Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

PESH PESH PESH !!!!!!!

PESH PESH PESH !!!!!!!

kulpreetsingh · 19 May 2003

VAAHEGUROOJEEKAAKHAALSAA !!!! VAAHEGUROOJEEKEEFATHEH !!!!!!! "laykhay kathhai na chhooteeai khin khin bhoolanhaar bakshanhaar bakhsh lai nanak paariothaar" (warning padchedd romanization may not be 100% correct) "by our accounts, we may never be liberated over, and over, we are forgetful and sinful oh great forgive, grant your forgiveness servant nanak begs, ferry me across (this world ocean)" ________________________________________________ What are the advantages / reasons / supports for doing PESHI (confession, repentance) in front of the Punj Pyare for all breaks of rehit, not just the kurehits ? and part 2 - please answer this under the heading part 2 - what is the difference between PESHI in Sikhi, and repentance or confession in Christianity? Is it the same idea? I will post my humble opinion later - please sangat do your kirpaa and provide your thoughts as related to gurmat. VAAHEGUROOJEEKAAKHAALSAA !!! VAAHEGUROOJEEKEEFATHEH !!!!!!!!!!!!!

Re: PESH PESH PESH !!!!!!!

Indy · 20 May 2003

Going Pesh seems like all the rage these days. Unless one of the major sins have been committed, I see no reason to confess any minor infrigments of rehat. Allegedly, even Bibian (AKJ) who have given birth need to go Pesh. This is some new fangled thinking of modern day Sikhs, who must be influenced by Brahministic attitudes. Guru Nanak openly chides those who attribute pollution to women because of menstruation and asserts that pollution lies in the heart and mind of the person and not in the cosmic process of birth. "If pollution attaches to birth, then pollution is everywhere (for birth is universal). Cow-dung (used for purifying the kitchen floor by Hindus) and firewood breed maggots; Not one grain of corn is without life; Water itself is a living substance, imparting life to all vegetation. How can we then believe in pollution, when pollution inheres within staples? Says Nanak, pollution is not washed away by purificatory rituals; Pollution is removed by true knowledge alone". (Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji, 472). Are we to follow the teachings of our Guru or the laws of Manu??

Re: PESH PESH PESH !!!!!!!

Kulbir Singh · 20 May 2003

>>>>> Allegedly, even Bibian (AKJ) who have given birth need to go Pesh. This is some new fangled thinking of modern day Sikhs, who must be influenced by Brahministic attitudes. Guru Nanak openly chides those who attribute pollution to women because of menstruation and asserts that pollution lies in the heart and mind of the person and not in the cosmic process of birth. "If pollution attaches to birth, then pollution is everywhere (for birth is universal). >>>>>>>>>> Please try to understand here Indy. Before you jump to conclusions on what AKJ women do or other women do, you should find out the facts. After giving birth only those women go pesh (in all jathas) who have had their operation done. Even men who get operation done on their body and if kesh are removed from their body, they get pesh. Even Jathedar Tohra, who is SGPC got pesh at Takhat Keshgarh Sahib after getting an operation done on himself. No Sikh woman gets pesh at amrit sinchaar for pollution reasons. All your quotes of baani are not relevant here as they pertain to the sootak practice of Hindus. The other reason for getting pesh ofter childbirth is to get amrit for the new born child. This practice too is in all jathas. Hopefully this will clear the misunderstandings you have about AKJ. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: PESH PESH PESH !!!!!!!

kulpreetsingh · 21 May 2003

umm.. hanjee... so could we get back to the question *humbly* VAAHEGUROOJEEKAAKHAALSAA VAAHEGUROOJEEKEEFATHEH !!!

Re: PESH PESH PESH !!!!!!!

keeraa · 21 May 2003

PART I: We make so many mistakes, over and over again, mistake after mistake after mistake. KHIN KHIN BHOOLANHAAR. Now, I could sit here and say "I forgive myself", but, who cares if *I* forgive myself?? When you've made a mistake and your friends get upset with you, do they forgive you just because YOU forgive yourself?? Highly unlikely. Whether we forgive ourselves or not is irrelevant because we can't judge how badly we've hurt Guru Jee through our actions. We have to ASK him to forgive us. We can't ferry ourselves across the world ocean -- only Guru Jee can carry us across. We can't wipe the slate clean ourselves -- only Guru Jee can. Guru Sahib is The Great Forgiver. Our own forgiveness is worth nothing. Now the question arises: should we get peshed for even "small" violations of rehit etc. (ie. anything that isn't a bujjar kurehit). I would say YES, by all means, YES!!! Why? Because all the "small" things add up. Can we honestly afford to have "small" mistakes unresolved on our account? If we seriously want to get ferried across the world ocean, then it is imperative that we free ourselves of any extra "baggage" (unforgiven mistakes) that might cause us to drown and land us back on the shores of this hell. Who can afford the risk of having the burden of unresolved affairs and outstanding accounts weighing them down?? Besides, how do we know what constitutes a "small" mistake?? Are we so intelligent that we can judge how big or small Guru Jee would consider our mistakes AND we can absolve ourselves of these mistakes as well?? I don't see why getting peshed is considered only for after committing a bujjar kurehit. Are only bujjar kurehits serious mistakes and the plethora of other mistakes we make are acceptable? Should we feel okay with ourselves after screwing up on a smaller scale and we shouldn't feel the need to beg Punj Pyaaray to forgive us? But how do we know what people are getting peshed for?? We may assume some are getting peshed just because "it's all the rage these days" and people may even tell others that this is why they're getting peshed, but what do we know of what is really being confessed inside?? Anyways, any violation of rehit seems pretty big to me. Even THINKING of violating it seems pretty big. I believe we should seek pardon from Guru Jee via Punj Pyaaray even if our mistake is relatively "small". Punj Pyaaray, as Guru Jee's form, are much better suited to decide how big or small our mistakes are and what we should do to correct them. We may think we'll be forgiven after a simple quickie ardaas, but Punj Pyaaray may feel you should do x number of this baani and x number times of that baani for x number of months... I think that often, we look for the easy way out and convince ourselves that we don't need to come to Punj Pyaaray. We may want to save face by not having to stand before the Punj to admit our mistakes for fear of the shame, embarrassment etc., or we want to get off the hook with only a quick ardaas instead of having to do what the Punj Pyaaray give us hukam to do. If we find our humility, I think we would realize that humbly seeking pardon from Punj Pyaaray is essential. PART II: I don't believe that getting peshed before Punj Pyaaray is ANYTHING like repentance/confession in Christianity. Christians seek pardon from a single priest who will judge things in accordance with his/her own lowly level of wisdom. Christians go through this "confession" under the cloak of anonymity, if I understand it correctly, and there is nothing binding them to follow the priest's suggestion/advice/"punishment". In Sikhi, on the other hand, a Sikh must present him/herself humbly before the Punj Pyaaray -- no hiding behind a box, no curtain of separation, no sliding door to disappear behind. Just a Sikh standing before the Punj Pyaaray wrapped in the cloak of humility, begging for forgiveness. Punj Pyaaray are the very embodiment of the Guru, so one is not being forgiven by a mere priest, but by the Guru himself in the form of five tyaar-bar-tyaar Gursikhs. It's like going to the very source of the forgiveness instead of having an agent in the middle. Whatever the Punj Pyaaray decide is not open for a Sikh to choose to obey or not -- it is Hukam and a Sikh is bound to it. If a priest forgives a confessing Christian, then the priest has forgiven; if Punj Pyaaray forgive a Sikh, then Guru Sahib has forgiven. Big difference. BAKHSHANHAAR, BAKHSH LAI

Re: PESH PESH PESH !!!!!!!

Jasbir Kaur Khalsa · 23 May 2003

vaheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Vaheguru Ji Ke fateh Women who give birth get pesh so their child can also have naam and amrit inside them from birth. At the end of the day...no one knows when they will pass away. The reason a sin is confessed to the panj piyarai is because Guru ji said where there are 5 tiyaay bar tiyaar singhs that's where he is...so the panj piyarai should be regarded as guru gobind singh ji himself. bolaa chuka maaf vaheguru ji ka khalsa vaheguru ji ke fateh

Re: PESH PESH PESH !!!!!!!

Indy · 25 May 2003

Kulbir Singh Ji wrote 'After giving birth only those women go pesh (in all jathas) who have had their operation done' Are we referring to a c-section here? Jasbir Kaur Khalsa Ji - Do these Bibian need to go Pesh for a Natural birth as well? Is it true that the men also have to turn up with the bibian. I'm just not comfortable with Sikhs going pesh for minute slip-ups or indiscretions in their Rehat. Unless hair have been removed during the process of birth their is no need to go pesh. Do the men accompany?

Re: PESH PESH PESH !!!!!!!

surgery · 25 May 2003

waheguru jee ka khalsa waheguru jee ki fateh! "indy" jee, hair does require removal in either c-section and in most cases in natural birth..im sure that is the only reason women who have given birth would go get pesh. I dont know how familiar you are with birth and the operating room, i suggest you do a search and read up on it..i dont think my posting it on this site would be appropriate. many mistakes, bhul chuk muaf. [%sig%]

Re: PESH PESH PESH !!!!!!!

rs · 25 May 2003

I don't see why people get so worked up about others getting pesh. It might be a small mistake in your mind, but maybe to them it isn't. It all depends on one's experience and perspective. If you're prone to making mistakes in your rehit, then most things will seem small. But to someone who doesn't, even a minor slip up will be big. I remember someone giving the example of a white sheet. If the sheet is dirty to begin with, any new spots on it won't seem like a big deal. But if the sheet is very clean, even a small spot will seem like a lot. Why not let the Panj decide? If they don't think it's a big deal, they'll tell the person. And getting pesh doesn't mean shukking amrit. It just means you go talk to the panj. I read in some taksal maryada somewhere that completely removing your kaschera requires peshee and a choola or something (they said accidental or temporary removal of other kakkars could be dealt with by an ardaas, but not the kascheraa). I laughed at this and thought this was just insane. But after a couple of years of keeping my kakkars on, I realize the significance of this and it doesn't seem like just a small thing anymore. I remember when I had a mess up in my rehit. It seemed like a really big deal to me (and still does), although some people might not consider it so. At first I decided ardaas would be good enough. I didn't really feel like facing the panj piarey. But I couldn't get over it. I could forgive myself, maybe vaahiguru would hear my ardaas and forgive me, or maybe not, who knows. But, when I received amrit, I gave my head to the panth khalsa as well. I basically swore an oath to the panth. And now I felt I'd broken this oath. Even though I'd asked Vaahiguru for forgiveness, I still felt I had to face the representatives of the Guru Khalsa and ask them for forgiveness for having a 'breach of contract' with the panth. I'm glad I did. It wasn't just 'forgiveness', I was able to discuss my problem with the guru roop panj and get priceless advice on how to deal with whatever issues I was having. And nothing can beat having the blessings of the guru roop panj. Another point is, if it's okay for me to bug vaahiguru with my ardaas all the time, why isn't it okay for me to appear before the panj? If they are willing to see me and let me confess whatever I need to, then why does anybody else care? It's between me and my guru. As far as women going after child birth, as Kulbir Singh and Jasbir Kaur already said, they go if they had surgery (with removal of hair) or to get their child a choola. If they are going to get the child a choola, then I assume 'the men would accompany' ie, the child's father.