Re: I am in disgrace
Aslo was in disgrace · 29 May 2003
A similiar incident happened to me.
Their was this idiot nihang guy from England he came to my university and he was saying good things during the group discussion but afterwards it was my friend and myself and these nihung guys and they went on about stupid stuff. I refuted them but not strongly enough. Should have beat them up etc.
IN any case don't feel too bad just try to learn from the mistake and make sure you are prepared next time such an incident occurs.
Even little incidents like these where we take a stand can have tremendously positive results
Re: I am in disgrace
Kulbir Singh · 29 May 2003
There are some times when we falter from taking the Gurmat stand especially when we are faced by a majority. Some times it is prudent to not argue because we can be certain that no one is interested in our opinion. At other times it is imperative that a Singh alone should take a stand and not worry about the consequences.
I just remembered a historical incident that should inspire us. When the two younger Sahibzaaday (princes/sons) of Guru Gobind Singh jee Maharaaj were arrested by Suba Sirhind, they were asked many questions. At one point, the Suba (ruler) of Sirhind got convinced that he should not kill two innocent children and should let them go.
Sensing that the Suba would let the Sahibzaaday go free, Sucha Nand asked the them what they would do if they get released. I think it was Baba Fateh Singh jee who responded very fearlessly saying that if they are set free, they will gather singhs and fight the tyranny of Mughals. Baba jee and other Sahibzaaday like their uncle Baba Attal jee were pooran Brahmgiyaanis. They did not have any fear. They did not try to mince words. They just told them the truth.
Taking lead from Babajees a Singh if required should take the Gurmat stand even if it means facing up the majority.
At other times, taking into consideration the Gurmat principle of not arguing with the foolish (Moorakhai naal naa loojhiye), a Gursikh should shy away from debates with the foolish.
Coming back to the original posting by "no name", I personally think that he/she should have taken the stand and spoken in favour of Dastaar in RCMP. By the same token, "no name" should not feel too much bad about it now and in the future or even next class she or he can bring up the issue again and say very politely and confidently that in the last class a question was raised by Mr so and so, and that you don't agree with him. Then go ahead and tell them why. It is as simple as that.
Daas,
Kulbir Singh
Re: I am in disgrace
Ardaas Karo · 29 May 2003
Sat Sri Akal:
Most of us are only human (Guru Di Kirapa, we may become more enlightened). Everyone has regrets like this. Do an ardaas and request that Guru Sahib give you the strength and wisdom to be able to defend the Panth in the future.
To shy away from useless arguements is good...but engage in discussions that you feel are worthwhile. It is the only way that ignorance can be dispelled. Remember that Guru Nanak Sahib also went all around the world discussing many things to grant his opponents a wider view of the universe.