Re: capital punishment in sikhi
Jarnail Singh Arshi Gyani · 05 Jul 2004
Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh.
Lets get Khalistan first... then we will discuss this....and a sarbat khalsa will decide.
One of the ways the GOI sidetracked the Kharkoo Lehr was getting its agents among the kharkoos to start "implementing" such practises as "rehat maryada", no dowry, no large janj, no show off weddings etc....and these agents went overboard...and the common people started to go against the kharkoo lehrr..... the main aim of the GOi was to SEPARATE the Common man from the Kharkoos and then get the kharkoos eliminated.....and we all know this happened soon after.
Dass Jarnail Singh
Re: capital punishment in sikhi
Jarnail Singh Arshi Gyani · 05 Jul 2004
Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh.
It is futile to look for "death sentence" ( physical death) to a criminal in GURBANI.
The GURU SAHIBAANS are way above...let us just have a look at the KHALSA RAAJ of Maharaja Ranjit Singh Ji. All historians are united in writing that Mahraja's Raaj was one of the most FAIR and JUST. Not a single criminal was given the death sentence during the decades of Maharaja's lifetime. Some like the Diwan of MULTAN who rebelled again and again agianst the Maharaja, and was defeated by the Sikh forces at great loss of life....BUT once the Diwan BEGGED FORGIVENESS - he was instantly PARDONED by the Mahraja even though this happened more than a DOZEN times.....and each time he was pardoned and given back his Diwanship....he would rebell and the Maharaja would defeat him and restore him back. Now this may seem a little bit "foolish" or self defeating but it underlines that fact that a True Sikh always beleives in GURBANI...Na KO beri nahin Begana...that is one may HATE the SIN but NEVER the SINNER.
It is historically correct to say that our GURUS fought against TYRANNY and INJUSTICE......not against Muslims/ Hindu Hill-Rajas per se. GURU HARGOBIND Ji fought FOUR wars and were Victorious in all FOUR aginst very heavy odds...but not a single Arrow was fired in ANGER or REVENGE. It is jsut a hsitorical fact that the Opressors and tyrants happened to be Muslim Rulers....ALL fair minded muslims like Sain Meean Meer, Bhikhan Shah Ji, Pir Budhu Shah Ji, hundreds of others more common men fought and died on the side of the GURUS against their own religious bigots. There is no historical basis and no fact that supports the theory that any GURU JI ever punished anyone to DEATH or even put anyone in JAIL for any crime.
Personally I find it hard to swallow that Divine Pita Ji Guru Gobind Singh Ji the Epitome of Fatherly LOVE would roast/FRY masands in oil...this is a TYPICAL MOGHUL TORTURE which was perpetrated on GURU ARJUN SAHIB JEE, Bhai Dyala Ji and many other Sikhs. GURU JI NEVER FIRED a shot in Anger or Revenge....even in Full BATTLE GURU JI would give a loud CRY and let the enemy have the FIRST BLOW or SHOT.....Guru Ji NEVER shot anyone in the BACK either or otherwise took advantage and kill with a disdavntage to the enemy....so how come GURU JI did not even give a Chance for these Masands to REPENT...dont tell me NOT a SINGLE MASAND begged for MERCY ?? abd if they DID BEG FOR MERCY !! then GURU JI comes across a heartless cheap revenge taker for tying up defenceless "criminals" and frying them to death in such a horrible style....how can cries of mercy not touch GURU JI's HEART which bleeds for whole Humanity !!!...... anyway that is what I personally beleive about My beloved Guru Ji and every single line of Gurbani backs me up. I for sure would like to beleive that GURU Ji will definitely hear the cries of mercy from a paapii like myself and save me from Dharam Raaj when the time comes.
dass jarnail Singh