Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Ram Muhammad Singh Azad.

Ram Muhammad Singh Azad.

kulsingh5 · 11 Apr 2007

Dear Sangath I have a question for every one on this forum. When Ram Muhammad Singh Azad (Udham Singh) cut his hair to avenge the death of 1000’s of Punjabis in Amritsar, was it right thing to do cutting his hair? And was he still a Sikh after that? Thank you aval aleh noor oupaaeiaa kudharath kae sabh ba(n)dhae || First, Allah created the Light; then, by His Creative Power, He made all mortal beings. Bhagat Kabeer Ji Raag Prabhaatee 1349 [%sig%]

Re: Ram Muhammad Singh Azad.

Balpreet Singh · 11 Apr 2007

Sd. Udham Singh took that name after becoming amritdhari. His previous name was Sher Singh I believe. When we chhak amrit, we pledge that in return for amrit, we are willing to give our lives and will not commit the four bujjer kurehits. Committing a bujjer kurehit is fatal to Sikhi and a person no longer is amritdhari. I understand what Udham Singh and many others did. I appreciate that it was very brave. But according to Sikhi it was not acceptable. We can never compromise our Sikhi and if we do, we have already lost. Satnam Singh Chheena was one of the last major Sikh fighters in 1993. He was the head of the Bhindranwala Tiger Force in Terai. He wanted to cross the border to Pakistan but was finding it very hard to move around undetected. He decided that he would cut his hair and did ardas that he would only keep it cut for 3 months and then grow it again. He took the appearance of a pandit with a long bodi on his head. While Chheena was still making plans to cross the border, the person who's house he was staying it informed the police and he was arrested. The police at first couldnt' believe that the pandit in front of them was Satnam Singh Chheena of the Tiger Force but he admitted it himself. He was killed shortly after. Life and death are in Guru Sahib's hands and so is success in any endeavour. Chheena thought he could save his life by cutting his hair but ended up dying and that too as a mona. At any rate, my point is that Sikhi and especially something like the bujjer kurehits is not something we can make any compromises with for 'strategic' reasons.

Re: Ram Muhammad Singh Azad.

Seeker of the Truth · 11 Apr 2007

<<>> lawl!!! When did Shaheed Bhai Udham Singh take amrit? Stop making up lies. He was never an amritdhari. He called himself "Ram Muhammad Singh Azad" to unite all Indians and rep. Indians for his cause.

Re: Ram Muhammad Singh Azad.

Balpreet Singh · 11 Apr 2007

For a "Seeker of Truth" you sure do have the wrong attitude for it. It's a very commonly known fact that Udham Singh was amritdhari and even after cutting his hair always wore his kara and carried his kirpan and gatra. >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> Udham Singh was a militant nationalist, was born Sher Singh on 26 December 1899, at Sunam, in the then princely state of Patiala. His father, Tahal Singh, was at that time working as a watchman on a railway crossing in the neighbouring village of Upall. Sher Singh lost his parents before he was seven years and was admitted along with his brother Mukta Singh to the Central Khalsa Orphanage at Amritsar on 24 October 1907. As both brothers were administered the Sikh initiatory rites at the Orphanage, they received new names, Sher Singh becoming Udham Singh and Mukta Singh Sadhu Singh. In 1917, Udham Singh's brother also died, leaving him alone in the world. >>>>>>>>>>>>>>> Do some research and I'm sure you'll find the same facts.

Re: Ram Muhammad Singh Azad.

Seeker of the Truth · 11 Apr 2007

Ha. You are quoting Wikipedia. Great source, eh? (I am being sarcastic)

Re: Ram Muhammad Singh Azad.

Balpreet Singh · 11 Apr 2007

The source is actually the Encyclopaedia of Sikhism Ed. Harbans Singh. Wikipedia has taken it from there. The fact that it's commonly accepted knowledge that his birth name was "Sher Singh" and was later changed to "Udham Singh" is proof in itself. Names are changed at amrit sinchaar if they were not initially taken from Sri Guru Granth Sahib. I find it quite strange that you refuse to believe he was amritdhari. All children that went to the Khalsa Orphanage in Amritsar were amritdhari and even now this is a Sikh institution that trains kirtanis/parchaaraks.

Re: Ram Muhammad Singh Azad.

Balpreet Singh · 11 Apr 2007

Here's another example of children coming to the school and becoming Sikhs and receiving amrit: Gurkha children embrace Sikhism By Varinder Walia Oct 28, 2005, 13:58 Amritsar, October 27: Singing hymns from Guru Granth Sahib, playing tabla and reciting Gurbani and conversation in chaste Punjabi by ‘ Kanchas’ (Gurkha children) from hilly Kingdom of Nepal may seem unusual. Nobody can imagine that earlier name of Parkash Singh could be Om Parkash and Amritpal Singh was once Munish, both hailing from Nepal. The Central Khalsa Orphanage (CKO) run by the Chief Khalsa Diwan is home to 175 children, including Nepalese, who were rendered orphans. It goes to the credit of the Chief Khalsa Diwan that the orphans are admitted to the orphanage without any consideration of caste or creed. The orphanage has the credit of producing Shaheed Udham Singh, who remained there from 1907 to 1919. The orphanage, which started with one child brought from Sindh (Pakistan) by Mr Harbans Singh Attari, celebrates its anniversary tomorrow — October 28, here. Mr Charnjit Singh Chadha, President Chief Khalsa Diwan said many ‘Kanchas’, brought up in its orphanage had been propagating Sikhism in various parts of the world. Many of them were also absorbed in the SGPC. They are so devoted to Sikhism that most of the Sikh organisations including the Shiromani Committee exempted them from required tests. He said that as per the constitution of the orphanage, only children above six years were admitted. Mr Chadha said it was mandatory for every inmate to attain education up to matriculation. For this, the orphanage runs a school till class while they join Khalsa school for higher education. Mr Chadha said that besides education, training in musical instruments and shabad kirtans, musical instruments like tabla, harmonium, dilruba, sitar is imparted to the students in this seminary. This institution gave the Sikh community eminent ragis like Bhai Santa Singh, Bhai Gopal Singh, Bhai Gurmej Singh, Singh Sahib Bhai Fateh. Other alumni of repute, include musician Dalip Chander Bedi and Principal S. S. Amol. Most of the students of the centre, however, end up becoming raagis, kirtaniyas and preachers. The latest comer is Pardeep Singh (previous name Pardeep Kumar) whose name was recommended by the Gurdwara Singh Sabha, Nepal. Mann Bahadur has been rechristened Bahadur Singh. Another student of orphanage is Vinod Singh (previous name Vinod Kumar). While most of the old converted Sikh students have forgotten their mother tongue - Nepali with the passage of time. They say they hardly visit Nepal due to the ‘communication gap’ that virtually has separated them from their roots.

Re: Ram Muhammad Singh Azad.

kulsingh5 · 11 Apr 2007

Dear Balpreet Singh I'm glad that you have tried to answer the question, but did you read the Shabad I have put at the end, for your sake i will put the full shabad. prabhaathee || aval aleh noor oupaaeiaa kudharath kae sabh ba(n)dhae || eaek noor thae sabh jag oupajiaa koun bhalae ko ma(n)dhae ||1|| logaa bharam n bhoolahu bhaaee || khaalik khalak khalak mehi khaalik poor rehiou srab t(h)aa(n)ee ||1|| rehaao || maattee eaek anaek bhaa(n)th kar saajee saajanehaarai || naa kashh poch maattee kae bhaa(n)ddae naa kashh poch ku(n)bhaarai ||2|| sabh mehi sachaa eaeko soee this kaa keeaa sabh kashh hoee || hukam pashhaanai s eaeko jaanai ba(n)dhaa keheeai soee ||3|| alahu alakh n jaaee lakhiaa gur gurr dheenaa meet(h)aa || kehi kabeer maeree sa(n)kaa naasee sarab nira(n)jan ddeet(h)aa ||4||3|| Prabhaatee: First, Allah created the Light; then, by His Creative Power, He made all mortal beings. From the One Light, the entire universe welled up. So who is good, and who is bad? ||1|| O people, O Siblings of Destiny, do not wander deluded by doubt. The Creation is in the Creator, and the Creator is in the Creation, totally pervading and permeating all places. ||1||Pause|| The clay is the same, but the Fashioner has fashioned it in various ways. There is nothing wrong with the pot of clay - there is nothing wrong with the Potter. ||2|| The One True Lord abides in all; by His making, everything is made. Whoever realizes the Hukam of His Command, knows the One Lord. He alone is said to be the Lord's slave. ||3|| The Lord Allah is Unseen; He cannot be seen. The Guru has blessed me with this sweet molasses. Says Kabeer, my anxiety and fear have been taken away; I see the Immaculate Lord pervading everywhere. ||4||3|| Read the shabad and try to think about the faith you are following, think outside the box. [%sig%]

Re: Ram Muhammad Singh Azad.

Bachitar Singh · 11 Apr 2007

He was no amrit dhari. An amrit dhari would rather have his head cut off then cut his hair. At least according to my standards.

Re: Ram Muhammad Singh Azad.

Balpreet Singh · 11 Apr 2007

kulsingh, What do you think the shabad means and what do you think the relevance is to Udham Singh? I have not called him anything less than human nor have I said he should be hated. I have said that he violated rehit and thus it is not an acceptable conduct for a Sikh. But please do share your thoughts so I too might be able to see your point.

Re: Ram Muhammad Singh Azad.

Roopkaur · 11 Apr 2007

Kul Singh, I do not understand the point you are trying to make here. THe original question was whether he was a SIkh or not, and the answer, as already given by Bhaji, is no. He could have been a great desh bhagat and patriot, but ultimately did fail on the path of gurmat. Being a national hero and being a Sikh are two different things. As for the shabad, I do not see any connection with it and Udham Singh. If you are trying to say that the same light resided in Udham Singh that resides in Amritdharees, well no one is denying or arguing that point. However, that same light also resided in Hitler, Mussilini, Stalin etc... It does not mean that as a SIkh, we cannot critically look at people's actions. After all, SIkhi is about BIBEK BUDHI.

Re: Ram Muhammad Singh Azad.

not important · 12 Apr 2007

WJKK WJKF ROCK ON ROOPKAUR PHENJI Bibek budhi its awsome!!!!!!! WJKK WJKF [%sig%]

Re: Ram Muhammad Singh Azad.

CSJ · 12 Apr 2007

I think there is a diffrence in shaeeds if it is for religion or ony other cause. I think For other causes they will not get mukti but they will get good life agian with chance to do bhagti. Some body gave shaeedi for religion with bhagti will get mukti. [%sig%]

Re: Ram Muhammad Singh Azad.

kulsingh5 · 12 Apr 2007

Dear everyone Many of you have said the shabad that I have written with my question is nit relevant. I think it’s very much relevant. First of all, you guys calling your self Sikhs, the Shabad is from Guru Granth Sahib, it talks about how everyone is equal in Gods eyes. Everyone will have to realise that God is not in your hair or in your 5k’s, the almighty is everywhere the hukam was his that Udham Singh will cut his hair. Everyone who said “he was not a Sikh because he cut his hair” guys it was a tactic used by the Great Ram Muhammad Singh Azad. Anyway I’m hitting my head against brick wall with you lot. Fathay [%sig%]

Re: Ram Muhammad Singh Azad.

Balpreet Singh · 12 Apr 2007

Kulsingh, I don't understand why you take such an defensive tone. you said >>>> "you guys calling your self Sikhs, the Shabad is from Guru Granth Sahib, it talks about how everyone is equal in Gods eyes." >>>> Yes, it is from Guru Granth Sahib but I don't think there's any problem in asking you to explain the relevance. For example if we're discussing krodh and someone posts the shabad "poota mata kee asees..." it would only be sensible to ask what the point is. God is in each soul. But that doesn't mean that everything everyone does is right. If it was "hukam" for Udham Singh to cut his hair, then will we say it's also "hukam" when someone drinks or steals or fornicates? Is that hukam as well? The fact that God resides in him and all life, doesn't mean everything everyone does is good and right. I've already said that I think what Udham Singh did was very daring. But as a "tactic", cutting one's hair is not something a Sikh is willing to consider. Guru Sahib's hukam/rehit/orders are not negotiable. When we are given amrit we agree that our life can go but not our Sikhi. Please give me an example of ANY puratan Gursikh hero who compromised their Sikhi to reach an end. You can't find them. I'm sorry you feel like you're "hitting you head" but why is it necessary for me to agree with you if you haven't made your point?

Re: Ram Muhammad Singh Azad.

dogra · 12 Apr 2007

Ram Muhammad Singh Azad- A beautiful message of anytime, a message for humnaity, a message against the hate spreaders of Jinnah and the Muslim league and Savakar and the Hindu mahasbha, both 2 nation theory parties. Shaheed Udham Singh did not go around killing innocent people, but the man who approved the attacks of the massacre in Amritsar. He fought for a united India, a India backed by the democratic will of the majority of people, that is its history from time immemorial. Bless Shaheed Udham Singhji. His last words:http://www.punjabilok.com/misc/freedom/udham_last_word2.htm "In a letter from Brixton Prison of 30th March, 1940, Udham Singh refers to Bhagat Singh in the following terms: 'I never afraid of dying so soon I will be getting married with execution. I am not sorry as I am a soldier of my country it is since 10 years when my friend has left me behind and I am sure after my death I will see him as he is waiting for me it was 23rd and I hope they will hang me on the same date as he was.' Facing the Judge, he exclaimed, 'I say down with British Imperialism. You say India do not have peace. We have only slavery. Generations of so called civilization has brought for us everything filthy and degenerating known to the human race. All you have to do is read your own history. If you have any human decency about you, you should die with shame. The brutality and bloodthirsty way in which the so called intellectuals who call themselves rulers of civilization in the world are of bastard blood...'

Re: Ram Muhammad Singh Azad.

kulsingh5 · 12 Apr 2007

Balpreet Singh I have not asked you to agree with me. Why I have said that I’m hitting my head against a brick wall is because it’s all the same with you guys. Many years ago I met a great man who said something which will never leave my mind; he said “How can you say that a diamond is a diamond when you haven’t even seen one. Same with a lot of people in this world, calling them self’s Sikhs but don’t even know what a Sikh is. Saints have come to death and have declared that they are not worthy to be called Sikhs and you guys are so quick to stand up and call your self’s Sikhs. What is a Sikh, mate the day you understand what Sikh is, you will never come on these forums again. Read the Shabad with a bit of love and you will find the relevance. Brother you and I have a long journey ahead of us and let’s give and arm to each other when we fall. Fathay [%sig%]

Re: Ram Muhammad Singh Azad.

Balpreet Singh · 12 Apr 2007

>>>>>>>> Same with a lot of people in this world, calling them self’s Sikhs but don’t even know what a Sikh is. Saints have come to death and have declared that they are not worthy to be called Sikhs and you guys are so quick to stand up and call your self’s Sikhs. What is a Sikh, mate the day you understand what Sikh is, you will never come on these forums again. >>>>>>>> I haven't called myself a Sikh anywhere in this thread. One of the most chardi kala Singhs I've ever met said to me once, "Until someone reaches that avastha (of jot vigaas) we're all duplicate Khalsas and Singhs." I hold that very true. But at the same time I can tell what is not Singh-like behaviour and I can guarantee you by any definition, cutting one's hair is not something a Singh or a Sikh will do. From your comment you seem to indicate that you know what a Sikh is. Please do tell me. I find it interesting though that you are also on these forums. Perhaps to educate people like me?

Re: Ram Muhammad Singh Azad.

kulsingh5 · 12 Apr 2007

So Balpreet Singh, by the way you write this thread, you seem to me that you are angered by what I have said. Yes, I am here to educate people like you, but people like you don’t want to listen. So that answers my previous thread “hitting my head against a brick wall". Thank you [%sig%]

Re: Ram Muhammad Singh Azad.

Balpreet Singh · 12 Apr 2007

I can assure you I'm not angered. It's not really all that big a deal that merits anger frankly. I'm asking you to indeed give your views and explain the initial relevance of the shabad and I've asked you to explain what you think a Sikh is but you haven't obliged. I can only be accused of "not listening" if I don't read what you write but as of yet you haven't written anything. Even if you do, I don't know why it's necessary that I have to agree with you.

Re: Ram Muhammad Singh Azad.

Roopkaur · 12 Apr 2007

Maybe its just me, but I didnt get any anger in that post. I too am eager to know what a real Sikh is and eagerly await your reply.

Re: Ram Muhammad Singh Azad.

Robert Langdon · 12 Apr 2007

Kulsingh5 veerjee, Balpreet Singh has made many valid points. Yes we all agree that Udham Singh had done a brave thing and is recognised all over. But it is important that you see that to be a amrithdhaari sikh you wouldnt compromise anything. The whole Sikh/Punjabi and Indian Community has respect for Udham Singh but to say if was a sikh of the guru after that; what do you think? He cut his kes, the most mahaan thing to a Sikh. To be a Sikh the first thing one starts to do is grow their kes. When we take amrith we are explained clearly that in no way you can cut your kes if you do so then its a bujjer kurehit and if one has done a bujjer kurehit you become a patit When we take amrith we are given rehit and told of the bujjer kurehits, in no stance would the punj say its ok to compromise even to avenge the killings. A Sikh is one that follows the guru, and his rehit. Keeping your kes is a huge part of rehit and being a Sikh Guru Gobind Singh Jee said Rehit Piaare MujhKo Sikh Piaara naahi(n) I hope that helps Bhul chuk maaf

Re: Ram Muhammad Singh Azad.

sikh_taz · 12 Apr 2007

Sat Shri Akal I have a question: Why Shri Guru Gobind Singh Ji made this rule (not to cut hair) at time of Mughal kingdom? Of course to have a unique identity. But Sikhi never teach us to just have a unique identity. The main reason was/is to have strength so that we can fight against exploitation and crime. So, the frimary thing is to fight for truth and poor. Sh. Udham Singh(Bhagat singh) did that. This make me believe that he was sikh till end of his life, when he was being hung. Bhul chuk maaf [%sig%]

Re: Ram Muhammad Singh Azad.

Khalsaspirit · 13 Apr 2007

Waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh Khalsa jio, [gurbani]so isKu sKw bMDpu hY BweI ij gur ky Bwxy ivic AwvY ] AwpxY BwxY jo clY BweI ivCuiV cotw KwvY ] ibnu siqgur suKu kdy n pwvY BweI iPir iPir pCoqwvY ]1] hir ky dws suhyly BweI ] jnm jnm ky iklibK duK kwty Awpy myil imlweI ] rhwau ] [/gurbani] Guru ki rehat and rehani is Guru ka bhana and that start with the basic rehat Kesh for a SIKH then with Khaday ke pahul and 5k's externally and for internally Gurbani reading and with every breath naam japna practice. Now Shaheed Udam Singh gave up the basic one eventually Guru's path. If you gave Guru's path then how some one will recognize you as Guru ka Sikh, then only be known as manmukh because you listened to your mind than Guru on giving up Kesh. So Guru sahib are very clear in the above shabad. Guru Mehar karay Waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh [%sig%]

Re: Ram Muhammad Singh Azad.

Roopkaur · 13 Apr 2007

>But Sikhi never teach us to just have a unique identity.< We read in Anand Sahib that Bhagtaa Kee CHaal Niraali. So the chaal or the path of a SIkh is unique, which would also mean that their identity is unique. Also Sri Guru GObind SIngh Ji said that Jab Lag Khalsa Rehai Niyaaraa, Tab Laag Tej Deeoo Mai Saraa. So clearly the SIkhs are to tread a unique path. I think for this question we should all look to Shaheed Bhai Taru Singh Ji's Saakhi. They could have sacrificed his Kesh in order to do more seva of the panth, but they did not and kept their kesh till their last breath. I think that Sakhi answers the question quite well.

Re: Ram Muhammad Singh Azad.

kulsingh5 · 14 Apr 2007

Chandra Singh Seems like you have a problem, I think you need some strong reading lessons in English. The question, I asked the sangat was if it was right for what Udham Singh did and for his actions did this not make him a Sikh. Where have I quoted anywhere in the thread that Allah of Quran? I got this shabad from the Granth sahib. I'm just questioning your beliefs, any way what is your belief? Share your ideas Mr Chandra Singh, Instead of being all hot headed. Good bye. [%sig%]

Re: Ram Muhammad Singh Azad.

singh_1985 · 16 Apr 2007

Didn't Shaheed Bhai Jinda and Sukha cut their hair before they assassinated Gen. Vadiya?

Re: Ram Muhammad Singh Azad.

Seeker of the Truth · 17 Apr 2007

Yes, they did cut their hair.

Re: Ram Muhammad Singh Azad.

Ibin Sikh · 17 Apr 2007

Kulsingh5, Shaheed Udham Singh is respected by all Indians especially Sikhs. Udham Singh will be considered a great Shaheed in the nationalist movement of India just as we respect Subhash Chandra Boss, Mangal Pandey, Rajguru, Chandrashekhar Azad. He will always be considered a gread Shaheed in the sense that he was great nationalist and he died for his desh. But if you are asking whether he will be considered a Shaheed in the tradition of the Sikhs such as Baba Deep Singh Jee, Bhai Mani Singh Jee or Bhai Taru Singh Jee (who died but did not allow his hair to get cut) then I think not. But that does not mean Sikhs do not honour Udham Singh. Almost every child in Punjab knows about Shaheeds like Udham Singh and Bhaghat Singh. These men are inspiring nationalists. We respect them.