Punjab’s economy riddled with paradoxes
sy · 25 Jul 2007
Punjab’s economy riddled with paradoxes Sarbjit Dhaliwal Tribune News Service Chandigarh, November 14 “Punjabis are the most globalised but Punjab’s economy is the least globalised. This is reflected in the nominal foreign direct investment(FDI) of 0.7 per cent in the state. It has a highly developed agriculture but without much direct linkages with industrial development”, says the report on “ Suicides in Rural Punjab” prepared by the Institute for Development and Communication( IDC) and sponsored by the Punjab State Farmers Commission. Analysing the crisis of the agrarian transformation and indebtedness-related suicides of farmers and landless farm labour in Punjab, the report says that employment in industry is less than 5 persons per thousand in the state compared to 7 persons in India as a whole. Paradoxes of Punjab’s socio-political economy are very sharp and shocking. Punjab figures among the states with highest per capita income, but has dismal social development which is clearly reflected in highly skewed sex ratio because of the high rate of female foeticide and farmers suicide. The state has an overall low poverty level but poverty among the dalits is five times higher. Though the state has the highest percentage of Dalit population, it has low access to schools, land and services. The state has highly developed infrastructure but the quality of public service delivery is poor and prohibitively costly. A survey conducted by the Public Affairs Centre places Punjab 11th in the quality of services among 16 major states. The report says that the planned capital expenditure of the government was Rs 2,375 where as the revenue expenditure is Rs 21,429 crore ( Budget2006-07). It means capital expenditure is only 11 per cent of the revenue expenditure. The most significant fact is the decline in the per capita income of the agricultural sector from Rs 12,375 in 2001-02 to Rs 11,587 in 2003-04. There has been slowdown in the economy and it has the third lowest growth rate among major states. Agriculture has witnessed slowdown as far as its growth is concerned. Because of declining trend in farmers income, large number of marginal and small farmers have been pushed into the vicious circle of debt. To fulfill their requirements and bridge gap between income and expenditure, farmers have been borrowing mostly from non institutional institutions. In Punjab 65.4 per cent farmer households are indebted and in Andhra Pradesh the number is 82 per cent. Over the years, the indebtedness among farmers has increased and it is because of unproductive expenditure, the need for more capital in agriculture, and the need to spend more on farm operations. Unemployment rate has gone up from 3.10 per cent to 4.03 per cent. Interestingly, as the far as general suicide trend is concerned, Kerala tops in the country. There number of suicides is 28.9 per lakh population, 22.7 in Karnataka and 18.7 in Tamilnadu. And compared to these states, suicide rate is much lower in Punjab. It is ranked 28th in all-India ranking. As many as 71.43 per cent small, 68.83 per cent semi medium and 48.67 per cent medium and 72.74 large farmers from their respective categories take short term credit from commission agents. That means informal sector advances huge amount of money to the farm sector.