Re: Meat eating...
Kulbir Singh · 23 May 2003
I agree with Indy jee that Macauliffe was a genuine person who had great respect for Sikhi. I heard that he considered himself a Sikh. His books may contain some errors but those errors are unintentional.
Maybe we are mixing him up with Mcleod who is a Christian missionary and have written some not-good things about Sikhi.
Daas,
Kulbir Singh
Re: Meat eating...
Mr Rice Pudding · 26 May 2003
I have read the Sakhi and know meat doesn't equal Keer, I know Rice Pudding is Nice but that does not mean we need to add it to this Sakhi. Did the Pudding Fairy tell this version to you.
Your argument makes no sence, especialyy when we consider what Guru Nanak said to the Pundits at the festival about meat. No reliable Sakhi mentions the Rice Pudding, and the whole Sakhi would not make any sence, nor would the composition the Guru made at the time if he changed the dear into Kheer.
Re: Meat eating...
Kio Ehe Galaan? · 26 May 2003
Sat Sri Akal:
So, what has this post achieved? Let us see...tearing one Sikh from another...not bad...with arguements like this, who needs enemies.
Sangat Ji, follow the Rehat given to you by the Panj Pyare. Do paath, read Gurbani, ask Guru Sahib to give you the capacity to make the right decisions. Guru Sahib will take you in the right direction ultimately. Have faith in that, and Guru Sahib will guide you to whether meat is allowed or not.
Re: Meat eating...
Kulbir Singh · 28 May 2003
>>>>>>>>>>>
Bhagat Kabir says that those who consume bhang (marijuana), fish (machhali is also a name given to a kind of drug), or alcohol, will lose the benefit of practising, the holy rituals.
However, Gurbani repeatedly says there is no benefit at all of theeruthh buruth naem like actions.
In this hymn, the words, bhaa(n)g maashhulee suraa paan are used as a phrase (which does not mean these three specific things, but it means all vices), and refer to a vicious life in which people do not restrain themselves. Today, such persons are mentioned as shrabi-kwabi, i.e., living a vicious life.
>>>>>>>>>>>>>>
Bhaang does not mean marijuana but it means chicken and maachhali does not mean any drug as you have mentioned. The word “maachhali” appears many times in Gurbani and always means fish. Who does not know that machhali means fish? It is a common Punjabi/Hindi word.
This pankiti makes it clear that ones who eat chicken, fish (by indication this means all kind of meat) and drink liquor lose all their good deeds. You mention that such persons who lead sinful lives lose their good deeds.
Indy jee, think about it. If you understand the meaning of first pankiti to mean “Sinful” life then also consider that this sinful life is lived if you eat meat and drink sharaab (as mentioned in the pankiti).
In this pankiti if you think that Guru Sahib is not prohibiting meat, then if we go by your interpretation, we could also derive that Guru Sahib is not prohibiting liquor either. Is this correct?
The reality is that this pankiti and several other pankitis in Gurbani prove that eating meat is not good. If one is still stuck in proving meat to be right for Gursikhs, then such person is far from prema-bhagee of Guru Sahib.
Daas,
Kulbir Singh
Re: Meat eating...
Kulbir Singh · 28 May 2003
Indy, why don't you attempt to translate these pankitis? Please do it without the "Kala Afghana" twist.
Daas,
Kulbir Singh