Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Broken Amrit?

Broken Amrit?

r2d2 · 28 May 2003

I have a simple question, although I'm not sure it will get posted because of it's sensitive nature. I know of someone who is amritdhari and he did bajjar kurahit with another amritdhari girl. These two people WANT to get married and expect to get married but as of yet are not engaged. Nor do the parents know of the relationship. The argument given by him was that he was going to marry this girl so having physical relationship does not break amrit because it's with his wife-to-be. MY arguement was that no one knows what the future holds and that Sikhi (i think) says that sex before marriage is completely wrong. Does he still have his amrit intact? My opinion is no. I know that this is a very bluntly worded post, and I know the nature of it is a little bit taboo. But please think about posting it as I would like some input on how to HELP this person. I don't want to crucify him, I want to HELP him. Please offer any Gurbani thukhs, Rehitnama quotes that back the position that sex before marriage is wrong and also any solutions on what they should do now.. Thank you.

Re: Broken Amrit?

Balpreet Singh · 28 May 2003

No matter if two people want to get married, or are engaged to be married or any other situation, any physical relations outside of marriage are strictly forbidden in Gurmat and are considered a bujjer kurehit. This is not something even open to debate as all Sikhs believe this is a kurehit. Your friends should appear before the punj pyaaray and admit their mistake. The punj pyaaray will then handle their situation in the best possible way.

Re: Broken Amrit?

(^_^) · 28 May 2003

This seems like a discussion that a certain confused Kaur would post and has on akj.org. I'm not convinced of the validity of these questions myself. r2d2, what do you hope to achive from these replies? It is blatantly obvious according to the Panthic Rehat Maryada that physical relations and keeping chaste before marriage is prohibited.

Re: Broken Amrit?

reow · 28 May 2003

i think r2d2 was simply asking how to HELP them, so i think balpreet singh's response is best: tell your friends to appear before the punj pyaaray and they will take it from there.

Re: Broken Amrit?

r2d2 · 28 May 2003

dear (^_^), I'm not here to stir up debate and this is not a 'fake' post. I honestly know of a situation like this and I would like to council this person further. I'm in the same opinion as you that what they have done is wrong. BUT, I was unaware if they should take amrit AGAIN or is they should simply get pesh OR if there is some other punishment. Also, I would like to scare them. I know that sounds bad, but it's true. I would like to instill a fear in them so that they will not do such things again. I'm sorry if my post seemed fake..I assure you it is not.

Re: Broken Amrit?

Aae Mil · 02 Jun 2003

The question raised was what to do in the case where a person has very likely committed a bujjer kurehit and continues to apparently violate gurmat while refusing to go before Punj Pyaray for forgiveness. And what should be done if this person is active in the community?

Re: Broken Amrit?

Balpreet Singh · 03 Jun 2003

I think you should personally go speak with this person about getting peshed along with others who share your views, and if s/he is doing wrong parchaar and having a bad effect on the community and still refuses to appear before Punj Pyaaray, then they should not be dealt with and attempts should be made to limit their involvement in the community as well.