Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Raagmala Crisis

Raagmala Crisis

Kulbir Singh · 19 Jun 2004

Looks like there will be a Raagmala debate in Panth again. Following the great book by Giani Gurdit Singh jee on the reality of Raagmala, the pro-Raagmala sections of Panth are not going to take it easy. Regarding Raagmala, our stand should not be what people we revere think. Panth should resolve this based on facts and not on sentiments. May Guru Sahib do kirpa on Panth. Daas, Kulbir Singh Takht Patna Sahib summons Vedanti Seeks clarification on book ‘Mundavani’ Varinder walia Tribune News Service Amritsar, June 19 In an unprecedented move in Sikh history, the Jathedar of Akal Takht, Giani Joginder Singh Vedanti, Giani Gurdit Singh, member of the SGPC’s Dharm Parchar Committee, and another Sikh scholar Mohan Singh Guard have been summoned at Takht Patna Sahib on July 20. They have been asked to personally clarify their position regarding the recent book “Mundawni”, authored by Giani Gurdit Singh . It is for the first time that the Jathedar of Akal Takht has been summoned by the Sikh clergy of another Takht . Though Jathedar Vedanti has taken a serious note of the step taken by ‘Panj Piyaras’ (five beloved ones) of Takht Patna Sahib and which could plunge the Panth into a deep crisis , he said he could personally visit Patna Sahib to give clarification on the book. Jathedar Vedanti said he had visited Takht Patna Sahib and Hazoor Sahib along with Giani Gurdit Singh, who studied the manuscripts of the holy Guru Granth Sahib in his presence. Talking to TNS, Jathedar Vedanti said he was shocked to learn about the move to summon him at Takht Patna Sahib, which had no precedent in Sikh history . He said Giani Gurdit Singh had simply documented the facts about “Raag Mala” and had not given any personal opinion on this issue. Similar views had already been given by the SGPC a long time ago. He said the Sikh clergy of Patna had no locus standi to take up such issues as it was the prerogative of Akal Takht only. The jurisdiction of Akal Takht and other Takhts had already been decided at the meeting of Sikh high priests, which was attended by Jathedar Iqbal Singh and Giani Rattan Singh , Jathedar and Deputy Jathedar of Takht Patna Sahib and Hazoor Sahib, respectively. While Akal Takht was declared supreme by all five jathedars, the other four Takhts were allowed to handle local issues Giani Iqbal Singh, Jathedar Patna Sahib, in a written directive, said the above decision was taken by the Sikh clergy at an emergency meeting held at Patna Sahib today. Meanwhile, Giani Gurdit Singh said the photographs in question are those taken by a local photographer from Patna Sahib in the presence of the author and others, including Granthi Iqbal Singh of Takht Sri Patna Sahib. “Itihaas Sri Guru Granth Sahib: Mundavani” is based on more than 50 years of research, and is the second in the series. The first, Itihaas Sri Guru Granth Sahib: Bhagat Bani Bhag was published in 1990 and is running in the second edition now. Both are research books and have been reportedly well received by scholars. Mundavani is profusely documented which photographs of manuscripts of Guru Granth Sahib that conclude at Mundavani. Bhai Mani Singh in his book, “Sikhan de Bhagat Maala,” has said that Mundavani is the seal that signifies conclusion. The book discusses Mundavani and examines various issues related to it. It is meant to increase the understanding of the Sikhs, and not cause and divisions, it was mentioned.

Re: Raagmala Crisis

khalistani · 20 Jun 2004

Vaheguru je ka khalsa, Vaheguru je ke fateh!! there are many books written by sant gurbachan singh je and other bhindranwale sants that can go head to head with these books and if u go to rara sahib, or pretty much most dehras like nanaksar, nihangs, they will also give proof to y raag maala is bani so it aint so easy to debate this raag maala issue bhula chuka maf Vaheguru je ka khalsa, Vaheguru je ke fateh!!

Re: Raagmala Crisis

uk singh · 20 Jun 2004

If they or any other research did come to the conclusion that Raagmala IS Gurbani, do we honestly believe this will change the views of the Jatha?

Re: Raagmala Crisis

Jarnail Singh Arshi Gyani · 20 Jun 2004

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh. Yes the situation does seem like what khalistanee veer says. The Guru Khalsa Panth has two opposing sides....On one side are the SANT/Mahapurash/Derawallahs ( IMMOVABLE PILLAR ...i.e. a PILLAR that NO FORCE can Bring down)...and on the other side we have the Academics, and Gianis,Jathebandies like AKJ ( the UNSTOPPABLE CANNON... i.e. a Cannonball so powerful that NOTHING can stand in its way..) So here we have the IMMOVABLE PILLAR that NOI force can bring down...standing before the UNSTOPPABLE CANNON that nothing can Stand up to it..??? Only GURU JI knows the answer to this riddle. Anyone can write as many books as they like and pass any hukmnamas they like...the other side is not going to move one mm. That has been the situation for so many decades already....now the only thing that has changed is that the Takhats OUTSIDE PUNJAB have begun flexing their muscles..and the only winners in this melee will be the Anti-Panth forces that want us all to knock off each other's dastaar.... Dass Jarnail Singh

Re: Raagmala Crisis

P Singh · 20 Jun 2004

From the book "Divine Mystic Reflections on Gurmat" by Sant Naranjan Singh Ji: Q: Please say something about Raag Mala's place in Gurbani. A: Sant Ji: Raag Mala is part of Gurbani. the original Kartarpur beed or Granth written by Guru Arjan Dev Ji and the other at the Dam Dama Sahib written by Guru Gobind Singh Ji both have Raag Mala in them. I have seen both volumes. The ink used and the writing of Raag Malaand the rest of the Gurbani is the same. My faith is that Raag Mala is authentic Bani and should be honored and given due respect as Bani.

Re: Raagmala Crisis

Singh · 20 Jun 2004

Maybe I'm wrong, but shouldn't we just ask our Guru.

Re: Raagmala Crisis

Rashminder Singh OZ · 20 Jun 2004

raag maalaa is a bani or not, lets leave it on panth.............. there are very strong proofs of declaring raagmaalaa not a baani of guru ji. what answers do all dera's and sampardaas have to the photographs in this book? obviously we want strong proof rather than saying " all the raags and raaginees we singing the praises of guru arjan dev ji at his door, he was about to seal the guru granth sahib ji, they ordered a sikh to open the door and saw all raags and raaginees singing his praises. guru ji became happy with them and gave them space in guru granth sahib ji" i am sick of listening this stanza from taksaali singhs and from different kathakaars of these sampardaas. i am not against any sampardaas or jathebandhi, only thing is i am interested in authenicity of raagmaalaa, if akj does try to prove that its not a baani, regardless of thier proofs most of the people say "they are not sikhs" bhul chul maaf Rashminder Singh OZ

Re: Raagmala Crisis

acadamia · 20 Jun 2004

"and on the other side we have the Academics, and Gianis" There are also academics and gianis that believe that ragmalla is gurbani, it is not as black and white as you are trying to imply.

Re: Raagmala Crisis

Mkhalsa · 20 Jun 2004

>>>Maybe I'm wrong, but shouldn't we just ask our Guru.<<< Exactly! Many gursikhs I know came to the conclusion that raag mala is not bani after asking guru sahib themselves. >>> the original Kartarpur beed or Granth written by Guru Arjan Dev Ji and the other at the Dam Dama Sahib written by Guru Gobind Singh Ji both have Raag Mala in them.<<<< Singh Jee, It is a well known fact that the whereabouts of the "original" birs written by guru sahib are unknown. If they existed in the public today, or even 100 years ago, there never would have been a debate. The gursikhs and scholars in forming the current SGPC rehat studied EVERYTHING, and had they found real puratan birs written by guru sahib, a decision would have been made a long time ago. These birs are copies of copies of copies and therefore entirely unreliable for such a debate. The fact that many puratan birs do not have raag mala (as proven by this book) and those that do, have it after kachi bani that has been removed by the panth such as rattan mala etc. >>>>do we honestly believe this will change the views of the Jatha?<<<< If Akal Takht Sahib were to decide today that raag mala is bani and it must be read, I will be the first to line up at an akhand patt and read it. Because akal takhts hukam is supreme, whether we disagree or not. We can ask akal takht for clarifications, modifications etc, but we still must follow hukam. I hope the same can be said by those who do beleive in raag mala, that they would stop their beleif if akal takht determines it is not bani, instead of following what sants, deras etc say.

Re: Raagmala Crisis

who cares · 20 Jun 2004

who cares. i dont think 99% of sikhs even read any of the 1429 pages in the Sri Guru Granth Sahin Ji anyways..lets worry about that and getting that fixed. Whatever Akal Takhat decides, we as sikhs should follow.

Re: Raagmala Crisis

Deep Singh · 21 Jun 2004

Well Giani Jarnail Singh Arshi ji, also some academics such as Bhai Veer Singh and Bhai Jodh Singh come to the conclusion that Raag Maala is Gurbani (at the end of their research). So the "fight" isn't just between Sants and Academics.

Re: Raagmala Crisis

Harpartap Singh · 21 Jun 2004

VahegurujikaKhalsa, VahegurujikiFateh! The original Aad Graqnth Sahib is still extant at Kartarpur and no one disputes its authenticity. Rasshminder Singh - you can get plenty of photograophs which show that the original saroop has Raag Maala. BUT this is not about how many photographs each side can present - it goes much deeper than that. All saroops were made from the original - logically the debate should centre around the original saroop - whether copyists OMITTED bani or added additional verses is a separate issue. Thanks to Kulbir Singh for raking this up again ;o) PS this has been said many times but is worth restating, if members of the Sangat are using 'Hukamnama's issued by the Akaal Takhat in support of their position, it is only logical that they follow them in all regards i.e. its stand on the Panj Kakkaars, vegetarianism etc etc. Akaal Takhat has already stated that Raag Maala HAS to be within a saroop of Guru Granth Sahib ji - reading it is optional so all Anti Guru ji's Raag Maala people should accept this Hukam as well. There is no need for further Hukamnaama's.

Re: Raagmala Crisis

uk singh · 21 Jun 2004

((((((PS this has been said many times but is worth restating, if members of the Sangat are using 'Hukamnama's issued by the Akaal Takhat in support of their position, it is only logical that they follow them in all regards i.e. its stand on the Panj Kakkaars, vegetarianism etc etc. Akaal Takhat has already stated that Raag Maala HAS to be within a saroop of Guru Granth Sahib ji - reading it is optional so all Anti Guru ji's Raag Maala people should accept this Hukam as well. There is no need for further Hukamnaama's.))))) thanks HS for clearing this up. Going by MKhalsas comment 'If Akal Takht Sahib were to decide today that raag mala is bani and it must be read, I will be the first to line up at an akhand patt and read it.' does this mean that he also believes in the Panthic Maryada that has been officialy published and endorsed by the Akal Takht for several decades or has he not read this?? and MKhalsa, why would you base your decision on wht Vedanti has to say?

Re: Raagmala Crisis

Mkhalsa · 21 Jun 2004

>>>The original Aad Graqnth Sahib is still extant at Kartarpur and no one disputes its authenticity. <<< Singh, I am going to copy and paste from previous useless arguments: >Author: Balpreet Singh Date: 10-07-03 15:59 The Kataarpuri BeeR we find today is not accepted as the Kartaarpuri beeR of the past. The description given by Bhai Kahn Singh Nabha in Mahaan Kosh does not match with what exists today. Many scholars don't think that the beeR there now is the original. Baba Aalaa Singh of Patiala had a copy made of the Kartaarpuri beeR and that copy does NOT have ragmala. It was in the Patiala Household last I heard. Please read any article on this issue for more details. I personally hate debating this topic since both sides are defending Guru Sahib's sanctity.< >>>PS this has been said many times but is worth restating, if members of the Sangat are using 'Hukamnama's issued by the Akaal Takhat in support of their position, it is only logical that they follow them in all regards i.e. its stand on the Panj Kakkaars, vegetarianism etc etc. Akaal Takhat has already stated that Raag Maala HAS to be within a saroop of Guru Granth Sahib ji - reading it is optional so all Anti Guru ji's Raag Maala people should accept this Hukam as well. There is no need for further Hukamnaama's.<<< This is an interesting new take that I have never seen before but is now being posted here and on akj.org but some dera dwellers. It makes me think that you feel insecure about raag mala being bani? why else would you now want akal takht to review it? If it is bani, then you should have full faith that akal takht will command everyone to read it, so you should be encouraging this. I have full faith akal takht will declare its not bani, because simply put, its not. Here is what I posted on AKJ.org in reply to you: Bhai Sahib, they didnt decide anything! The current SGPC maryada was meant to be a draft, and labelled as such, but it was never revised due to other conflicts etc, so SGPC just continued printing that and thats what we are stuck with. What the intention of SGPC saying not to print a bir without raag mala, is that until this debate is resolved, its better not to take it out. But if they resolved it, then they would have removed it. I am 100% confident the panth will find that it is not bani as it is not and I cannot accept it as such, and neither can many gursikhs who look at evidence, logic, history, and ASK GURU SAHIB!

Re: Raagmala Crisis

curious · 21 Jun 2004

is Takht Patna sahib abusing its authority and just trying to push its own jathedars personal agenda. As we see with many vioces in tha Panth are being silenced by these so-called jathedars, except the vioce of RSS, which is rampant in Punjab. They should be trying to stop the RSS, rather than relighting age old flames

Re: Raagmala Crisis

- · 21 Jun 2004

The Solution is simple. The Jathedars show which 'Saroopp' they found ending with 'mundavani' From the 34 old saroops of Patna Sahib

Re: Raagmala Crisis

Daas · 21 Jun 2004

Ask the NAAM Abiyasis joths Singhs about it, if you can find one. They will tell you all about it, whether Raag Mala is Bani or not. Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh has wrote so many things i.e amrit naam ras, dasam duar, anhad bani, sachkhand, face of Guru Gobind Singh, naam and naami in so much detail, that no one academic till now has ever or can ever challenged his writings, as he has not made any reference when he wrote those amolak books, all reference were from his anbevi link with sachkhand. So sikho, naam abiyass kero, te juth ke kero. Forget about everything that revolves around you, as we don't know anything much about our bani, our Guru's etc. You will find all the answer when you reach the right state. And when that state comes, raag mala authenticy will be known by yourself. Guru ji gave us the gafa of Naam, use it well and all the answers will be given by the MASTER. No need to wait for the wars with jathehs and academics.

Re: Raagmala Crisis

khalistani · 21 Jun 2004

Vaheguru je ka khalsa, vaheguru je ke fateh!! veer je, brahm gianis like sant baba nand singh je, sant baba ishar singh je, well all of nanaksar sants, all of rara sahib wale sants, all of damdami taksal sants, all of nihang brahm gianis, they all belive in raag maala so, bhai sahib wasnt the only great soul who had an opinion on raag maala bhula chuka maf Vaheguru je ka khalsa, vaheguru je ke fateh!!

Re: Raagmala Crisis

Harpartap Singh · 22 Jun 2004

VahegurujikaKhalsa, VahegurujikiFateh! Daas bhaji made a very good post :o) Vaheguru, Vaheguru, Vaheguru...

Re: Raagmala Crisis

Singh · 22 Jun 2004

Clergy to discuss summoning of Vedanti Tribune News Service Amritsar, June 21 The Sikh clergy are likely to discuss the issue of summoning Giani Joginder Singh Vedanti at Patna Sahib. However, Giani Iqbal Singh and Giani Rattan Singh, Jathedar and Deputy Jathedar of Takht Patna Sahib and Hazoor Sahib, respectively, may not be invited for the discussion. It is after a long gap that the Jathedars of both Patna Sahib and Hazoor Sahib Takhts have started attending the meetings of Sikh high priests at Akal Takht. Earlier, the declarination of Mr Mohinder Singh Romana as ‘tankhaiya’ had created an unsavoury situation which was resolved following a lot of efforts. The high priests had decided that Akal Takht being the supreme Takht, it was authorised to handle the matters pertaining to the Sikh community and the other Takhts were authorised to take up local matters . It was also decided that the right of excommunicating a Sikh would be with Akal Takht only . Dr Gurbachan Singh Bachan, former SGPC secretary and leader of the Sikh Watch Group, took a strong view of summoning of Jathedar Vedanti at Takht Patna Sahib. He said though the jurisdiction of Akal Takht and the other Takhts was decided by the Sikh clergy to which Giani Iqbal Singh and Giani Rattan Singh were party, the Sikh intellectuals should come forward to decide the role of Jathedars at the earliest. He said authority of the Jathedar of Akal Takht being the supreme leader of the Sikh community could not be challenged. Though Jathedar Vedanti had announced that being an authority on manuscripts, he was ready to give his opinion by visiting Takht Patna Sahib, but there was no question of his appearing before the Sikh clergy there. The Sikh clergy of Patna Sahib had directed that if Giani Gurdit Singh, noted Sikh scholar, failed to appear before Takht Patna Sahib on July 20 to submit a clarification on his controversial book ‘Mundavni’ along with his two associates (including Giani Joginder Singh Vedanti), stern action would be taken against them as per the Sikh maryada.

Re: Raagmala Crisis

Raagmala PIC · 22 Jun 2004

A Bir from Maharaj Ranjit Singhs own scribes, is in the National Museum Delhi, it also has Raag Mala in it.

Re: Raagmala Crisis

Mr. Singh · 22 Jun 2004

>>>>>>veer je, brahm gianis like sant baba nand singh je, sant baba ishar singh je, well all of nanaksar sants, all of rara sahib wale sants, all of damdami taksal sants, all of nihang brahm gianis, they all belive in raag maala so, bhai sahib wasnt the only great soul who had an opinion on raag maala bhula chuka maf >>>>>> My logic. Their is one truth. So therefore a brahmgiani would know what the truth is...because if they didn't they wouldn't be brahmgiani. This begs the question... how can all the people that Khalistani veerji has mentioned be Brahmgiani's when it is known that their rehit's differ greatly and they have different maryada's that they follow. I mean a Brahmgiani would follow guru's rehit. Guru rehit is one ... there are no variations but these sants all have different rehit maryada that they follow. Please explain???? I have heard that Baba Gurbachan Singh ji has translated Raag mala. If someone wants to put up the translation on the message board we can all discuss it. We won't actually be debating raag mala just the translation that is done. so i think it would be a safe thing to do as long as the discussion has an academic tone.

Re: Raagmala Crisis

yeah · 22 Jun 2004

I agree with veer khalistani.

Re: Raagmala Crisis

Harpartap Singh · 22 Jun 2004

VahegurujikaKhalsa, VahegurujikiFateh! 'Mr. Singh' - the translation is available but this thread is not supposedly about Raag Maala itself. I doubt if many posts would be allowed if that were the case. I have the translation as pictures in a MS Word document but don't know how this could be put here - or even if it should? I think that is up to Admin

Re: Raagmala Crisis

Harpartap Singh · 22 Jun 2004

VahegurujikaKhalsa, VahegurujikiFateh! Going back to the topic - apparently Gurdit Singh has given photographs of manuscripts of some 'Beerhs' of Guru Granth Sahib Ji. According to him, 'Bhog' of the 'Beerhs' is on 'Mundaavani'. On the other hand, there are 34 old 'saroop' of Guru Granth Sahib in Takht Sri Harmandir Sahib, Patna Sahib. All the 'Beerhs' have the Raagmala. Gurdit Singh was accompanied by Giani Joginder Singh Vedaanti when he had 'Darshan' of those 'Beerhs'. He claimed that some of these Beerhs, in which 'Bhog' is on 'Mundaavani', are there in Takht Patna Sahib. Now, The 'Panj Piyare' of Takht Sri Harmandir Sahib, Patna Sahib has asked the author to tell which 'Beerhs' have the 'Bhog' on Mundaavani. So based on this Gurdit Singh and Giani Joginder Singh should go to Patna Sahib, and tell the 'Panth' where are those 'Beerhs'. The fact is that all the 34 'Beerhs' kept in Takht Sri Harmandir Sahib, Patna Sahib have the Ragmala according to the authorities of that Takhat. If Gurdit Singh has lied, he should be given hard punishment. Giani Joginder Singh has not been summoned as 'Jathedar' of Sri Akal Takht Sahib. His photographs have been given in Gurdit Singh's book. Giani Joginder Singh should appear before the Takht Patna Sahib as a Sikh, not as a Jathedar of Sri Akal Takht Sahib. He was not the Jathedar of Sri Akal Takht Sahib, when those photographs were taken.

Re: Raagmala Crisis

Mkhalsa · 22 Jun 2004

>>>If Gurdit Singh has lied, he should be given hard punishment. <<<< Pictures dont lie. Singh, I suggest you actually read the book before even discussing it further. Until you discuss this with an open mind and actually look at the issue, you will not come to a truthful conclusion on your own, you will just beleive what others say. This is the problem we have, everyone is following others. We follow other humans around like they are our gurus and listen to them and their opinions as gospel. And no, akhand keertani jatha is not exempt from this either.

Re: Raagmala Crisis

Dogma · 22 Jun 2004

Admins.. ..I believe it was Akal Takht's hukam that the issue of Raagmala NOT be discussed in any forum. Us moorakhs will not reach a conclusion for the Panth. Please close this thread.

Re: Raagmala Crisis

Admin · 22 Jun 2004

Although we are not aware of any such hukam that ragmala cannot be debated, we are of the opinion that debating this issue using old arguments etc. is of no use. Unless someone has some revolutionarily new information to present, this thread is closed.