Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Manmohan Singh

Manmohan Singh

sy · 10 May 2007

what is everyonce opinion of manmohan singh as a sikh prime minister of india and the job he has done so far.

Re: Manmohan Singh

Seeker of the Truth · 10 May 2007

Generally speaking, he is the right man to run India, but in sikh p.o.v, he hasn't done much for his community.

Re: Manmohan Singh

jassmannn · 11 May 2007

I think he has done a Brilliant job. Put Sikhs on the map and also the economy is doing great. A lot more still to do, but has done a lot more than the previous leader especially with the Pakistan-Indo realtions

Re: Manmohan Singh

hps · 16 May 2007

To me he is only a spokesperson of Sonia ji. Yes he has done some original thinking with P chitambaram.He has admitted publicly that he is not in religion. [%sig%]

Re: Manmohan Singh

SomeSingh · 16 May 2007

after the whitewash nanavati commissions report on the anti-sikh pogroms in 1984, manmohan released the 'action taken report'. this was basically a coverup that made it look like the government had taken some solid measures for positive change. he also resisted kicking mass killers out of the congress party, but eventually had to bow to increasing public pressure. he's a good leader of INDIA, a great economist, but in the end he is a sikh of the congress party first and foremost. Of course, as above posts have shown, there is a lot more good for our community with this PM than there has been with many previous PM's. So in conclusion, manmohan singh is mixed blessings for the sikh community.

Re: Manmohan Singh

hps · 16 May 2007

You may be right veer ji. But he has done nothing for sikhs ,atleast, so far. A general observation.He is old as well. 75+. [%sig%]

Re: Manmohan Singh

jassmannn · 17 May 2007

Some people seem to have a very limited understanding of what a politician, prime minister should do. As the Premier of India, his allegiance is with the people of the country, not to the religion. He can't show favouratism for the Sikhs; all are equal. We can't go in the country if we keep dragging up the past at every opportunity to make political gains. We have to u nderstand where we are now, where we want to go and the best way to get there. If Tony Blair has declared his religious convictions and made all his policies pro catholics and the church, just imagine the uproar. He has been a very savvy and smart politician. Politicians themselves may come to office with good intentions, where in fact it is the people, pur demands that turn a good intentioned MP bad. Think about it!!

Re: Manmohan Singh

Harjas Kaur · 17 May 2007

Well, all I can say about Manmohan Singh is...... thank Goodness for India it wasn't Sonia Gandhi. [%sig%]

Re: Manmohan Singh

SomeSingh · 17 May 2007

nobody here is saying that he should. but there is a need for honesty, integrity, and compensation and justice for sikhs who have been wronged in the past by the state and congress politicians. you think that by ignoring it (ie. saying don't drag up the past) such things can go away? how do you think it was possible for the Gujurat government to engineer the pogrom of over 2000 people and get reelected (not to mention to get away with it?) failed justice leads to future injustice. it must be dealt with. btw, i think it's pretty wrong of you to imply that sikhs shouldn't drag up the past. Have you ever had your relatives burned alive while the police stand by and watch, or actively help in the killing? I'm lucky enough that i haven't, but you (even if you have) have absolutely no right whatsoever to speak for Sikhs

Re: Manmohan Singh

jassmannn · 18 May 2007

Who said I was speaking for the Sikhs? This is a forum and I was giving my opinion. That's what forums are intended to do. I think you are little niave as to where the Hindi, Sikh policical saga stemmed and grew. Sikh's came off worse because we are a minority, and innocents did lose their lives. I'm not going to talk about it, because I know it will just go on forever and people will accuse me of being some undercover RSS member or something like that. Let's take a deep look at where we went wrong, and then understand the real reasons why some of the atrocities took place.