim, you will recognize the underlying true religion. The problem is, almost all religion has lost all of this, "Sraavag sudh samuh sidhaan kay daykh firio ghar jog jatee kay || soor suraardan sudh sadhaadik sant samuh anayk mathee kay || saree hee days ko daykh rahio mat kou naa dekhiath praan pathee kay || " This is the Sikhi of Dhan Guru Gobind Singh, the Sikhi of Dhan Guru Nanak, the enlightened path in the kal yug. All paths that are based on that true religion, and make God the husband soul and God's name the source of life can lead to muktee... but i am a sacrifice to the Sikhs of Guru Nanak ... the ones who ask not for reign or liberation, but humility. "raaj n chaaho mukath n chaaho man preeth churun kumulaarae" I am a sacrifice to those Gursikhs - who show that true religion with pride, that long-lost true religion that Guru Nanak brought back into the Kal Yug. The true religion had always been there, "mun thoo joth suroop hai," but we are forgetful and fall back into maya. We do not recognize our roots. "apnaa mool pachhaan." As all the saints had their Guru, the "jagat gur baba" of the dark age is Nanak, by whose grace, the fortunate Gursikhs become exhalted. "Satgur naanak pargatiaa mittee dhundh jag chaanan hoaa" On this dark and long travel across the world ocean, Gursikhi is like a high-speed jet. "aisay gur ko bal bal jaeeai... aap mukat mohay thaaray" i went way overboard, and said too much, and made many mistakes i'm sure - please correct me and forgive me. VAAHEGUROOJEEKAAKHAALSAA !!! VAAHEGUROOJEEKEEFATHEH !!!

Re: Who constitutes 'Guru Ka Sikh'?

.. · 20 May 2003

sorry to ask this but i got a q on my mind , who did bhagat prahlaad and raja janak take amrit from in order to get to god? or was it their own individual efforts ie naam japping all their life that got them to liberation?

Re: Who constitutes 'Guru Ka Sikh'?

Manjit Singh · 27 May 2003

Indy Ji writes >>> How can Nigure Ka Hai Nauon Burraa apply to these individuals whose Bani is included in the Guru Granth Sahib. <<< and .. (two dots) writes >>> sorry to ask this but i got a q on my mind , who did bhagat prahlaad and raja janak take amrit from in order to get to god? or was it their own individual efforts ie naam japping all their life that got them to liberation? <<< Let me ask you both this, did these individuals(Bhagats, Gurmukhs, Raja Janak) exist physically after Vaisakhee of 1699? Even a foolish like me will say no to this. Then what is the question of them taking amrit(the current way). They did what their Guru told them to do and at this time for to be Sikh we have to do what our Guru Sahib Jio told us to do. As Bhai Kulbir Singh has already written that even Guru Gobind Singh Ji took Amrit and this is a big slap on the face of those liars and fools who say(intentionally) Amrit is not necessary to be a Sikh. Gurbani says that it is mandatory to have a Guru in order to reach the destination(God). There are so many stories or sakhies about the Gurus of Raja Janak and Prahlad, then how can you call them nigure. Of course every individual has to do effort(bhagti) to reach God but no effort can be successful without Guru. Manjit Singh

Re: Who constitutes 'Guru Ka Sikh'?

Manjit Singh · 27 May 2003

Mr/Ms .. ji said: >>>does the guru granth sahib state u have to become amritdhari??<<< Yes, if you can undersatand. How can you otherwise call Guru Granth Sahib Ji as your Guru. To become guruwala you have to adopt some way otherwise even a Ganja(by choice) can call himself a Sikh. Do you think you will become a sikh by just calling yourself a sikh? Please do not cheat on yourself. I urge all please do not ask naive questions like: Is all sikh rehit written in Guru Granth Sahib Ji? Is it written in Guru Granth Sahib Ji that Guru gobind Singh Ji took amrit too? Is it written in Guru Granth Sahib Ji that Sarbloh is a rehit? Are all bujjar kurahits written in Guru Granth Sahib Ji? etc.etc.etc.

Re: Who constitutes 'Guru Ka Sikh'?

daljit · 31 May 2003

i dont mean to be rude manjit singh but whats naive to u isnt always to other peopel who wish to lern and come to this site for that reason...do u expect everyone to be at ur level of understanding in sikhi ?? this isnt fair.. if they dont know please hemp them with answers so they learn and benefit.. each individual is different everyones level here is different, at one time i thought sarbloh ki ustat mite have been in guru granth sahib till someone corrected me. on this site how do u know what kind of person ur comminucating with?? it cud be someone with rehat, somebody who doesnt know anything, someone who may know little. in that case shudnt we try and help them understand?? i would much rather meet a ganja who does his banis, and refrains from intoxicants remains humble, than a person with kes who doesnt even see god shining through the whole of humanity, when their time coms to grow kes they will get the inner call, meanwhile who am i to judge who is a sikh who isnt? thats for God to know in His hands.. i am supposd to become the dust of the floor in order to get anywhere..

Re: Who constitutes 'Guru Ka Sikh'?

Indy · 31 May 2003

Manjit Singh Ji, There seems to have been a misunderstanding. When you wrote 'the Khalsa(or Sikh) is one who do take amrit from Panj' and "Nigure Ka Hai Nauon Burraa", I thought you were implying that because the Udasis, Nirmaley etc did not have a Guru or recieve pahul from the Panj Piyare they therefore by default had a bad reputation and were not Sikhs?? I concur with Daljit Singh that not everyone has the same level of thinking where Sikhi is concerned - this of course is dependent on the amount of Kirpa Guru Ji has bestowed on them.

Re: Who constitutes 'Guru Ka Sikh'?

Manjit Singh · 31 May 2003

daljit ji You wrote >>>i dont mean to be rude manjit singh but whats naive to u isnt always to other peopel who wish to lern and come to this site for that reason...do u expect everyone to be at ur level of understanding in sikhi ?? this isnt fair.. <<< Even if you are rude to me I don't mind because that does not going to effect me physically or mentaly. Another thing you are absolutely write that this site is to learn something but I will add to that that this site is not to abuse that learning process. Next you wrote >>>on this site how do u know what kind of person ur comminucating with?? it cud be someone with rehat, somebody who doesnt know anything, someone who may know little. in that case shudnt we try and help them understand?? <<< I think after reading few messages on a topic any sensible person can guess who is talking from which channel. Next you wrote >>> i would much rather meet a ganja who does his banis, and refrains from intoxicants remains humble, than a person with kes who doesnt even see god shining through the whole of humanity, when their time coms to grow kes they will get the inner call, meanwhile who am i to judge who is a sikh who isnt? thats for God to know in His hands.. i am supposd to become the dust of the floor in order to get anywhere.. <<< It is a very humble request to you, please read carefully and think twice before you say or write something. To me what you have said is irrelavent to this topic. I will request you read all the posting in this topic again because I don't want to repeat same thing again and again. We are not judging if someone is Sikh or not, we are here stating facts based on Gurmat, Gurbani and history that makes you understand who you can call a Sikh. I am sorry to say that the kind of statements you used like ........... who am i to judge who is a sikh who isnt? thats for God to know in His hands.. are being used by antipanthic forces to exploit the sikh nation. They have a very general definition of a Sikh, you are a sikh if you call yourself a sikh and that all you need to be a sikh and you get all the rights like 1. Manage the sikh institutions 2. Decide what is Gurmat 3. Redefine who can be a sikh etc.etc.etc............ Please pardon me if I have said anything against gurmat.