Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Calling Husband's Name

Calling Husband's Name

Khalsaspirit · 20 Mar 2007

Waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh Khalsa jio, Give your opinions on this. Recently we got call from a bibi ji (not Amritdhari) and she had an issue with her mother in law. The problem begins here her mother in law heard a Katha from a student of a popular school. The Kathavachik while doing his Katha mentioned this. “Sadh Sangat jio bibiyan nu apnay patee (husband) da Na nahee layna chahida kuankay (because) Patee parmesar sman hunda hain” then he mentioned “sangat ji jado (when) main (I) ahuy (this one) katha England wich kar riha se ta ik ladki (girl) khadi ho ke (stood up) kahan lagi baba ji je kar patee parmesar sman hah ta tay oosda na lana chahida ha, hun dasso Sadh Sangat ji auj kal di generation nu kive samjaiay” After listened this Katha her mother in law came home and asked her not to call her husband’s name which this bibi refused and when she asked who told you that then mother mentioned about that Kathavachik which she said heard from some one that this baba ji belongs to that school which relates it to Guru Gobind Singh ji. Now that bibi ji is asking us “This is what Guru Gobind Singh ji's teaching is!” which teaches you not to call your husband’s name. She further mentioned that although she is not a Amritdhari but at least she knows that in Sikhism women has equal rights as men do then why this restriction that you cannot call your husband’s name? Certainly we tried to answer her but she is upset with the situation in her home. And we leave this question for the Sangat whether it is true or not? Guru Mehar Karay Waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji ki fate [%sig%]

Re: Calling Husband's Name

Roopkaur · 20 Mar 2007

This is a personal matter between the husband and wife on how they decide to refer to eachother. However, I find this obsession with women's equal rights is sometimes read in different ways. I do not know how to deal with this situation from a non-Gursikh perspective since it is really hard to apply some principles of Sikhi to situations where others are completely ignored. So for the sake of my argument, I will use an example of a Gursikh couple. If a Gursikh bibi does not call her husband by his name, does this mean she is giving up her equal rights as a woman? I do not think so. It is out of respect for her Gursikh husband, for his kamaaee and for the strength and support he gives her throughout life that she chooses to give this respect to him. To be equal as a human being does not mean that we lose respect for others at the same time. I look to puratan Sikh couples for inspiration, and one of the most inspiring couples of all is Bhai Sahib Bhai Randhir Singh Ji and Mata Kartar Kaur Ji. Just do a search on this site to get examples of how much respect Mata Ji showed her husband. Another inspiring couple was the parents of Dr. Surinder Singh Ji, who never fought or spoke a bitter word to each other their whole lives. This kind of relationship is based on love and respect, and I know I keep repeating that word over and over again, but I do not beleive that you can love someone without having respect for them. All Sikhs do have equality, but we should keep that equality in the perspective of Gursikh culture, not modern interpretations of this world. For example, a Gursikh bibi is equal to a Singh, but will you see a bibi bathing in front of everyone at Darbar Sahib like Singhs can? No, however, with modern interpretations of "equality" there would be nothing wrong with that scenario. Another thing I would like to say, at the risk of being politically incorrect, and also at the risk of unintentially offending some people, is that we cannot demand equal rights without taking on equal responsibilities. I am not applying this to the situation being discussed above, but to Sikhi in general. You cannot ignore all of the rest of Sikhi, (Amrit chaknaa, keeping rehit, naam abhyaas, doing paath etc), which are the most important part of Sikhi, and then expect to have all of the rights and priviledges that come along with Sikhi. In other words, I do not think Sikhi is something you can pick and choose to your fitting, it is a holistic religion, with its own lifestyle, culture and principles. Its not one of those games where you can mix and match to come up with something that suits you.

Re: Calling Husband's Name

ms k · 21 Mar 2007

WJKK WJKF When talking about equality i believe that Guruji meant that giving women equal rights in practising the dharam (religion) and allowing women to read from the Guru Granth Sahib Ji which was a noticeable difference in other religions who forbid women to partake in such activities. There are some things that are down to nature - for example we would never expect a male to have a baby would we? therefore certain physical roles are pre-determined by nature, or Guruji's will as you might like to say! I don't call my husbands name out of respect for him and the knowledge he has obtained over the years. I also believe that he has achieved a lot of kamaaee so i respect that 110% BUT - a question - what if there is a Bibi who has done a lot of kamaaee as well...shouldn't the respect be reciprocated? There are some females who i have seen who do a lot of sewa and simran...but have ended up in some violent situations...we put that down to Guruji's will and kismat... My experience is that if the female and male has done similar kamaaee this is reflected in the partners that you obtain! Also, just because you may call your husbands name doesn't mean you have any less respect for him....our name is our identity and it is a way of calling upon a person. Of course, you learn from experience of what you see your parents do etc...and surprisingly i hardly ever heard my father call my mothers name as well! He would only use her name when talking to someone else about her...so take whatever thought you would like to from that.... Just my thoughts - no offence intended. WJKK WJKF [%sig%]

Re: Calling Husband's Name

Harjas Kaur · 21 Mar 2007

Beautiful post Roop Kaur bhenji. [%sig%]

Re: Calling Husband's Name

CSJ · 21 Mar 2007

Waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh Calling by name is not realy religious issue it is more our culture. We dont call our elders or teachers with name in these contries they do. In a same way usally hasband is 1or 2 year older and that is also a reson why calling by name is not good. if we say same thing about our parents we call them with there name it is not aceptable in our culture. I dont thing all old ways are wrong. In Sikhs men and women have equal rights it is true but depend how we use this equality for good or not. if husband stays home and women work and earn money. There life is not going to be peacefull. I have seen it. God has given resposbility for each person he should follow it with each others respect. As we have shabad in GGS ji about this. some time equality is taken too far. Guru sahib has given man name singh and womens kaur. I also read in one of the post that keeping chuni (dupatta) is desrepect of bana. This is what i am talking about talking too far. it is a matter of husband and wife they should solve it. [%sig%]

Re: Calling Husband's Name

maha_moorakh · 22 Mar 2007

hmm does it really matter what you call your husband. wether you call him by their full name, nick name or summit else? Respect doesnt just come by mere words, it is also shown through actions and feelings. The main thing is that you show one another piaar and respect, personally i dont think names matter. call each other by whatever you want. But yeh your better off listening to roop kaur penjis advice, or others who are actually married lol vahigurujikakhalsa vahigurujikifateh. [%sig%]

Re: Calling Husband's Name

Prabhjoyt Singh · 22 Mar 2007

i always thought the pati parmeshar concept had no place in Gurmat................. [%sig%]

Re: Calling Husband's Name

Man Singh · 23 Mar 2007

words have great powers along with Actions and feelings. Let's not advocat usage of anyword for spouses (not only for husbands) of any word. Eleders should be respected as per tradition. It is not only wife should be respectable towards husbands and not call by name, husband also should show same respect to wife and should not call her by name. Gurus taught us to pay equal respect to man and women. Rest is common sense. Everything can neither be written nor desirable. Bibek is to be used whileusing baani in our daily life as baani remains the same while time, society and circumestances keep on chnaging. Bibek is supreme in such cases.

Re: Calling Husband's Name

Harinder Singh · 28 Mar 2007

I feel that khalsa has only 1 gender and that gender is feminine. KHalsa lives and dies for SAtguru/Waheguru. So all this husband wife thing is just maya/haume/bikh. A gursikh wedding is an association of 2 soul brides helping and serving each other to marry Waheguru.These 2 soul brides are exactly same and have different worldly roles. BUt even these roles have become quite similar as both partners do job and both partners are expected to be apt in cleaning and cooking in order for them to be called tyar bar tyar. Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh was a brahamgyani and hence in his marriage pati parmeshar concept will apply, other than that its just association of 2 soul brides. Personally i feel both parters shud call eact other by name(use ji in the end). It was an indian tradition where the wife of haddmaas calls her pati "aap aap" and gives FOOK to the mortal husband of haddmaas. RAJ KAREGA KHALSA

Re: Calling Husband's Name

singh sahib · 28 Mar 2007

"I feel that khalsa has only 1 gender and that gender is feminine." "Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh was a brahamgyani and hence in his marriage pati parmeshar concept will apply" why do we allow such nonsense on these boards. reading posts like this make me wonder what peoples interpretation of sikhi really is, and what narrow understanding they have.

Re: Calling Husband's Name

ms k · 29 Mar 2007

WJKK WJKF singh_sahib, One of the most important ideas that sikhi promotes is vichaar. I agree that sikhi is sikhi...but for those who don't know anything by it need to discuss it. that is the purpose of such 'nonsense on these boards'. if you don't like what is said then refrain from accessing such websites. Controversy will always cause discussion that is a given...please give ppl space to make their own interpretation and if someone else gives their opinion it will make you think even more into it. This isn't intended to upset or offend you but merely to highlight that there are many who can get sikhi and culture mixed up and it should be the more knowledgable ppl who suggest their input to help differentiate. May i take this opportunity to thank Bhai Kulbir Singh Ji for his valuable knowledge becuase apart from him i don't think a single other person gives information as diplomatically and with pyaar as he does. Sorry singh_sahib if i've offended you WJKK WJKF [%sig%]

Re: Calling Husband's Name

Khalsaspirit · 29 Mar 2007

Waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh Khalsa jio, Beautiful opinions are coming in. As an opener of this thread we keenly reads everyone's opinion. We did not provide our opinions yet. We like to continue this topic until a concrete conclusion come up with the light of Gurmat thru Gursikhs. So far what we understood is that it is matter of mutual understanding between H and W, but please carries on your opinions. You can disagree with one’s opinion but please try to be friendlier. Thanks, Guru Mehar Karay, Waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh [%sig%]

Re: Calling Husband's Name

kar kirpaa sabh rayN thheevaa · 30 Mar 2007

[quote]"I tried to look in Guru Granth Sahib ji and could not find an instance where it was said that your "pathi" should be your "parmeshar" However I did find many examples where your "parmeshar" should be your "pathi" !!! [gurbani]khu nwnk ijin ipRau prmysru kir jwinAw ][/gurbani] kahu naanak jin prio paramaesar kar jaaniaa || Says Nanak, she who looks upon the Transcendent Lord as her Husband, [gurbani]DMnu sqI drgh prvwinAw ]4]30]99][/gurbani] dhha(n)n sathee dharageh paravaaniaa ||4||30||99|| is the blessed 'satee'; she is received with honor in the Court of the Lord. ||4||30||99|| If your husband is your Lord then your wife is your Lord, your son and daughter, mother and father, brother and sister, friend and foe, high and low - the Lord is all pervading." [/quote]

Re: Calling Husband's Name

CSJ · 30 Mar 2007

I think in above tuk prio means pati. I think this is not religious matter. It is how your family is setup. You can see in westren contries equality is taken too far. People have seprate accounts etc. They have much higher devorce rate then ours because they dont care about family they care more about thier ego and freedom. If you talk about souls and god is equal in every body. It is true but dont apply here because to run the family or company or any other organization you need one person to lead and others to follow. if everybody is leading nothing work. Now this depend on family who is leader and how they their family run. If we look at the equal soul thing and how can you tell your kids not to do something. "again no body should abuse the leading power too". If you dont respect somebody with word and say you have it in your heart is wrong beacuse in asa di war guru sahib ji says " jo jee hovey so ugavy" means what ever is in your heart will come out from your mouth". All old ways are not bad. [%sig%]

Re: Calling Husband's Name

Harinder Singh · 31 Mar 2007

<> Thandd rakh "singh sahib". You seem to confused with sikhi and punjabi culture. WE have come to this world only for ONE reason. It is to serve Satguru and as a result unite with Waheguru. Nuthing else is of any use. Everything else is temporary and like a dream. Everything a sikh does is a seva. The tatt seva is Naam and then comes bani de seva, then comes seva of fellow gursikhs in the form of dasvand, jorriyan de seva, langar de seva etc. IN the same way, marriage shud be seen as a seva too. Its a chance to serve a fellow sikh and help him realize the goal of this human life. All this husband wife thing is maya and haume and a gursikh couple shud be above all this. THere is only 1 Husband and rest all his soul brides. Some are trapped in female body and some in male body. Bhul Chukk Maaf RAJ KAREGA KHALSA

Re: Calling Husband's Name

maha_moorakh · 31 Mar 2007

hmmm yeh CSJ has a valid point there. Most of the time we dont like it when someone takes the lead, because it hurts our own ego. As long as the person 'taking lead' follows gurmat, and bases their decsions on gurmat, then there shouldnt be a problem. Obviously there isnt really such thing as a 'leader' and followers. we all follow mahraj.