Re: Can the creator of the universe be seperate from it?
fresno sikh · 27 Jul 2007
SSAKAL
Chandra Singh some views of Baba Nand SIngh ji from his biography. This is Kalyug, Guru Nanak is the True satguru. Kalyug age is 432000 years. After 38000 years there will be khalsa raj. Satjug Avtar Vishnu ji, Treta Avtar Ram ji, Dawapar avatar Sri krishan ji. But Guru Gobind Singh ji said in Krishan Avatar Dasam Granth "Main Na Ganesha pratham Manaeo Kishan Bishan Kabhu na Dhaiayo" . The universe came about with one word "Oankar". You can tell all this to your employer Govt of India who has hired you to spread confusion on various websites among sikhs.
Re: Can the creator of the universe be seperate from it?
Harjas Kaur · 28 Jul 2007
[quote]I don't dispute your view. What you wrote above is Hindu view too. But Abrahamic view is that God created world 5000 years ago (without explaining where was the God before the creation) and creation is moving linearly towards the end i.e judgment day. In short, there is a beginning and end. This is in contrast to what you said above.
As i said this post was for spiritually illiterate Khalsitanis who view sikhi in the mold of monotheism and feel proud of themself as follower of one true god. Basically trying to mimic Muslims and christians without having any clue about what in realty sikhi is about.[/quote]
Chandra says...See you Sikhs have Hindu beliefs just like us! We're not like those spiritually illiterate Abrahamic idiots the Christians, the Muslims and the Khalistanis!
Of course he can never answer why Guru Sahib blessed even the Abrahamics, out of whom many became Sikhs.
Chandra, in the years I've read your posts, you always say the same thing over and over. Stop and think, when is labeling anyone a spiritual idiot a sign of spiritual maturity in oneself? Rather it makes you look the idiot to make so outrageous an assertion.
[quote]for spiritually illiterate Khalsitanis who view sikhi in the mold of monotheism and feel proud of themself as follower of one true god. Basically trying to mimic Muslims and christians without having any clue about what in realty sikhi is about.[/quote]
Only Guruji has the complete understanding of what Sikhi is about. Guru says:
[quote]EuN nmo BgvMq gusweI ] (897-1, rwmklI, mÚ 5)
oN namo bhagvant gusaa-ee.
I humbly pray to invoke the Universal Lord God, the Lord of the World.
Kwlku riv rihAw srb TweI ]1] rhwau ] (897-1, rwmklI, mÚ 5)
khaalak rav rahi-aa sarab thaa-ee. ||1|| rahaa-o.
The Creator Lord is all-pervading, everywhere. ||1||Pause||
jgMnwQ jgjIvn mwDo ] (897-2, rwmklI, mÚ 5)
jagannaath jagjeevan maaDho.
He is the Lord of the Universe, the Life of the World.
Bau BMjn ird mwih ArwDo ] (897-2, rwmklI, mÚ 5)
bha-o bhanjan rid maahi araaDho.
Within your heart, worship and adore the Destroyer of fear.
irKIkys gopwl guoivMd ] (897-2, rwmklI, mÚ 5)
rikheekays gopaal govind.
The Master Rishi of the senses, Lord of the World, Lord of the Universe.
pUrn srbqR mukMd ]2] (897-2, rwmklI, mÚ 5)
pooran sarbatar mukand. ||2||
He is perfect, ever-present everywhere, the Liberator. ||2||
imhrvwn maulw qUhI eyk ] (897-3, rwmklI, mÚ 5)
miharvaan ma-ulaa toohee ayk.
You are the One and only merciful Master,
pIr pYkWbr syK ] (897-3, rwmklI, mÚ 5)
peer paikaaNbar saykh.
spiritual teacher, prophet, religious teacher.
idlw kw mwlku kry hwku ] (897-3, rwmklI, mÚ 5)
dilaa kaa maalak karay haak.
Master of hearts, Dispenser of justice,
kurwn kqyb qy pwku ]3] (897-3, rwmklI, mÚ 5)
kuraan katayb tay paak. ||3||
more sacred than the Koran and the Bible. ||3||
nwrwiex nrhr dieAwl ] (897-4, rwmklI, mÚ 5)
naaraa-in narhar da-i-aal.
The Lord is powerful and merciful.
rmq rwm Gt Gt AwDwr ] (897-4, rwmklI, mÚ 5)
ramat raam ghat ghat aaDhaar.
The all-pervading Lord is the support of each and every heart.
bwsudyv bsq sB Twie ] (897-4, rwmklI, mÚ 5)
baasudayv basat sabh thaa-ay.
The luminous Lord dwells everywhere.
lIlw ikCu lKI n jwie ]4] (897-5, rwmklI, mÚ 5)
leelaa kichh lakhee na jaa-ay. ||4||
His play cannot be known. ||4||
imhr dieAw kir krnYhwr ] (897-5, rwmklI, mÚ 5)
mihar da-i-aa kar karnaihaar.
Be kind and compassionate to me, O Creator Lord.
Bgiq bMdgI dyih isrjxhwr ] (897-5, rwmklI, mÚ 5)
bhagat bandagee deh sirjanhaar.
Bless me with devotion and meditation, O Lord Creator.
khu nwnk guir Koey Brm ] (897-6, rwmklI, mÚ 5)
kaho naanak gur kho-ay bharam.
Says Nanak, the Guru has rid me of doubt.
eyko Alhu pwrbRhm ]5]34]45] (897-6, rwmklI, mÚ 5)
ayko alhu paarbarahm. ||5||34||45||
The Muslim God Allah and the Hindu God Paarbrahm are one and the same. ||5||34||45||
-SGGS Ji p. 897[/quote]
[%sig%]
Re: Can the creator of the universe be seperate from it?
Harjas Kaur · 03 Aug 2007
[quote]There is contradiction in the above two quotes by you. People with even minimal knowledge of Abrahamic theology know that Abrahamic God is not omnipresent. [/quote]
Chandra jio,
Don't you think it's rather simplistic to interpret all Abrahamic theology? Seriously, I can actually see the argument that Buddhism is derived from Hinduism. But I disagree that Buddhism IS Hinduism. The differences are there as well. Now, when you say "Abrahamic. All Abrahamic religions teach..." It brings to mind a rhetorical discussion intended for the simple minded.
Let's have some intellectual honesty. A Jew, is his theology the same as Christian? A Christian, is his theology the same as Muslim? A Wahabi Muslim, is his theology the same as a Shia, a Sufi, a Bahai?
Chandra Ji, not even all Jews are the same. Not even all Christians are the same. How can you say, "All Abrahamics believe..." It's terribly short-sighted. Give credit where credit is due. Yes, I agree with some of your point. But your scholarship is sloppy. A Sufi Muslim did not share the same narrow conception and definition of God which a fundamentalist political militant missionary has. And this is why bhagats who were Sufi have written bani which is accepted by Sikhi like Baba Farid and Kabir Ji.
The error is not in translation. The error is you try to force every Abrahamic based belief system into the worst one.
Jewish Belief is NOT what Chandra says:
[quote]Mainstream Orthodox Judaism teaches that God is neither matter nor spirit. They teach that God is the creator of both, but is himself neither. But if God is so different from his creation, how can there be any interaction between the Creator and the created? This question prompted early Kabbalists (Jewish mystics) to envision two aspects of God, (a) God himself, who in the end is unknowable, and (b) the revealed aspect of God, His "light," which created the universe, preserves the universe, and interacts with mankind in a personal way. Kabbalists believe that these two aspects are not contradictory but complement one another, similar to a creation inside a person's mind.
This view has been developed further in Hasidic and anti-nomian circles, however. Kabbalah teaches that in order to create the physical universe, God "withdrew" His light, and created the universe within the space from which "He" contracted ("Zimzum"). It is taught in the Zohar that God, at the beginning of creation...God shattered the vessels to hide His unity, allowing creation to seem separate.
With this in mind, the Kabbalist Isaac Luria, explained that all creation contained ("nitzutz" or "holy sparks") — the remnants and shards of the sephiroth/kaylim which God had shattered — and offered a theological purpose known as ("Tikkun Olam" or "rectifying the world") which states that humanity's duty is to recognize the holy sparks inherent in all creation and to elevate them... Ultimately, this will reveal God's unity once again, but this time through our efforts. This work to perfect the world is the ultimate good that God bestows on mankind. This view gave rise to the concept of panentheism in Judaism: The notion that God is inherent in all things, and is corroborated by the Jewish principle ("b'tzelem Elohim" or "in the image of God"), inferring that all humanity is created with God inherent. The concept derives from Genesis 9:6 (serving as a Biblical proof-text for the position), "For in the image of God He made man." Thus, suggested Luria, by doing mitzvoth directed towards our fellow human being, we recognize the nitzutz within them, and thus sanctify and elevate their inherent Godliness.
This notion is exemplified rather well by a Jewish nursery school song
Hashem is here, Hashem is there, Hashem is truly everywhere. Up, up, down, down, right, left, and all around. Here, there, and everywhere, is where He can be found.
Over time, this view evolved into the belief that all of creation and all of existence was in fact God itself, and that we as humanity are unaware of our own inherent Godliness and are grappling to come to terms with it. The standing view in neo-Hasidism, currently, is that there is nothing in existence other than God. I.e., all being is God. As it is stated in the ancient Kabbalistic incantation, ("Ain od milvado") — "There is nothing but God." Thus, it has become understood that God used God's self to form the universe...
So if "God is everything," why are you and I here? Because we are the appearance of God in this particular form. And God likes to appear in countless forms and experience countless lives...We are not so far advanced yet that we can explain all these things, but deep down, the deepest level of the pattern is that God is everything. So it's not that God created the world but that God became the world.
[url]http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kabbalistic_definition_of_God[/url][/quote]
Christian Belief is NOT what Chandra says:
[quote]34"Then the King will say to those on his right, 'Come, you who are blessed by my Father; take your inheritance, the kingdom prepared for you since the creation of the world. 35 For I was hungry and you gave me something to eat, I was thirsty and you gave me something to drink, I was a stranger and you invited me in, 36 I needed clothes and you clothed me, I was sick and you looked after me, I was in prison and you came to visit me.'
37"Then the righteous will answer him, 'Lord, when did we see you hungry and feed you, or thirsty and give you something to drink? 38 When did we see you a stranger and invite you in, or needing clothes and clothe you? 39 When did we see you sick or in prison and go to visit you?'
40"The King will reply, 'I tell you the truth, whatever you did for one of the least of these brothers of mine, you did for me.' -Matthew chap. 25
Here you see Christians who believe that Jesus is one with the God, or even a part of God, also teach in their scriptures that every least brother is the same as jesus. And whatever you do to the least and to the poor and suffering, you actually do it for God.
------------------------------------------------------------
Genesis 1:26 (New American Standard Bible)
26 Then God said, "Let Us make man in Our image, according to Our likeness; and let them rule over the fish of the sea and over the birds of the sky and over the cattle and over all the earth, and over every creeping thing that creeps on the earth."[/quote]
Christians have used this scripture to teach human beings are made in the image and likeness of God. And whatever anyone does to harm a human being is wounding the heart of God. One of the most beautiful expressions of this teaching is found in Catholic liberation theology. During the repression of the El Salvadoran civil war, when Death Squads were torturing and murdering thousands, Archbishop Oscar Romero spoke out to defend human rights. Despite arrest and death threats he continued to try to stop the slaughter appealing to the conscience and highest spirituality of the persecutors. He was assassinated for being a human rights defender. How can you say everything that he believed in was an Abrahamic lie?
This is what I mean by give credit where credit is due. Anyone can take the worst example of any nationality or any religion and positively demonize its best qualities. We don't have to be afraid of other religions, or bully them to prove superiority. Have confidence in the beauty and truths of your own religion, so you can respect the highest good and most precious things in the teachings of every human faith. The world is in so much trauma now. If everyone embraced the highest ideals of their own religious teachings we would have real brotherhood.
Every religion worth the name is a defender of human rights and human dignity. And every religion can become corrupted to betray it's primary purpose which is the evolution of the human spirit and genuine love of the God in every manifestation. Anything that humiliates, degrades, disparages, denies, bullies, traumatizes, justifies torture and cruelty and murder is not a true religious teaching. Because it violates the justice of the God. And anything that defends, protects, nourishes, heals, blesses, reconciles, brings hope, loves and cherishes living beings, that teaching is a true teaching.
We all know better. If we concentrated on being good, we could stop promoting suffering in this world in the name of religion. Chandra, I will fight against any missionary. But you're just trashing peoples beliefs in general. You DON'T have to believe them. If people took to heart the most beautiful teachings of all religions, we would all be sants.
One of the saddest notions is this attempt to divide people as Indic or Abrahamic. Chandra Ji, do you know all your past incarnations? Do you realize the body is just a cloak you wear? Do you realize at the core of the atma there is no such thing as Indic or Abrahamic? There is only Akal Purakh. Our religion needs to be love of every human being, and not just those close to us. Our cause needs to be human rights, and not just our own communities rights. We need to be broadminded, because the God is one and every living being on the planet is a part of the oneness of Waheguru.
BTW while I have your attention, please check out this link. Thanks.
10 Years - Wasteland
[url]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EkKz7fyGECM[/url]
Rwanda
~bhul chak maaf
[%sig%]
Re: Can the creator of the universe be seperate from it?
Harjas Kaur · 04 Aug 2007
I pretty much agree with Vijaydeep's assessment. Of course there are errors in religious teachings, especially since they are so removed from the original utterances of their teachers.
But yes, their are particular sects within major religions who cause a majority of the world's grief. Personally, I believe Abrahamic religions are derived from the Vedas. Early Gnostic Christians resided in India and Tibet and made their way with a very Buddhist influenced version of Christianity into China, called the Pure Land Sect which is now a branch of Buddhism. But it started with the Gnostic Christian, Mani. The Tibetan lamas still have preserved writings from Mani, who called himself Christ, in their monasteries. Unfortunately modern Christians have completely lost touch with these early teachings.
I honestly believe the original Jesus was a very holy man who taught reincarnation, karma-dharma, and yoga. Certainly he was a vegetarian and celibate ascetic who never cut his hair. He meditated for days in solitude. Early Christianity was a monastic movement. He believed in the oneness of God as something that included enlightenment. "The kingdom of Heaven is within you." "I and my Father are one."
The language of a sant is really universal. We all know what goodness is. I have respect for good teachings, but I do not deny the worst interpretations are believed by the majority in the kaliyug. Missionaries really are a plague and have nothing to do with spiritual teachings. They are based on racist/nationalist intolerance for anything different. No one should attack the good things in Christian religion. But absolutely oppose disruptive and hateful missionary activities.
Christian extremists disrupt Hindu Senate invocation
[url]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EZ9To30Hz7A[/url]
They were from a group called "Operation Save America." Well, if they take their own slogan to heart, they should do America a favor and kill themselves for the good of the whole. Seriously, no one should tolerate fanatical and abusive missionaries.
One thing I really dislike about missionaries is when they ask you if you believe in God...they also ask what God? Because they can't believe you even have the same God. And some even think you believe in a devil-god because you look different. Absolutely Guruji said that Allah is the same as Parabrahm. Names are just sound vibrations of blown air by human beings. The real spiritual concepts are far beyond the conceptions of human brains or the delimiting definitions of human religions. But the one true Akal Purakh is spiritual reality for the whole world, however limited the world's understanding. Pure truth is always pure truth, no matter what anybody's opinion is.
~Bhul chak maaf
[%sig%]