Re: akj young sikhs
Balpreet Singh · 29 Jun 2007
I frankly think that the emails that are sent out about young Gursikhs and their so-called "exploits" are a shame and disgusting.
If we find out that a young Gursikh has made some mistakes like chatting to girls or making comments otherwise inappropriate to be coming from a Gursikh, should we send out mass emails and hold demonstrations in front of their house and stone them?
As they say, "let he who is without sin cast the first stone".
Khimaa is a MAJOR quality in a Gursikh. Every day we remember those who "dekh kay andith keeta". I'm not saying that young Sikhs with these problems should be praised or ignored. I'm saying, if someone is genuinely well-intentioned and has even an ounce of Gursikhi in them, they'll approach the young Gursikh in question, and discretely ask them what's going on. Offer them all possible support to overcome their problem. Let's help them.
If you condemn and shame them, does that help them? Or does it make you feel like a big man and hence it's alright?
Yes, if there is a perpetual offender who doesn't care and won't stop his activities and is hurting others then go ahead and warn everyone. But if someone is going on some inappropriate website, is that enough to ruin his/her life?
Have some mercy. Have some compassion. Look at your own jeevan and ask if you're spotless. Let's help each other. Sending mass emails is not the way to do that.
Re: akj young sikhs
Niranjan Singh · 29 Jun 2007
I agree with Bhai Balpreet Singh Ji.
Such problems can't be solved by sending anonymous mass e-mails.
Why not talk to the individual one-on-one, or with an elder? Work it out at a local level. If the problem still persists, there are still other alternatives than just trying to blackmail the individuals via e-mail.
This problem is not unique to just the "akj youth" but others as well, the Taksali, Dodra, and other youths are in the same boat.
If the youth would concentrate more on Gurbani, and Naam Abhyaas and Rahit rather than sitting on kirtan stages or wearing flashy banna, showy gatka, much of these problems would disappear with Guru Ji's kirpa.
Staying humble, gupt and in the Sangat's charn sharn gets you a long way. The more one is in the lime light the more vulnerable one become - unless there some Jeevan and Kamai to go with it.
Re: akj young sikhs
Robert Langdon · 29 Jun 2007
I was speaking to an elder singh, he said to me the during the times he was younger, what the elder singhs would do if they found out that some singh did a dhil they would do a meeting on how to make sure that his dhil wouldnt get out, and then they would approach the person during rehainsubaee keertan and talk to him. He said they would help him, guide him and if needed get the person to go pesh for his bhalla.
He said that the singhs made sure that the jatha didnt get badhnaamed and if someone was doing wrong then the singhs would talk to him and guide him and help him to get back on the path of sikhi. He said that these day some of the youth in jatha and out of jatha are doing the opposite they are actually exposing people which can destory ones life and may make them fall off Sikhi more. Even though this singh is old but he has childeren that tell him things they read on message boards and as he visits message boards he had seem some things on them some time ago himself and we began to talk about this and I actually agree with the elder singh and veer balpreet singh on this, that we should try to help them instead of creating emails and posts which is actually destroying someone live. We being Sikhs should actually help our veer/bhens if there falling off their horses. If we cant help our brothers and sisters how would be able to help others as guru sahib has instructed
[%sig%]
Re: akj young sikhs
Harjas Kaur · 29 Jun 2007
I also agree with bhai Balpreet Singh.
This action you are taking is scandalous. If a Gursikh is falling into temptation and you are aware of specifics, you need to go to the Gurudwara the young Gursikh's family attends and speak to the elder Gursikhs about it so they can give the proper guidance.
It's a matter of guidance...these are YOUNG PEOPLE!
There is a very different matter if you are discussing direct bujjar kurehits or if it is just behavior which can cause temptation and then...maybe...lead to bujjar kurehits. Is the behavior bad? Yes, I'm saying it needs to be corrected. BUT can you expel amritdhari's from the Panth because they were "innappropriately chatting?"
Let's have some realistic balance and wise maturity here. With that mentality, throw EVERYONE out since no one is perfect! A sadh sangat is not about who's reputation it can destroy. A sadh sangat is not a collection of purely spiritually perfect human beings. A sadh sangat is a brotherhood and a sisterhood, a FAMILY!
As a family, for these kinds of things do you publically ruin and destroy your own brother and sister? Your own father and mother?
Where is the loyalty to a human being? A sadh sangat is supposed to be an advocate before Waheguruji. An ADVOCATE! This means, you take it to Guru and say ardas for them...and you yourself be the right kind of wise and holy example. And if the problem is serious enough, and persistent enough, you take it to the Panj Piara. Let wise Gursikhs give them guidance and counselling so they become better people.
The sadh sangat is supposed to LOVE them. And discipline is a form of love when needed.
When you make a mistake you go to Guru and you say you're sorry. When did we become the Taliban morals police to go out and decapitate all the reputations of our brothers and sisters without FIRST going to the elder Gursikhs to make the loving correction so our brothers and sisters become the holy people they need to be?
Serious, it almost sounds like something the GOI would concoct to destroy and alienate all the imperfect young people out of the AKJ. But it sounds so typical of frustrated people within the Panth itself to do this. Usually when people are condemning something about someone, they are trying to distract from the guilt of their own involvement.
There is no morality, no holiness in condemning your own publically. That's just assured self-destruction. Correct problems within, like a family, and you build up strong loyalty to that family. Guruji shows us time and again that bad people can turn around and become great Gursikhs. But why is this community always taking the young Gursikh and trying to destroy him as if he was the enemy?
If it's your own kid...with your own LIFE do everything you can to help them be better. You don't destroy and disown your kid because he was chatting with the girls. The person who is doing this is NOT a part of the family of Gursikhs. The person doing this is committing scandal against the family of the Gursikhs. You are the enemy of the Panth to threaten to harm and drive away the young people like this. Whoever is publically exposing the mistakes of young Gursikhs in an effort to shame and destroy their reputations must be exposed and EXPELLED! You are the danger, because you alienate Gursikhs from the sangat to shut the gates of God against human beings like a demon. You have no right to do this. Guruji is about MUKTI. NO ONE without proper cause and proper hearing before Panj Piara is to be THROWN AWAY LIKE GARBAGE BASED ON EMAIL HEARSAY AND NINDYA!
THIS IS NOT THE WAY!
Be careful, or you yourself will be thrown away like garbage.
[%sig%]