Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Anyone see Partition:Last days of the raj on Channel 4?

Anyone see Partition:Last days of the raj on Channel 4?

Dalbiri · 13 Mar 2007

Saw this last night (9.00pm). Never seen such a biased program before. Made Sikhs look like savage trouble makers during partition. Hardly broached the Sikh perspective apart from a bit by Master Tara Singh's granddaughter. Made complaint to Ofcom and Channel 4 for what it's worth. Program was sickening.

Re: Anyone see Partition:Last days of the raj on Channel 4?

Manvir Singh Khalsa · 13 Mar 2007

The documentary was nicely put together and showed that the documentary makers had put efforts to produce a representative account of the days leading to partition. However, the documentary did not do justice for the Sikhs. Below is a Complaint which I have sent to Channel 4 and Ofcom (the television regulators). Benti to Sangat - please help to complain. I sent this to Channel4.com, building upon what Dal Singh jee wrote in his complaint: [quote]Subject: Racism & Ill-Feeling Against Sikhs in Documentary On 12th March 2007 at 9pm, Channel 4 aired the programme "Partition". The programme was totally biased, misrepresentative of the Sikh perspective, which was very offensive, and many Sikhs feel invoked racism against Sikhs. 1. The Sikhs of Panjab were portrayed as communal troublemakers and shown as barbaric savages whereas the Muslims were simply defending themselves and the Hindus were peace-loving people caught up in the tension. This is firstly, totally false. Secondly, it invokes racial hatred against Sikhs as the other two communities (Hindus and Muslims) were portrayed as the victims. 2. The programme largely focused on Panjab, which historically has been the Sikh homeland and it is widely known the Sikh Kingdom which the last part of India to be annexed by the British was based in Panjab with it's capital Lahore and stretched from Kabul to Delhi. However, the programme only featured one Sikh speaker who was featured making comments "twice" only. Considering the history and politics, it was irresponsible of the documentary makers not including more Sikh speakers and the bias views shown incited hatred and ill feeling against Sikhs. 3. The documentary overlooked the disproportionate contribution and sacrifice of Sikhs for the independence movement as well as failing to explaining the position of Sikhs prior to the British invasion/annex of Panjab was mischievous to say the least. On the other hand it focused on the Muslim League and Congress Party contributions. 4. The documentary portrayed the British as a concerned innocent party throughout the programme, which was very patronizing, hypocritical and offensive. Prior to the British invasion of Panjab, the Sikhs had achieved communal harmony in the Panjab under Maharaja Ranjit Singh. However, 100 years of the British Raaj and the British policy of "Divide and Rule" led to communal in fighting as shown in the programme. 5. Master Tara Singh and Mr. Baldev Singh were only mentioned in minor detail. The documentary failed to even mention whom Baldev Singh was, his background and proposal. The proposal of a Sikh independent state was not mentioned and how the Congress made promises of the Sikhs of full autonomy and sovereignty in the independent India. In conclusion the documentary makers did a praise-worthy job in compiling the programme together and efforts to make a balanced account of history, however the Sikh community are disappointed and hurt by the bias and misrepresentation shown in the programme, which undoubtedly invokes ill feeling and racial hatred against Sikhs in viewers who are unaware of the reality. I would urge the documentary makers to make an apology to the Sikh Community for indirectly invoking racial hatred against Sikhs through the poor documentation of the programme, and in future documentary makers produce a more representative, unbiased and wholesome account of historical events. I await a reply. Kind regards[/quote] Benti - The more people that complain to Ofcom and Channel 4, the more seriously television producers will take in account the Sikh Opinion. It may seem "minor" or "small issue" to some, however, if this goes unnoticed it allows more misrepresentation and more bias in the future. Best to nip the issue in the bud. To make a complaint: [url=http://help.channel4.com/SRVS/CGI-BIN/WEBCGI.EXE?New,Kb=C4_Author,Company={2EA1BB9C-510E-44A5-A481-01EB1DDA1669},T=CONTACT_VE,VARSET_TITLE=General]Channel4 Complaint Form[/url] [url=http://www.ofcom.org.uk/complain/progs/specific/?itemid=286480]Complain to Ofcom[/url] Details of the Programme: Programme title: [i]PARTITION: The Last Days of the Raj [/i]Date(s) & time(s) of broadcast: [i]12/03/07, 9pm to 10.30pm[/i] Channel / station: [i]Channel 4[/i] Bhul Chuk Maaf. Manvir Singh

Re: Anyone see Partition:Last days of the raj on Channel 4?

Pwalla! · 14 Mar 2007

http://help.channel4.com/SRVS/CGI-BIN/WEBCGI.EXE/,/?St=66,E=0000000000012538581,K=6732,Sxi=0,remove=problems,PROBLEM=obj(494),VARSET_OBJECTID=494,VARSET_OBJECTNAME=Making%20a%20complaint Link for Channel 4 Complaints. Please listen to the benti made by gursikhs. Waheguroo ji ka khalsa, waheguroo ji ki fateh

Re: Anyone see Partition:Last days of the raj on Channel 4?

High Spirits · 14 Mar 2007

I used Manvir Singhs template because it was excellent and have also logged a complaint.

Re: Anyone see Partition:Last days of the raj on Channel 4?

Dalbiri · 14 Mar 2007

The template was based on something I wrote earlier on another site. I beg the sangat to write the complaint in their own words and complain to both Channel 4 AND Ofcom. The reason I say this is because I feel that sending duplicate copies of complaints will have less of an impact than sending your own personalised one. Otherwise it will look like lemmings are acting together. No offence intended if anyone takes it that way.

Re: Anyone see Partition:Last days of the raj on Channel 4?

Satwinder Singh Khalsa · 14 Mar 2007

Please sangat jee, send them complaints as many as we can. I just send it. It is very important to raise this issue with people who made this documentary, so that in future they don't present such a biased and irresponsible account of Sikh history. [%sig%]

Re: Anyone see Partition:Last days of the raj on Channel 4?

Sitara · 16 Mar 2007

There was also a comment made by a Pakistani gentleman he said the following... The Hindus can see a storm coming from far away and will act on it The Muslims will only act when the storm is on top of them and; The Sikhs will only act when the storm has passed away. [%sig%]

Re: Anyone see Partition:Last days of the raj on Channel 4?

Dalbiri · 16 Mar 2007

There was also a comment made by a Pakistani gentleman he said the following... The Hindus can see a storm coming from far away and will act on it The Muslims will only act when the storm is on top of them and; The Sikhs will only act when the storm has passed away. ---------------- Sadly that is usually true....

Re: Anyone see Partition:Last days of the raj on Channel 4?

dogra · 17 Mar 2007

Some historical facts were missed as pointed out. Master Tara Singh, raised his sword in March 1947, but the Muslim League National Guards were commiting acts of murder against nonmuslims before: http://voi.org/books/mla/ch3.htm “Among Hindus and Sikhs resentment at the agitation is growing and, particularly in the case of the latter in an ominous degree.  On the 12th of February in the second statement he has issued against the agitation since it started, Master Tara Singh declared that it was communal in its essentials and has as its purpose the domination of the Punjab by Muslims.  He called on the Sikhs to prepare themselves to face the Muslim League onslaught and towards this and to reorganize the Akal Fauj. There is no doubt that this historical fact of the Muslim League agitation of violence and murder was to create a 'them' and 'us' situartion, where before people of all faiths got along peacefully for the most part. Jinnah was the leader who turned to the dark side to push communal hatred, these r facts. Channel 4 completely failed to bring these facts into focus, and the reasons for Master Tara Singhs Actions. Partition was an abomination of evil, against the democratic will of the people. The Muslim League got proportional representation: Yet, when the British Colonial govt. invited representatives of the Indian people for political negotiations in 1945, the Muslim League was given as much representation as the Congress. The Congress, that represented all sections of Indian society and had support all over the country, was allowed to nominate only 5 members out of 14! The Muslim League with a fraction of the Congress's mass base was also allocated 5 nominees, and the colonial government picked 4 of it's own to represent Sikhs, Dalits and Muslims. http://india_resource.tripod.com/hist-2nation.html

Re: Anyone see Partition:Last days of the raj on Channel 4?

Dalbiri · 18 Mar 2007

I just got a reply from Channel 4 which basically said "sorry you felt offended and that the program was biased. We have passed on your complaint around the company via bulletin boards. Thank you" I sent a reply asking what they will do to make sure Sikhs are not misrepresented in this way again and what they plan to do to redress the portrayal. Don't expect much from them though.

Re: Anyone see Partition:Last days of the raj on Channel 4?

sloughsingh · 18 Mar 2007

If the British picked their own four to represent the sikhs then how can any of you be so blind not to see that the british governments intention was to screw the sikhs.....you would have to be pretty ignorant.....they sure got revenge on us for causing them such problems but hey I love karmic law because they are reaping the rewards in plentiful supply of their creation of pakistan...ha ha ha

Re: Anyone see Partition:Last days of the raj on Channel 4?

dogra · 18 Mar 2007

The British govtn, actions was to partition India, in the first place, as they wanted a buffer state to gain access to the Middle East Oilfields. Through Jinnah they pshed this, even when other leaders of the Muslim faith like: Allah Baksh-Sind Sikhnader Hayat Khan-Punjab Abdul Ghaffar Khan -NWFP, were all against partition. Jinnah never spent a single day in Jail also verifies this. https://www.vedamsbooks.com/no42136.htm Allah Baksh even organised a Azad muslims conference a few months after the 1940 Lahore declaration, to oppose partition: http://www.countercurrents.org/comm-naurya140503.htm "Soon after the assassination of the legendary Allah Baksh on May 14, 1943, a young Sikh in Lahore wrote an elementary biography of the murdered leader. The first part of the title of the book by Jagat Singh Bright was "India's Nationalist No 1". Today, 60 years after the killing, India barely remembers Allah Baksh and his resounding challenge to Muslim separatism through the Independent (or Azad) Muslims Conference that this Sind Premier organized in Delhi in April 1940, a month after the Muslim League passed its Partition resolution at Lahore. The Conference, presided over by Allah Baksh, shook up the British establishment. Azad wrote: "The session was so impressive that even the British and the Anglo-Indian press, which normally tried to belittle the importance of nationalist Muslims, could not ignore it. They were compelled to acknowledge that this Conference proved that nationalist Muslims were not a negligible factor". This all-India Conference, which Nehru described in his `The Discovery of India' as "very representative and very successful" is today a forgotten event. The man who organised it may not even have existed so far as most of our historians are concerned. "

Re: Anyone see Partition:Last days of the raj on Channel 4?

jassmannn · 20 Mar 2007

I also watched the programme, and am a Sikh working in the media. Why do faiths always get up in arms when someone critisizes them on TV. Do you all honestly believe that Sikhs are always blameless and must always be presented in a positive light? Minorities from all faiths were to blame for the havoc caused during the partition. As there were innocent Sikhs, so there were Muslims and Hindus. And if you think that no Sikh acted irresponsibly during the attacks, then all we need to do is to look at the things that we do wrong, daily or in our lives. We are humans after all, and I's just dissapointed that faiths stand up in arms in an attempt to dissolve themselves of any blame, or because of their political and rational ignorance or because they actually have somethime to hide, and this applies to all faiths. Sorry for rudeness, but it does get on my nerves.

Re: Anyone see Partition:Last days of the raj on Channel 4?

Dalbiri · 22 Mar 2007

Jassman I'm not saying that we need to be purely presented positively but that program was blatantly biased. The Sikh perspective was practically ignored.

Re: Anyone see Partition:Last days of the raj on Channel 4?

Man Singh · 22 Mar 2007

Mr Jassmannn, I am a village boy and have seen dacoits coming to my village many time during my childhood and looted the whole village. Terrorised by those thuggs, a village youth organised the youngusters and inspired them to face the dacoits. These village boys killed a few dacoits when dacoits next time attacked. Police came and media reported. The conclusion of the story was that village boys behaved irresponsibly and they should have called police when dacoits came and should not have taken law in their own hands. This village is around 45 Km South West of Meerut and tere were no telephones, proper Roads or cars in this village in 1978 when it happened. You are not rude Mr Jassmann at all. Your mind is trained to associate with hunters and not with lions who suffered at the hands of hunters. If I were the reported, I could have identified very clearly who the culprit that and who were victims based on the following simple questions: 1. Who demnded separation? 2. Who thretened `direct action' ie violence and killing 3. Who acted merely to defend themselves Clearly those did item no 1&2 are the cause of evil. Those who acted as per item 3 were innopcent victims.

Re: Anyone see Partition:Last days of the raj on Channel 4?

jassmannn · 23 Mar 2007

The world, my friend, is not soo black and white. The evil and righteous etc. i.e. even the Lion itself is a hunter when it hunts for its food, and the Lion is not always the one being persecuted, although as Singhs it is a very romantic idea we like to associate with. Also, it is hard to determine who threatened 'direct action' and violence, as we know how hot blooded Punjabi's can be, especially when it comes to land. So it could have been either side, whether the Sikhs the Hindus or the Muslims. As an ex-jornalist myself, I think it is important that we take an open minded approach to understanding issues as sensitive as these, and sometimes look at ourselves and our own communities to see what we might have done wrong, rather than speculating conspiracy theories that the director and producer of the programme had an agenca to purposely make the Sikhs look like they were the ones in the wrong. Sorry for anything that may have sounded rude, or out of line. regards

Re: Anyone see Partition:Last days of the raj on Channel 4?

Man Singh · 23 Mar 2007

Jassmanjeo, while intropecting , blaiming ourselves, finding faults withing ourselves and most of the times giving clean chit to culprits or diluting nager of victims towards culprits, we lost 28% of land and 24% of people. Loosing is not that bad. Even worse is that these lost brothers acts like enemy to our civilisational values vis a vis Arab civilisation. Lions' hunt for their food only. Not more then that. This is nature(Prakriti). We should take from this mother nature that's exactly required. Like our mother 's milk. Those who are cultured food and share it with sommunity. This is the culture(sanskriti) that great Gurus taught us. Those who snatch away the food of others is torture (Vikriti)and that's what happened in 1947 when 3 million lives were lost. Those who do not understand this concept of Prakriti(Nature), Sanskriti(Culture) and Vikriti(Torture). When Mohammed was creating trouble in Mecca, peace loving Meccan pagans gracefully asked him to recolate elsewhere in place of creating trouble in that place of pilgrimage in spite of being powerful enough to eliminate him. But within 2-5 years, when he formed a gang of 10,000 people , he attacked his own home town and starting destruction of pagans. It is a simple common sense to judge who is evil and who is righteous. But modern minds educated in Macaulian systaem of education do not have such Bibek to diferentiate between the two. As this system of education was designed to create inferiority complex among Indians and reverence fro British imperialists, results are opne enough. Modern english educated people loose their bibek to identify who is right and who is wrong? I sometimes wonder if thye are not able to se ethe reality. I'll giver certain examples in India context: 1. Who strated Attacking India? Indians themselves or Arabs? 2. Who imprisoned Guru nanak Devi Ji. Babur or Indians themselves 3. Who murdered Guru Arajna Devji : Jehangir or Indians themselves 4. Who murdered Guru teg Bahadur Ji : Aurangjeb or Indians themselves 5. Who demanded Pakistan and called for violent direct action: Jinnah or Indians themselves. Mr Jassmann Jeo, This mentality of `blameyourself' is exteremely harmful to community when reached beyong limit as it indirectly protects the culprits. Justice is really needed to establish peace on the earth. If we start blaming the victims, the chaos is bound to happen and that's what happening today.

Re: Anyone see Partition:Last days of the raj on Channel 4?

abc2 · 23 Mar 2007

NEWSFLASH: "as we know how hot blooded Punjabi's can be, especially when it comes to land" unlike Americans, Israelis, Arabs, English, Scots, and every other type of human being presumably. "Sorry for anything that may have sounded rude, or out of line" There's rudeness, and there's unacceptable racism. Both can offend, but one is out of place even on internet forums. Don't compound this with further banal platitudes. You have offended. Not one of us was there in 1947 but we've all heard eyewitness accounts so how about you stop the media literacy lecturing right now and have some respect. If you want to help, please describe how you entered your journalism career, so that I can guide my own children not be brainwashed to go against their own people in favour of British.

Re: Anyone see Partition:Last days of the raj on Channel 4?

dogra · 23 Mar 2007

The facts are clear on the actions of the muslim leafgue national guards who started direct action: http://www.voi.org/books/mla/ch3.htm "At a place called Daddar in Hazara District, on 11.12.1946, 40 Hindu and Sikh evacuees from the surrounding area were waylaid by Muslims; 10 of them were killed and the rest were seriously wounded. All were deprived of their belongings. By the end of December, in Hazara it became a general uprising against Hindus and Sikhs, who were killed and robbed, and their houses burnt and sacred places desecrated. This ‘holy’ war was carried into the village of Mohri, Dival, Akhroota, Pipal, Jaba, Gohra, Phulgara, Dhanak, Muhari, Karchhan, Malach, Dakhali Sair, Bafa, Sihalian, Samadhra, Jabori, Sankiari, Balakot and Bhata. In all these and other places Hindus and Sikhs were killed, their houses looted and burnt down, Gurdwaras and/or Hindu temples desecrated, Hindu and Sikh evacuees from places of danger waylaid and attacked and the entire Hindu and Sikh population forced to seek refuge in the Punjab. As, however, the numbers involved were not very large, and moreover, neither the Frontier Congress Government nor the Congress-Panthic-Unionist Coalition Government of the Punjab wanted to excite the Hindus and Sikhs of the Punjab, this serious campaign of extermination against the Hindu and Sikh minorities was given the minimum of publicity, and the general public never had a notion of the serious magnitude or import of what was happening, or that another Noakhali was being enacted at the other extreme of India. The features of Noakhali, or for the matter of that, of all Muslim attacks on minorities, were repeated here-mass murder, looting, burning, desecration, collusion between the police and officials and the marauders, with the Muslim League working as the guiding hand in pursuance of its Direct Action Programme, behind what was happening. In some of these places wholesale massacre of the minorities occurred. In Bhata 116 Sikhs were burnt alive, and several shot dead. In Malachh 115 Hindus and Sikhs were killed. " Of course later nonmuslims responded. Remember most of the Punjab police force was of the muslim faith.

Re: Anyone see Partition:Last days of the raj on Channel 4?

jassmannn · 26 Mar 2007

Well ofcourse I take any criticism of my opinions with open arms. I am open to all suggestions and as the bani constantly reminds us to look at ourselves 'hum nahin chunge bhura nahin koe' Just for the record abc2 I am not going against my own people, because I Sikh, British, and a man of the world. All people are my people, whether they call god Allah, Ram or waheguru. I prefer to seek the truth and not just assume that I must support someone becuase they are Sikh. I will support what I think is right, and what the search for truth leads me to. If you don't want your child to be enquisitve, question and search for the truth, then what does being sikh mean? (student, learner). I have also heard eye witness accounts from Hindus and muslims, as my dissertation was on 1947 and the partition. I'm offended by the comments people have made on this internet forum about Hindus and Muslims. Once again racism is only unacceptable one it is targeted towards you. Also if you take a look at Bani, what guru ji has told us about loving, accepting, of course standing up for what is right. Don't forget Guru Tegh Bahadur Ji's sacrifice was for the hindus. All men are created by God, non is superior and Sikhs are not immune to wrong doing and sin. I've made mistakes in my life but I am willing to put my hands up and admit them. What is great about this site is that you can have your own opinion, whether it is hot blooded passion, scientific know how, or jounalistic research. If you don't agree with what I say then fair enough, but don't make out of line accusations what you can't back-up or is personal dig.

Re: Anyone see Partition:Last days of the raj on Channel 4?

abc2 · 26 Mar 2007

jassmann, I am not making "out of line accusations" that I can't back up. It's in this thread. You said: "as we know how hot blooded Punjabi's can be, especially when it comes to land" That IS racist, it IS offensive and your apology/excuses were not asked for, and, unsurprisingly, not given. I am not asking you to apologise because as you're an anonymous such an apology would be meaningless. Don't you think it's a bit unlikely, that a real journalist interested in dispassionate unbiased research, would come up with such a crass generalisation about a race/nation/culture? Only 5 years ago, if you worked for BBC for instance and said that sort of thing about ethnic group, you could be fired. If you worked for police, you could still be fired even today. Please don't lecture with these English words, "loving", "accepting", "search for the truth" etc. because as everyone knows, words like these from a stranger are not just cheap, they are completely free. And open to interpretation. Who you are and what you're doing here is your business alone. There have been people coming from unfriendly Sikh site for years, and you (or I) could be anyone. First you say you are a journalist, then you said you're an ex-journalist, and now you intimate that either you are a journalist, or a recent graduate who has written a paper on 1947. It doesn't matter who you are - it's none of my business and I don't want to know so don't tell. The only problem is that you have been racist to all Punjabis in an attempt to defame them and reduce credibility of our accounts ("we all know how hot-blooded"), and that you have to realise is unacceptable. Think about others' feelings before writing such thing. Look at your parents/grandparents. Do you think they deliberately went out and thirsted for the things that happened in '47? It was the Muslims who caused this thing. [%sig%]

Re: Anyone see Partition:Last days of the raj on Channel 4?

Man Singh · 26 Mar 2007

Mr Jassmann, When people like me condemn the crooks of campus engaged in trap and convert game with innocent impressionable minds and they happen to be muslims by a matter of chance, why you interpret it as if we are criticisng whole muslim community. My simple question is : Are you with victims or with culprits? In todays tough times nobody have time to understand deep argumentative philosophy of religion as material career is dear to majority of us to tell the truth. But we all love our legacy and heritage and we don'nt want to loose the same even if we do not follow it with perfection. Under such circumestances if a well trained evangelist or muslim dawa'ist traps our people using ethical or unethical means, it is crime and criminals should be exposed. Can you differentiate between loving relationship and flesh trading? Former is the sacred and sanctioned. later is crime. Agents of former are respectable while agents(dalal) of the former are criminals as per law. The same way, conversion out of free will is respectable but soul trading is sick like flesh trading. Though till date there is no law to ban soul trading, yet nobody have right to stop us from creating awareness its dangers to the society. From my own experince in Malaysia, India, Middle east and North America, such trained muslim goons marry the girls, convert them, produce few kids and run away to prey on another one. This is wrong and devastating to women and children and no civil society should accept sucjh crime. I wonder if you are on victims side or culprits side.

Re: Anyone see Partition:Last days of the raj on Channel 4?

jassmannn · 26 Mar 2007

Just for the record I am a Punjabi. I go back to India every year and can only speak for the people I know, the land fights I've seen and my family has been through. Yes there are land fights all over the world, but as a Punjabi I feel as though I am in a position to intorvertly look at my own culture and see what is wrong with it. If you thought I was racist then fair enough and for that I apologise. I'm not going to argue this point because you have already made up your mind for what you think happened. I speak from a different opinion, one based on more than one side of the story. If you disagree then fair enough. I am just dissapointed that people are unable to fully look at a part of our history. That's how we learn not to make the same mistake again.

Re: Anyone see Partition:Last days of the raj on Channel 4?

jassmannn · 26 Mar 2007

Well I'm on the vicitims side, whether they be Sikh, Hindu, Muslim or Christian or other.

Re: Anyone see Partition:Last days of the raj on Channel 4?

Man Singh · 27 Mar 2007

Mr Jassmann if you are with victims of any community, then here in this case if victims are Sikh or Hindus and culprits happen to be Muslims, why are you shy in calling a criminal as a criminal? Your statement "vicitims side, whether they be Sikh, Hindu, Muslim or Christian" is highly civilised and Indian civilisational values only preach such humanistic attitude for which we should be proud of. Hope Muslims also start thinking the way you think. This world will become heaven on the earth. But problem is that they by hooks or by crooks try to convert five people in their lifetime so that a room is booked by God for them in heaven. I don'nt know if you this fact or not?

Re: Anyone see Partition:Last days of the raj on Channel 4?

jassmannn · 28 Mar 2007

Because Man Singh, I do have muslims friends who have never tried to convert me, and I think some Sikhs were also to blame, as were Hindus and muslims. So who should I blame, when all sides were to blame and all sides had victims. Don't also forget all the positive relationships our Gurus have had with muslims. Which indicates not all of them are bad, but beware of all people who are stepping out of line, but don't assume it just because of someones religion.

Re: Anyone see Partition:Last days of the raj on Channel 4?

Man Singh · 29 Mar 2007

jassmann Ji, did I ever blamed the any whole community? Nope. Here in this case of partition of India, Muslims as a community demanded separation. Muslims threatened `direct action' if their demand not met. I am pretty sure that you understand `Direct action' means either give what I want else face violence and goondaism. This was the first step. When Muslims strated rioting, Hindus/Sikhs also took action to defend themselves and in this second phase Muslim victims came in to existence. Now look the scenerio. A gang of dacoits attacked a village. Villagers looted and killed. Some village youth chalenged the dacoits and killed few of them. Theoretically there are victims among villagers and there are victims among dacoits who attacked the village. But do you feel that this two category oif victims deserve equal treatment? Nope. Innocent villagers are the real victims of violence and goondaism. Some attackers if killed while attacking others can never to equated with victim villagers and those who try to equate them, in my opinion are killing justice and encouraging the dacoits. Awareness about crimes and thefts and safety measures doesn'nt mean that compiagners are blaming the whole communities to be thiefs. Criminals exist, theisfs exist and that's why we put lock/securuty on our houses and cars. It doesn'mt mean that we are calling whole city as city of criminals. Exactly the same way, crooked conersion agents, exteremists and violent people exist among almost all communities. In some more and in some less. All need condemnation of course. here in this case of conversion by bullying or partition of India criminals hapen to be from muslim community and why we should try to hide their criemes? Such our tendency to not speak plainly gives shelter to criminals and makes innocent vitims mnore vulnerable. Sufis associated with great Gurus definietly desreve respect but Mullas associated with Auranjeb and jehangir definitely deserve justice.

Re: Anyone see Partition:Last days of the raj on Channel 4?

ssjsgob · 04 Apr 2007

ive tried starting a petition against this programme and it has been rejected i have four weeks to edit it so can someone please help me? the message Hi, I'm sorry to inform you that your petition has been rejected. Your petition was classed as being in the following categories: * Language which is offensive, intemperate, or provocative If you wish to edit and resubmit your petition, please follow the following link: http://petitions.pm.gov.uk/Racism-to-Sikhs/Cad6bsEOHNWvECMqFcARlq3 You have four weeks in which to do this, after which your petition will appear in the list of rejected petitions. Your petition reads: We the undersigned petition the Prime Minister to: 'urge channel4 to make a public apology to the Sikh community for indirectly invoking racial hatred against Sikhs through the poor documentation of the programme, Last days of the raaj, and in future documentary makers produce a more representative, unbiased and wholesome account of historical events.' Racism & Ill-Feeling Against Sikhs in Documentary On 12/03/2007 @ 9pm, Channel 4 aired the programme "Partition". The programme was totally biased, misrepresentative of the Sikh perspective, which was very offensive, and many Sikhs feel invoked racism against Sikhs. The Sikh community are disappointed and hurt by the bias and misrepresentation shown in the programme, which undoubtedly invokes ill feeling and racial hatred against Sikhs in viewers who are unaware of the reality. -- the ePetitions team sorry if i copied your words but they were to the point and i couldnt rite anything better ive tried to do as much as i can so far

Re: Anyone see Partition:Last days of the raj on Channel 4?

abc2 · 04 Apr 2007

ssjsgob, I understand where you're coming from and the gist of your partition and would sign it immediately just as it is. However, in the strict sense, it doesn't make any sense. The grammar is poor, and it's not clear what you're asking the PM to do. I would do it like this: ------------------------------------------- "We the undersigned petition the Prime Minister to make an announcement concerning the broadcaster Channel4, stating the following: 1) That its "Partition" documentary which was broadcast on several occasions since 12/03/2007 has caused hurt and upset to the Sikh community as evidenced by this petition; 2) That the aforesaid documentary as broadcast is considered by the Sikh community to be in breach of the Ofcom Broadcasting Code as pertaining to fairness and balance; 3) That the aforesaid documentary as broadcast is considered by the Sikh community to be outright racist in its treatment of the Sikhs (particularly insofar as it was stated expressly by one person shown in the documentary that compared to Muslims and Hindus who supposedly had more foresight and intelligence, the Sikhs would only see a storm and act on it "after it had passed"); 4) That the aforesaid documentary as broadcast is perceived by the Sikh community to have proffered a highly skewed and misleading account of the actual events of 1947, as a result of the failure of the programmers to research the subject matter accurately by consulting sufficiently with contemporary Sikh community leaders prior to producing the programme; 5) That Channel4 ought to have carried out an analysis of the effect on community relations of this documentary, prior to it being broadcast in the form in which it appeared. ------------------------------------------------ I think we have to be careful about throwing around words like "inciting racism" and hostility, because in the UK these types of words have to be treated with a sense of seriousness by law enforcement, and tend to mean when someone has deliberately used words to incite hatred against an ethnic group. Therefore I think point 5 above is how this particular aspect should be worded, so that it's not misconstrued (you know sometimes things can be deliberately misconstrued if convenient).

Re: Anyone see Partition:Last days of the raj on Channel 4?

Dalbiri · 04 Apr 2007

Oftel didn't get back to me on this but channel four did. The last email they sent me about this was as following: Thank you for your follow up e-mail. As I have stated your complaint has been logged and passed on. I cannot unfortunately speak on behalf of programme makers or commissioning editors as to what action if any will be taken. I would like however to assure you that Channel 4 does take the opinions of our viewers very seriously and your comments have been noted in the strongest possible terms. We appreciate you taking the time to contact us on this matter. Kind Regards Molly Dornan Channel 4 Viewer Enquiries I think we just need to keep our eyes open and make more stronger protests should they continue in this fashion in future. but if they are, it is likely that material such as this will be put out far apart from each other.

Re: Anyone see Partition:Last days of the raj on Channel 4?

ssjsgob · 05 Apr 2007

thank u veer ji its nice to kno im not the only person who cares im sending off the new petition now and will get bak to u all when its gone through im trying to do as much as i can im sorry if im slow as im still doing uni work and i dont have internet in my flat

Re: Anyone see Partition:Last days of the raj on Channel 4?

dogra · 05 Apr 2007

Facts are also required to be told. Why did Master Tara Singhji raise his Sword, as mentioned, the muslim league national guards were commiting atrocities in Hazara district in 1946-47 check post above. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Muslim_League_Attack_on_Sikhs_and_Hindus_in_the_Punjab_1947 "It has been reprinted several times and cited in various academic compilations of literature concerning the Partition of India. Ishtiaq Ahmed, of the Department of Political Sciences at Stockholm University, has examined the book and reports that many of the incidents related in the text can be independently verified. In one such incident, Muslim "goondas" (thugs) in Lahore received packets containing "churis" (bangles) and "mehndi" (henna) from some Muslims of Lahore. Ahmed describes this as a "bizzare antic meant to shame them for their unmanliness and cowardice at not finishing off Hindus and Sikhs", thereby inciting them into violence against Hindus and Sikhs.[1] This incident has been verified by the British political officer at the scene, a Mr. Eustace. However, Ahmed also writes that the book does not mention the counter-attacks on Muslims by Hindus and Sikhs. He notes that "The Sikh reprisals against Muslims in East Punjab are explained [in the book] merely as a reaction".[1]Where as such events accelerated after hundreds of muslim imigrants burned alive in train to Pakistan by Sikhs and Hindus. " Facts are in black and white, it is grossly unfair to not state these facts, also:http://india_resource.tripod.com/hist-2nation.html "It is also noteworthy that all important Islamic theologians were against partition. Maulana Madani undertook a whirlwind tour to campaign against the League. Representatives of the Muslim working class were also sharply against partition. The Ansari Muslims (weaver caste) who were very politically conscious and well-organized in the Gangetic states publicly demonstrated against the Leagues partition resolution. The Muslim League had connived with the British to present partition as a fait-accompli. With great regret, many accepted it as a temporary setback, but hoped that once the British left, the future would be different. But the Muslim League and the British were taking no chances. To ensure that Hindus and Muslims did not get together to reverse this precipitous course, the Muslim League (with British backing and cover) resorted to several acts of blackmail and terror. All Muslim civil servants and army officers were exhorted to leave for Pakistan. First, they were warned that they would be mistreated in India. When Maulana Azad combated the vicious rumor-mongering by the League and assured Muslims that their rights would be protected in secular India, many Muslims sought to stay on. At that point, the League threatened to harm their property interests and their relatives in Pakistan. Under the pressure of such blackmail, most caved in and migrated to Pakistan. Simultaneously, armed gangs with the complicity of the League and British officers engineered a campaign of terror against Pakistan's Hindu and Sikh minorities. Arson, rape, and mass murder resulted in an unprecedented exodus of millions of refugees, with it's inevitable anti-Muslim backlash in India. "

Re: Anyone see Partition:Last days of the raj on Channel 4?

dogra · 05 Apr 2007

"In spite of all this rigging, the Muslim League initially won little support even amongst the Muslim elites of the sub-continent. Even in provinces where Muslims were in overwhelming majority, there was no League ministry before 1945. The majority of the Indian people were with the secular program of the Indian National Congress (or with forces more radical). There was a Congress ministry in The Frontier Province. In Punjab there was a Unionist Ministry. The Unionists were a party of the Punjab landed elite but included Sikhs, Muslims and Hindus. In Sindh, the ministry led by Ghulam Hussein depended on Congress support. Yet, when the British Colonial govt. invited representatives of the Indian people for political negotiations in 1945, the Muslim League was given as much representation as the Congress. The Congress, that represented all sections of Indian society and had support all over the country, was allowed to nominate only 5 members out of 14! The Muslim League with a fraction of the Congress's mass base was also allocated 5 nominees, and the colonial government picked 4 of it's own to represent Sikhs, Dalits and Muslims. Still, out of it's 5 members, the Congress chose to nominate only 2 Hindus, and nominated a Muslim, a Christian and a Parsi to reflect it's secular composition. The Muslim League of course, only nominated Muslims, but it complained when the Congress nominated a Muslim - claiming that only it had the right to nominate Muslims. The Congress maintained that because it represented all communities it would also nominate a Muslim representative. India was thus represented by 7 Muslims in a group of 14, even though the Muslim population at that time was only about 25% of the country. No one could have argued that Muslims were being crowded out or dominated by Hindus in the independence discussions and negotiations. (In fact, it is more relevant to point out that the Indians picked to negotiate with the British were not true representatives of the Indian people.) " THESE ARE THE FACTS, CHANNEL 4 DID NOT STATE THESE AND DECIDED TO PRESENT SOME NONSENSE!! MUSLIM LEAGUE COMMITTED ATROCITIES B4 MASTER TARA SINGH RIGHTLY RAISED HIS SWORD! YES LATER NON MUSLIMS RESPONDED, BUT THIS WOULD NEVER HAVE HAPPENED HAD THE MUSLIM LEAGUE NOT SPREAD DIRECT ACTION EVIL

Re: Anyone see Partition:Last days of the raj on Channel 4?

Dalbiri · 05 Apr 2007

This situation is not clear cut. I can't see British institutes being interested in the truth because it would make them look bad. They would rather manipulate the facts and have us fighting amongst ourselves. They've always did this divide and rule thing. Not saying we should trust anyone but just be aware of the dynamics at play here.

Re: Anyone see Partition:Last days of the raj on Channel 4?

dogra · 06 Apr 2007

Nevertheless, one must try with the facts, and i will respond to Channel 4 like wise with the facts. Just as Slavery has been apologised and acknowledged, one must try to show the facts, so that people of fair mind will acknowledge what happened. The clock can never be turned back, and we must accept that the subcontinent now has 3 nations, but acknowledgement of the past too, must be done RAM MOHAMMED SINGH AZAD-SHAHEED UDHAM SINGHJI

Re: Anyone see Partition:Last days of the raj on Channel 4?

ssjsgob · 13 Apr 2007

Thank you for the support everyone i have finally had my petition approved please could you follow this link and sign it http://petitions.pm.gov.uk/Documentary/ WAHEGURU JI KA KHALSA! WAHEGURU JI KI FATEH!!

Re: Anyone see Partition:Last days of the raj on Channel 4?

ssjsgob · 13 Apr 2007

remember to check ur junk mail for the verification email without doing this ur signature will not show on the petition making it pointless

Re: Anyone see Partition:Last days of the raj on Channel 4?

ssjsgob · 14 Apr 2007

could evryone please please please forward this petition also to evry friend or relative with an email so we can get as many numbers as possible for the petition and feel free to post the link in any other forums the more publicity the more names thank you

Re: Anyone see Partition:Last days of the raj on Channel 4?

jassmannn · 18 Apr 2007

I think you guys should get together and put a film together of what you think really happened, and try and get that aired. Voicing concerns like this will make no difference. I work in PR, ex journalist, it makes no difference.

Re: Anyone see Partition:Last days of the raj on Channel 4?

SilentElegance · 21 Apr 2007

There is a lot of confused debate here. For whatever, the responses from the Sikhs and master tara Singh were a RESPONSES TO muslims attacks and killings for Sikhs. It is unthinkble that a mere 2,000,000 Sikhs west of lahore were in any position to commit atrocities upon the 18,000,000 muslims. The channel 4 programme was manipulated by a muslim flavour in its presentation , there is no doubt about that. It spoke of Sikh militia launching attacks in the first instance...this is cannot be further from truth- as the Sikh militia reffered to -Akal sena came into force in response to muslim leaguers attacks.It was mainly to organise Sikh for self defense- not an offensive force. The attacks and killings in muslim dominated areas like NWFP and Hazara began long before master tara Singh raised his sword. Later atrocities were committed on both sides, but this does not abolish any responsibility of the initial perpetraters who started this.That is the point. Sikh leadership was not poor, but not in any position to carry out actions or programmes or apply heavy pressure upon the brit adminsitration, as the Sikh numbers were in the minority.Simple. The hindus and ,muslims had the numbers game on their side.The sikhs did not.sadly, we also did not have a sea coast line- which would have made a difference as in israel. [%sig%]

Re: Anyone see Partition:Last days of the raj on Channel 4?

Man Singh · 21 Apr 2007

Gangs of Mao, Marx, Macauley and Mohammed can never have courage to tell the truth. This is secular mentality that belives in blaming all communities culprit as well victims. Demonising the VICTIMS is old game of these gangs. Look through the history. Folowers of Mao and Marx killed brutallu all their political opponents and declared them as exploitist capitalist to justify their own crimes against humanity. Followers Macauley tortured humanity all around the globe through imperialism and enslavement. They also justified their crimes against humanity by decalring their criminals acts as `civilising missions'. Mohammed himself carried our crimes against humanity by attacking, killing and converting tribe after tribe thus eliminating native religions and demonised victims only. He also justified his crimes against humanity by putting every blame on VICTIM pagans. Muslims follwoed the suite for last 1400 years and blame VICTIMS for all their crimes. jehangir justified his brutal act of tortuing Guru Arjan Dev and Aurangjeb did the same for Guru Teg Bahadur using same ancinet tactic of `demonise VICTIMS. The same way today these gangs of 4 M's are trying to put all blames on Hindus and Sikhs to protect the culprits and demonise the victims. I wonder how even educated people like JASSMANN can be so forgetful about history. Who demanded partition in first place. Who thretened `direct action' to achive their goal. Whao started attacking innocent unprepared Hindus/Sikhs mesmerised by `see no evil' & `patition will take place on my dead body' type of false philosophy of Gandhi. What these secular gangs of 4 M want to say? Even if Hindus/Sikhs killed few muslim goondas while protecting themselves, they have become equally responsible? Do these secualrs expect Hindus/Sikhs to 100% surrender to the tyrrants to get a certificate of tolerance from these secular gangs. In my childhood a gang of dacoits used to attack my village. Villagers were terrorised badly. One fine day few village youth resolved to fight back. When dacoits invaded the village these villaged youth retaliated and killed 4 of the dacoits. Police came as usual after the rest of dacoits ran away and arrested these brave youth for killing dacoits. This is what exactly these secular gangs of 4 M are doing to Hindus/Sikhs by blaming them equally with attackers and perpetrators of crimes. But truth is that village youth above are herores while dacoits are criminals. Criminals should be identified clearly and be punished while these village youth should be awarded for bravery. Police responsible for protection should be termated and these village youth should be given job against these vacancies. This is what Justice is. Rest is sychphancy and flatery to dacoits and muerderers. Channel 4 is no exception. Let those raise voice who are for Justice and expose the fallasy and irratinality of the approach of these gangs of 4 M's.