Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Questions thrown at sikhs

Questions thrown at sikhs

sy · 18 Apr 2007

I have a few questions that ive had thrown at me which ive had a difficult time answering im just begining to read into sikhism but have bin asked some tough questions. Now i know sikhism and hinduism but how do you explain to them we are two different religions, this one guy claimed that the guru granth sahib said that the hindu gods exsisted how do i let this guy know he's wrong. Another question do sikhs believe all religions lead to the same god, because i had a christian ask me this and i said no but how do i explain this.

Re: Questions thrown at sikhs

Demonic Warrior · 18 Apr 2007

'this one guy claimed that the guru granth sahib said that the hindu gods exsisted how do i let this guy know he's wrong.' The hindu gods did exist and do now, except that Bhrama became a Sikh - I think his name was pika pat or something.

Re: Questions thrown at sikhs

Demonic Warrior · 18 Apr 2007

'question do sikhs believe all religions lead to the same god' All religions lead to God if they recite his name, and wish to meet him through his name. Kirtam Naam may be recited which is Govind, Ram, Allah etc. Although, the easiest way to reach God is through Sikhi, since the true name of God, Satnaam gurmantar, has been given to us. With this, and Guru Ji's teachings - by having a guru - we have a straight forward path to God. But, you don't tell your christian friend this. You tell him that if, for example, you are true to your religion and meditate on God's name then his name as a mediator will lead him to God. But, only if you meditate on his Name - as meditation on his name is the true religion.

Re: Questions thrown at sikhs

Khatarnak Times · 18 Apr 2007

Which Brahma became a sikh? Brahma, according to my understanding is a position that different beings occupy throughout creation. There are many lakhs of Brahmas. In anycase, according to what I've heard from Singhs, not all paths lead to God. ONly Sikhi leads to God. It is very important to understand what one means when they say "leads to God". If they mean heaven, then according to Sikhi that is a very low level. Meeting God is being a Sachkhand Vasi and going to heaven is Dharam Khand. But everyone gets what they work for. So, for example if a Christian is a really good Christian then he will get whatever he's after (heaven? good health? etc.) This sort of dharam leads to continuous transmigration of the soul. Because whatever good karmas one has collected will be gone once we've got the fruit of our labour (heaven). Then they will have to take another birth and so on. Sikhi from what I understand is about getting to Sach Khand and from there, their is no coming back. Guru sahib has given us naam for this very reason. By japping Gurmat naam, the naam that God himself created and not a kirtam naam which are names assigned to him by people, we can get to sach khand. Nanak Nadri Nadar Nihal.

Re: Questions thrown at sikhs

Ibin Sikh · 18 Apr 2007

Brahma was one of the Bhatts. When he incarnated as a human as one of the Bhatts he also became a Sikh of Sri Guru Arjun Dev Jee. [%sig%]

Re: Questions thrown at sikhs

Demonic Warrior · 18 Apr 2007

'Khatarnak Times', Bhagat Dhroo Ji, Bhagat Namdev, Bhagat Kabeer Ji and so many more went to saachkhand through kirtam naam. Tell me, what does the V, R, H, G in VaHeGuRu stand for? Well, V for Vishnu, R for Ram, H for Har and G for Govind. These are kirtam naam. 'for example if a Christian is a really good Christian then he will get whatever he's after (heaven? good health? etc.)' If a Christian chants God's name such as Ram, and he does this to meet God then God will ascend him higher then the seven heavens and to Karam Khand. From Karam Khand Satguru Ji will bless him with the ability to enter Saachkhand by giving him amrit and Satnaam - gurmantar. The only difference between Kirtam Naam and Satnaam is that by japping the former one attains what he wants from meditating on it and nothing more. Although, with the latter, Satnaam, even if we meditate on this to attain e.g. spiritual power, we will still reach Saachkhand. Why? well Satnaam is the source of everything, it's God, and through Satnaam everything exists. Thus, automatically pulling us towards truth and God by meditating on it. 'sy' 'guru granth sahib said that the hindu gods exsisted how do i let this guy know he's wrong.' To answer the first question correctly, Gurbani tells us that only God exists, as your Hindu friend, from his limited intellect, thinks that we, the particulars exist. Even though, we do not and God does. So, Vishnu, the sustainer, Bhrama the creator and Shiva the destoryer are actually all Gods doings and power which he performs through these gods. Gurbani also tells us that there are countless of these three gods occupying the all other countless universes created.

Re: Questions thrown at sikhs

Balpreet Singh · 18 Apr 2007

I have heard that Bhikkha Bhatt was the incarnation of Brahma. Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh has written this as well in his lekh "Sri Akal Purakh Ka Khalsa" in Gurmat Vichaar. Although japping of kirtam naam will have benefits, it is clear in Gurbani that liberation is only through "Gur Parsaad" and there is only ONE Satguru and that Satguru is Satguru Nanak. Without taking Satguru Nanak as a Guru and receiving naam from him, there is no way to reach Sach Khand. Only Gurmat Naam from Satguru Nanak has the power to do that. But as mentioned in previous posts, other religions aren't condemned and will get what the fruit of their efforts to what end they desire. Demonic Warrior, You've mentioned the Bhagats. These Bhagats were all Sikhs of Guru Nanak. Before, Bhagats like Prehlad and Dhru were blessed by Guru Nanak specially because Guru Nanak hadn't given Gurmat Naam openly to the world yet. But now, there is no way but to take Guru Nanak as Satguru to reach SachKhand. There must be kamaiee of Gurmat Naam via Guru Nanak. [gurbani]rwm rwm sBu ko khY kihAY rwmu n hoie ] [u]gur prswdI rwmu min vsY[/u] qw Plu pwvY koie ]1] [/gurbani]

Re: Questions thrown at sikhs

sy · 19 Apr 2007

ok so does sikh religion say hindu gods like ganish shiva and stuff exsisted??? because i find it funny to believe that their were 333 million gods really funny Plus every religion believes in a different god.

Re: Questions thrown at sikhs

jassmannn · 19 Apr 2007

Sikhism is not the only way to god. All men are created by God, and so are religions. As with Dhanna Jatt, he worshipped a stone and found god through that. God is not looking for rituals, names etc: god is looking for true love. Call God, ram, allah whatever but if you are not a good human being and don't have true love for god, then you can be a nitneemi, amrit dhari whatever, it will be to no end.

Re: Questions thrown at sikhs

Demonic Warrior · 19 Apr 2007

Balpreet Singh, The second line of the shabad you have provided clarifies it: Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh Ji has said that Kirtam Naam has the power to take one to Karam Khand. From there Guru Ji would bless the being into entering Saachkhand. Thus, you're correct in saying that only through Satguru Ji can one be allowed in Saachkhand. To reach, even, karam Khand it is difficult by reciting Kirtam naam alone, and not Satnaam. But when Guru does Kirpa for the love, faith and patience the being has shown Guru Ji will help and guide him in his own way. It could be by showing the being the path of Sikhi.

Re: Questions thrown at sikhs

Atma Singh · 19 Apr 2007

VahegurooJeeKaKhalsa,VahegurooJeeKeeFateh! Sadh Sangat Jee, The following Panktee should lay to rest whether 'Naam', according to the Gurmat perspective, is available from anywhere else apart from Gurmat. [gurbani]hir nwmu cyiq iPir pvih n jUnI ][/gurbani] harnaamchaethfirpavehinjoonee || Remembering the Lord's Name, one is not subject to reincarnation. [gurbani]gurmiqswruhornwmibhUnI ]20][/gurbani] guramath saar hor naam bihoonee ||20|| The Guru's Teachings are the most Excellent; all other ways lack the Naam, the Name of the Lord. ||20|| (Siree Guroo Nanak Sahib Jee, Raag Raamkalee, Ang 932) We must understand that Vaheguroo does not ignore sincere devotion through 'Kirtam Naam-Simran' whatever form it takes, but in order to achieve Sachkhand, one must go beyond Kirtam Naam... That is perhaps why Karam Khand is eternal yet those who inhabit it, although given immortality and brimful with Vaheguroo's love according to Jap Jee Sahib, have not actually reached Sachkhand. The final piece of the puzzle remains; they haven't received Gurmat Naam, yet Vaheguroo has obviously rewarded them greatly. Therefore, my understanding is that Kirtam Naam are merely descriptive names given to Vaheguroo by humans...sincere devotion using these can take one very far. However, 'Vaheguroo Gurmantar' is not merely a human-created 'descriptive name' but is actually much more...it is truly the 'Sat Naam' that Gurbanee refers to so often. In fact, my personal understanding is that within Mool Mantar, when we say Ik Onkaar, then Sat Naam, we are referring to the fact that The One Creator is The Sat Naam (i.e. Vaheguroo Gurmantar)...they are One and the Same. After Sat Naam, we say Karta Purakh i.e. Sat Naam is The Creative Entity/Energy which has established all Creation...i think i'm digressing now and putting-in too much of my own thoughts so i should stop! Gurmat Naam is most certainly The One Vibration, The Quintessence/The Tat, The One Wavelength through which Nirgun and Sargun Vaheguroo is manifest...and of even more concern to humans, It is the road to and from Nirgun Vaheguroo...all Creation i.e. all that exists in the form of 'vibrational wavelength', has emanted from the One Primal Vibration. Naam has created everything and is within everything, yet only humans can 'tune-in' to it and retrace that path...from their position as creations at a 'lower vibrational wavelength, straight back to The Primal Creator who resides infinitely, throughout and beyond creation, via the Primal Light and Vibrational aspects of Naam... To conclude, the Gursikh must come to accept with complete faith, even if it is 'complete blind faith' at first, the fact that Naam is the 'spiritual super-highway' established by Vaheguroo upon which we can travel if we receive such Kirpa. The Gurmukh eventually comes to KNOW that Naam and Vaheguroo are One and the same when their Dasam Duaar opens and the sham of I-amness (i.e. Hau-mai) finally leaves them. NOTE: My interpretation of Gurbanee may be at fault so please don't rely on the above as 'Gurmat fact'. [%sig%]

Re: Questions thrown at sikhs

Demonic Warrior · 19 Apr 2007

jassmannn, religions such as hinduism, Islam, Christianity etc, will lead that person that is true to any of those religions to Sikhi, in another life-time. Why? Well you told us that yourself that to be a 'good human being' and to 'have true love for god'. Through the Satguru this is possible. Without Satguru there is only darkness, since Satguru unlike the prophets became one with God. For example, the angel gabreial told Mohammed the teachings of Quran, and he, the angel, lives in the lowest of heavens from the seven. However, Saachkhand is above all the heavens Muslims, Hindus and Christians believe in. God could not create Sikhi before these religions since people were to corrupt at those times. So, God needed to give the people some level of good human understanding, whereby sending prophets to achieve his goal. How does one be a good human? First, we jap naam to be human and follow Guru Ji's teachings. Why do we recite God's name? Because God's name is the source of Everything - including TRUE LOVE, not what humans call love but true love. Through reciting God's name we can overcome MAYA, who has deluded nearly all of God's creation, as well as the 5 DEMONS, who also have nearly every being under their control. God's name is an instrument of love, fearlessness, knowledge and the ultimate Truth that like a magnet pulls us towards God, until we become one with him. Only through Sikhi can this be achieved. [%sig%]

Re: Questions thrown at sikhs

Demonic Warrior · 19 Apr 2007

'sy' Of course they existed, they even exist now. We're not the only beings that God created. He created numerious and various demons, gods, angels, dragons, ghosts, titans, witches, devils, spirits, goblins etc. The list goes on and on. This planet we live on is a heaven which goes in order from the highest of heavens. But only in this heaven can a human, the most blessed life, meet God through his name. The only differience between Human beings and the other supernatural beings is that we are created out of clay and the others fire. Therefore, we cannot see them or even our true selves; due to the sins we've committed we cannot see what we really look like underneath this body. Only Ghosts realise their mistake and sin. Hope that helped.

Re: Questions thrown at sikhs

sy · 20 Apr 2007

but how is that possible to believe in other gods. And how can we say each religion leeds to the same god when they believe in a different god, each religion conterdicts the next one, i mean why would god create religions that have heaven and hell and others that believe in re incarnation. I mean islam christianity juddism out of these three religions two of the three have to be wrong how can we say all three lead to god when they conterdict eachother. Were in the guru granth sahib does it acknowledge any of these gods exsisted.

Re: Questions thrown at sikhs

Demonic Warrior · 20 Apr 2007

'sy', Heavens, Hell and re-incarnation all exist that are temporarily, but these are only for manmukhs who are true to their religion. But, not for Gurmukhs. Gurmukhs will ascend well above these lowly attributes. None of these contradict, for example, someone who has been true to their religion will be told by Dharam Rai that he/she may enter heaven but will have to be punished in hell for a sin committed. But after both, he will have to come back onto earth probably as a human to lead another good life which will eventually lead to a life and to the religion Sikhi. Although, another being that has sinned greatly will have to go to hell and then will have to go through the 8.4 billion life forms. God does this because he still loves his creation, that is why hell is temporarily and all being still obtain another chance by taking birth on earth. Oh yeh, and also if a being has a good heart but hates and envies others then he will have to be reborn as a demon in an underworld - there you go the existence of other beings. kee kott dhaev dhaanav ei(n)dhr sir shhathr || Many millions are the demi-gods, demons and Indras, under their regal canopies. This gurbani line has provided us with the fact that there are countless other beings such as demons and the hindu god, Indra that exist. Below, shows that heavens exist too: siv puree breham ei(n)dhr puree nihachal ko thhaao naahi || The realm of Shiva, the realms of Brahma and Indra as well - no place anywhere is permanent. Gurbani also talks of fourteen worlds, of these there are seven underworlds and seven heavens which make up fourteen. God created the hindu gods such as Vishnu to create the universe so that God would remain hidden from everyone. Throughout, the three ages - satyug, tretayug and dvapar - people were to meditate on Vishnu who represented God at that time. After, in Kalyug, the dark age, which is now God showed himself through prophets by giving them a small portion of divine knowledge, not the complete knowledge that Guru Ji was given, by becoming one with God, whereas the prophets hadn't. God probably did this to give humans some understanding of good human behaviour, as people at those times were too corrupt. You know if you want the complete package of truth and knowledge you could just jap an immense amount of Naam.

Re: Questions thrown at sikhs

sy · 20 Apr 2007

demonic warrior thanks for taking the time to answer my questions, ok now this confuses me if sikhs believe in hindu gods doesn't it make sikhism kind of part of hinduism, as well it is still imposible for all religions to exsist and be a way to god in their own way for example christianity and islam one believes jesus was god and the other believes he was a prophet showing that one of these two religions has to be wrong and man made at certain points showing that anything that religion claims can't be taken at truth since their is no credibility.

Re: Questions thrown at sikhs

dalbir123 · 20 Apr 2007

Sy, your reasons for being confused is justified and is welcome. Your confusion will bring you thirst to find out the answers you look for. Firstly , remember only a fool closes his eyes to the truth or denys it, which we all have got in a habit of doing . We were all Hindus/ Muslim before we became sikhs, Our generation and maybe two or three before us were born sikhs, before that we all converted or as i like to call it evolved. A Guru cannot enlighten or show someone a better paath if the sikh/sishiya could not relate to what the guru says or does. So the prevailing religions of that time were used to... explain, to communicate , to bring about relationships and then the new paath was disclosed. The Gurus took the best out of all the prevailing religions. And did not proclaim that what they felt was good was there's , they were beyond how we all could ever imagine or think. They gave due respect and even had greatness to include the bani / verses of other saints who did believe in the devtas , devis , others who believed in sufism and spirituality and gave you choices. Then took all that and composed it into raags (music). Our prevailing Guru and takes you on a journey through Durga, Vishnu, Brahma but with a seperate destination. And that is the only way to become like " Nanak" is to be like him , and the only way is .... naam simran. Like the human race we all have evolved from the caveman to what we are now, so it is in religion. We do come from the Hindu or some of us from Islam, but we were to become the greatest religion because we were to have such heart that we could consume every religion and maintain our own identity. It took nine gurus to first change our way of thinking, it did not happen over night. And it took one, our Tenth Guru, to finally give us our seperate identity , the Khalsa. Guru Gobind too mentions Durga, Kali, Shiva, Vishnu etc in his granths.. So does not mean we necessarily believe in them, he has told us a story of where we did come from till we evolved. It is no big deal... The Big deal is that what the guru granth sahib says from the first page to the last, that "NAAM" di kamai is what we are to do , walking , working, playing ,we are to remember him, by whatever name you may know him as, it does not matter. There is a lot common in all religions because the subject is the same, Ik Om Kar (the " One God "). By showing respect to the devtas , hindu gods, does not mean we accept them as ours nor do we deny them, it should not be an issue. The issue is your own purity as a Khalsa and if you are able to obey what the Gurus say about naam simran in praise of the one and only akal purkh, you can do no wrong, you can do no harm, you can do no injustice... We all are more worried about looking like sikhs than becoming one... I hope this helped a little.... [%sig%]

Re: Questions thrown at sikhs

Demonic Warrior · 21 Apr 2007

sy, 'sikhs believe in hindu gods doesn't it make sikhism kind of part of hinduism' Sikhs know that Hindu gods existed but we do not worship them, whereas Hindues do. Also, its the other way around, every religion has small fragments of truth that which are apart of Sikhi; God took small amount of truth from Sikhi and turned that much into another religion such as Islam or Chirstianity. 'as well it is still imposible for all religions to exsist and be a way to god in their own way for example christianity and islam one believes jesus was god and the other believes he was a prophet' You are correct when you say that the religions could be man-made but only to the extent that man could have added a few teachings of their own. For example, Mohammed did not write the Quran, his followers did. Jesus did not write the Bible, again, his followers did by listening to his teachings. Thus, the followers could have added wrong, meaningless teachings to the holy books so that others believed what their weak minds believed in. This is the flaw of humans. One more thing to clarify: Jesus was not God but just a messanger. Baba Harnaam Singh Ji has had a spiritual discussion with Jesus, Moses and Mohammed. They all said the same thing, that they want all their followers to become Sikhs. Hope that helped.

Re: Questions thrown at sikhs

Man Singh · 21 Apr 2007

SY confusion is for those who never went ahead on path of sprituality and never think rationally. Foundation of all religions is same and that is humanity having 10 characterstics ie Daya(Kindness), Dhriti(Courage), Khsama(Forgiveness), shoch(Purity), asteya(Not stealing), dama(control of mind), Satya(Truth), Dhee Vidya(Intellectual knowledge), Akrodh(Free from anger) , Indriya nigrah(control on senses and passion). These principles are universal to all religions and different great people Grurs , prophets avatars or whatever you call them establihsed methodology to inject these human values in the society. These methods (panths) seems to be different due to socio economic and georgraphical background of the founders of the Panths. This universal thread makes all religions same being the same final outcome while makes them unique as well due to method used to inject these values are diffenert. Therefore Sikhi is unique in spite of its similarity in many ways with vaishnavism, shaivism, saaktism etc (Hinduism is not a rleigion at all, it is false hood. Hindus means people living beyond Sindhu). Similarly there are many similarities between Judaism, Islam and christianity. It is upto individual if they consider these three semetic religion as part of Judaism due to many similarities or separate. same way it is upto individual to see unity or separatims between religion of Indian origin like Budhism jainism and sikhism and many more togather foolsihly called Hinduism. But if you go deeper inside any rleigion you will find these 10 fundamental universal principels and if someone adopts them he will reach God ir liberated. Those who adopt them partially with a desire of heaven or any worldly benefit they will get worldly benefit. But Mukti comes only if we merge with God and Sikhism stands for this. Others Devas fulfil your worldly desires and hence for seekers of liberation, Sikhi is unique way. Even in Bhagwadgeeta Lord Krishna says the same thing that if you worship devas you will reach devas and will come back. If your worship HIM you will get liberated. He very clearly showed his viratroop `HIM" ie Kaaloasmi means I am Akaal Purakh in reality and is supreme personality of Godhead. Sikhi also recommends not to worship these devas as they are temporary and not able to give Mokhsa. To get Moksha worship akal Purakh the supreme personality of Godhead. If you are not interested in Mukti and looking for temporary worldly pleasures , then Sikhi is not for you. Go for devas and enjoy the fruits and enjoy the pains associated with pleasures of thse temporary fruits. Bhul Chuk Maaf

Re: Questions thrown at sikhs

Khalsaspirit · 23 Apr 2007

Waheguru ji ka khalsa, Waheguru ji ki fateh Khalsa jio, According to Bhai Sahib Bhai Gurdass ji [gurbani] mwirAw is`kw jgq ivc nwnk inrml pMQ clwXw] [/gurbani] In the world, Nanak established the authority, devoid of any impurity (niramal panth). and further Gurbani states [gurbani] nw hm ihMdU n muslmwn ] Alh rwm ky ipMfu prwn ]4] [/gurbani] I am not a Hindu, nor am I a Muslim. My body and breath of life belong to Allah - to Raam - the God of both. ||4|| Now what Guru Nanak Dev ji brought special to this jagat, the only important thing [gurbani]nwnk kY Gir kyvl nwmu ]4]4] [/gurbani] Nanak's home is only filled with the Naam, the Name of the God. ||4||4|| With above briefing it is clear the purpose, aim and uniqueness of Sikhism. Guru Mehar Karay Waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh [%sig%]