Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Army Reveals Startling Facts on Bluestar

Army Reveals Startling Facts on Bluestar

News · 19 Mar 2007

Army reveals startling facts on Bluestar Says Longowal surrendered Varinder Walia Tribune News Service Amritsar, March 19 The Army has come on record for the first time, giving startling facts on the infamous Operation Bluestar in June 1984, including the break-up of the casualties of officers, civilians and militants, apart from the persons who had surrendered. In his affidavit, D.V. Rao (68), a retired Brigadier, filed in the court of Harjit Singh Khalsa, civil judge (junior div)-cum-judicial magistrate first class, revealed that the then SAD president Sant Harchand Singh Longowal and his colleagues had surrendered before the Army. It reads, "The unit commander received information from the two civilians that H.S. Longowal with his colleagues were in the SGPC building and were willing to surrender." On this, Brigadier Rao deputed senior officers to make arrangements to take them safely and lodge them in the Circuit House. Brigadier Rao submitted evidence by way of an affidavit in the court of civil judge senior division in connection with the suit filed by some Jodhpur detainees against the Union of India and others for recovery. Brigadier Rao, who is currently working in the Training Institute of Hyderabad, stated that in June 1984 he was posted as Commander, 350 Infantry Brigade in Jalandhar which was part of the Ninth Infantry Division. He was called by the civil administration to assist the civil authorities in clearing the Golden Temple complex from terrorists and to recover all illegal arms ammunitions, explosives etc from the complex. He stated that all major buildings in the Golden Temple were heavily fortified when he reached Amritsar on May 30, 1984. The Army under the command of Brigadier Rao was ordered to undertake Operation Bluestar by the GOC Ninth Infantry division on the directions of the Punjab Government. Brigadier Rao, in his affidavit, stated that special instructions were given to the troops that no weapons should be fired at Shri Harmandar Sahib and heavy machine guns were not to be taken. The troops would not wear boots but caps and other uniform. The instructions were clear that troops would respect Shri Harmandar Sahib with proper regards like they do in their temples. They would fire in self-defence only. However, as the troops advanced, terrorists opened fire from all places, leading to heavy casualties of forces. The Army suffered 83 deaths which included four officers, four JCOs and 75 other ranks while 13 officers, 16 JCOs and 220 other ranks sustained injuries. The casualties to the civilians inside Golden Temple were 492 dead. The Army had apprehended 433 persons who were segregated as terrorists from total of 1592 persons apprehended. S.S. Sood, lawyer for the Jodhpur detainees, said he would 'smash' the affidavit during the next hearing on April 17 at the time of cross-examination. He said Brigadier Rao, who could not appear today, was likely arrive here on the date fixed by the court.

Re: Army Reveals Startling Facts on Bluestar

Degha Singh · 19 Mar 2007

"The initial crime was celebrated and indeed had been planned a year before hand...The army went into Darbar Sahib not to eliminate a political figure or a political movement but to suppress the culture of a people, to attack their heart, to strike a blow at their spirit and self confidence." -Joyce Pettigrew The Sikhs of the Punjab (1995) The Army invasion of the Golden Temple left 8-10,000 pilgrims dead, 500 buildings destroyed and 30,000 people homeless. -The Guardian 6/26/1984 The attack was simultaneously carried out on 74 other Sikh shrines, leaving thousands of innocent Sikhs dead. [%sig%]

Re: Army Reveals Startling Facts on Bluestar

Harjas Kaur · 19 Mar 2007

[quote]Brigadier Rao, in his affidavit, stated that special instructions were given to the troops that no weapons should be fired at Shri Harmandar Sahib and heavy machine guns were not to be taken....The troops would not wear boots but caps and other uniform. The instructions were clear that troops would respect Shri Harmandar Sahib with proper regards like they do in their temples.[/quote] Indian Army tanks in Darbar Sahib Parkarma hats? no boots? Proper regards? [%sig%]

Re: Army Reveals Startling Facts on Bluestar

shere punjab · 19 Mar 2007

both the indian governmetn needs to be punished and the men inside. Why didn't the men inside the harmandar sahib like sant jarnail bhindranwale just let the army arrest him rather then let inocent civilians get caught in the crossfire. If the indian government was planning an attack on harmandar sahib before hand then they used bhindranwale as an excuse to attack if he had come out peacefully then civilians would have bin saved. Politically it would of hurt india bad in front of the international community to attack the harmandar sahib for no reasion and have more then half the sikhs resign from the army but with an excuse they were able to say we had to attack because of him.

Re: Army Reveals Startling Facts on Bluestar

Khalistan_zindabaad · 20 Mar 2007

Do you belief everything the army has to say???????

Re: Army Reveals Startling Facts on Bluestar

jassmannn · 20 Mar 2007

I have a few opinions on this whole debate. Although not a scholar, I do think this Khalistan thing is being taken too far. Every Sikh I see that has recently taken Amrit or has refound his faith, has it based not on the foundations of Sikhi, but based on a sense of revenge for 1984, which was a political upset, with religion dragged into it. It's very disturbing, as most people I meet are not able to tell me when Guru Nanak Dev Ji was born, they can't recite any bani off by heart, which I think is a better way of spending your time, rather than struggling for an independent state. Although I am not against Bhinderawale per se, as I have read accounts from both sides of the fence, I just think that people are becoming militant about the issue, and I see it day in day out, where as most would not spare a few quid for charity. History is important, and the future is brighter for Punjab, as Manmoham Singh is doing a great job leading the country forward economically. Cutting ourselves off from the rest of the nation would be a drastic mistake, as Punjabi leaders have proven once too many times that too much power corrupts. Although I understand your sensibilities, if you look into the historic accounts of the event, and yes from both sides, you can paint a clearer picture of mistakes made on both sides of the attack which were detrimental in the deaths of soo many innocent Sikhs.

Re: Army Reveals Startling Facts on Bluestar

shere punjab · 20 Mar 2007

Lets grow powerfull inside the country, we can take control and rule any sikh who thinks sikhs can't accomplish this is just a weak man. First thing accountability if sikhs in punjab are uneducated and practicing weird traditions doing drugs then we have to educate and prevent this from happining this is our problem no one puts a gun to their heads and does these crimes if we waste tiime pointing fingers problems will get worste. Punjab has an advantage richest state say what you want those are facts unless someone can show me facts that prove otherwise. Education and buisness and industralising the punjab is what will help us turn the situation around. Create our own politicionss that will take control of punjab and india.

Re: Army Reveals Startling Facts on Bluestar

Gurnit Singh · 20 Mar 2007

The police issued an arrest warrent for Sant Ji months prior to the attack. Sant Ji gave him self up to the police soon afterwards. Zail Sing, the President of India at the time then let him go free. It was clear that if india really wanted Sant Ji again all they needed was an arrest warrant, not thousands of armed troops and tanks.

Re: Army Reveals Startling Facts on Bluestar

Harjas Kaur · 20 Mar 2007

It was an attack on Sikhi, not Sant ji. This is very clear. How many thousands of Sikhs have been arrested, tortured, slaughtered and disappeared after Sant ji's death? It started with the Amritsar massacre. And the attempted Hinduization of Sikhism for a political and nationalistic cause. Gursikhs have always opposed this. Even at the sacrifice of their lives. The reason? They do not compromise Gursikhi to dogs and politicians. What we see happening after the 1984 attack is complete infiltration and corruption. Sikh youth should know that our Sikh leaders were not corrupted. They were murdered. In the aftermath of 1984 was a tremendous degradation within Sikh institutions, orchestrated by the Hindutva government, and continuing till this day. Hinduization of Sikh faith and history ~ Rashtriya Sikh Sangat http://www.info-sikh.com/PageRSS1.html [%sig%]

Re: Army Reveals Startling Facts on Bluestar

Harjas Kaur · 20 Mar 2007

Punjab Chief Minister Parkash Singh Badal and Namdhari chief Baba Jagjit Singh at the foundation stone laying ceremony of Satguur Baba Partap Singh Apollo Hospital in Ludhiana. Since when do Sikhs, let alone a Sikh leader, bow to, sit with a false baba who calls himself Satguru? If you bow to anyone other than ShabadGuru Sahib, you are no longer a Sikh. Here, we see the degree of Sikh degradation by Hindutva politicians. There are celebrating a new hospital, dedicated to Satguru Baba Partap Singh?!!! What the hell? http://www.tribuneindia.com/2000/20001029/ldh.htm Who do you think is paying for this kind of thing? [%sig%]

Re: Army Reveals Startling Facts on Bluestar

Harjas Kaur · 20 Mar 2007

Badal seen with Rashtriya Sikh Sangat leaders Badal at the feet of satguru (?) Jagjit Singh Namdhari Namdhari Kookay at the feet of their satguru Jagit Singh http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CvYlk9EPVd0 The latest news from Hindustan. Wednesday 7th of March 2007. Amritsar (KP) - After winning the elections in Punjab, Parkash Badal, the anti-Panthic leader of the so-called Shiromani Akali Dal has kept himself busy visiting his favorite deras and cults, and personally thanked his real 'masters' for thier valuable votes in the recent elections. 'Ram' Act Fatwa Furthermore, his BJP cabinet minister Tikshan Sood, showed his true colors when he announced that a new 'Ram' act would be introduced in Punjab that would make it mandatory for every individual in Punjab to recite the name of Hindu diety 'Ram'. Sood's remarks, which came only days after his inaugural, offended the Sikh community and raised an alarm about the real intent of the BJP/Akali combine. Sikhs are monotheistic and worship only one God. They openly reject the worship of Hindu dieties, and any personified idols. BJP's Tikshan Sood was elected by the Hoshiarpur Constituency Sikhs organizations including Shiromani Akali Dal Amritsar, the Delhi Sikh Gurdwara Prabandhak Committee, quickly criticized Sood's 'fatwa' and warned of serious consequences if anyone attempted to force a pro-Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh (RSS) agenda on Sikhs and other non-Hindu minorities in Punjab. http://www.panthic.org/news/125/ARTICLE/3157/2007-03-07.html AND WE WONDER WHY THERE IS A SANT/BABA/GURU EPIDEMIC! What evil forces are at work to promote it? [%sig%]

Re: Army Reveals Startling Facts on Bluestar

Harjas Kaur · 20 Mar 2007

This link will let you to find and play Youtube videos. Just cut and paste to this site. http://tubesurf.com/ Tribute to Sikh Martyrs of 1984 cut and paste --> watch?v=x6eB1Fk5voU Dedicated to the Martyrs of 1978 Amritsar Massacre watch?v=dNUwmkXlea4 Children of Tommorow - Guru Gobind Singh.wmv watch?v=H2OyUg3FACw [quote]"Today I read the newspaper report in which it was said, a body of fanatic Sikhs.... If doing kirtan and defending the good name of our father Guru Gobind Singh ji makes us fanatics, then we welcome this allegation. Remember, those who do not defend the grace of their father are never worthy of respect on the earth. These martyrs of Amritsar have shown us that we shall live in grace; if it is not possible, we choose to die in grace." -Harbhajan Singh Yogi[/quote] [quote]"O true Guru, we will serve your everlasting Sikhi with our every word, thought and deed. We will devote our youth, wealth, and all worldly possessions to the cause of the Panth. My body, preserved since childhood will be sacrificed now the need has arisen. By continuously repeating and sincerely following Gurbani we will get rid of all our evil-mindedness. If you keep your grace, my Graceful Lord, we will sacrifice ourselves limb by limb." -Shaheed Bhai Fauja Singh ji[/quote] सलोक कबीर ॥ salok kabeer. Shalok, Kabeer: गगन दमामा बाजिओ परिओ नीसानै घाउ ॥ gagan damaamaa baaji-o pari-o neesaanai ghaa-o. The battle-drum beats in the sky of the mind; aim is taken, and the wound is inflicted. खेतु जु मांडिओ सूरमा अब जूझन को दाउ ॥१॥ khayt jo maaNdi-o soormaa ab joojhan ko daa-o. The spiritual warriors enter the field of battle; now is the time to fight! सूरा सो पहिचानीऐ जु लरै दीन के हेत ॥ sooraa so pahichaanee-ai jo larai deen kay hayt. He alone is known as a spiritual hero, who fights in defense of his faith. पुरजा पुरजा कटि मरै कबहू न छाडै खेतु ॥२॥२॥ purjaa purjaa kat marai kabhoo na chhaadai khayt. He may be cut apart, piece by piece, but he never leaves the field of battle. -SGGS p. 1105 RAJ KAREGA KHALSA [%sig%]

Re: Army Reveals Startling Facts on Bluestar

jassmannn · 21 Mar 2007

Whatever your opinions on the matter, we need to reconnect to the Bani, not falter in a vain attempt to make a Khalistan, as it is more than evident everytime I go back there, that most youths are making plans, or have ambitions to go abroad. The attack on the Golden Temple and the following events and deaths of innocent Sikhs was becuase of the mistakes made on both sides. There is no conspiracy theory by Sikhs or Hindus, but a power struggle between political parites, which as we have seen in the past, lead to communal violence.

Re: Army Reveals Startling Facts on Bluestar

SomeSingh · 21 Mar 2007

if you really want to learn about what happened and why, i suggest you read 'the gallent defender' written by AR Darshi, former Chief Minister of Punjab and a friend of Sant Ji's father. He discusses some of the behind the scenes politics as he was involved in some of that.

Re: Army Reveals Startling Facts on Bluestar

Harjas Kaur · 21 Mar 2007

Shaheed Bhai Jaswant Singh Khalra's Last International Speech Eleven years ago, on September 6, 1995, the Punjab police abducted, tortured, and murdered human rights defender Jaswant Singh Khalra because he exposed the disappearances and killings of thousands of Sikhs by the Punjab police. In his last speech made to a Canadian audience, released today with subtitles by Ensaaf, Jaswant Singh Khalra discusses his investigations into the disappearances and his readiness to die to expose the truth about these crimes. http://www.ensaaf.org/docs/khalravideo.php [%sig%]

Re: Army Reveals Startling Facts on Bluestar

dogra · 21 Mar 2007

Indiras government is gone, as she is gone like her son, who made that abominable comment about apples falling, the earth shakes. Bhindrawale too is gone, his bigotted comments on Hindus, and ordering attacks on Hindus is also known. Ground reality in Punjab, Police force under KPS Gill commited human rights violations and the Khalistanis too, commited murders. http://www.hrw.org/campaigns/kashmir/1994/kashmir94-03.htm "Abuses by Indian Government Forces(83) Indian authorities engaged in a pattern and practice of gross violations of human rights and humanitarian laws in Punjab. These abuses included arbitrary arrests, torture, prolonged detention without trial, disappearances, and summary killings of Sikh civilians and suspected militants. Attacks by government forces against civilians often were carried out in revenge for the activities of armed opposition groups. Numerous incidents involving the shooting of civilians in reprisal for acts by militants have been documented by Human Rights Watch/Asia and reported in the press. Summary executions and deaths in custody were regularly covered up by the practice of filing reports claiming that individuals were killed in "encounters" with the security forces. In addition, the security forces were issued shoot-to-kill orders, and were permitted by several changes in law to conduct mass round-ups and warrantless house-to-house searches in Sikh areas, as well as to detain people without approval of the courts. Government personnel were virtually immune from prosecution for human rights violations. " "Beginning in 1981, however, Sikh militants regularly engaged in a pattern of serious violations of humanitarian law.(95) Most of these violations involved deliberate attacks on unarmed civilians. These took a variety of forms: random assaults on civilians; targeted killings of Hindu civilians and Sikh civilians suspected of collaboration with the Indian government; and assassinations of political figures and Hindu religious leaders. Although most militant Sikh attacks on civilians took place in Punjab, they were also undertaken in other regions of India, particularly in the neighboring state of Haryana, and in Delhi and Bombay. Militants frequently opened fire in public areas such as marketplaces, crowded streets, and residential neighborhoods; targeted Hindu laborers for murder; attacked public buses and trains; assassinated political and religious figures and government employees; engaged in election-related violence; threatened the lives of journalists; extorted money from local businessmen through threats and kidnapping; killed the families of policemen; and used religious sites frequented by civilians for military purposes. In almost all instances, they used light weapons such as automatic rifles, grenades, rockets, and bombs. "

Re: Army Reveals Startling Facts on Bluestar

shere punjab · 21 Mar 2007

sikhs need to grow and take control of india from the inside we dont' need our own country i thhink our own country would struggle bad. Second if we can grow in power we can bring the men behind the 84 riots and the hindu rioters themselves and soilders involved in operation blue star to justice. For killing inocent civilians We need to start are own political party and attack congress and bjp and rss but right now the RSS really piss me off i mean do they have that much low self esteem and pride that they need to call sikhs hindus to make themselves a little proud to be hindu.

Re: Army Reveals Startling Facts on Bluestar

sunny87 · 26 Mar 2007

in the militant groups be they .kcf zaffarwal.kcf panjwar. btfk sangha.or manochahal group there was good and corupt militants.some did kill inocents hindus aswell as sikhs.the leader of kcf panjwar general labh singh ji was a proper.jujaroo who had a code of conduct for his cadres.not to kill children.women or men.not to extort money.etc etc most did follow his code some didnt.a lot of the top kharkoos helped hindus aswell as sikhs.they only killed corupt punjab police/paramilitary forces.mlas,mps.of all partys.and imformers.