Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Vaisakhi event marred by violence

Vaisakhi event marred by violence

gb2000 · 23 Apr 2007

http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/england/west_midlands/6582373.stm

Re: Vaisakhi event marred by violence

Seeker of the Truth · 23 Apr 2007

It is sad to hear grown men (not kids) fighting each other. This is sick and the Sikh community in the UK should feel ashamed at those men who prolly give rest of the Sikh a bad rep. in the UK.

Re: Vaisakhi event marred by violence

sloughsingh · 23 Apr 2007

I hate to say it but i am ashamed of the punjabi community that i belong to and will probably avoid vaisakhi parades in the future...........they are more akin to an orangeman march in northern ireland than the experience during Bhai Randhir Singh's time.........the word sikh has to be seperated from events and incidents that involve punjabis, all punjabi culture means to me is plenty of meat and sharab at weddings.....please from now on correct people when they use the term 'sikh weddings' when they talk about the amazing amounts of free booze on offer and tell them it was a traditional punjabi wedding void of sikh traditions.

Re: Vaisakhi event marred by violence

Man Singh · 23 Apr 2007

I read many places that Punjabi culture in India is being spoiled by crooked Brahmins and Hindu organisations by supplying plenty of wine to rural punjab and Sikh youth is being spoiled out of it. I am curious to see whom to blame these Europeans or America Sikhs merged in Sharab and kebab. can we find some other scapegoats to blame with for non Indian sikh community? Truth is that we can not generalsie any community good or bad. Every community has good or bad people in it. Even among Brahmins there are good people and bad people. Therefore let's keep on improving ourslef internally aswell externally. protect from outside attacks and strenthen from inside to face the attacks. Sprituality is the only answer.

Re: Vaisakhi event marred by violence

abc2 · 23 Apr 2007

Man Singh the situation in this case is not transparent, and it seems unlikely that this violence took place on the spur of the moment, unpremeditated. It is a serious and unusual incident - not typical of the Vaisakhi melas in the UK which are almost 100% remarkably peaceable (much more so than sports gatherings for instance). So NO conclusions can be drawn from this. In every case, for violence to take place there has to be an aggressor. Sometimes there is an aggressor and a defender, but it's unusual for there to be 2 aggressive parties. All that's needed, to create an incident like this, is 1 aggressive party and not 2. You state that every community has good and bad people within it, but all that's needed to cause trouble is some "bad" people. What you're saying is that there is no white and black - only shades of grey. I disagree: there are absolutes and therefore there are innocents and victims. No conclusions can be drawn from this atypical one-off incident with unique causes giving rise to it. There is no pattern of behaviour to address here.

Re: Vaisakhi event marred by violence

kulsingh5 · 23 Apr 2007

Thats the way man singh. [%sig%]

Re: Vaisakhi event marred by violence

jassmannn · 24 Apr 2007

abc2, I disagree with you. Everything is a shade of grey. There can never be black and white. This is not the first time there has been trouble at melas. It always happens. I lived in Birmingham all my life, before I come to London a few years ago. It's not usually on this scale, but there are always a few scuffles every year. Even the police have said that if the sikhs want a nagar kirtan, they can pay for security themselves, because there is always trouble. Hsve we forgotten about the violence when that play was being held at the hippodrome. There is always something. The sikhs were supposed to be the tolerant and more integrated, but it seems, those who call themselves sikhs, are just a joke.

Re: Vaisakhi event marred by violence

Dalbiri · 24 Apr 2007

Well said Abc.

Re: Vaisakhi event marred by violence

abc2 · 24 Apr 2007

Jassmann we do not control the media: the reporting of Behzti (a very offensive play seemingly designed to hurt Sikh sentiments) was highly sensationalized and one-sided. Indeed, it would seem that Behzti was a play enacted in full by the media: they set up the scene and made the entire nation the audience. This had the effect of terrorising anyone who dared to raise their voice or a placard against the literal "Behzti" symbolic violence against Guru. The targets in this elaborate frame-up were not just the Sikh community but the entire nation. The entire nation was terrorised by the news reporting (the news just repeated what the police and other agents of government were saying, and ignored all the preceding peaceful campaigning to stop the play). The whole goal was to show: there is nobody and nothing off-limits to the government of this land. And the way things were in the past (multiculturalism and religious tolerance) is coming to an end. Events that happen in the real world are not art, and cannot be depicted with the postmodern ("everything is shades of grey", "there is no truth only versions") art brush. When the reporting is not fair and balanced, truth is the victim. Unfortunately with events that are newsworthy, the background is completely ignored and the police and agents of government take full control of the media to PUSH THEIR OWN AGENDA (which is basically anti-religion, anti-religious-rights, pro-New World Order). Just taking this latest incident as an example, you have dozens of news agencies, some of them sending a reporter. The police close the mela and the Park, and send everyone home. The reporters can't enter the park during or immediately after the trouble. So where does ALL the news come from? The police who TELL the reporters what's what, who was injured, how many people were involved, when and where, etc. Thus you have 6 or 7 major news stories, all merely REPEATING the police's version of events, using different word order and vocab to repeat exactly the same CAREFULLY CHOSEN details (with careful omissions too). What does Joe Public think, reading his chosen newspaper or watching his chosen TV channel? EXACTLY whatever the government wants him to think. After all, he's chosen the newspaper or TV channel he thinks he can trust. In this case, he is supposed to conclude that like always, the English police are just like Dixon of Dock Green and play fair play cricket, while the Sikhs are like bearded thugs who should not be allowed to carry (** SHOCK **) full-length kirpans in public. Considering this, who do you really think was the mastermind setting the match to the tinder in this incident? It's political stakes, and politics is the power game. A much set-upon minority is not the true culprit here, and doesn't play the UK power game because it doesn't have the numbers or the muscle. As for those "integrated" so-called Sikhs who have cut their hair and try their utmost to shed their heritage and traditions and to transform into the lowest class of English, they sometimes tend to conveniently overlook that the sun does not always shine out of the asking of English. Go to any football match and there will be a very heavy police presence (tasers, horses, riot shields and special ex-armed forces riot units) to stop them breaking out into mindless violence which they are OFTEN wont to do. Therefore, this is an unusual incident. Also, what do you call "trouble at melas"? A few scuffles? I think that hardly qualifies. If nobody was fighting but there had been some drunks falling over themselves, causing a nuisance and needing to be hauled away forcibly by your police, would that be classed a scuffle too? What about the same drunks being hauled off by some Singhs instead of the police? Does this become a scuffle now? In any public gathering, there are some outbreaks of violence. It's generally kept within acceptable limits if it's just a punch-up for instance between a small number of people. In this incident, there was Sikh security present, who were the agreed-upon "police" within the precincts of the Handsworth Park area. This had been agreed with the English Police. Why would they agree on this??? Because there are usually no serious (potentially lethal) acts of violence between Sikhs themselves AT VAISAKHI MELA. So, you see that according to their actions and words, the Police did not expect this incident. If they did expect something like this (as opposed to a few fists flying), they would not have allowed the Park to open on that day, or they would have used completely different football-stadium style policing in the grounds itself. The reason they did not, and allowed the Sikhs to police it themselves, is because any violence NEVER escalates to this level at UK Vaisakhi melas. Show me one similar incident at ANY UK Vaisakhi mela. What we're seeing here is someone else's carefully enacted master plan. We can all see that this incident was not entirely unexpected (to say the least), even as to exact time, date and location. To draw ANY conclusions from this very unusual one-off incident would be foolish, and to play the media-Behzti game on behalf of someone else.

Re: Vaisakhi event marred by violence

gb2000 · 24 Apr 2007

Jasmann, I was there on Sunday, granted not when the trouble occurred. And believe me it was difficult to find an amritdhari sikh. The main contingent were mone wearing 'khanda emblazoned head scarves'. I left with my family because I knew it was only a matter of time before it kicked off. When the AKJ have a keertan/reinsbhai you never get trouble, I wonder why ...... [%sig%]

Re: Vaisakhi event marred by violence

Man Singh · 24 Apr 2007

Criminals exist in society. No doubt about it. We have to put security and lock on our house. But this not enough. If by defying security somebody intrudes inside our house, we should have enough strength to defend ourselves. Both are required. Our own awareness and our own strenth. Those communities nations or individuals who are alert and plan these internal and external security live happily. Those who ignore and keep on blaming others for their ills will never improve or never be happy. Blaming others , demonising otehrs is fine upto a limit. But to solve the problem, action is required on internal and external fronts.

Re: Vaisakhi event marred by violence

abc2 · 24 Apr 2007

I wish to add that I will speak only the truth from my mouth, and I will not be a party to the crimes of others. In this case, I strongly suspect that the actors behind the scenes who chose to tacitly encourage criminality as and when it suited them, and to suppress the actions of religionists, are firmly in the Home Office/police ball court. I believe they knew what was going to happen (as did the rest of us), and let it go ahead. The timing for this was following a schedule in a much larger plan for domination and oppression of ethnic and religious minorities. In the Machiavellian school of thought, the governed must be punished and oppressed even if he is the perfect citizen, in order to preserve and exalt the Principality. The timetable has been set by some big players behind closed doors (Carlyle, Bilderberg, G8 and others), and is CONNECTED with this incident right here: http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/uk/6549515.stm http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/england/london/6547403.stm which those of us in the UK will know was immediately followed by a "special" news programme broadcast by BBC and presented by Ross Kemp, in which Mr Kemp interviewed the Home Secretary and invited him to talk about knife/gun crime in the black community, also inviting him to respond to the widely held belief (which I share) that the guns on the streets of London are there with the tacit complicity and assent of the Home Office (selective enforcement, combined with "black" covert ops running guns and drugs to undermine spiritual and political centres of communal power and strength as represented by the Rastafarian temple).

Re: Vaisakhi event marred by violence

sloughsingh · 24 Apr 2007

Chill out abc2....the UK...the british establishment are experts...don't try to beat them at there own game.............step 1 : GET OUT OF THE UK............step 2: WARN THOSE IN THE US AND CANADA THAT THE BRITISH ARE STILL IN CONTROL OVER THERE AS THEY ARE IN INDIA.......THEY NEVER LOST THEIR EMPIRES......WHY IS THE QUEENS HEAD STILL ON CANADIAN DOLLERS AND WHY DOES BUSHES BLOODLINE LEAD TO THE BRITISH ROYAL FAMILY???????????? step 3: GET NAAM, ITS LIKE GARLIC TO THESE VAMPIRES WHO IN THIER LUSTS FOR POWER BRING UTTER MISERY TO MANKIND.

Re: Vaisakhi event marred by violence

jassmannn · 25 Apr 2007

abc2 you have a very warped reality of how the media works and as far as I can see everything that happens anywhere, people like you turn into a conspiracy theory. If you have ever worked in a newsroom, you will better understand how the media works. They are a business and they will publish whatever sells. Which most of the time is anti government and anti Police. Pick up any national newspaper, and i'll show you several examples of where journalists, especially in this country are trying to get leeks to expose anything about the government and public bodies. Given that many amrit dharis may not have been involved, who ever did it, it was still a vaisakhi mela, which was marred by violence, and I have been seeing it for years. It was not staged, it was not planned it was just some idiots who got into a fight, which was more violent than isual. "(selective enforcement, combined with "black" covert ops running guns and drugs to undermine spiritual and political centres of communal power and strength as represented by the Rastafarian temple)." That is total rubbish. What will the home office achieve apart from more bad press. After everything that has leaked about that department, almost weekly, it is shocking that you hold such a view, which is unfounded and just feeds other people's thirst for a conspiracy theory. There will always be rascism, and prejudice, but to assume that all people, journalists, government officials and public servants are all planning and conspiring to bring down riligious groups is utter rubbish. I think you need to spend a day working in a government department, and you will better understand how they operate.

Re: Vaisakhi event marred by violence

kharkoo · 25 Apr 2007

The violence was over Smethwick Gurdwara Committee elections. The man stabbed was the ex President of the Gurdwara RS Pawar.

Re: Vaisakhi event marred by violence

abc2 · 25 Apr 2007

Sloughsingh I agree 100% with every word. I am relieved that others can see what's really going on, and what the only solution is.

Re: Vaisakhi event marred by violence

abc2 · 25 Apr 2007

Jassmann you can present any opinion you want (conspiracy theory - everyone go back to sleep - can't you do better than that?), but I will not be silent about the tactics used by the government of the UK. You would be surprised how many people are aware of the history of the British establishment and don't consider them an innocent third party in this and other matters pertaining to religious communities, but choose to remain silent. You stated: "it is shocking that you hold such a view" This is exactly the same turn of phrase used by the Home Secretary in the television documentary in response to the same question in that interview with Ross Kemp regarding the question of selective enforcement re: guns and drugs in the black community. It is therefore the OFFICIAL LINE. FYI (in case you didn't already know, which is a possibility given that this and other Sikh forums are being monitored by "relevant bodies" and nobody knows you here) I was a Home Office EO for almost 3 years. That's more than enough time keeping silent over the lies and political machinations that are behind EVERY decision they make and policy they adopt. The journalists and police personnel on the ground are not clued-in to the NWO schedule. They just do as they are told, and REPEAT what they are told. Thank you for demonstrating perfectly exactly how this works, in your responses in this thread. I have interceded here, and will continue to do so to make a point so that this kind of stunt is shown to serve nobody at all, even your government. I saw that you were trying to push an agenda, by putting a spin on the events that took place in Handsworth Park, and I refuted your assertion that there is an underlying problem in the Sikh community (which by inference would need addressing by more restrictive laws and oppressive attitudes to expressions of religion/multiculturalism). I did this via a detailed message, which has obviously made you annoyed and forced you to concede the point. I proved that this was a unique isolated incident with unique causes giving rise to it. It is not a common occurrence, and so NO CONCLUSIONS can be drawn, least of all more government interferece on carrying kirpans, etc. You will not use BLOOD to pursue a private agenda. I Will make sure of it.

Re: Vaisakhi event marred by violence

jassmannn · 26 Apr 2007

OK, I've still got contact with some journalists. You show my one email, document or anything that proves what you are saying, I will get it published. You did not prove it was an isoliated incident because I see fights at nearly every mela I go to. Have you ever been to Southall Mela? Birmingham is my home town and I have been going to the mela for years. Just give me one piece of official home office documentation, or give me the contact details for one emplyee who is willing to go on the record, even if it a Home Office email, I will publish it in a national paper about their stand on gun crime, multi culturalism, anything that you can prove. I suppose you think it's the Government which makes Gurdwara Commitees fight, and roudy young men cause trouble? I just think you are Barking up the wrong tree. Prove what you are saying, and I'll prove that I don't work for M15 or some government agency as you think and I will publish the evidence. Well?

Re: Vaisakhi event marred by violence

abc2 · 26 Apr 2007

Jassmann I'm going to wait until you've read my earlier message regarding "fights" and "scuffles" at Vaisakhi melas. You say there are attempted murders at these melas as opposed to punch-ups of the sort we might see at football matches? The onus is on you to prove it. Yes I have been to Southall mela. I've never seen anything at a level that perturbed me even slightly. Perhaps you're a bit more sensitive? There are pockets of trouble everywhere, especially at large gatherings. The normal reaction people have is just to move away from it, if it's nothing to do with them. The little skirmishes might be "fights", but they are never a wider public distudisturbance or involve pre-meditated lethal force between opposing factions (both of which are characteristics of the Handsworth incident). I have no smoking-gun evidence to prove beyond reasonable doubt that the government deliberately set the stage for the Handsworth Park mela incident, but the circumstantial evidence is, in my opinion, substantial. I stated that I had a "strong suspicion" that they deliberately set it up, and I am personally absolutely convinced. They hold the monopoly on violent force, and they employ this in order to achieve political ends. Divide and rule is the classic British tactic. I don't see why or how this is so surprising to you. As the earlier poster said, they are experts. If you want evidence for my claims about myself and my personal history, just drop me an email at [address removed]. I'm happy to do this, but I will tell you right from the start that the media is controlled by them, and nothing will come of this. I have my own plans, so thanks but you may see the evidence but I'm not interested in your offer to publish anything.

Re: Vaisakhi event marred by violence

jassmannn · 26 Apr 2007

Regardless if whether you want to call it a fight or a scuffle. It was a big gathering and people were taken to hospital. That's why the story got printed and publicsed, because there was a fight, not because the Governemtn are out to get us, or whatever it is you think they are doing. And you have just proven my point. I'm not going to take your word for it, I need documentary evidence that this so-called corrunption on the scale that you are talking about exists. If you don't have that evidence, then why are you making any accusation at all? It's the first mistake of a conspiracy theorist. Where's the evidence? It's very irresponsible, without evidence to accuse people of something you can't prove. Innocent until proven guilty! I hate it when people always play the 'I'm being opressed' and the race and religious cards when nothing has happened, when the Sikhs in the this country have enjoyed such priviledge. Oppression is in Zimbabwe, Sudan, Iraq, Palestine. Yous hould stand up for what you think is right, and protest it as well, that is the right that you have. However, misinformed theories that you are not able to substantiate is just pure theory. THe offer still stand if you come up with anything that you think is damning and I will personally ensure that it is printed.

Re: Vaisakhi event marred by violence

abc2 · 26 Apr 2007

You must learn to read, if you want to be a journalist. In what context did I bring up the subject of fights/scuffles? LEVEL OF SERIOUSNESS. For the fourth time, NOTHING this serious has happened before, so to hell with anyone's agenda. So we're not going to take this to email then with real identities etc. then? I thought you were going to prove to me that you were not an agent of the government. This is a Sikh forum. If you have been to Zimbabwe, Sudan, Iraq and Palestine you are more widely-travelled than I am. Otherwise we're still in the same boat of believing or not believing the outright lies and propaganda in the newspapers, etc. for whom the ONLY source is the government of the United Kingdom, and this isn't the right message board to propagate your tertiary source propaganda. What a pathetically weak "solution" you propose too!! Publish what I know and the information I have (including about the government's policy information regarding the countries you mentioned) just to get it in the newspaper for a day or 2! Which rag do you have influence over anyway? And what do YOU consider damning?? And why should I care? Don't you see how impotent that is. If you publish about this Handsworth incident, the main response from the public would be the one they (the government) desired and planned all along: more laws restricting gathering in the public places, more restriction on kirpan rights, etc. A New World Order agenda. Handsworth Park incident. This is what's damning: 1) The time and location and nature of the incident was widely published on the internet before it took place; 2) There were formal complaints to local police regarding Tari and Co. and their very serious crimes, which were NOT pursued and investigated; 3) Police stood around outside Handsworth Park and allowed cut-hair troublemakers free entry and did not enter the park during the critical episode of violence; 4) It was widely expected that there would be serious trouble at this mela, because of what had happened previously (Muslims were expected to attack people indiscriminately) but the authorities did not stop the mela from taking place. This is what I call SELECTIVE enforcement for a political end. Between the 2 UK Sikh groups who have been bickering over the past few years, we can see the same lack of action by the police despite serious violence and threats of violence. These kinds of incidents are in THEIR interest, just like the Behzti play and the response to it (all of it was 100% intentional - a setup/frameup like the Mohammed's cartoons in Europe). Of course, it's possible that none of this is a problem or a concern for you, because you are a clean-cut "secular" non-amritdhari uncle Tom who considers the UK cops higher than Guru Khalsa panth. I do believe you are here on behalf of the UK authorities to support their agenda (oh yeah I'm a conspiracy theorist sure - esp. if you didn't know that some members of Canadian sangat have already been investigated because of this message board), and I repeat I will not allow you to succeed.

Re: Vaisakhi event marred by violence

sloughsingh · 26 Apr 2007

Dear ABC2 ,I told you that you can not beat them at their own game but you have gone 1 further and decided you can second judge them ..........they don't have to do anything but sit back and wait for one little incident at the right place at the right time and it makes headlines just look at todays story on 1 indian out of billions who complains about richard geres kiss and the west makes a news day out of it.....what about thousands of sikhs (amritdharis) who were raped and murdered???? wheres their story???????????

Re: Vaisakhi event marred by violence

abc2 · 26 Apr 2007

Sloughsingh you're absolutely right. I've got a bit carried away about this. This incident doesn't deserve so much discussion and debate. If anyone wants to carry on the discussion privately then feel free to email, otherwise there's no more public statement from me about this incident.

Re: Vaisakhi event marred by violence

jassmannn · 27 Apr 2007

Well abc2, we will just have to agree to disagree. Yes I am a moderate, but I am not clean cut and have a dastaar and daara. But I live in a secular society. All Governments have a degree of corruption and the UK Government is no different. But to the degree you that you are proporting is silly. You may believe what you want and do whatever it is you have planning to intercede.

Re: Vaisakhi event marred by violence

Khatarnak Times · 27 Apr 2007

The British government had a very large empire that spanned the globe. To doubt that British are not capable of analyzing a culture and costructing policies to make sure that the people are under their control is simply an act of turning a blind eye to British History. They paid of the Dogra ministers. They recruited Sikhs to the army and made it manadatory that they be amritdhari AND have jaap sahib kunth. They exported opium into China to make sure that chances of ebelllion was minimal They took the best of their warriors (Sikhs) and invited them into England only because they feared the powers the Sikhs possessed and wanted to be able to control/guide the Sikh people The make a list showcasing British intelligence and political maneuvering and generaly treachery is easy enough. People will believe what they want regardless.

Re: Vaisakhi event marred by violence

kharkoo · 27 Apr 2007

What a strange twist this posting has taken!

Re: Vaisakhi event marred by violence

sloughsingh · 27 Apr 2007

Well maybe this 'strange twist' was for a reason because today on national government propaganda radio BBC2,which has a very important listenership in regards to demographics.It was reported on the news headlines that this weekends Vaisakhi event in wolverhampton has been canceled in response to fears of public safety by the gurdwara committies due to the stabbing at handsworth...............(a scuffle in the park and look at the BBC's major black op covering of the story spanning a week to the entire nation).....................now this is where you choose sides.......you either will continue to live in ignorance to this evil behind the scenes and wake up one morning and realise you can't wear your kirpan thus no longer be a sikh of the guru.....then you will wonder why you didn't see it coming......well it has been coming since 9/11.....but only now is there enough proof for me to never doubt this ever again.....so its up to you decide if you are comfortable that the queen will look after your rights to practise sikhi......think of 1947....you have been warned!