Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

hindu website attacking sikhs and khalistan

hindu website attacking sikhs and khalistan

khalistani · 16 May 2007

http://www.hinduunity.org/HinduUnity/viewtopic.php?t=1246

Re: hindu website attacking sikhs and khalistan

SomeSingh · 16 May 2007

it's an RSS website. there are tons of these. some other RSS fronts include india development and relief fund (IDRF), seva international, world hindu council, etc etc.

Re: hindu website attacking sikhs and khalistan

SikhBlood · 16 May 2007

They can attack us online, emails, msn, news, etc. I hope you get what i mean. [%sig%]

Re: hindu website attacking sikhs and khalistan

sidharth · 17 May 2007

khalistani - ummmm. what's wrong with this thread? there is not a single word against sikhs and as for khalistani's, what do you expect from us? hug them and give them sweets when the whole concept of khalistan is based on driving hindus out of punjab. sikhblood - no, i don't get what you mean. please explain, if you care to.

Re: hindu website attacking sikhs and khalistan

PTE SINGH · 27 May 2007

To be fair Ladies and Gents, I found nothing on that website that was any worse than the anti Hindu sentiment banded about on this forum. The comments however were distasteful and somewhat pointless. The reason that there will not be a Khalistan is because the vast majority of Sikhs do not want it and because it is not viable or desirable. Mr "Sikhblood", i don't know what you mean! but am sure that if you carry on in "shaheedi" mode, that Mi5 or the FBI will pop round to find out. I know retro 80's is in style now, but that extends to fashion and not politics.

Re: hindu website attacking sikhs and khalistan

Dalbiri · 27 May 2007

Chandra and Sidharth If you can't understand the natural impulse of a people to rule, govern and direct themselves, especially since they have already done this in the recent past, then you must have some sort of intelligence deficit.

Re: hindu website attacking sikhs and khalistan

Mystic Warrior · 27 May 2007

Maybe to some indivduals the concept of khalsitan is to drive out hindus, which is obviously a contridiction of Sikh teachings. If there is to be a Khalistan it should not be bound to a specific people but should be open to all regardless of religion, colour or caste and should be a country or a land free from corruption. Om, Amen, Sat Sri Akal, Allah -O- Akbar

Re: hindu website attacking sikhs and khalistan

Bachitar Singh · 27 May 2007

To PTE Singh: This is no anti-hindu website. The only anti-hindu sentiment has been presented by me. You have a problem with Sikhblood and his commando shaheedhi mode because your an idiot. Sikh Blood I like where you have your heart. Only a true sikh knows that the highest goal in sikhi is to become a shaheed. That they find sikhi so pyaaree that they are willing to die for it. To Sidharth: Why don't you ever be quite you uncle tom. The rest of you Khalistan Zindabad. Who said anything about driving hindus out of punjab? [%sig%]

Re: hindu website attacking sikhs and khalistan

SomeSingh · 28 May 2007

There was an investigation of IDRF conducted in the US, it proved that over 80% of their funding goes to hinduise tribal peoples etc. despite the fact that the charity claims to be secular. For a look at the insanity, power, and reach of the RSS look up the incident in Maharashtra where Shiv Sena went on a rampage attacking cops, busses, and shutting down markets, all b/c the statue of the party chief's wife was defaced!!! the governor, or was it CM, said to take it easy on them b/c it was understandable that they were angry!!! Their organisation skills are so superb that they flooded US government offices with phone calls and managed to successfully lobby the US government to NOT condemn the anti-muslim killing spree RSS conducted in Gujurat. I know all this b/c I've written a paper on these fascist hitler loving murder-justifying bastards.

Re: hindu website attacking sikhs and khalistan

PTE SINGH · 28 May 2007

Mr Bachitar Singh I don't recall saying that this was a anti hindu website, nor do i have a problem with Sikhblood, i only voiced concern that in the current climate this kind of retoric is detrimental to Sikhi in the view of most Sikhs and the wider world. However i do have a problem with you, hiding behind an e-mail address and calling me an idiot. I have alot more class than to personally insult any one, especially in a cowardly way such as this. I will point out that your goal of 'shaheedi' will be attained quite quickly if you were to develop the courage to be so insulting to a persons face. Regards

Re: hindu website attacking sikhs and khalistan

Harjas Kaur · 28 May 2007

Sikhblood is right. Shaheedi mode is the Sikh way! There WILL be a Khalistan and there WILL be a Khalsa Raj. Khalistan Zindabad! Dhan Dhan Shaheedi! Retro all the way back to Purataan Gursikhi! [%sig%]

Re: hindu website attacking sikhs and khalistan

vikram_bajwa1 · 29 May 2007

Waheguru ji ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh.. Well I dont think that I am intelligent enough to answer this, But still I will like to mention that no one who is a Sikh of the Great Guru Gobind Singh Ji can ever think to drive sommebody away from their Living place or even think about destablising somebody's livelihood just because the other person is from some other religion. Sikhism is based on Sewa (means helping others in the time of need irrespective of their caste and religion). And this Sewa is what we in this Global age know as "humanism". So who are we to fight on this issue when the Great Guru Gobind Singh ji himself sacrificed his Father " Guru Teg Bahadur Sahib Ji (Ninth Guru of Sikhs)" for the safety of Kashmiri Hindus from the tyrannous rule of Aurangzeb.. Well this is my answer to you Mr. Sidharth. ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ Bhul Chuk Maf karna Mera Mujh Mai Kich Nahee || Jo Kich Hai So Tera || Please rectify me if, because of my ignorance, I have said something wrong. [%sig%]

Re: hindu website attacking sikhs and khalistan

Bachitar Singh · 30 May 2007

PTE Singh come up with your own lines. I have been using that line since day one. The one where you are brave on a computer and in real life you are a coward. You say I am hiding behind an e-mail address. Do you want my house address. You are welcome to come to my house any day and continue this discussion. You call me an idiot and yes I am one, but you are the bigger idiot because you know I am an idiot and still want to continue this argument. Sarbat Khalsa has already declared Khalistan. Now you are either with us or get out of our way.

Re: hindu website attacking sikhs and khalistan

jassmannn · 30 May 2007

Well, this thread has taken a very bad turn hasn't it. Just for the record, we don't all want Khalistan, and Shaheedi is not the greatest thing a Sikh can achieve, it is the razaa and hukum of the guru, whatever that may be. Why are we all sitting outside of the country fighting for a Khalistan, when no one is moving back to get it. I think it would be a bad idea and I just do not think it is a viable option economically. Also, for a respectable forum, the kind of language and taount that is taking place is not appropriate for what this forum is supposed to be about. Discuss all issues by all mean, but respectfully. I can't see the signs of a unified punjabi sikh community, what chance would a united khalistan have.

Re: hindu website attacking sikhs and khalistan

khalistani · 30 May 2007

I read this one article talking about india having a sikh prime minister but yet the 84 riot victims still face abuse, were they have ppl come up to them and tell them the prime minister might be a singh but don't forget who owned you people and put you on the run.

Re: hindu website attacking sikhs and khalistan

PTE SINGH · 30 May 2007

Mr Bachitar Singh, You seem to attach a real importance to yourself! Do you really think that any body pays any attention to what "lines you use". I thought i was expressing my self in english not bachitarish. Please tell me where i can pay the royalties to that sentence you have invented. I don't recall calling you an idiot at all, it was you who chose to get personal. like i said in that mail (please re-read), i don't insult people behind an electronic veil. I don't remeber starting an argument or insulting any one, all i said was that you should be brave enough to dish out your insults to a man's face. As the couragous instigator of this 'argument' surely you should make the effort to come see me. Feel free to make an arrangment using my e-mail, Just don't make it Saturday, i have golf. [%sig%]

Re: hindu website attacking sikhs and khalistan

Shaheed · 30 May 2007

PTE Singh, I can see where you may anti hindu sentiments displayed on this site or amongst sikhs. However, you need to take this with a grain of salt; Sikhs as a people have gone through great atrosicties due to the leaders of India who happen to be hindu and put forth a majority hindu agenda before those of Indias minorities (Sikhs, Muslims, Jains, Christians, Buddhists). This much I would hope you would agree to as well. Therefore, it is impossible for many of us not to show favor to the declaration and establishment of a Sikh State. Now all you really stated that many Sikhs are not in favor of this Sikh state and I my self have encountered such opinions many times. I don't feel the need to be defensive about it though. You say many sikhs are against the establishment of Khalistan, but those same Sikhs will agree to the pro Hindu agendas by the government in most cases and then there will be the discussion of how both sides were wrong in the 80's. What I am getting at is Akal Thakt (Sarbatt Khalsa) had a few options. MAinly either to establish Khalistan or, to take the beating Sikhs had taken and hope for a better future, a future that would rest in the hands of those same leaders who stood by in delhi and overlooked the pogroms of Delhi. Yourself hopefully being of a scholarly nature would know Sikh history and would surmise that it is not our way to let people get hurt and harmed and stand by and not make change. We did not stand by when it happened to Hindus and we had good favor with the mughals of the time, so why would we take it then or now? From this my friend we have sentiments to leave and form our own state, and many of the sikhs who you say are against this are the same ones who have felt the need to conform to the majority, or have had a bad exprience with the 80's where the government harmed their families, or the FEW TIMES some fools full of Josh went around with guns saying their fighting for Sikhs and freedom harrassed poor farmers or got people in toruble for just knowing them, those are the people that are at odds with this, but i ask you, is this more fault of the movement or the government of the 80's? These people were put through conditions where the mention of sepparating reminds them of the great peirals of the 80's. Also, I would ask of all my veereh and penji's that they excercise some restraint when somebody questions Khalistan the movement or shows disapproval. It's it better to engage and understand why rather then get full of josh and think of them as ignorant or cowards, becuase after all many of them went through hard times and being anti khalistani was the result in fact sympathize and be patient and in the end its their opinion and they will not help, you keep doing your seva for Khalistan. Lastly, Siddarth Paji I have been an avid reader of your posts you seem to be very sharp and show less ignorance then most of the hindus i know of. All i can say is right from the thought of Khalistan was there ever a moment where the intent was to drive out Hindus or Muslims, if our gurus whom you know we hold in the highest regard didnt do it why would we. Paji the day we would do that to any non sikh is the same day we SIKHS will be taring out the angs that all saints who were born non sikh, verses out of SGGSJ. Forgive me if I uttered somthing inappropriate. [%sig%]

Re: hindu website attacking sikhs and khalistan

Bachitar Singh · 30 May 2007

PTE Singh: You can pay my royalties via paypal. You have no right to use words from the bachiterish dictionary. I appreciate you taking out time to continue the argument with me other then the main argument at hand. That really means a lot to me. Makes me feel special. You sound like a brave man, but what have you contributed to sikhi. I have paid my dues have you. I have lost three fingers and walk on a perminant limp. Now tell me what have you done? [%sig%]

Re: hindu website attacking sikhs and khalistan

PTE SINGH · 31 May 2007

Mr Bachitar Singh, Cheques in the post! I do think that this personal discussion is some what irrelevant to the original point about the anti sikh website and the formation of Khalistan. My bravery and contribution to Sikhi is better judged by others and my waheguru. I am sorry that you have lost three fingers and the use of your legs are hindered, but with all due respect i have no idea about your personal history and who you have paid your dues too? I also don't see how any of that gives you the right to be rude to me. Regards [%sig%]

maliyaan vale

dssingh · 31 May 2007

wjkk wjkf, sadh sangat jee, daas wanted to ask u if any guru ka gurmukh could send daas some pics of the maliyaan vale singhs. here is my id: [address removed] or onto this post. please singho i need inspiration. thanx alot. take care wkk wjkf.

Re: hindu website attacking sikhs and khalistan

navpreetsingh · 19 Jun 2007

r u just gonna talk saying that | Khalistan Zindabad - Be prepared for Shaheedi |r u ready urselfff,go 2 indai and do smthinggg don jus talkk online nothing is gonna happen just by talkingggg

Re: hindu website attacking sikhs and khalistan

jassmannn · 20 Jun 2007

Shaheed, You have made some interesting points but they are not all correct entirely. I have never lived in Indian and am infact British born and raised and count myself British. I do on the other hand have family in Punjab where some Sikhs intend to have this Khalistan. Now if you go back to 1947 when Pakistan was created, did you see the havoc caused? Because the Country was intended to represent the muslims, people across Indian were uprooted and millions died as a result. Now if we go for a Sikh state, apart from the economical issues and the Governing issues, what would the Sikhs living in the rest of the Country do. Can you Guarantee that they will not be forced into moving to Khalistan, the seperate state? Why can people not just leave things be? Why do you have to be sepratist. Our Gurus lived in a undived country why are we shopping up and cutting out our connection to some of the most sacred shrines around India. We are in essence, I believe inviting more disaster on to a religion which I feel has suffered already. It's always the innocents that die who are more missed and cause turmoil, than the ones who are fighting a cause for a religion for which they are not representative.

Re: hindu website attacking sikhs and khalistan

Shaheed · 20 Jun 2007

Jassmannn Your argument is valid as well being that your scope of Khalistan being slightly limitied. I will concede that most people recognize the word 'Khalistan' as the name of a separate Sikh State, which would be punjab annexed from India. However, Khalistan is actully the name of the entire movement, really it was an effort to get equal rights for Sikhs in India, the same rights that have been neglected to the Muslims, Buddists, Jains, and Christians of India. During the movement leaders Such as Sant Jarnail Singh Ji himself stated they would rather stay in India but as equals, but was not against or for the idea of establishing Khalistan. What those Sikhs faught for was equality. As for now, I would rather see Sikhs today still apart of India but that does not mean i would want them to live as second class citizens, Sikhs need to continue the struggle the fight for equality, not just for us but for all. I cant garentee that there would be little or no loss of life if Khalistan was created via political negotiation, or forced but; the loss of life has never detered the panth from following through on an objective concerning Justice and it would be out of our characteristics to do so now. I will admit that what i am saying is far easier then done, but i am mearly stating what would happen, if, and when it happens. The loss of our history and shrines occured during partition, Sikhs were hurled out of punjab, now pakistan, and upon the creation of Khalistan we will be hurled out of India. I ask you though, should we not have a place where we have secuirty, in our stronghold of Punjab we are repressed and disadvantaged, in our own home, and if we are not safe there we cannot worry about our instability anywhere else. Our economic and other such concerns will be taken care of by God, the same God who will give Khalistan we fight for if he wills it, if not the panth will continue fighting for their rights. Your right about one thing we have suffered greatly, but we have always suffered. Guru Sahib calls Dukh Daru and Sukh a Rogh. In Dukh we find medicine a nasha that focuses us, a pain that makes us think of God who is the healer, and Sukh a disease that makes us relaxed and nonchalant. We have suffered, but if that keeps us fighting, and keeps us pushing back then the panth will have to pay that price. [%sig%]

Re: hindu website attacking sikhs and khalistan

jassmannn · 21 Jun 2007

I don't understand what rights you are fighting for as Sikhs. There are some contentious issues in terms of our identity and that we should fight for, but we are represented in the political system, and we can enjoy wealth and all the other things that any other Indian can enjoy. When was the last time you actually went to India? And also why are the punjabi's and soo many sikhs soo keen to get out of the country, and here we are in the west fighting for Khalistan? I don't get it. The India you are talking about is not the one I see today, and it is not 1984 anymore. The world has progressed. A sikh in India can achieve, and as far as I'm concerned, I do not want people fighting under a banner of Khalistan fighting for me, and that is what those people claim to do. Nobody in my whole family wants a Khalistan state. If they are fighting for rights, then fair enough, I understand that their are irrigation issues, land and law issues, then take those up why do people have to claim sepratism. And I will not stand by when someone tries to create a Khalistan and even one person has to lose his/her life. Guru Ji, never said we needed a Khalistan, so I don't want one.

Re: hindu website attacking sikhs and khalistan

Shaheed · 21 Jun 2007

The last time i went to India was 3 years ago today actually. When i went there i stayed all over the place not just punjab. So really i have a good idea what indias about. And i wasnt born a Khalistani, Ive only learned about it during post secondary education. until then i thought it was a nickname for punjab that we shout at the annual Nagar Kirtan. So what I am getting at that my background surrounding this issue would be as an extream moderate as far as some staunch Khalistani's are concerned. As I said I travaled all over India and i noticed in States where there is little means to produce any electricity there are no electricity cuts, but in punjab there are cuts twice a day at the very least. Punjab a state given the chance to control its resources can have all the prospertity other states enjoy. You yourself do not deny the Irrigation, land and law disputes and also the need to protect the Sikh identity. however you have missed an important issue which is justice. How can a country progress if it is not able to apologize for the destruction it has caused. I will let you know now, that personally until i hear an apology from the Central Government of India, and see atleast ONE person/politician get charged and convicted with the pogroms of Delhi, i will continue to hold my stance of Sikhs being second class citizens. Rats are exterminated, insects, and other pests with out remorse or apology are Sikhs to be considered that same by India? Just because nobody in your family doesnt support it doesnt mean that the rest of the panth doesnt want it right? If i wanted to contrast your family with mine i would say we have somthing in common. My family was very harsh of Khalistan and my questions when i started asking. When i started debating with them about it. They were more upset, and argued back. It came to a point were they all agree that somthing needs to be done becuase 'punjabi's and 'sikhs' are not being treated justly but do not want to separate, which is a compromise i can accept for atleast they are not blind to the ill status of punjab. I ask you, that if punjab was allowed to grow unhaltered since independence with some autonomy do you think all these punjabis would leave for wealth abroad? Also, do you think that if in the 80's and 90's (India's highest emmigration periods) the government did not send out Punjab Police to kill Sikhs in fake encounters that they would leave? As for what Guru Sahib said Guru ji did say that Soverignty is needed in order for religion to move forward. Maybe someone can kindly give the proper arth and tukh so Jassmann Ji can read it for themselves. [%sig%]

Re: hindu website attacking sikhs and khalistan

jassmannn · 22 Jun 2007

Well we will just have to agree to disagree. I was there last year and spent most of my time in Delhi, where the electricity does go out more than you are proporting. But hey, if that's what you believe then fair dos.

Re: hindu website attacking sikhs and khalistan

khalistani · 22 Jun 2007

shaheed what your talking about has to be spread, the problem is the reasion nothing is being done about the problem is most sikhs in the west dont care for khalistan or punjab and dont teach their children no one knows whats happining in india, have you talked to most youth most of them don't care anymore they say oh we live in the west we live in canada or america who cares.

Re: hindu website attacking sikhs and khalistan

Shaheed · 23 Jun 2007

jassmann, i would agree to disagree, besides my goal isnt to make anybody a 'khalistani' my point is just to make sure people have an idea why there are khalistani's but i respect your opinion nonetheless [%sig%]