Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Raag Mala file

Raag Mala file

skaur · 28 May 2003

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa, Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh! What happened to the file about Raag Mala under the Gurmat section? I really need a copy of it, so if someone could tell me another website that has it or send me a copy, I would appreciate it. Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa, Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh!

Re: Raag Mala file

keeraa · 28 May 2003

bhain jee, perhaps you should try opening it again. it seems fine to me. it's pdf format. i don't think it's anywhere else. it's a tapoban.org exclusive ;)

Re: Raag Mala file

Sarbloh Badman · 29 May 2003

LOL! guess what actually it isnt a tapoban exclusive....because a few months ago i was reading this and my uncle said "hey hold on a minute i helped madan singh type this up in english!!!!!" ...its a small world lol

Re: Raag Mala file

keeraa · 29 May 2003

nice my bad thanks for the correction small world indeed :)

Re: Raag Mala file

Tarsem SIngh · 29 May 2003

you should adress it as bhai madan singh ji and he will be in canada on july 1st stayin in oakville

Re: Raag Mala file

Sarbloh Badman · 30 May 2003

lol i am in uk, and bhai madan singh is a family friend. however since all my family are anti ragmalla and i am the only pro, id rather not stir up controversy lol

Re: Raag Mala file

Manjit Singh · 30 May 2003

Some kids donot keep up the good thing of their family.

Re: Raag Mala file

Sarbloh Badman · 31 May 2003

lol manjit singh ji before making such a judgement please read hte ragmalla article on the fauj.3giga site. my family believe keski but before i believed in keski i did the research, my family believe in many other things, but i do not blindly follow no matter what, i make sure in my own mind i am on the most direct path to guruji. wjkk wjkf

Re: Raag Mala file

Mkhalsa · 01 Jun 2003

Dear Sarbloh Badman jeeo, The Singh in california have recently edited that article again and again. Originally there were many lies and untruths in it. THIS WAS NOT at the fault of the author. He is an amazing singh and sevadaar. He was just mislead on a few topics. I am not sure if all the corrections are up, but many untruths about bhai randhir singh and other things about the history of raag mala, kavi alam etc are being removed or have been removed. I hope this was not your only research as I wouldnt beleive that article. We cannot blame the singh who made this site, his only concern is some sort of ekta in the panth, and if you read the site you will notice that he tries to agree with every group and find a common ground. I think that is an amazing seva of his.

Re: Raag Mala file

Admin · 01 Jun 2003

We are unable to approve messages that debate Raagmala. At this time it is not in our (Panth's) interest to debate issues such as this. What our panth needs at this time is Bhagtee. Let us discuss Baani and post inspirational messages.

Re: Raag Mala file

Sarbloh Badman · 02 Jun 2003

If you cant talk about it how can u find the truth!!!!!! Akal Takht stopped discussion on Dasam Granth and I was left thinking it was not gurus bani till I heard Bhindranwales Katha on it!!!!!!!

Re: Raag Mala file

Admin · 02 Jun 2003

Sarbloh Badman, Our stand on Ragmala is very clear. We don't consider it to be baani of Guru Sahib and we have a long analysis of this baani's authenticity in the "Gurmat" section. This article has been written by Bhai Sahib Madan Singh jee of England. Please refer to that for our opinion on it. As for the ones who read Ragmala, we don't have any issue or problem with them. Debate on Ragmala has been done hundreds of times on the net and it leads to no conclusion. The fate of Ragmala can be decided at panthik level only. If after reading the Gurmat section, you still have any questions please email us at [address removed] and we will be glad to answer your questions.