Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

AKJ - How much of the below is true?

AKJ - How much of the below is true?

jassmannn · 04 Jul 2007

Don't know very much about the AKJ movement, but saw this online and thought I would get some clarity? All comments welcome. They believe in the efficacy of kirtan (devotional singing) and regularly hold overnight sessions (rain sabai). This group also attaches particular importance to the meditation and repetition of the Sikh mantra 'Vahiguru' ('wonderful guru'). The group observes strict vegetarianism and will only cook with, and eat out of, iron utensils. All references to caste distinctions are strictly forbidden. They reject the list of musical modes at the end of the Adi Granth (rag-mala), because of its inaccuracies and do not repeat it when there is a complete reading of the scritpure. However, believing that the words of the Guru Granth are literally the words of the Guru, they can be called fundamentalist. Furthermore there is no interpretive explanation (katha) given of scriptural passages, since the meaning is assumed to be clear and transparent. The group replaces the original uncut hair (kesh) with a small under-turban (keshki), which both women and men wear. In such beliefs the group reject the general code of conduct known as the Sikh Rahit Marayada of the S.G.P.C. (See introduction and Singh Sabha and Sikh Panth entries), and produced their own called rahit-bibek (bibek means discrimination, discernment, insight). They also believe in a different Khalsa initiation ceremony, wherein the five beloved ones, or five Gursikhs place their right hand on the neophyte's head and meditatively repeat the mantra "Vahiguru", revolving around the innitiate for five or so minutes.

Re: AKJ - How much of the below is true?

Harjas Kaur · 08 Jul 2007

The Akhand Kirtani Jatha is not a movement but a Jatha of Sikhs that believes in preserving principles purataan Gursiki. What you will not find is alterations, modernism, British or Hinduized additions to Gursiki, which are prevalent in many Gurudwara's today. The SGPC Rehit Maryada is a compromise of purataan rehitnamas. AKJ does not believe in compromise or change, or that modern scholars know better than Guru. Take the 5 k's. If you remove your kirpan to board an airplane, you know you're not supposed to take it off, but you have to. So you say ardas to Guruji. But how can you take off your kes and put it back on? So removing kes is a bujjar kurehit. All the 5 k's compliment the physical form. You put on kacchera, kirpan, kara, kanga, and keski. But you don't put on kes. Kes is fundamental part of the body like your teeth, or your arm. All the Kakkars are something on the body. So AKJ simply believes in clarifying this. For an amritdhari to remove kakkars is doing something wrong. But to cut kes is to break the bond with Guru. So it is more serious and more fundamental. Kes is not a kakkar. It is respecting the human form as God gave. You are born with your hairs. You are not born with kakkars. There are 5 kakkars, not 4. Kes is not a kakkar, it is a part of your natural human form. Your keski and dastaar is the crown to protect your kes and give you noble appearance, give the world darshan of the King. [url]http://www.sikhiwiki.org/index.php/Akhand_Kirtani_Jatha[/url] [url]http://www.sikhiwiki.org/index.php?title=Bhai_Randhir_Singh[/url] [url]http://www.ekhalsa.com/[/url] If you follow the link under Toronto, then under literature, you can read more interesting and informative articles. Perhaps can give broader understanding. Hehe, the link TS will take you here, to Tapoban Sahib. [url]http://www.gurbani.org/menunew1.html[/url] Great Gurbani articles! [url]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6kXuZNePyb4[/url] AKJ is about kirtan which is very simple, devotional, and a form of heart-felt love and praise of Waheguru. It's not about great musical skills or professionalism, it's just recitation from the heart. [url]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WcHTGN9fR1M[/url] Bhai Jeevan Singh Ji [url]http://keertan.waheguroo.com/[/url] Some rainsabhai and samagam kirtan ~bhul chuk maaf karni Ji [%sig%]

Re: AKJ - How much of the below is true?

Khalsaspirit · 09 Jul 2007

Waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh Khalsa jio, The definition brought here for Akhand Kirtani Jatha by Jassmannn is 100% Niddar Nang's definition. Jassmannn jio it is better to find the truth about that man first who wrote the above definition which you just copy paste here. And for jatha per our 30 years experience with them they are the Sikhs who are trying to be Guru Kay Sikh till death. When we say Guru Kay Sikh means to accept all Guru Kay Bachans and do his seva by naam kamai. We think for you this simple definition of jatha is good enough nothing more nothing less is required. Furthermore there are and were many Gursikhs who became one with Akali jot by that definition period. All Singh/Singhnia are requested to use sanjam on this topic. Guru Mehar Karay Waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh [%sig%]

Re: AKJ - How much of the below is true?

BirRaas Singh · 10 Jul 2007

Before this becomes a "lets slate Niddar Singh" thread, the origin of this quote is from http://philtar.ucsm.ac.uk/encyclopedia/sikhism/akha.html

Re: AKJ - How much of the below is true?

kulsin · 11 Jul 2007

Dear Jassmannn Ji, I think this topic is unnecessary and undesirable. You should know one thing. That if you don’t know about AKJ as you are enquiring, then obviously you don’t think yourself as part of AKJ. In that case. Your job is just to show immense love for your fellow Gursikhs and while you mingle with them and see the beauty of your Guru Sahib through their devotion and love you will automatically come to know them better. I am sure this your question even answered as you have asked will not trigger a loving relationship with fellow Sikhs. So Brother throw away your questions and all the thing associated with them and Just show your LOVE for Guru and Gursikhs then all the questions will be answered and you will have nothing to ask. Simple recommendation. Let the LOVE take over you. [%sig%]

Re: AKJ - How much of the below is true?

ns · 12 Jul 2007

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji ke Fateh ku1sin jeeo is 100% spot on. I can say with my hand on my heart that thorugh my 40 odd years of life that without the jatha I know I would've been in turmoil.AKJ is one shining bright flower in the kaum today and has been for a long time.There are words we use such as "fundamentalists", this doesn't exist for sikhe it may do for the goras out there, where sikhe is concerned it's the ultimate game of love and giving your head. AKJ has been blessed with beautiful gursikhs who continue to inspire with love and there is no power in the world that can do anything about it let alone people like Niddar Singh.Because where there is so much pyar for Gursikhe, Guru Sahib's kala is even more present.However there are people in the AKJ who are learning and have a real backward mentality.You have to undertand that this kind of thing exists in every group, family, jatha, non jatha, etc, you cannot have good without the bad...So if you really want clarity , I don't think clarity existS anywhere apart from in SGGS. " hum ne changee buraaa nee koeeeeee"

Re: AKJ - How much of the below is true?

jassmannn · 12 Jul 2007

WHy are you getting so defensive Kulsin? I only asked a question. I'm not AKJ, just didn't know what it's all about. Why can't I ask. Shall I just assume what I read then, or ask the forum for their input?

Re: AKJ - How much of the below is true?

Kulbir Singh · 12 Jul 2007

I am not a spokesperson for AKJ and the following are my personal opinions: ---------------- They believe in the efficacy of kirtan (devotional singing) and regularly hold overnight sessions (rain sabai). ----------- This is true about AKJ. Which Sikh doesn’t believe in the efficacy of Kirtan? -------------- This group also attaches particular importance to the meditation and repetition of the Sikh mantra 'Vahiguru' ('wonderful guru'). ----------- This is true about AKJ. The whole of Gurbani talks about the greatness of Naam-Gurmantr. ------------ The group observes strict vegetarianism and will only cook with, and eat out of, iron utensils. --------- Absolutely True. -------------- All references to caste distinctions are strictly forbidden. ------------ True. --------------- They reject the list of musical modes at the end of the Adi Granth (rag-mala), because of its inaccuracies and do not repeat it when there is a complete reading of the scritpure. ------------- True. -------------- However, believing that the words of the Guru Granth are literally the words of the Guru, they can be called fundamentalist. ----------- If obeying hukams of Gurbani means Fundamentalism, then AKJs are fundamentalists. ------------ Furthermore there is no interpretive explanation (katha) given of scriptural passages, since the meaning is assumed to be clear and transparent. ------------ As per writings of Bhai Sahib particularly his book called “Katha Kirtan”, Gurbani itself is the katha of Vaheguru done by our Great Satgurus and Bhagats. To sing baani and to utter Gurbani is to do katha of Vaheguru. There is no need for any other katha. This katha (kirtan or paath of Gurbani) is the tool to cleanse one’s mind and to get an understanding of Vaheguru. There is not a single pankiti of Gurbani that gives hukam to do lecture-roop katha that’s done in Gurdwara Sahibaan, nor there is any hukam to do katha of Gurbani itself. Having said that, AKJ does not take any stand against Katha-doers. It’s just that Katha is not part of AKJ parchaar of Sikhi. AKJ does not stop its members from doing katha and there are kathakaars who have AKJ background doing katha in their own capacity (not as representatives of AKJ). ------------- The group replaces the original uncut hair (kesh) with a small under-turban (keshki), which both women and men wear. ------------ True, however it does not replace Kesh as Kakaar. Kesh were never kakaar in the first place. ---------- In such beliefs the group reject the general code of conduct known as the Sikh Rahit Marayada of the S.G.P.C. (See introduction and Singh Sabha and Sikh Panth entries), and produced their own called rahit-bibek (bibek means discrimination, discernment, insight). ----------- Gurmat Bibek written by Bhai Sahib was written 10-12 years before the SGPC maryada was published. There are not too many differences. The only two differences I can think of are Kutha and Keski. ------------ They also believe in a different Khalsa initiation ceremony, wherein the five beloved ones, or five Gursikhs place their right hand on the neophyte's head and meditatively repeat the mantra "Vahiguru", revolving around the innitiate for five or so minutes. ------------ Again this is puratan maryada and has been in practice centuries before the SGPC maryada was published. Bhul chuk dee maafi. Kulbir Singh [%sig%]

Re: AKJ - How much of the below is true?

jassmannn · 13 Jul 2007

Thanks Kulbir Singh. What would you say to the Dam DAmi Taksaal, which was started by Guru Gobind Singh Ji in the early 1700 hundreds and has knowledge passed on from that time till now, who disagree with some of the AKJ principles?

Re: AKJ - How much of the below is true?

Manjot Singh Khalsa · 13 Jul 2007

>>>>>>>What would you say to the Dam DAmi Taksaal, which was started by Guru Gobind Singh Ji in the early 1700 hundreds and has knowledge passed on from that time till now, who disagree with some of the AKJ principles?<<<<<<<<<< I would say do some searches on this forum about the lineage of taksal and do some of your own research into the different lineage stories. I have seen a book published by taksal between Baba Gurbachan Singh and Baba Kartar Singh's period I beleive and the lineage in there includes some 30 odd babas as jathedars, nowadays, I beleive its down to 14 jathedars.

Re: AKJ - How much of the below is true?

Khalsaspirit · 13 Jul 2007

Waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh Khalsa jio, Since we are visiting this forum we never seen such cleverness before although we knew the intentions of this so called journalist (or media person) guy jassmann since he started posting on this topic. Although he/she himself claimed a journalist (or media person) of BBC. But seeing his clever twist in this topic surprised us how the hell BBC hired such a stupid person in their corporation who has no sense at all about the field he claims. Jassman listen carefully although you showed the nang of your journalism here by twisting the topic. You are the one who opened the topic about Akhand Kirtani Jatha and you were informed very well by many Singhs and now you talking about Damdami Taksal here. We know how people like you do their work smartly (in Panjabi called "LAAMBU LANA"). You want us to say some thing which will go against Damdami Taksal so that stupid like you can start a cyber war between two jathaybandis. If you do not know things about Damdami Taksal then ask them and if you are no satisfied do your own research by reading Sikh history. And again we do not know if Damdami Taksal was started by Guru Gobind Singh jee or not but this is 1000% (one thousand percent) true that in 1699 Guru Gobind Singh ji started the Khalsa Panth and passed his knowledge, roop and patshahi to khalsa panth. "Khalsa mero roop hai khass, Khalsay mai huan karo nivas" "In Sikhan ko deei Patshahi" And the Khalsa panth was started way before from whom you are enquiring about. In future try stick to the topic. Our wording may sound you harsh but your bad intention forced us to do this. Khalsa jio, khima karna. Guru Mehar Karay Waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh

Re: AKJ - How much of the below is true?

Harjas Kaur · 13 Jul 2007

[quote]What would you say to the Dam DAmi Taksaal, which was started by Guru Gobind Singh Ji in the early 1700 hundreds and has knowledge passed on from that time till now, who disagree with some of the AKJ principles?[/quote] I would say that the AKJ and the Taksal have more in common than just about anybody in the Panth. There are differences. But the respect of Guru, the respect of Gurmat, the respect of purataan Gursikhi is there. All you are trying to do is somehow invalidate the AKJ. You couldn't if you tried. AKJ and Taksal had the highest percentage of shaheeds in the Gallughara. That alone commands respect of the Panth for BOTH Jathas....forever, irrespective of differences. Please do not disrespect the sacrifices of the shaheeds by your argument and comparison. It makes you look bad. You don't have to share the same understanding as the AKJ. You are free to oppose and believe your own way. No one is going to you. Why come to an AKJ forum just to be critical? You have no idea what beautiful and courageous people have belonged to this Jatha. You have no idea what sacrifices many from this Jatha have made out of love for all Sikhs...out of love for you. Today no one speaks of them as the Taksalis, or the AKJ, but as the Gursikhs. Because that is what they are. Bhai Sahib Bhai Randhir Singh Ji Bhai Fauja Singh Ji and family in happier days. Bhai Sukhdev Singh Babbar Ji In 1978 Amritsar AKJ and Taksal stood together as one, fought and died together as one. Why do people always try to create divisions within the Khalsa Panth? Sant Ji in 1978, after the Amritsar massacre of Gursikhs by Sant Nirankaris, comforting the injured. The pivotal catalyst of Sant Bhindranwale Ji was the massacre of the 13 Gursikhs. He did not divide them between the Taksalis and the AKJ. Why should you? These are all our brothers. They belong to each and every one of us. These are OUR shaheeds. They fought and they died for love because they believed in love. Dedicated to the Martyrs of 1978' [url]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dNUwmkXlea4[/url] [quote]"Oh True Guru, we will serve your everlasting Sikhi, with our every word, thought and deed. We will devote our youth, wealth, and all worldly possessions to the cause of the Panth. My body, preserved since childhood will be sacrificed now the need has arisen. By continuously repeating and sincerely following Gurbani we will get rid of all our evil-mindedness. If you keep your Grace, my Graceful Lord, we will sacrifice ourselves limb by limb..."~Shaheed Bhai Fauja Singh Ji[/quote] [quote]Just as Baba Gurbachan Singh had predicted, the leaders of the Sikh Resistance Movement began to fall one by one. With human rights no longer a factor, KP Gill ordered his men to slaughter families and torture those who might have information. Bhai Rachhpal Singh Chandran, head of the Malwa Bhindranvala Tiger Force was martyred on June 18, 1992. Bhai Geraint Singh Budhsinghvala of the Khalistan Liberation Force was martyred on July 31 1992 and then 10 days later, Bhai Sukhdev Singh Babbar, Jathedar of Babbar Khalsa became a Shaheed. When Baba jee heard about the Shaheedee of Bhai Sukhdev Singh Babbar, he was staying with his sister. Baba jee read the news and tears began to flow from his eyes. His sister had not seen this happen before and asked, "But you used to say that Sukhdev Singh Babbar was opposed to your political stands [The Babbars had supported the election boycott] and now you are crying? What is going on?" Baba jee replied, "Yes, I had a strong disagreement with him, but we had the same mission. And he was after all just like my brother…" ~Final Days: Baba Gurbachan Singh Manochahal [url]http://www.panthic.org/news/130/ARTICLE/3192/2007-03-28.html[/url][/quote] ~Bhull chak maaf [%sig%]

Re: AKJ - How much of the below is true?

jassmannn · 16 Jul 2007

Well, I never said I worked for the BBC, I just gave my views on them, please read my posts again, and tell me where I said I worked for the BBC?? Also, why do you assume everyone who challenges you is evil, out to get you, or haas an agenda? Why can't you just answer the question instead od getting so over sensitive and hitting back. This is a forum after all. Ii I can't ask questions here, then what is a forum all about? Your comments make me laugh Khalsa Spirit. Since I started the topic and wanted the kbnowledge, why can't I ask more questions for clarification. No I'm not from Dam Dami taksaal or otherwise, and I'm not trying to start a war or anything. I'm asking simple questions and hoping for simple answers. Which some people have very kindly done, but you seem to have some issues for some reason. Next time I won't bother and will just read and believe whatever is printed and written on the internet. Will that make you happy, if you think I'm some sort of under-cover agency.

Re: AKJ - How much of the below is true?

Khalsaspirit · 16 Jul 2007

Waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh Khalsa jio, jassmannn wrote ----------------------------------- Well, I never said I worked for the BBC, I just gave my views on them, please read my posts again, and tell me where I said I worked for the BBC?? ----------------------------------- Thanks for clarifying that you saved BBC and Sikhs from further destruction. ----------------------------------- Also, why do you assume everyone who challenges you is evil, out to get you, or haas an agenda? ----------------------------------- Twist of AKJ topic 180 degree to Damdami Taksal. Yes clearly shows some one has agenda. ----------------------------------- Why can't you just answer the question instead od getting so over sensitive and hitting back. ----------------------------------- Open separate topic. Sangat will let you know. ----------------------------------- This is a forum after all. Ii I can't ask questions here, then what is a forum all about? ----------------------------------- Yes you can. This is your right. ----------------------------------- Your comments make me laugh Khalsa Spirit. ----------------------------------- You can cry if you want to no one has control over it. ----------------------------------- Since I started the topic and wanted the kbnowledge, why can't I ask more questions for clarification. No I'm not from Dam Dami taksaal or otherwise, and I'm not trying to start a war or anything. I'm asking simple questions and hoping for simple answers. Which some people have very kindly done, but you seem to have some issues for some reason. ----------------------------------- Why particularly knowledge about Damdami Taksal in your AKJ topic why not Sgpc, Nanaksar, Dodra, Nihungs etc. ----------------------------------- Next time I won't bother and will just read and believe whatever is printed and written on the internet. Will that make you happy, if you think I'm some sort of under-cover agency. ----------------------------------- You already mentioned in a separate topic that "I work in the Media". Having said that we believe media persons are not dumb. Guru Mehar karay Waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh [%sig%]

Re: AKJ - How much of the below is true?

SomeSingh · 16 Jul 2007

Taksaal's lineage does go to the Guru's time. Baba Gurbachan Singh ji Bhindren wrote in a book published before his passing that Baba Sunder Singh ji's gurdev was Baba Bishen Singh ji Muralewaley. He also wrote that sant Sunder Singh ji studied from a few other sants as well, such as sant Gulab Singh ji. Most who disparage Taksaal's lineage claim it began from Sant Sunder Singh ji. Another group that has a lineage going back to the Gurus time, Bhai Daya Singh Taksaal, also has members verifying Taksaal's claim. Baba Jagjeet Singh ji Harkhowal has more than once stated that Taksaal's rahit is correct.

Re: AKJ - How much of the below is true?

jassmannn · 16 Jul 2007

Khalsa Spirit, A point was made about the AKJ beliefs that someone clarified, then I asked for further clarification, since the Dam Dami taksall thought differently which is the school of thought I have been told was right. Insead of clarifying that point you get all shifty like you've got something to hide or cover up. If you can answer the question then do so, if you can't then please don't respond to the thread and post on another topic. You are soo paranoid that people are out to get you that you are becoming malicious when you don't know me from Adam. So before you decide who I am and what I do, maybe look at your own lack of knowledge and narrow mindedness. Everyone else before you seems to respond fine to the point ok and have made clear their points of view; why do you feel the need to get personal when you don't know who I am. Like I said, stick to answering the question, and if Admin feels I am saying something inappropriate, they are free to stop me posting and block my posts.

Re: AKJ - How much of the below is true?

Khalsaspirit · 16 Jul 2007

Waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh jassmannn quote "So before you decide who I am and what I do, maybe look at your own lack of knowledge and narrow mindedness." This reaction is expected when someone's bad attention explored. Anyway keep learning about your so called clarifications. Guru Mehar Karay Waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh [%sig%]

Re: AKJ - How much of the below is true?

jassmannn · 17 Jul 2007

Khalsa Spirit, Who do you think I actually am, and what do you think I want to achieve? I don't get it? Let me here your account of my intentions. Do you think someone asking a few questions on a forum is that bad that you feel the need to bring the conversation to the gutter? If you can't answer my questions just stay out of the thread. It was all legitimate and you are just paranoid.

Re: AKJ - How much of the below is true?

kulsin · 18 Jul 2007

Dear Jassmannn Ji, If you say your intentions are not to create some bad air but just asking the question then I have to take your word for it. It is know in our community that when somebody concentrate on the difference of two people then people start to be suspicious ( including me). But I am open hearted to accept your word for it. Vir Jee Sikh community is like a big garden, in this garden you will find very different kind of flowers, every single one of it have very valuable, Very precious, very enjoyable fragrance and colour , although some are very different from each other in the colour and fragrance they are still growing up and blossoming in the same garden. Problem exist in this Garden’s vistors who visit it and just look at the difference and either say one flowerer is better then other, or one’s fragrance is better then other. Flowers themselves never say they are better then other, neither they take resources from each other they complement each other with providing fantastic scenery and enjoyable experience with variety of ways. Now these visitor who themselves something think they have allegiance to one flowerer or another are misguided as they forget the reason they are hear to be in the Garden to enjoy rather then criticise each other. I am edgy about people who bring these kind of criticism in the Garden. I love this garden and I am part of each and every flower. There is no flowerer which I don’t want to flourish and blossom, and so do the rest of the Sikh community, we have people who try to create criticism and then put words into people’s mouth to create bad smell in the Garden so to be perfectly honest that I do feel edgy when I smell this bad air. Vir Jee If you don’t mean to create bad smell then, come and mingle with AKJ and then you will have far better understanding then just asking question, we can question till the end of the world. Better choice is to experience it. You are a valuable member of the community as you put efforts into learning. My advice is why just learn from the text of internet why not experience it at first hand, I bet you let your guard down and come without any preconceived ideas to the one program arrange by AKJ and you will not go home without falling in love. I apologies to you for not replying to your comments earlier when you said, “WHy are you getting so defensive Kulsin?” I hope my this mail cover that and I hope your heart get pierced by the love of Guru Sahib and then you will not look for differences for the sake of it, you will look for the enjoyment, blessing and Love in this garden of Sikhi. Bul Chuck Maf. Kulwinder Singh [%sig%]

Re: AKJ - How much of the below is true?

jassmannn · 19 Jul 2007

Kulsin, Thanks for that nice response. Although very nice, I came onto this forum for a better understanding of Sikhi and to hear other people's opinions. Because my opinions have differed from many people on this forum, people get suspicious and have called me everything from an undercover agent, a spy, to a BBC spokesperson. As I started the post, and have neither been to the DamDAmi Taksaal, or an AKJ sat Sant, that is the most obvious comparison as they are both points of reference for 2 differing schools of thought. I wanted to clarify AKJ's opinions on what the DDT have said about key issues like Keski, Raag Mala and understand why AKJ believe as they do. Why is there a need to be suspicious. If you are able to, then I think people should answer the questions. If they have sources that I can follow, then suggest them. I have tried time and again to engage with some of these topics on this forum, but people are just not used to, or don't like people who have a difference of opinion. Then why start a forum, when all you want is to have your current held beliefs reaffirmed and allow no room for discussion or otherwise? I came as an outsider to get a better understanding, but the amount of rude responses I have had has been overwhelming.

Re: AKJ - How much of the below is true?

kulsin · 19 Jul 2007

Dear Jassmannn ji, Your question about Keski and Raag Mala can be answered in simple answer, Keski is not only used by AKJ many many other traditions also enjoy the blessing of Guru Sahib in the form of Keski. So it is not an issue for somebody who just wanted to know about AKJ. Raag Mala: there are other people who don’t believe in Raag Mala apart from AKJ. Yes this is a disagreement, Raag Mala is the last part of Guru Granth Sahib Ji. From the point of view of people who want to debate this should that should only be allowed for those who have brought the rest of the Guru Granth Sahib in their practical life, then they may have right to say anything, people who engage in this kind of debate is Like a Nursery Class child trying to debate about a M.A level subject. The whole argument then is a failure as first condition is to learn about the rest of the Guru Granth Sahib and bring that in your practical life then you may earn the right talk about this issues. Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh Ji of AKJ was a fantastic level Sikhs and So was the Sant Gurbachan Singh Ji of Damdami Taksal both had fantastic relationship. It is naïve and emotional people who fall in the trap of getting into conflicts About this thing, It is not an issue for Sikh Panth it is an issue for people who want to show either their physical power, political power or metal power or some other kind of ego. The bottom line is no body in the world is going to make anybody read something they don’t want to read or stop them from what they want to read. Either way you cant compel somebody to follow one way or other. As I said different flowers of Sikh have different colours and different fragrances , so the difference is very easy to pick but the intelligent Sikh would not pick the difference for the hell of creating conflict they will celebrate the Varity of Guru Sahib’s Garden and stand up to protect each and every flower of this garden. People who encourage us to fight on these issue, we need to be aware of them and aware of our own actions, thoughts and feeling and keep on rechecking ourselves are we walking towards Guru Sahib or walking away from him. Be 100% clear if you love your Father Guru Gobind Singh Ji you will never ever even think of any ill will for his other chidren. I hope Jassmannn ji I have answered your question. Dear Jassmannn ji we do have people lurking around the Sikh community to incite the emotional and naive Sikhs to say unpleasant remarks about other Sections of the Sikh Community, That is the reason when somebody pick these controversial topics people smell the bad air even when the intentions are right. So please try to understand that. The people who have called you names they are just worried about these kind of things, they don’t mean any harm they just feel bit protective as in the past many Anti Sikh people do try to satire up the bad feelings. Which up to certain level fault of us rather then other people never the less encouragement to fight do exist and we are bit suspicious of these kind of topics. Please feel free to ask any valuable questions. I do value your quest for answers we just need to be careful how we handle them. Thanks Kulwinder Singh [%sig%]

Re: AKJ - How much of the below is true?

Harjas Kaur · 19 Jul 2007

[quote]Why is there a need to be suspicious.[/quote] Because maybe this is one of the most persecuted Jathas in the gallughara and persisting even today? [quote]As I started the post, and have neither been to the DamDAmi Taksaal, or an AKJ sat Sant, that is the most obvious comparison as they are both points of reference for 2 differing schools of thought.[/quote] What is a sat Sant? Do you think this is Sant Mat or something? Or is this another deliberate misportrayal? You were already told that you cannot learn about a Jatha from the internet. If you want to know then go to a samagam program. All you are doing is critically debating, dividing, and defending your bad approach. The differences are simple. People have already stated them to you and provided abundant links. You aren't here to learn, you're here to criticize. And that's what is unappreciated and giving you the negative response. how can anyone trust you when you make statements calculated to offend? Which is altogether different from an expression of question or different opinion. Your views really do resemble thos of Niddar and the Sanatan Dharam Nihung faction which has been terribly abusive of AKJ, hence the suspicion of your tone and divisive quality of your comparisons. No one learns about one Jatha by debating every point of difference against another. That's a ploy. You say you've never been to DamDami Taksal, so what is the purpose in your line of questioning? I personally attend a Taksali Gurudwara majority of the time, and I have never been poorly received. And I always show most respect to Guru, since Gurudwara is house of Guru and all Taksalis are my brothers and sisters. So what the hell is your agenda? [%sig%]

Re: AKJ - How much of the below is true?

jassmannn · 20 Jul 2007

Harjas Kaur, thanks for your imput, but not one person has compared the link I sent about DDT and the AKJ School of thought. No one has answered the points which were made in the post from the DDT web link I sent, so my questions has not been answered. Why can't people discuss like human beings, why do you always think it's going to turn into some sort of riot. I'm not turning it into a riot. I don't know why you think it will become one. You said: "Your views really do resemble thos of Niddar and the Sanatan Dharam Nihung faction which has been terribly abusive of AKJ" I don't even know who those groups and people are so no comment on that point. And I meant Sat Sang, not Sat Sant - that's a typo. But I suppose it gave you an opportunity for a dig. About the internet issue, soo many people of knowledge on this forum and other have put the thoughts forward from books and internet sites. I just want some fact base info, not a spiritual experience. That's all I want, I don't understand the hullaballoo. OK, I close this thread on my part, I'm obviously not going to get the info I want, so It's fine. I'll look for other sources.