Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

A picture paints a thousand words

A picture paints a thousand words

sloughsingh · 01 May 2007

In todays world an image can give a very misleading message to many people of another faith ........check this link and tell me if it is more in line with the images shown of young kids in hizbollah martyr dress or the punj pyara that we have grown to know leading the procession.... http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/in_pictures/6611499.stm

Re: A picture paints a thousand words

Kulbir Singh · 02 May 2007

Because of ignorance of others, we cannot change our traditions. The option of not dressing like this is not on the table. What we can do is to educate ignorant people of other faiths. [%sig%]

Re: A picture paints a thousand words

sloughsingh · 02 May 2007

Sorry Kulbir Singh, what I meant was not their appearance in reference to bana, but that normally we see elder punj pyara walking very solemnly but in this image they have caught their young 'impressionable' faces as if they are giving a war cry and are thinking of violence?????? maybe someone like Atma Singh could comment from a photographers point of view of what the photo is trying to express about the subject matter or any hidden agenda such as showing Sikh children being indoctrinated in a faith based on martial violence....this is obviously not my opinion but what the photo might be expressing to others who as you are right to say are ignorant but I feel the media plays upon this ignorance to further their agendas.

Re: A picture paints a thousand words

sloughsingh · 02 May 2007

this image from the same source (bbc) shown the next day gives a different message, http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/in_pictures/6615965.stm , this one portrays innoncence and non-violence and no hot headedness or fanaticism , sikh ideals are under attack by the world governments,the ideas of using force against tyranny by sikhs is nothing more than a terrorist act as far as they are all concerned.

Re: A picture paints a thousand words

abc2 · 02 May 2007

Sloughsingh once again I must express my respect and gratitude that people are at last waking up to what's really going on (and has been going on with increasing intensity for centuries). http://en.wikipedia.org/Wiki/Psychological_operations With regard to Sikhs, the whole of rural India including the Punjab where Sikhs are to be found, is being placed under enormous pressure by forces intent on killing off regional identities and basically enslaving the entire population of 500 million (to transform the Indian economy from agrarian to industry cheap-labour Taiwan-style), because India never obtained "Independence" and has been under the direct control of the United Kingdom and the United States since 1947.

Re: A picture paints a thousand words

Atma Singh · 03 May 2007

VahegurooJeeKaKhalsa,VahegurooJeeKeeFateh! 'sloughsingh' Jee, i had a look at the first link (image of young boys/Panj Piyarae) but the second link displays a non-Sikhee related image. Here's what i think about the image from a photographer's point of view: Firstly we have to accept that people dressed in Bana and holding Kirpaans is a typical aspect present within Vasaikhee celebrations, and a very prominent one. Therefore by presenting this image i don't think the photographer has magnified an issue disproportionately. In terms of a preferred reading of the image (i.e. what the photographer may be trying to 'make us think'), this is much trickier. Some could argue that 'devotion' comes across. Hands are clasped together and the camera angle is neutral so neither are we looking down upon them (i.e. in a position of judgement) or neither are we looking up at them too much (i.e. in a position of sub-ordinancy). In other words, the viewer shouldn't really feel threatened at all but is left just to observe. It's also worth noting that the boys are not looking directly at the camera in a confrontational manner. The juxtaposition the image presents, 'young boys dressed as men holding big weapons', was what proabably led to the image being taken. That and the vivid colours. The caption is very respectful and in no way tries to highlight the 'boys holding weapons' as the central issue commanding this story. i think most people would see these as 'ceremonial swords' anyway - they probably perceive it all as people wearing 'costumes' holding 'cultural artefacts' on a 'religious day'. As Sikhs, it is natural for us to ponder over, and perhaps even worry about, the way we are portrayed by the media. However, we are also going to be much more sensitive when it comes to our reaction as a result - it is all so close to home. One image that i would say was captured and projected in a very inappropriate manner was that which was taken of our very own Balpreet Singh wearing his Kirpaan, during the rail-network legal issue. When i saw the image, it was clear to me that the photographer must have used a wide-angle lens, stood much lower than Balpreet Singh and very close to his Kirpaan. This led to the picture showing a 'towering Sikh', 'looking down' at viewers with a 'very large dagger' almost thrusting-out of the image. The angle and the manner in which it was taken meant that the size and shape of Balpreet Singh's Kirpaan was distorted and made to look much larger than it actually was. Given the nature of the story, this was irresponsible. It would naturally lead viewers to feel not only intimidated by Balpreet Singh but also by his 'massive dagger'. This was through no fault of his own but simply because the photographer obviously wanted something dramatic, challenging and above all controversial. Therefore, he used a particular technique to achieve this. One thing that i learnt during my brief days as a trainee journalist with the BBC is that journalists should never be trusted. This is because even if they want to truly understand the perspectives of people involved in their stories, editors who are the true gate-keepers are usually much more interested in creating a reaction amongst their readers/viewers/listeners. It's a numbers game - agree with or compound what most of your customers already believe and you can guarantee adequate success. One thing that Sikhs can do is exploit the natural state of the worldwide media - which is a state of radical pluralism i.e. there are many outlets, sources, channels, methods etc. Media consumption therefore takes place in a diverse way; we consume so much from so many perspectives. We Sikhs simply have to put our 'stories' out there which if done successfully will provide an offset to any 'negative stories'. However, to think globally but act locally is truly the way to go. Jagdeesh Singh from Slough has realised this lesson excellently; many Sikhs may have laughed when via SCAN (Sikh Community Action Network) he offered cash rewards for those who could help identify perpetrators of crimes against animals. A dog which was hurled down from a block of flats is one example. A donation to a sanctuary for injured swans was also made. Most importantly, as a sincere animal-lover, his approach was full of honesty which came across and coupled with the fact that English people are perhaps the biggest pet-lovers, the local coverage generated could only have helped Sikhs. English readers, even if they may have been the type wary of 'turbans and beards' were confronted by a Sikh who probably cares more about animals than they ever will, so much so, that he is willing to put money behind his conviction. Their hearts can only warm to such stories. Another Sikh in Slough who works for the council has managed to convince several of his non-Sikh co-workers to help him feed homeless people during the weekend. This story too shows that Sikhs are more than 'Bin-Laden look-alikes' and care about the community around them, be it Sikh or non-Sikh. This contrasts with the way that the media present extremist Muslims as people who live here but want to 'kill or convert everyone' while they enjoy the good-will of the British people. These kind of local, high-impact, grass-roots approaches should be used by Sikhs to change the way local populations perceive them. There is no need for rocket-science approaches; change the people who come in contact with you in your local town/city - if everyone does this, the world will change. Always remember that The Khalsa never changes because it has been minted in the very image of perfection. Therefore, The Khalsa is meant to change those who come into contact with it. i truly believe that if we acted like this, whilst Japping Naam, keeping Rehat and wearing Bana (the latter which would actually almost have a 'brand-effect'!), there would come a day where most non-Sikhs would look to us as they did to police officers until relatively recently - people in commanding uniforms, to be admired, listened to and respected...a brand of people who are aloof from the world yet full of love and selflessness towards it. May Maharaaj Jee bless and forgive us, who are full of so many faults and lapses. [%sig%]

Re: A picture paints a thousand words

Khalsaspirit · 03 May 2007

Waheguru ji ka khalsa, Waheguru ji ki fateh Bhai Atma Singh jio, Very good observation of the picture and Psychic of Sikhs living abroad. Although those Sikhs of Slough tried there best to explain Sikhs identity but unfortunately Sikhs at large are not aware of Sikhi either so they can not even think of those small efforts can make a big difference. We would like to share our personal experience, one of khlasaspirit.com member while serving in Gurudwara committee in United States advised committee members that the town where Gurudwara is situated has many other churches who Co-run a community program called "WE FEED" for hungers or home less people and being Sikh we should join this program and it is not expensive either if we save a bit from our langer we can make a big difference in that town's community which is very crucial post 9/11 but instead of listening to this Singh they went against him stating we have no fund for extra expenditure. When this Singh argued that this is not extra expenditure we can save from the wastage of our Langer (even saving few paper paltes , cups) which we throw in garbage any way and just ask sangat to make less items in Langer and save (beans vegitables, salad etc) for this cause. Anyway because of lack of education and Sikhi big arguments started then this Singh had no choice but to keep quite and this is what happening across the nation the Singhs who have vision they are trying hard to interact with other communities by any good means but the system which established by our Guru Sahib for noble cause, The Gurudwaras which by act of modern day committees is becoming hurdle for these efforts. And we all know the momentum of contribution to society is always huge if done at Gurudwara platform than at an individual level. Anyway some thing is better than nothing. Guru kay piyare are out there and they are doing there best. Seeking help from Gurudwara committees seems waste of time and energy. All they have is “WE EAT” program and thats all they do in Gurudwara and you can become part of it very easily. Again, good post by bhai Atma Singh ji. Guru Mehar karay Waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh [%sig%]

Re: A picture paints a thousand words

Harjas Kaur · 04 May 2007

The kids look beautiful. Very chardikala. Who cares what the media thinks! [%sig%]

Re: A picture paints a thousand words

Sitara · 04 May 2007

So does this mean that the poster on here will reprimand poster like Harjaas Kaur who continually post pictures of RSS/Bajrang Dal etc etc with the attempt of influencing impressionable minds that Hindus are fundamentalist mobsters intent on destroying other people

Re: A picture paints a thousand words

sloughsingh · 04 May 2007

everyone has lost the point on what i was trying to say...there is nothing wrong with the image but for the purpose of mind manipulation say for example conveying the required impression to the mass population who know nothing about what sikhs are about, this was a very cleverly selected photo especially in juxtposition with the buddhist kids photo remember public perceptions are shaped by the media very slowly and cleverly at the subconcious level of the mind...remember this is the BBC, the state broadcaster......anyway aren't the punj payre mean't to be baptised sikhs who can give amrit baptism???????????

Re: A picture paints a thousand words

Harjas Kaur · 04 May 2007

[quote]So does this mean that the poster on here will reprimand poster like Harjaas Kaur who continually post pictures of RSS/Bajrang Dal etc etc with the attempt of influencing impressionable minds that Hindus are fundamentalist mobsters intent on destroying other people[/quote] Why should I be reprimanded for warning my brothers and sisters of dangers to the Panth? That is, after all, my obligation as a Sikh. This is a Sikh website. And what has this to do with beautiful photo of Sikh boys which I do praise? RSS is about Hindutva politics, and in every post I have taken care not to implicate Vedantic religion but the politics. So you lie in my name that I slander Hindus when I do not. RSS/Bjarang Dal are not innocent. And Sikhs should know their enemies. Hindutva is the enemy of Sikh sovereignty! Here, this is no propaganda. Watch the leaders of RSS based VHP and Bajrang Dal for yourselves and form your own intelligent opinions. if they look bad, then they make themselves look bad. Just listen to them, it says everything. Sadhvi Rithambara http://video.google.com/videoplay?docid=-8817218285615987893&q=VHP&hl=en Acharya Dharmendra http://video.google.com/videoplay?docid=7987487391206129272&q=VHP&hl=en From the Bajrang Dal Website Hinduunity (in their own words): [quote]4. HinduUnity.org presents this Hindu agenda before the political parties to salvage Bharat and Hindu Nation unfortunately surrounded by inimical forces and innumerable difficulties to ensure just human rights to the vast community of 80 crores in their homeland. It is the duty of every political party in the country to promise to safeguard the interests of the national mainstream, i.e., Hindu Samaj (Sanaatan, Boudha, Jain, Sikh Panths, etc.) 21. Mother tongue will invariably be the medium of primary education. 22. Teaching of Bharatiya culture and Dharma will be made compulsory. 34. Terrorist and anti-national activities will be ruthlessly crushed by appropriate legal provisions. Who in your opinion should rule India today? The perfect man for this job is Shri Bala Thackeray of Shiv Sena or perhaps Shri Narendra Modi (BJP) who have displayed a true dedication to the Hindu cause. (Of Gujarat riots fame) Are you not flooding the minds of young Hindu youth to become violent in nature against all other religions? Absolutely not. Our policy is simple. Don't mess with Hinduism, its followers and our mother land of India or we'll mess with you. Hindu youths need to know the truth like it is. If they don't take a stand now, their children will be going to Mosques and Churches within no time. They will loose everything Hindu in them. Nahi naam or nishan! Hindu youths must learn to be proud of being Hindus. They must stand tall and ready to deal with the nuisances that hinders the progress of Hinduism and Hindustan! What is this Soldiers of Hindutva group? Young, strong and fearless group of Hindus who are willing to die for the cause of Hindutva. The protectors of the faith! What is HinduUnity.org's future plans? Muslims talk of liberating Kashmir. We intend to liberate our Bharat which includes Jammu and Kashmir and the rest of India. Let it also be known that India will not loose anymore land. There will be no partition or separate states created to suit minorities. India will remain a union or blood shed will be inevitable. [/quote] So in their own words, what does this say about the future of Khalistan? [%sig%]

Re: A picture paints a thousand words

sloughsingh · 05 May 2007

Dear Harjas Kaur......the point of this thread was not to say the photo of the kids should not be shown or that it is inappropiate in anyway but it was to show how a british government media organisation is making its move on the sikh religion i have posted about the major broadcasting by the BBC on the Vaisaki stabbing......soon as the wearing of the kirpan is outlawed then you can tell me "The kids look beautiful. Very chardikala. Who cares what the media thinks!" ....the BBC aren't there to entertain...they don't run a world service to be helpful...they are there as a propaganda and mass mind manipulation tool....HinduUnity.org's doings towards sikhs is in your face and so bloody obvious that you would have to be blind not to notice and thus it is easier for people like you to fight against it.......but what if the enemy is so clever that not even you can spot it....then it will carry on until it is to late..........ever wonder how Hitler got to do what he did....he tip toed to it until it was to late for anyone to stop him.....like the jews in nazi germany when will you wake up to what is about to happen to the practise of sikhisim in its one and only true form in europe????? think this is conspiracy then think back to the singhs back in the times of the british raj and how they were to be admired because they had kumai unlike todays sikh community all around the world so if back then the british saw real supernatural power in the sikhs and wanted to destroy something so good to mankind then why would they still not have that same policy today as to make sure it never rekindles that fire again amongst the sikh community????.......you have to remember this is to do with bloodlines that have ruled this earth for thousands of years and yes britian in Iraq is not some mistake or accident that they got caught up in while on a jolly,all 42 presidents of the USA have belonged to a secret society called skull and bones you can see news reels of bush and kerry admitting to their membership on news reports on you tube and this all links back to freemasonary that in the higher ranks delves into mystical practices including black magic.....if you think this is all nonsense then how can you be a supporter of sikh ideals which only cares about truth and how our gurus stood up to the tyrannts who lived off the blood and sweat of the masses ? think of the banking system and globalisation and its effect on poor indians and chinese, .......the human race is in the process of being enslaved by world government.

Re: A picture paints a thousand words

maha_moorakh · 05 May 2007

"e intend to liberate our Bharat which includes Jammu and Kashmir and the rest of India." hey, no one can touch jammu its a very special place :-)

Re: A picture paints a thousand words

kulsingh5 · 05 May 2007

Harjas Kaur I have been reading through several topics on this forum and many of your answers belong on blaming the Hindus. I like to point out that we are all part of the same dharma, the Sanathan Dhram. This dhram in the past extended from Japan to all the way to Middle East (this is before Islam). The meaning is very simple, there is one God and all mankind belongs to this one God. Over time people have changed this dhram to suit their own ways and make fit to profit them in any way. If you research Hindu dhram they also believe in one God. Talking about the Hindutva; they do not want loose land, they have lost too much after the independence. The land in true contrast belongs to the Hindus then the Muslims. The Muslims declared an Independent state and called it Pakistan, if I was an Indian (Hindu & Sikh) I would be angered and would not want the country to split even more. The creation of Khalisthan would be a complete joke, Sikh’s can’t take control of small Gurdwaras, how are they going to take care of a country? Can you answer this question? Faitha [%sig%]

Re: A picture paints a thousand words

Harjas Kaur · 05 May 2007

The Sikhs were genocidally butchered and our leadership all but decapitated by sanatan Hindutva treachery. Don't insult the Sikhs man. The reason the Panth is so divided now is because of being a minority in a treacherous Hindutva sea (pro-Hindu only). These tactics of divide and conquer are well written in the Laws of Manu. And that is why present-day Gurudwara management is a reflection of the greater crises. But our many hundreds of thousands of shaheeds which were ruthlessly tortured and butchered to suppress the Sikh Independance Movement will come back to us. They'll be reborn in our children, and in our children's children. And Sikhs WILL have an independant homeland. Sikhs are NOT part of larger Hindu dharam. We refuse to be assimilated into any sanatan Hindu dharam. We are Sikhs, independant, separate, our own unique, non-Hindu religion. And Khalistan will one day include everything you consider Bharat. Raj Kharega Khalsa! [%sig%]

Re: A picture paints a thousand words

Harjas Kaur · 05 May 2007

[quote]They are there as a propaganda and mass mind manipulation tool[/quote] Yes I agree with you veerji. But I was responding to other peoples comments also, not only your own. We can't really stop blatant propaganda against us. So my attitude is very in-your-face. When I got all kinds of harassment at this one job over keski, I wore the bigger and brighter. I don't know how else to respond to it. But definitely I don't advocate conformity, shame or any other buying into the prejudice. But yes, you are clearly right. It was a blatant propaganda point to discredit and make Sikh religion fit the stereotype of "terrorist."

Re: A picture paints a thousand words

sloughsingh · 18 May 2007

I am seriously thinking of getting rid of my liability of paying the BBC TV licence http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/in_pictures/6669351.stm

Re: A picture paints a thousand words

sloughsingh · 18 May 2007

sorry,please click on image no.7