Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Hindu Guy asked me this - Pls help!!!

Hindu Guy asked me this - Pls help!!!

surajsingh · 28 Mar 2007

I was talking to this Hindu guy who raised a question regarding a line from dasam granth. The line from Dasam Granth was 'Chharti Ka Poot Hon, Baahman Ko Nahey, Kaiy Tapp Aavat Hon Jo Karon'. He said this line was written by Guru Gobind Singh Ji. He translated this line like this, "I am son of Khatri and not of Brahman who does 'Tap'." This guy asked if Guru was saying that only brahman should do 'Tap'. He then quoted another line from Dasam Granth, which goes like this, "Teh Ham Adhik Tappasya Saadhi". He said this line was written by Guru Gobind Singh. Here Guru Gobind Singh said that he did lots of 'Tap' there (in his previous life). This guy said that if Guru Gobind Singh refused to do Tap because he considered himself a Khatri, then why he did Tap in his previous life? Does it mean that Guru Gobind Singh was a Brahman in his previous life? This Hindu guy quoted a line from Bhai Gurdas, which goes like this, "Bhari Kari Tapassya Rorhan Ki Gur Kari Vichhai". He said that this line means that Guru nanak did lots of 'Tap'. He asked if Guru Nanak was a Brahman. He asked if Guru Nanak Ji did 'Tap', then what was problem with Guru Gobind Singh? This guy asked if Khatri Guru Nanak Dev did 'Tap', then why Khatri Guru Gobind singh could not do 'Tap'? Please share your views so that I could give him reply... [%sig%]

Re: Hindu Guy asked me this - Pls help!!!

Balpreet Singh · 28 Mar 2007

ਸਵੈਯਾ ॥ਛਤ੍ਰੀ ਕੋ ਪੂਤ ਹੌ ਬਾਮਨ ਕੋ ਨਹਿ ਕੈ ਤਪੁ ਆਵਤ ਹੈ ਜੁ ਕਰੋ ॥ ਅਰੁ ਅਉਰ ਜੰਜਾਰ ਜਿਤੋ ਗ੍ਰਹਿ ਕੋ ਤੁਹਿ ਤਿਆਗ ਕਹਾ ਚਿਤ ਤਾ ਮੈ ਧਰੋ ॥ਅਬ ਰੀਝ ਕੈ ਦੇਹੁ ਵਹੈ ਹਮ ਕਉ ਜੋਊ ਹਉ ਬਿਨਤੀ ਕਰ ਜੋਰ ਕਰੋ ॥ ਜਬ ਆਉ ਕੀ ਅਉਧ ਨਿਦਾਨ ਬਨੈ ਅਤਿਹੀ ਰਨ ਮੈ ਤਬ ਜੂਝ ਮਰੋ ॥੨੪੮੯॥ Guru Sahib here is clear about his devotion to Vahiguru and requests that his consciousness remain with Akaal Purakh. The tap of a Brahmin is totally different than the tap of a Gursikh. Tap is a type of meditation that involves sitting in heat or near fire. Guru Sahib says: [gurbani] so jpu so qpu sw bRq pUjw ijqu hir isau pRIiq lgwie ] gur syvw qpW isir qpu swru ] jpu qpu sBu iehu sbdu hY swru ]5]2]4] so qpu pUrw sweI syvw jo hir myry min BwxI hy ]11] [/gurbani] So here you can see from these tuks that Guru Sahib has totally re defined "tap". In the second line of the svaiya in question, Guru Sahib asks for the gift of real tap. The tap of a Gursikh and the tap Guru Sahib encourages is jaap of shabad which enshrines love of Vahiguru in the mind. Brahmin idea of tap is different than this.

Re: Hindu Guy asked me this - Pls help!!!

surajsingh · 28 Mar 2007

Thanks for your response. I will let him know and post his reply if he gives any... thanks [%sig%]

Re: Hindu Guy asked me this - Pls help!!!

Man Singh · 28 Mar 2007

Meaning of tapa is universal and continuous for last 5000 years of known history of Indian civilisations and from to time numerous great sould nurtured this ancinet system of tapa and great Gurus being latest and purest in series. In my My opinion it is circumestances. Everybody can do tapa in normal peaceful circumestances Guru Nanak and Guru Gobinnd Singh Ji or me or you all can do tapa. But when tyrrants are harrassing humanity, tapa is not recommended. Guru Gobind Singh Ji says that all those who have fire in them and sensitivies towards defence of innocent people, Those who use their power to defend the weak and innocent people (Real meaning of Khatri not todays stamping by birth) they will take up arms and fight with demon and not do tapa. In Bhagwadgeeta also, Arjuna wants to do tapa but krishna asks him that this is not right time to do that. war is on your head and tyrrants are ready to eliminate humanity. Justice is awated by a women whose modesty was compromised in the parliament. Therfore Arjuna, being a Khatri, no japa but take bow and arrow and kill these demons. Therfore, real meaning of Gurus words has to understood with background circumestances in mind. Humanity was trembling at that time. fake tapaswis and yogis could not do anything. Humanity was suffering. Righteosuness was being ridiculed and evil was being forced on humanity. Guru sahebs, came with mashal of knowledge and valour and a vortex was formed in the scoiety. The most powerful kingdon on the earth was reduced to dust withing 50 years. Rest is history. Therefore tapa is meant for peaceful days. But when enemy is sitting on your head , ready to attack your identity, teerath daan, daya tap sanyam all become vain. Sword is the only sadhna under such circumestances. This is the meaning of the mentioned lines. These my opinions only. I am not welltrained or amritdhari and may be wrong. My apology for any mistakes. Bhul chuk maaf.

Re: Hindu Guy asked me this - Pls help!!!

High Spirits · 29 Mar 2007

Vaheguroo jee kaa Khalsaa Vaheguroo jee kee fateh Sadh Sangat jee I'm not very knowledgable, but I think I remember hearing kathaa which mentioned ਛਤ੍ਰੀ ਕੋ ਪੂਤ ਹੌ ਬਾਮਨ ਕੋ ਨਹਿ (Shatree ko poot hau baaman ko nahe). In this case I think Dasmesh Pitaa is saying he is the puttar (son) of Shatree which means shaster (weapons) and not of a brahmin. Because a hindu came to Pitaa jee and kept saying he was a brahmin/hindu or something (can't remember the full saakhi). And then Maharaaj did uchaaran of this shabad. So, I think (please correct me if I am wrong) this part means what I wrote above. If this saakhi is true, then what this hindu guy is getting at is void, it seems to me this hindu man is a little dodgy?? Please forgive my mistakes.

Re: Hindu Guy asked me this - Pls help!!!

High Spirits · 29 Mar 2007

Just another thing Sadh Sangat jee. The lines this hindu guy is quoted are not full. To understand the whole shabad, you can't just take one line as a basis for your veechaar. "Teh Ham Adhik Tappasya Saadhi" I think comes in Bachitar Natak and the line before this line is where Maharaaj tells us about Hemkunt Sahib. There are many learned people on this forum who I am sure can tell you exactly what the shabads this hindu guy has quoted ACTUALLY mean.

Re: Hindu Guy asked me this - Pls help!!!

surajsingh · 30 Mar 2007

Here is his response. He can't come online so asked me to post here... <> Can you please give a reference to any BRAHMAN book which favours 'Tap' sitting in heat or near fire? Also, what is Bhai Gurdas saying when he writes, "Ret Akk Ahaar Kar, Rorhaan Ki Gur Kari Vichhai". How a 'Vichhai' of 'Rarhaan' is different to so called Brahman Tap? [%sig%]

Re: Hindu Guy asked me this - Pls help!!!

singh5 · 30 Mar 2007

How Bhai Gurdas has described Guru Nanak Dev jee's stay in Emnabad is the way he has envisioned Guru Sahib staying in hardship there during Babar's invasion. Guru Nanak nor any other Guru in Sri Guru Granth Sahib advocates giving the body hardship in order to meditate (tap). Meditation through bodily hardship has no place in Sikhi. As for citing a Brahmin "text", I'm not sure what the point of that would be. It's a known fact that tap is a Hindu form of meditation practiced by countless sadhus. I'm not sure what your Hindu friend wants to prove. My question is "what's your point?"

Re: Hindu Guy asked me this - Pls help!!!

sunnybondsingh · 03 Apr 2007

that hindu wants to prove that all sikh guru sahibaan where brahmins in their previous lives a propaganda made by rss [%sig%]

Re: Hindu Guy asked me this - Pls help!!!

Man Singh · 03 Apr 2007

sunnybondsingh Ji, Nowadays it has become a fashion among non hindus and secular hindus that anything coming out of free mind is branded as RSS propganda? After seeing a number of friends citing RSS name in this website, I started tracking RSS bosses lectures and their website and new papers `Organiser' and `Panchajanya'. To my great surprise, I nowhere found any such anti sikh article or opinion in their literature. "sikh guru sahibaan where brahmins in their previous lives a propaganda made by rss" sounds to be your propagnda against RSS otherwise you will give some erefernce to your quote? Where you find such RSS propganda againt great Gurus. Any reference? Otherwise for a Sikh, telling lies about any individual, society or organisation is never liked by great Gurus or God.

Re: Hindu Guy asked me this - Pls help!!!

Bachitar Singh · 04 Apr 2007

I swear I have called you an uncle tom before Man Singh. Well here I go again. Your an uncle tom. It seems to me that you have a selective perception. Your just seeing and hearing things you want to. Let's Make a list and see what good hindus have done for sikhi. Good ????????? Bad They have stabbed sikhs in the back every chance they got. Who martyred Guru Arjan Dev Jee? Who gave up Guru Gobind Singh's family? Who were the pahari rajay? What did they do to us after 1947? Must the list go on? Now i'm not saying go out and kill hindu's all I is saying is that they are extremely extremely chalak people. [%sig%]

Re: Hindu Guy asked me this - Pls help!!!

dogra · 07 Apr 2007

Hmm, here we have the bigotted repsonse, Hindus all think alike, WHAT A BIGOTTED COMMENT. Now, did not some Hindu faith people join Guru Gobind Singhji at Anadpur Sahib? Was not Banda Singh Bahadhurji, Lakshman Dev, a dogra from Jammu, and was in an ashram when Guru Gobind Singhji found him? How many Hindu faith families made their first son fo Sikh faith. Thing is, there are a number of bad individuals in all forms of socities, hen ce prisons and prisoners throughout the World. The post by Bachitar Singh is not that of the Gurus, but that of hatred, poison of the individual. To judge people from the actions of a few, is racist pure and simple. When a person changes faith, does his blood change?

Re: Hindu Guy asked me this - Pls help!!!

dalbir singh shergill · 07 Apr 2007

ਛਤ੍ਰੀ ਕੋ ਪੂਤ ਹੌ ਬਾਮਨ ਕੋ ਨਹਿ ਕੈ ਤਪੁ ਆਵਤ ਹੈ ਜੁ ਕਰੋ ॥ ਅਰੁ ਅਉਰ ਜੰਜਾਰ ਜਿਤੋ ਗ੍ਰਹਿ ਕੋ ਤੁਹਿ ਤਿਆਗ ਕਹਾ ਚਿਤ ਤਾ ਮੈ ਧਰੋ ॥ छत्री को पूत हौ बामन को नहि कै तपु आवत है जु करो ॥ अरु अउर जंजार जितो ग्रहि को तुहि तिआग कहा चित ता मै धरो ॥ I am the son of a Kshatriya and not of a Brahmin who may instruct for performing severe austerities; how can I absorb myself in the embarrassments of the world by leaving you; ਅਬ ਰੀਝ ਕੈ ਦੇਹੁ ਵਹੈ ਹਮ ਕਉ ਜੋਊ ਹਉ ਬਿਨਤੀ ਕਰ ਜੋਰ ਕਰੋ ॥ ਜਬ ਆਉ ਕੀ ਅਉਧ ਨਿਦਾਨ ਬਨੈ ਅਤਿਹੀ ਰਨ ਮੈ ਤਬ ਜੂਝ ਮਰੋ ॥੨੪੮੯॥ अब रीझ कै देहु वहै हम कउ जोऊ हउ बिनती कर जोर करो ॥ जब आउ की अउध निदान बनै अतिही रन मै तब जूझ मरो ॥२४८९॥ Whatever request I am making with my folded hands, O Lord ! kindly be graceful and bestow this boon on me that when ever my end comes, then I may die fighting in the battlefield.2489. [%sig%]

Re: Hindu Guy asked me this - Pls help!!!

Bachitar Singh · 07 Apr 2007

You say my post is of hatred and poison. To an extent you are correct. Have you ever read the Dasam Granth. What does it say about hindus. Look at our Siri Guru Granth Sahib. Name me one thing that it says good about brahams. I can name you over a hundred that say bad about them. Hinduism is not a religion. The path of hinduism does not lead to the path of god. If it did Siri Guru Nanak Dev Jee would not have made sikhism. Read there holy texts I have spent countless hours reading them. Do you know what I read? How to make money and do kala jadoo. You can call me a bigot, a racist, a hater. It's not like I care. People said the same to Sant Jarnail Singh Bhindrawale. Unlike you I care about my religion. Until we have the same equal rights as hindus in india I am going to keep on preaching what the Guru Granth Sahib says. The first Chaupee of Akal Ustat. ਬ੍ਰਹਮਾ ਬਿਸਨ ਅੰਤੁ ਨਹੀ ਪਾਇਓ ॥ Brahma and Vishnu Could not know His end. ਨੇਤਿ ਨੇਤਿ ਮੁਖ ਚਾਰ ਬਤਾਇਓ ॥੫॥ The four-headed god Brahma described Him ad `Neti Neti` (Not this, Not this) ਕੋਟਿ ਇੰਦ੍ਰ ਉਪਇੰਦ੍ਰ ਬਨਾਏ ॥ He hath created millions of Indras and Upindras (smaller Indras). ਬ੍ਰਹਮਾ ਰੁਦ੍ਰ ਉਪਾਇ ਖਪਾਏ ॥ He hath created and destroyed Brahmas and Rudras (Shivas). Oh even better. What is the swayie before Anand Sahib in Rehras Sahib "..Ram Raheem Puran Quraan, Anaykh Kehay Math Ek Na Maniyo Simrat Sastar Baes Sabai Boh Payd Kehay Hum Ek Na Janiyo Siri Apaan Kirpa Tuhmaree Khar MAIN NA KEHIYO Sabh Thohai Bakanyo." -Guru Gobind Singh Jee

Re: Hindu Guy asked me this - Pls help!!!

dogra · 08 Apr 2007

Guru Nankji took his path to move away from the corruption of the caste system, which by the way is not in Hindu scriptures, as anyperson can be anyone according to their previous Karma. Again u natter about Brahamins, as if they all think alike, this is bigotry. Does it say Brahmins are all bad people who should be despised? Please, on meeting a person do u judge that person based on what religion they are, or what their personality is like? Guru Nanakji said there is no Hindu no Muslim, i.e. only human beings, this is a humanistic message. Wheteher u care or not is ur choice, if u say such statements, then these r bigotry pure and simple and not the message of the Gurus, which is humanity. U dont know me , so dont judge what i care about. Difference between caring and hating.

Re: Hindu Guy asked me this - Pls help!!!

dogra · 08 Apr 2007

"The Mool Mantar (literally, the root verse; the first hymn composed by Guru Nanak) sums up the basic belief of the Sikhs. Guru Granth Sahib begins with the Mool Mantar. Every Sikh is expected to recite it daily. The English translation is given below: Ik Onkaar Sat Naam Karta Purkh Nir Bhau Nir Vair Akaal Moorat Ajooni Saibhang Gur Parsaad Jap Aad Sach Jugaad Sach Hai Bhee Sach Naanak Hosee Bhee Sach There is only one God His Name is Truth He is the Creator He is without fear He is without hate He is beyond time (Immortal) He is beyond birth and death He is self-existent He is realized by the Guru's grace. Chant and meditate: True in the primal beginning True throughout the ages True here and now O Nanak Forever and ever true " It clearly stated that Guruji said 'he is without hate'

Re: Hindu Guy asked me this - Pls help!!!

Bachitar Singh · 08 Apr 2007

"Hindu Anha Tur Koo Kana Doha Thay Giani Siana." Dogra there is a big difference between hating and not caring for. I do not hate hindus. Yes I do not care for hinduism. I am entilted to my opinion as are you. I'll admit I am not perfect infact i am a mahan papi. Now I am not an ethnocentric person. I have immense respect for every other religion. I just not care of hinduism.

Re: Hindu Guy asked me this - Pls help!!!

Demonic Warrior · 09 Apr 2007

'dogra' and 'Bachitar Singh' A message to both: 'Guru Nanakji said there is no Hindu no Muslim, i.e. only human beings, this is a humanistic message.' You're almost right about this statement and truth that Guru ji made. The meaning is what it says, that there is no muslim nor hindu anymore. So, he said this because they've forgotten the meaning of being one. In Gurbani, Guru Ji defines a muslim and hindu. To be one, one should look upon humans with one impartial eye, equally, and should meditate on God daily. Bestow all faith and love upon him, and see him in every being. This is a message for all in this world. Bhagat Namdev Ji and Bhagat kabeer Ji are true. So, hindus and muslims should adopt their personality and qualties, and lovingly devote their selves to God by meditating on him, just as they did. If a Brahmin, meditates on Kirtam Naam such as, ram, har or govind or Allah and does this to meet God. His meditation, love and humbleness, as a mediate, will lead him to God. Remember, the worshiper becomes the worshiped. God is merciful to all. But those who love him are rare diamonds. To love God is to love all. See God through all, as God himself is in this drama. Only he exists. When we understand and accept this truth, then and only then, will God accept us.

Re: Hindu Guy asked me this - Pls help!!!

Man Singh · 09 Apr 2007

Bachitter Singh Ji, I appreciate your honesty. You have spilled out your worldview honestly and that's how human beings should be. Yes you have every right to perceive the history the way you want. But Broader is your information bank, better will be your decsion making power. Who martyred Guru Arjan Dev Jee? "I think you should read Tujuk-e- Jehangiri for the answer in which Jehangir has written that I was planning to trap this Hindu known as Arjan, who wears clothes like fakirs and having very big influence on Hindus and muslims both." I can'nt do anything if in spite of reading such statement froma killer, you blame some fictious people. Who gave up Guru Gobind Singh's family? My question is who were the five people who offered their heads for Guru? Individuals's treachery can not be put on heads of a community. Who were the pahari rajay? You Tell me who were they? They were namakharams and gaddars who ditched the motherland and associated with foreign invaders? Do you feel any religious person can do such namakharami and gaddari? What did they do to us after 1947? You tell me better? Secular namakharams nehru and gandhi ditched the motherland and their tendency to please Muslims caused death of 3 million hindu and sikhs and destruction of billions? My feeling is that poor hindus were the biggest sufferers and the most unfortunate thing is that people like you are trying to blame and demonise the victims. Must the list go on? List more. A lady of no religion Indira Khan attacked Akal takht and cleverly put blame on Hindus and people like you belive her. List more that goondas loyal to Super Secular(Hindu haters) Rajive Gandhi butured 2000 Sikhs in Delhi and shamelessly put blame on `Hindus' and people like you belive such thuggs and join your voice with them. Truth is that your mind is not able to differentiate between gangs of Mao, Marx and Macauley(Secular) with Hindu names and starts poor helpless hindus for the sins of these secular goondas. Do you feel that if sikh is criminal, then whole community should be called that way? Definitely not?

Re: Hindu Guy asked me this - Pls help!!!

dogra · 09 Apr 2007

Demonic thanks for ur message. Also, the actions and deeds of us as individual human beings is what is important, not to judge people without knowing them, not to condemn people just because of the actions of the few Bachitar, ok, so u do not hate, then fine. Hate is of the dark side of humanity, and only serves to poison people and their thoughts. Guru Tegh Bahudhurji sacrificed his life for the Kashmiri Pundits, to help them, Guru Gobind Singjii a nine year old, at the time, suggested that Guru Tegh Bahdhurji help them. This magnificent act of humanity is an example to all human beings reagrdless of faith, creed or any other difference.