Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

guru gobind singh - goat?

guru gobind singh - goat?

kar kirpaa sabh rayN thheevaa · 18 Jun 2004

vaaheguroo jee kaa khaalsaa vaaheguroo jee kee fatheh !! in max arthur mccauliffe's sikh history book, he says that after coming out of the macchiwaraa jungle, guru jee stayed at a house of a poor Hindu along with Daya Singh and Dharam Singh mccauliffe says that guru jee was quite tired / hungry from the rest in the jungle and he shot a goat and ate it while he was staying at the house. later on gani khan and nabi khan came and they went as "uch ka pir" out of the area. vaaheguroo jee kaa khaalsaa vaaheguroo jee kee fatheh !!

Re: guru gobind singh - goat?

Jarnail Singh Arshi Gyani · 18 Jun 2004

Waheguru Ji Ka Khlasa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh. And the story further goes.....The Hindu was scared of the noise of goat slaughter and smell of cooking the meat as the next door neighbour was the KAZI.... But GURU JI not only slaughtered the goat, cooked it BUT THREW all the BONES over the Wall into the KAZI's Compound.......when GURU JI heard the KAZI muttering and complaining, He then THREW some GOLD MOHARS over the Wall and the KAZI became CALM immediately..... Dass jarnail Singh

Re: guru gobind singh - goat?

anon · 19 Jun 2004

guru ji was tired or hungry? if you can believe that then you dont have much faith.

Re: guru gobind singh - goat?

Jarnail Singh Arshi Gyani · 19 Jun 2004

WAHEGURU JI KA KHALSA WAHEGURU JI KI FATEH. DEAR ANON: You have hit the nail right on its head. The trouble with us kacheeh- pillay singhs is that we "judge" GURU JI on our puny level. 1. So many sikhs went to complain to Mata Gujri Ji about what GURU JI was doing in Anadpur Sahib Fort during the seige believing Mata Ji could "put some sense" into Guru Ji ??? 2. So many Sikhs pleaded with GURU JI to take the swearings/oaths/promises of the Hindu Rajas and Mughal Generals at WORTH and evacuate the Fort Anandpur and no harm would come.....GURU JI repeatedly told them these promises oaths are FALSE...but the Sikhs kept insisting that Guru Ji follow their advice.....Then GURU JI even PROVED His point by loading the donkeys with RUBBISH/GARBAGE and passing it off as the GURU'S TREASURE KHAZANAH.....and in the wink of an eye the Mughals attacked the convoy of Donkeys carrying Garbage with intention to LOOT the Khazanah.....GURU Ji was proved RIGHT. 3. The 40 Sikhs inssited on writing the BEDAWA to GURU JI inspite of repeated assurances from GURU JI to just wait a bit more ??? If these SIKHS could DOUBT GURU JI right to HIS FACE.....is it any wonder that even TODAY there are "SINGHS"....who read these FAIRY TALES and believe them rather than Have COMPLETE FAITH in GURU JI. Some other religion have no qualms in beleiving something totally UNNATURAL such as Virgin Birth...... We Sikhs cant even put our Faith in GURU JI's Completley NATURAL ACTIONS..... We need to look INWARDS into our own HEARTS rather than "judge" and bring down GURU JI to our low levels. Dass jarnail Singh

Re: guru gobind singh - goat?

.... · 19 Jun 2004

Sorry just trying to understand this. Did Guru jee eat meat ? I heard stuff like this before ? Just want to know.

Re: guru gobind singh - goat?

kar kirpaa sabh rayN thheevaa · 19 Jun 2004

vaaheguroo jee kaa khaalsaa vaaheguroo jee kee fatehh !!! sadh sangat jee i know i am a kacha pilla and a lot more but definately i don't believe any fairy tales, and i was not trying to distort history nor do i have a lack of faith in guru jee i posted a few questions on the board - and this one was meant to be a question too but i forgot to phrase it that way i just wanted to know what the sangat thought of it that's all please forgive me for my mistakes - the dust of your feet

Re: guru gobind singh - goat?

Singhstah · 19 Jun 2004

If this is true(even though i highly doubt guroo ji would get tired) Guroo JI must have been giving the goat mukti.

Re: guru gobind singh - goat?

we · 19 Jun 2004

we dont eat for a reason GODD

Re: guru gobind singh - goat?

singh · 20 Jun 2004

McAuliffe also states that Goats were sacrificed in 1699 and that Guru Nanak Sahib cooked and consumed deer hunted by a Prince (devotee).

Re: guru gobind singh - goat?

khalistani · 20 Jun 2004

Vaheguru je ka khalsa, Vaheguru je ke fateh!! mcauliffes an liar end of story we gonna belive him or maryada and bani? bhula chuka maf Vaheguru je ka khalsa, Vaheguru je ke fateh!!

Re: guru gobind singh - goat?

uk singh · 21 Jun 2004

(mcauliffes an liar) would not go that far, he is one the greatest writers of Sikh history of our time. if you read his books, you will find that his work gives us a brilliant insight into the lives of our Guru Sahib. some may find the work a little controversial, but on the whole an excellent read and worthy of recommendation to anyone who wants to learn about Sikhi

Re: guru gobind singh - goat?

anon · 21 Jun 2004

macauliffe lied about dasam granth being kacchi bani. he also lied about guru eating meat.

Re: guru gobind singh - goat?

knows nothing · 21 Jun 2004

i don't think mcauliffe purposely did those things to hurt sikhi in fact he quit his job and worked for more than 20 years on his books and he died while reading jap ji sahib i think he cared about sikhs maybe he was just miseducated

Re: guru gobind singh - goat?

lakhvir singh · 22 Jun 2004

GuruFatehJi. KhalsaJi, Read as you may, but let your faith and trust in the Guru be your guide to truth. Don't believe anything from just anyone. That is why we have the guidance in our Guru Granth Sahib Ji and Sikh Rehat Maryada. GuruFatehJi. L*

Re: guru gobind singh - goat?

Balpreet Singh · 22 Jun 2004

Maccauliffe was a very good historian and did a great job writing Sikh history. But the thing is, he didn't witness any of it. The question arises: what is his source for this story? Why would Guru Sahib throw bones over the wall to begin with? It doesn't seem to make any sense to me. If someone could tell me another source for this story, I'd be very interested.

Re: guru gobind singh - goat?

uk singh · 23 Jun 2004

<<<>> Balpreet Singh Ji - The question arises, how much of Sikh History was written by the Sikhs? You will find that most if not all was written by non Sikhs, as we were constantly involved in tit for tat battles with Mughals and other unsavoury characters. If we rely solely on material written and witnessed in the same period of the Guru then you can forget most of the history written post Guru Gobind Singh Ji - as a reliable source. When writing on history the only way one can check their sources to be true is to cross reference with other material produced during or after the time by Scholars, Historians, Biographers and so on. You will also find that alot of historical facts are not properly documented. Verbal sources are often used by so called learned men, and these are passed from one generation to the next. Puratan Singhs used this form of information far more than we are led to believe. Ask any of the Nihangs and you will find this to be the case. Speak to Baba Nihal Singh Ji. MaCauliffe used many sources for his book, including Bhai Kahn Singh Nabha, Bhai Dit Singh, bahi Sardul Singh (Gyani of Harimandhar Sahib), Janamsakhis, Gyan Ratnawali. The list is endless.

Re: guru gobind singh - goat?

Balpreet Singh · 23 Jun 2004

Uksingh, fair enough. I agree with you for the most part. I'd be interested in knowing, at any rate, what other source mentions this story.

Re: guru gobind singh - goat?

goat! · 27 Jun 2004

Fateh! Did u say that guru ji ate a goat?????????? Because if that is true that is really odd! Guru ji is telling as not to eat meat and then why would guru ji eat himself!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! If you read this somewhere it totalty a lie!!!!!!!!! Guru ji never ate meat! If u where the one who said u read in a book what is your name?? I want your mane because it seems like a lie to me . And also show me the lier book u read that said guru ji ate meat! And which guru ji would do such a thing like that!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!