Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

RSS calls Sikhism a separate religion in 'great Hindu samaj'

RSS calls Sikhism a separate religion in 'great Hindu samaj'

News · 02 May 2007

RSS calls Sikhism a separate religion in 'great Hindu samaj' PTI Wednesday, May 02, 2007 15:32 IST NEW DELHI: The Rashtriya Swayamsewak Sangh (RSS) has described the Sikh faith as a separate religion belonging to "one great Hindu samaj". In a view that may not go well with BJP's ally Akali Dal, the Sangh says it sees a "problem" if minorities assume a 'political' character. Spelling out its stand on minorities on its website rss.org under a mission header, it says it believes the Hindu Code Bill is applicable to Sikhs, Jains and Buddhists and that it should be applicable to all, including the Christians and the Muslims. "The RSS believes in the plural structure of society. Therefore, it recognises that there is bound to be a majority-minority syndrome, and hence each group, whether in the majority or minority, will have a distinct identity and distinct character," it says. But minorities, according to the Sangh, should restrain themselves from overstepping their basic character. "... the majority-minority distinctions must be restricted to the bases on which the minority character is sought to be claimed. ... the problem arises when a particular minority transgresses the basis of its minority character and assumes a political one." it says. In its stand on Sikhism, the Sangh has called it a separate religion but its followers part of Hindu samaj. "We regard the Sikh religion as a separate religion, but we regard the Sikh people as belonging to our samaj. When we say that they are a part of the one great Hindu Samaj, we do not deny the existence of their separate religion and separate beliefs. The Hindu samaj is a commonwealth of many religions," it says. The samaj, it adds, includes idol worshippers as well as those who oppose idol worship and those who accept the authority of the Vedas as well as those who do not. They are all included in the wider Hindu conceptualisation, the Sangh says. "Many Sikhs attend RSS Shakhas, but nobody is asked to remove his beard or his pugree (turban). The RSS will never try to obliterate the identity of the Sikhs. That will be against the very grain of the RSS," it says.

Re: RSS calls Sikhism a separate religion in 'great Hindu samaj'

ijs · 02 May 2007

actually speaking its not their fault but the fault of the sikhs who take part in shaakhas or are a part of shiv sena like in punjab...... one of our late relatives was a part of VHP and close associate of atal behari........... i see those guys doin bhetaas and lot of sikh guys goin to teeraths.... all this sorrily justifies these comments of rss and they cant be blamed majorly...... the same goes for guys supporting congress in elections in delhi........the man who stood for the gurdwara elections was busy with his family near the election booth helping the workers of congress............. inspite of all that has happened lot of us cant seem to get it in their head......

Re: RSS calls Sikhism a separate religion in 'great Hindu samaj'

A Singh · 03 May 2007

The RSS itself is confused. It does not know what to say. They cannot digest the success of the Gurus teaching, therefore find some excuss or the other to oppose it.

Re: RSS calls Sikhism a separate religion in 'great Hindu samaj'

Khatarnak Times · 03 May 2007

Ask the RSS to come up with a definition of a Hindu and they'll fail spectacularly. These people don't care about religion or truth, they're motivated by politics. Leave them to slowly chip away at the branch that is sustaining them. As Sikhs we should keep our mann clean.

Re: RSS calls Sikhism a separate religion in 'great Hindu samaj'

Kulbir Singh · 03 May 2007

I am of the opinion that actually all Hindus are destined to become Sikhs sooner or later. They are following the Dharma of Treta and Duapar yugs and the dharma of Kalyug is Gurmat i.e. to Japp the true Naam. jath sa(n)jam theerathh ounaa jugaa kaa dhharam hai kal mehi keerath har naamaa ||2|| Celibacy, self-discipline and pilgrimages were the essence of Dharma in those past ages; but in this Dark Age of Kali Yuga, the Praise of the Lord's Name is the essence of Dharma. ||2|| [%sig%]

Re: RSS calls Sikhism a separate religion in 'great Hindu samaj'

Khalsaspirit · 03 May 2007

Waheguru ji ka khalsa, Waheguru ji ki fateh, Khalsa jio, Agree with Bhai Kulbir Singh ji, we would further say that every one will become Sikh sooner or later because and there is no other Dharma in kuljug except Naam. Which is only achieved in Nanak's home. Also following is the information for those who say that every other dharma is equal to Sikhi or lead to same destination. Read the following what Guru Sahib has to say for those. [gurbani]iesu kiljug mih krm Drmu n koeI ] klI kw jnmu cMfwl kY Gir hoeI ] nwnk nwm ibnw ko mukiq n hoeI ]4]10]30][/gurbani] panna 161 And this whole shabad explain it in detail. Guru Mehar Karay Waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh [%sig%]

Re: RSS calls Sikhism a separate religion in 'great Hindu samaj'

Harinder Singh · 04 May 2007

The whole world is destined to be sikh and not just hindus. I feel Waheguru Himself in the form Guru Nanak Dev Ji Maharaj came to this part of world as people here had degenerated the most. But these poor bhaagheen people did not even spare Waheguru/Satguru. Satguru helped and saved them and in return these people became his enemies or supported his enemies and they continue to do this even today. I dont know whether all hindus will convert to sikhs or not but one thing is sure, the indian region is going see a terrible destrution and may be after that the remaining indians might become sikhs. Personally I will prefer goras becoming sikhs than hindus/indians. We already have large no of present sikh population from hindu background and they keep on following bipran ke reet even to this day. RAJ KAREGA KHALSA

Re: RSS calls Sikhism a separate religion in 'great Hindu samaj'

Harinder Singh · 04 May 2007

<> Veerji, Gurmat is nihchall, above time. Gurmat is the only dharam and is not just valid in kaliyug.Without Gurmat no one can reach Sachkhand and the dharams of treta and duapar were incomplete and limited to 3 maya gunns. The avtars of previous juggs like krishna themselves drowned in the world ocean, so how did common people could have crossed over. In kaliyug, Satguru Himself came to this world and reveled the True Complete Dharam. Matt ko bharam bhulle sansar, GUR BIN KOI NA UTRASS PAAR||

Re: RSS calls Sikhism a separate religion in 'great Hindu samaj'

Harjas Kaur · 09 May 2007

[quote]Hindus know that much better than any khalistanis like you who put abrahamic coating on the Gurubani and dirties it. [/quote] How dare you dirty the name of Gurbani by defending the RSS and insulting Khalistanis.

Re: RSS calls Sikhism a separate religion in 'great Hindu samaj'

Man Singh · 10 May 2007

RSS never said a single bad word to Sikhs in its 82 years of history. I am surprised why we need to react so negatively everytime RSS says something. If RSS says that Sikhs are brothers of Hindus and we all are like one family of religions of Indian origin just like judaism and Christianity call themselves Judeochristian civlisation. What's wrong in it? I have seen people penalising somebody fro their bad deeds. here is the case of punching RSS even for sweet friendly words coming from an organisation engaged in revitalising society on almost similar lines as great gurus did. I feel proud when yuoth from North east India or Andman Nikobar sing the songs of glorification of scarifices of great Gurus. Why people who are doing nothing to spread sikh values should feel jelosu out of it. Everybody wants to take shelter under big tree. Our great Gurus being the powerhouse of self confidence , courage and valour, if RSS guys take inspiration from them and talk respecatbly about them, inspire their followers in the name of Gurus, what's wrong in it? One more question: Do Sikhs have monopoly on great Gurus and Gurus teachings? Again as highlighted by bhai khatarnak times, Hindu word is difficult to define under current days of utter confusion among follwoers of people of Indian religions. Real definition of Hindu is people living beyong Sindhu river. When first used by Persians and Greeks, Sikhism and islam did not existed on this earth. Now its upto Sikhs and Muslims if they want to call themselves Hindus or not though theoretically any person living east to Sindh river is a Hindu. Bottomline is that Sikhs are part of Hindu samaj with different religion makes complete sense and has nothing offensive to Sikhism. I have seen many sikh preachers preaching that Sikhs consider whole humanity as one family as all of us have been created 1 kartapurakh. Does Hindus also are part of that humanity for us? RSS being organisation of Hindus loyal to India, will consider others as its family members as per its choice. Why we are reacting without using our minds only because media presents every word RSS speaks with salty and chilly. Please think again if there is anything offensive to Sikhi in RSS's statement before making such a hue and cry. I find nothing like that at least. I will appreciate if people highlight which words are offensive to sikhs and in what manner.

Re: RSS calls Sikhism a separate religion in 'great Hindu samaj'

Esher Singh · 11 May 2007

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh , Veer Man Singh Ji, << When first used by Persians and Greeks, Sikhism and islam did not existed on this earth. Now its upto Sikhs and Muslims if they want to call themselves Hindus or not though theoretically any person living east to Sindh river is a Hindu. >> This reply of your suggest that you do not look outside for knowledge but solely relies on the material supplied by organization like RSS etc. . They give this explanation like this " Persians called river Sindhu as Hindu due to difference in pronunciation " just like your post explains. But they fail to explain that the interpretation for the word Hindu is a corrupted version of Sindhu does not or fails to explain why the Sindhu River or the people who live in the valley of this river did not acquire the name ‘Hindu’. This river is called Sindhu and the people are called Punjabis and Sindhis. No body calls the state of Sindh as Hind or Sindhis as Hindis. There are some Indian writers who have looked at the word "Hindu" with critical eye and they does not agree with the interpretation what RSS people give. "The political situation of our country from centuries past, say 20-25 centuries has made it very difficult to understand the nature of this nation and its religion. The western scholars, and historians, too, have failed to trace the true name of this Brahmanland, a vast continent like country, and therefore, they have contended themselves by calling it by that meaningless term ‘Hindu’. This word, which is a foreign innovation, is not made use by any of our Sanskrit writers and revered Acharyas in their works. It seems that political power was responsible for insisting upon continuous use of the word Hindu. The word Hindu is found, of course, in Persian literature. Hindu-e-falak means ‘the black of the sky’ and ‘Saturn’. In the Arabic language Hind not Hindu means nation. It is shameful and ridiculous to have read all along in history that the name Hindu was given by the Persians to the people of our country when they landed on the sacred soil of Sindhu." (R. N. Suryanarayan, Universal Religion, p 1-2, published from Mysore in 1952.) " "Some people, according to the author, say that this word Hindu is a corrupt form of Sindhu but this is wrong because Sindhu was the name of the river and not the name of the community. Moreover, it is correct that this name has been given to the original Aryan race of the region by Muslim invaders to humiliate them. In Persian, says our author, the word means slave, and according to Islam, all those who did not embrace Islam were termed as slaves." (Maharishi Shri Dayanand Sarswati Aur Unka Kaam, edited by Lala Lajpat Rai, published from Lahore in 1898, in the chapter of introduction.) Besides, a Persian dictionary titled Lughet-e-Kishwari, published in Lucknow in 1964, gives the meaning of Hindu as ‘chore (thief), dakoo (dacoit), raahzan (waylayer), and ghulam (slave)’. Yet according to an other dictionary named Urdu-Feroze-ul-Laghat – part 1 (p 615), the meaning of the word Hindu is as under: In Turkish: chore, raahzan and lutera (looter). In Persian: ghulam, barda (obedient servant), sia faam (black color) and kaalaa (black). The hypothesis that Persians had difficulty in pronouncing Sindhu is baseless and preposterous. For example, how do the Persians who are Shia Muslims pronounce words like Shia, Sunni and Shariat, Siaysat,sifar? In Punjabi there are many, many words of Persian origin, which start with ‘s’ and ‘sh’. For example, sardar or sirdar (leader), shaheed (martyr), shhadat (martyrdom) shair (lion), sahir (town), sar (walk) shayer (poet), shakar (sugar), sja (punishment), siahi (black ink), siah (black) and so on. The word Punjab is also derived from Persian panch and aab (five waters). Veer Man Singh Ji , as you you have suggested that people living east of Sindhu river then can you explain why there is moutain range in Afghanistan that goes by the name "Hindu Kush" (in english it translates as "Killer of Hindus") valley and it is not in the east of Sindu river ? Hinduism is derived from the word Hindu, the names of the other three religions, Buddhism, Jainism and Sikhism founded on the Indian subcontinent are derived from Indian words with noble meanings: "Budh" (enlightenment), "Jan"[victorious (over vices)] and "Sikh" (learner), respectively. Does it make any sense for Indians who are never tired of talking about the glory of their past, their religion and their civilization to call themselves "Hindus" when this word is not found in any Hindu text. This label "Hindu" was given to the people of the Indian subcontinent by outsiders in the derogatory sense (black, slave, servant, thief, robber and waylayer), except the term "black". What right or justification do the champions of "Hindutva" have to apply this label to others, Sikhs, Jains and Buddhists?