Re: Was Maharaja Ranjit Singh an incarnation of Aurangzeb?
Harjas Kaur · 14 Jul 2007
I don't know if the story is true or not. But I don't see how it would create a bad image for the Sikhs. Guruji is about liberation and kirpa. So if Guru decided to save and care for Aurangzeb, anything can happen. Definitely he would be born in a Gursikh family. And definitely he would be given the chance to make amends. Isn't that what mukti is all about?
~Bhull chak maaf karni Ji
[%sig%]
Re: Was Maharaja Ranjit Singh an incarnation of Aurangzeb?
Kulbir Singh · 16 Jul 2007
Aurangzeb and Maharaja Ranjit Singh did not have much in common. I have heard of this theory that Maharaja was an incarnation of Aurangzeb but if you compare the two personalities, it seems hard to believe this theory. Aurangzeb was a very strict Muslim who strictly adhered to Sharia the rehit of Muslims and Maharaja on the other hand was not too much of a Rehitvan Sikh since there are reports of him getting indulged in liquor and womanizing in his later life. Aurangzeb was not known to be a womanizer and nor was he a drinker. He tried to lead his life according to Islamic piety.
At the age of 35 he started memorizing Koran Shareef and within couple of years he had whole of Koran Shareef memorized. He did not use the royal treasure for food. It is said that he used to do binding of Koran and money earned from this hard work, was used on making his food. Maharaja on the other hand was engaged in Sikhi as Aurangzeb was to Islam.
Aurangzeb was known to hate Hindus but Maharaja did not have such rigidness. He loved all people and his court employed all kind of people including Hindus, Muslims and Sikhs.
Aurangzeb did not have a harem as his predecessors did and he was not into Kaam (womanizing) whereas Maharaja had 15-20 wives and committed Kaam-related mistakes e.g. the incident of courtesan called Moraan of Amritsar for which he later was punished at Siri Akal Takhat Sahib.
As the matter of fact, I don't see any striking similarity between Aurangzeb and Maharaja. It's hard to believe that Aurangzeb was born as Maharaja.
[%sig%]
Re: Was Maharaja Ranjit Singh an incarnation of Aurangzeb?
Rashpal Singh · 16 Jul 2007
VaheguruJiKaKhalsa
VaheguruJiKiFateh
I've always wondered did Maharaja Ranjit Singh take amrit at any time in his life?
[%sig%]
Re: Was Maharaja Ranjit Singh an incarnation of Aurangzeb?
Harjas Kaur · 16 Jul 2007
Sangat Ji please forgive my foolishness. But I have often wondered about this possibility.
Re: Was Maharaja Ranjit Singh an incarnation of Aurangzeb?
Kulbir Singh · 17 Jul 2007
----------
The attributes of a person do not necesserily have to be passed on to the next life they take up. So, Aurag may have had certain traits it does not mean that M Ranjit Singh would have the same. So comparing the two and saying one was like this and the other was like this - one was womainser and the other was not etc - seems pointless.
-----------
The basic inclinations, propensities and instincts of a person do not change janam to janam. If a person was krodhi in his previous life and died like that (i.e. a krodhi) that person will be krodhi in his next janam too. If you think about it logically, it would make sense because all that happens by taking new janam is that the jeev-aatma gets a new body. Everything else stays the same. It is the same person with same qualities and ideas who takes new birth. Just because you get a new body does not means that one's personality changes too.
True, that one's memory is erased in order to give one an other chance. The only way to change one's inclincations and basic nature is through gyaan. Naam and Gurbani are the ultimate gyaan and rubbing one's mann with these divine detergents one can change one's basic nature.
[%sig%]
Re: Was Maharaja Ranjit Singh an incarnation of Aurangzeb?
Harjas Kaur · 17 Jul 2007
[quote]The basic inclinations, propensities and instincts of a person do not change janam to janam. If a person was krodhi in his previous life and died like that (i.e. a krodhi) that person will be krodhi in his next janam too.[/quote]
This is true. There is a physical resemblance between them. But not at all a spiritual one. Thank you all for clarifying, because I had wondered when I saw the pictures.
[%sig%]
Re: Was Maharaja Ranjit Singh an incarnation of Aurangzeb?
Khalsaspirit · 18 Jul 2007
Waheguru ji ka khalsa
Waheguru ji ki fateh
Khalsa jio,
Reading all posts on this topic sounds like Maharaja Ranjit Singh was alcoholic, womanizer etc. Yet we see Maharaja Ranjit Singh as a wise, well disciplined, kind hearted, visionary (by brain) best of the best and unmatch ruler in world history yet. In his raaj we had best Jathedaars for every field from Sri Akal Takhat Sahib to battle fields of Kabul. We do not think his raaj was weaker from any point. Yes he had a small weakness of having many Ranees. But every one have to understand that once you are great ruler and established the best empire on a certain terrain which was never been stabilized in more than 10 centuries. Do not you think the forces who were against will sit quietly? These forces continually worked to weaken Sikh Raaj by indulging Maharaja in Ranees. Luring him by certain cabinet members about this showed some effect. But see for this he accepted the Sri Akal Takhat Sahib Hukam and presented himself before panth. He has such a high regard for panth, for Sri Akal Takhat Sahib, for Sri Darbar Sahib that he never shown even a single time his Rajagiri against those highest institutions of Khalsa Panth. Routinely did the Sangat so how he can be bad as posed in this topic. This single example shows such an extreme regard for sangat.
Once upon time Ranjit Singh was sitting in Darbar Sahib listening to kirtan. A poor boy with some dirty cloths after doing Matha Take unknowingly sat ahead(facing towards Guru Sahib and back before Raja) Ranjit Singh. Some guards saw this and rushed to the boy to move him forcefully, Ranjit Singh immediatly shouted to them "leave him there THIS IS GURU SAHIB'S DARBAR NOT OF KANNA RANJIT SINGH"
That was his extreme regard for Sangat even had all the power even he himself called him Kanna (single eyed). How such a person can go so low. No way, it is just written to defame him. And who are we to highlight his weakness. We have thousands more than him today. All we remember him as a great ruler whose has his highest regard for Sri Akal Takhat Sahib and had one of the best Jathedaars of Sikh history in army who had highest level of character which every Sikh must have. On the other hand Aurangzeb was opposite.
Although this is also true that some dhillan also started in his rule but they are not related in any manner to his weakness.
Guru Mehar Karay
Waheguru ji ka khalsa
Waheguru ji ki fateh
[%sig%]
Re: Was Maharaja Ranjit Singh an incarnation of Aurangzeb?
Mehtab Singh · 30 Jul 2007
Afghans hate his legacy, primarily because it was Maharaja Ranjit Singh's main army general Sardar Hari Singh Nalwa who gave the Afghans a befitting reply, something they never thought they'd get.
[%sig%]