Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

< Weekly Article >

< Weekly Article >

jagroop singh · 27 May 2004

TITLE: When Things Go Seriously Wrong SUB TITLE: So who’s to blame and should account for BBC Asian Network’s major mishap…Kiri the 22-year-old guest, the show’s Production Team or the Presenter? BY LINE: It’s time to look at the technical aspects surrounding the way in which the show was constructed, directed and executed. It is only in this way that we will be able to progress and truly understand not only why this happened, but also which issues can be challenged and pursued. ARTICLE: According to an email I read last week, which appears to be a response from the show’s Senior Producer Rabiya Parekh (who is Muslim), the necessary ‘checks’ were made regarding Kiri. What actually were these checks is the 64 million-dollar question. I worked at a BBC Local Radio Station for 9 months as a trainee Broadcast Journalist. It is due to this experience of mine that the first thought that popped into my head upon hearing the now infamous comments made by Kiri was: Did the Production Team do their job properly? From a ‘production perspective’ let’s analyse the components. According to Kiri (one of two guests) religion was forced upon her from both sides – her ‘Sikh’ father and her ‘Muslim’ mother have always wanted her to sign their respective religions’ ‘dotted lines’; a competition as it were. Nigel was the other guest whose parentage is Catholic/Sikh – the difference being his parents didn’t force anything upon him. He came across as open-minded and completely secure and credited his parents for this positive outcome. The show in terms of set-up sounds absolutely balanced; we have both sides of the fence here so the Production Team had done a good job to this extent. But things soon begin to go a bit haywire. The theme of the discussion is ‘Do inter-religious marriages work?’. Any Radio Producer or Presenter will tell you that when you’re doing a discussion show, keep the guests and callers to the theme – allow tangents every now and again but do not, especially when the subject matter is potentially controversial, allow the guests or callers to construct their own rail-roads off the subject. Simply speaking, you’re asking for trouble if you don’t follow this golden rule. Sonia’s directive skills boded well to begin with; but Kiri just didn’t want to talk about the subject of her email - the very reason she appeared on the show is because she wanted help regarding ‘breaking the news’ to her father that she had chosen Islam over Sikhi. She had chosen Islam over Sikhi because she didn’t want to; “burn in the fires of hell”. The half-way mark is a good point at which to stand back and assess the show thus far. Three callers have been let through who all add points of interest to the debate. Kiri’s comments about having chosen her path haven’t overshadowed or displaced the main theme of the discussion. Sonia seems to want to analyse Kiri’s choice…and it is at this point that the Production Team, and her own personal sense of judgement, may have failed her. The BBC’s Presenters, Producers and Broadcast Assistants have at their disposal a live communication system via their computer screens. The BBC’s ENPS (Electronic News Production System) among many other things allows them to type messages to one another whilst on air. If the Producer (having sounded-out the guest before the show goes live on air) senses that things may be a bit risky, he/she can quickly send a message to the Presenter who doesn’t have to stop listening or speaking to the guests/callers. The question is, was the Producer aware that this line of questioning would produce controversial answers? In other words, what was the extent of her checks – did she talk to Kiri about her particular brand of Islamic philosophy? It is when Sonia asks her as to what she; ‘liked about one over the other’ (because Sonia finds that ‘interesting’) that Kiri runs with it…and boy does she run. She can pronounce Qu’ran and Hadith as well as any Arab-national yet she evidently knew nothing regarding Sikhi. For her, Islamic literature backs-up any ‘arguments’ there may be yet ‘Guru Nanak Singh’ and Siree Guru Granth Sahib Jee do not contain a lot of ‘evidence’. She seems very confused about who taught her what about Sikhi – she’s ‘read through their ways’ yet knows less than a non-Sikh primary school child exposed to a handful of Religious Education classes. On the other hand, she drops the name of a bookshop which sells Islamic literature! Poor Nigel mentions that in Sikhi Siree Guru Granth Sahib Jee provides a source/evidence. Kiri then goes on to make her unacceptable comments and Sonia quite rightly rebukes her and then later goes on to ask her how much she has researched Sikhi. My dear Sonia, why did you have to try and put a teeny-weeny plaster over a great bug gushing wound! Never mind; I’ll explain later! Kiri glosses over the question and mumbles that she has studied; ‘books on their ways etc.’ and concludes she has made her decision. As to why she can’t even pronounce Siree Guru Nanak Sahib Jee’s name properly yet claims to have studied Sikhi, Kiri’s golden response to a caller named Tajinder is: ‘I’ve done…[remains continuously speechless and then stutters]…done what I need to do’. I think it is highly likely that Kiri is someone who came onto the show simply to ‘put across’ the ‘fact’ that she had made an informed choice and chosen Islam over Sikhi, thereby indirectly demoting the perceived worth (amongst listeners) of the latter. It’s the kind of cheap stunt one would expect from members/sympathisers of right-wing ‘Islamist’ groups such as Hizb-ut-Tahrir or Al Muhajiroun who love nothing more than ‘proving’ the supremacy of Islam over everything else. The Production Team could have ‘sounded Kiri out’ more before she showed-up on the day. I am sure they know that religion (whether it features directly or indirectly as part of a live discussion) is always going to be a sensitive area. Therefore, by trying to ascertain exactly what this guest’s views were regarding Sikhi, the Production Team could have realised that she in fact had a distinctly pro-Islamic Supremacist agenda. Rabiya Parekh the Senior Producer must answer this query. This whole episode is all the more upsetting when one considers that later on, Raj (the second from last caller) is cut-off when he according to Sonia; ‘seems to be suggesting mixed marriages between religions will not work if you marry a Muslim’. In fact she made a point of saying slightly earlier regarding Kiri that some of the things she said were; ‘completely wrong…she was corrected – I hope that was satisfactory for you’. Well Sonia, it wasn’t satisfactory for us…why didn’t you cut-off Kiri whose comments when compared to Raj’s words made the former’s diatribe seem like a tender love song! I’m not saying you should be sacked by the BBC or forever more reviled by Sikhs, but seriously consider how you could have done a better job. And before you ask, here’s what I would have said to Kiri if I had been in Sonia’s shoes: “Right; you have the opportunity to withdraw those disgusting comments and apologise now; that is before you leave the studio after you have done so. Otherwise, you will lose this chance, and I will have no option but to ask that you put down your headphones and leave the studio immediately. Your comments are unbelievable and have hurt my sentiments and many of our listeners because not only are they wholly inappropriate but they are extremely prejudiced. They are also perverse and show your contempt for the Sikh community and others who respect Siree Guru Nanak Sahib Jee. What’s it going to be Kiri?”. It’s worth mentioning at this point that according to a letter sent to me in response to an official complaint I recently made, Dawn Varney (Assistant Head of Programme Complaints) states: “It will take a little time to review the relevant material and talk to the people responsible…we should be in a position to give you a response by 16th June 2004 unless we encounter any unexpected delays”. Well, let’s see what they come up with. Meanwhile, Kiri if you’re reading this, here’s a word of sincere advice. When you recite your Namaaz later today, humbly beg The One God who is truly Al Rehman (Most Gracious), Al Rahim (Most Merciful) to forgive you for what you have said. For just as Siree Guru Gobind Singh Sahib Jee told the cruel Arungzeb that if The Prophet Muhammad were here upon earth, he would inform him of Aurangzeb’s treachery, you also have taken upon your shoulders a heavy burden which will not go unnoticed in the True Court of The True Lord. (This article appeared in The Sikh Times, a UK-based English/Punjabi national newspaper)