Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Re: Community of differences

Re: Community of differences

jassmannn · 01 Jun 2007

What kind of sense are you talking Chandra Singh. Firstly, Hindu's have been fighting with each other since the very beginning over who is what caste and who is touchable and not. Sikh's are a pluralist religion, and if you have ever studied or even bothered to read what Guru Granth Sahib Ji says or studied the life of Guru Nanak Dev Ji, you may have a better understanding of what the Sikh philosophy is and the actions of certain sections of the Sikh community does not reflect the whole community, as I dare say neither does the actions of certain Hindus reflect the whole community.

Re: Community of differences

Harjas Kaur · 01 Jun 2007

1. "dissent or difference is shunned in the Sikh religious establishment." If you will kindly note, Punjab has been peacefully coexisting with various cults, splinter groups and imitation Sikh sects. What has been a point of contention is when groups such as these which mock mainstream Sikh teachings become powerful enough, financially wealthy enough due to government and political funding, to outrightly INSULT and PROVOKE Sikh sentiments.... Then, it becomes an issue, why are these groups converting from the Sikh mainstream in order to create anti-Sikh sentiments, and what kind of hand does the government play in such mischief. 2. "This is the logical outcome of believing that all wisdom was revealed only to a select few prophets and is resident in only one revealed book." Sikhism has no prophets, as you are well aware. You only use this linguistic artifice to imply that Sikh elements which do not subscribe to your sanatan vision are similar to Islam. This is just political rhetoric intended to incite and inflame sanatan Sikhs and Hindutva groups against purataan Gurmat Gursikhi. But it does further illustrate the degree of hostility and potential violence against mainstream Sikhi which mascarades under Hindu Unity. To even imply that Sikhs follow a revealed book, or other books as equal to Guru is defamatory. We follow Guru who is one jyote in all his forms, meaning all 10 forms of Guru were one Jyote, and the Siri Guru Granth Sahib Ji was invested with Guru's own Jyote by Guru and thus is Guru Ji. Guru's Jyote is also in Panj Piare and in the Panj Takhts and in the consensus of the Khalsa Panth. Guru's bani is also in the Dasam Granth, and possibly in the Sarbloh Granth. But neither of these has been invested with Gurgaddi and any contentious issues on this point will be resolved by the Khalsa Panth and Akal Takht. And as a Sikh, I submit my own opinions to this Gurmat and Panthic authority. But to imply that Sikhs who don't want to be labeled "terrorist co-Islamic traitors to India" must follow the Vedas, it's certainly not Guru's bani. So why should we? Because Hindutva will categorize Sikhs as a threat to Hindu Unity and restart the killing campaign if we don't? Well that's tolerance for you. Or maybe the intolerant fanaticism is on the other foot. 3. "It is only that fact that Sikhism was born of the womb of its Hindu mother that has stopped it from becoming a totally fanatic death cult." So, unless Sikhism submits to sanatan assimilation and erosion of it's own identity, it is labeled by Hindutva as a fanatical death cult. That's good to know. For so long we all kept hearing about Sikh brothers. I knew there was a catch! Attitudes like these imply a new Hindutva sponsored anti-Sikh gallughara isn't far away. Funny how that Hindu Mother keeps killing and oppressing minority religions and financially rewarding cults and breakaway groups and promoting an anti-Sikh agenda within them. Hindutva has been at war with Gursikhi since at least 1984. How unfortunate there is utterly no tolerance, and Hindutva feels the arrogance to tamper with Sikh religion in order to force conformity with sanatan views...even to the point of genocide. Talk about a fanatic death cult. Chandra, why don't you try to show a little less rhetoric, and more intellectual honesty in your posts. ~From Shaheed Bhai Jaswant Singh Khalra collection HINDUSTAN STOP KILLING SIKHS! [%sig%]

Re: Community of differences

ijs · 01 Jun 2007

chandra ji can u please put in "layman terms" wot u wanted to say..........

Re: Community of differences

SomeSingh · 01 Jun 2007

basically, he's saying that Sikh dharm's basic foundations, such as belief in Guru Granth Sahib as Guru and the Guru's as being all-knowing avtars of God, are wrong and have lead to Sikhs being intolerant of different viewpoints. He's also saying that Sikh's are part of Hinduism, and that's the only thing that has prevented Sikhs from being mass murderers. Btw, not all Sikhi is in Guru Granth Sahib ji. That's a severe oversimplification promoted by either ignorant or downright nefarious people. Sikh teachings are also in rahit, and in Gurbani such as Bhai Gurdas Dian Vaaran, Bhai Nand Lal's ghazals, Dasam Granth Sahib ji. There are also numerous other works about Sikhi and Sikh teachings that have earned a respected place in the panth such as pracheen panth prakash, nanak prakash etc.