Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

broadcast rights being inforced in gurdwara during kirtan

broadcast rights being inforced in gurdwara during kirtan

sikh · 05 Aug 2004

this august there will be taking place an atam ras kirtan darbar at various gurdwara here in the uk. http://www.atamraskirtan.com/ at the bottom left of the poster is a message in red against a balck background stating that no recordings of either a vdeo or audio nature can take place? can these people really enforce these rules? i very often make either audio or video recording for my own pleasure so that i may listen to the kirtan sometime later in the future and i will sometimes make copies (free) for other members of the sangat. what should i do take my video camera with me on the day to make my recording or not go at all, in view that some jumped up 'organiser' will give me a hard time? can sangat please advise

Re: broadcast rights being inforced in gurdwara during kirtan

.................... · 05 Aug 2004

Please go to the below link to get the answer, Read GSGHKS posts http://forums.waheguroo.com/index.php?act=ST&f=2&t=6006&s=48c8af6ca5ec329e4d7578585bc31a01

Re: broadcast rights being inforced in gurdwara during kirtan

:@@: · 05 Aug 2004

how the hell can you sell rights of kirtan being performed in a gurdwara? just go and record bro

Re: broadcast rights being inforced in gurdwara during kirtan

.................... · 05 Aug 2004

Please read the link, They will provided free CDs and Download from the net after the Kirtan. The whole thing is that they don't want everyone bringing camera, as this will not allow the sangat to listen to the kirtan with they heart. Please read the LINK. CDs A DOWNLOADs will be FREE

Re: broadcast rights being inforced in gurdwara during kirtan

singh · 10 Aug 2004

i wouldn't believe everything you read. it does not state which kirtans will be recorded.

Re: broadcast rights being inforced in gurdwara during kirtan

singheee laad · 10 Aug 2004

Waheguru ji Ka khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh!! This is being disguised as not disturbing the keertan with cameras etc but rellay it is about ETC enforcing contractual agreements. We have had a similiar issue with ETC here in the UK. They are not very keen to film/show keertan unless they exclusive rights to it. Arrangments can be made so that video cameras do not disturb the sangat, at the april smaagam this year one side was given to video cameras that didt interfere with sangat. Also individual mics stands were not allowed. On a seperate point i think this whole "AtamRas" thing is wrong, and what an inappropriate name!!! Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh!!

Re: broadcast rights being inforced in gurdwara during kirtan

sikh · 10 Aug 2004

singheee laad i totally agree with you and unfortunately i think the people at GSGHKS don't see the potential problems of signing exclusive rights deals with companies such as etc, and anyway how can you have 'rights deals' on gurbani? the people at GSGHKS i feel are more interested in bringing over the best kirtanees, regardless of what these actual kirtanees represent! e.g some of these kirtanees will go and do kirtan where ever regardless of what there host or pay master may believe in! soem of these kirtannes have doen kirtan programs for various cult groups which are not apart of mainstream sikhi my advice to sangat is: if your taking your video camera please be mindful of other sangat and try not to disturb. and do not let anybody tell you can't record, they got no rights.........!

Re: broadcast rights being inforced in gurdwara during kirtan

Singhz · 10 Aug 2004

Gurfateh I have just spoken to ETC who are filming this Atam Ras event... and i am shocked that they have said that it was agreed with the organisers of this event that no person would be able to record as ETC will be given full copyright of the event and it was in a signed agreement. That is pure Byadbee of Gurbani, who are we to Copyright GURBANI ... the organisers really need to think twice before falling at the feet of these big corparations who just make profit from these type of events, anyone can phone ETC and discuss this issue with them, they said it is no secret and that when their air the event on their video station later this year they will say its copyright to ETC. So thats the real reason that the don't want anyone recording at the event, it will jepordise their contract with ETC and they could be liable... morrakhs!!!!

Re: broadcast rights being inforced in gurdwara during kirtan

sikh · 10 Aug 2004

just proves the GSGHKS spokes person charanpreet singh has been lying...! which is what i thought all along and he has led the people on the sikhsangat a merry dance, saying it was not copyrighted to etc.....

Re: broadcast rights being inforced in gurdwara during kirtan

sikh · 10 Aug 2004

if anybody visits the sikhsangat forum can they inform the sangat there what is happening, the post seems to have gone dead due to them being satisfied that etc did not have any rights on the kirtan.......which obviously not the case well done Singhz for finding this out link to post is - http://forums.waheguroo.com/index.php?act=ST&f=2&t=6006&s=48c8af6ca5ec329e4d7578585bc31a01

Re: broadcast rights being inforced in gurdwara during kirtan

lakhvir singh · 11 Aug 2004

GuruFatehJi. KhalsaJi, I would lead a peaceful demo at the venue and let the Sangat know what is happening. Do these people know that the organisers are trying to negotiate the Guru for maya??? If you do not stand up for it now, soon this will become an everyday thing, like the tables and chairs issue. Please, do something. Get off the dicussion and get down to action. Make some noise for the Guru, please!! How can one contract the Guru? Ridiculous!! That is manmat!!! GuruFatehJi. L*

Re: broadcast rights being inforced in gurdwara during kirtan

sikh · 11 Aug 2004

how amazing that the people from GSGHKS have suddenly gone quiet........ this really is a disgusting affair which shows have the sangat have been duped by thoughtless Sikhs

Re: broadcast rights being inforced in gurdwara during kirtan

MS · 11 Aug 2004

I have two fundamental problems with this. Fristly with regards to the recordings, it has been mentioned by charanpreet singh that the no one else will be doing recording for benefit of sangat for obvious reasons. however I ask will the person who is doing the recordings be the same individual who often shows is rear end to guroo sahib or to the sangat and cant keep still for more than 5 seconds, will it be the same singh that has a flash light so bring it gives one a tan! will it be the singh that puts his camera and ligh in a way that it blocks the STTM projector AND is not only a distraction to the kirtanee but to the sangat too. is this the same person that zooms into every single person in the sangat so far that we can see up their noses. I home im wrong but if im not given the above do u really think your argument can really stand up to that. also the gurdwara sahibs sound system is pretty, how can i say this, pathetic really. SECONDLY which is my major fundamental point is that this program is nothing more than a glorified bramical rock concert. i seriously hope im wrong but from looking at the sites, all the pics, the promotons "chill with the sant jee" etc.. it really seems like if you pump up their egos any more that they might explode! the difference between jatha programs and ones like this is that they are fundamentally engineered and based on a FAN BASE and nothing more than a FANISM rock concert type program. Im totally open to the possiblity that im wrong here charanpreet singh so plz entertain this moorakh and prove me as such as the implications of me being wright are just too too pathetic. i realize that SOME ppl do come because of the kirtanee, however use ur brains, is this really right, and should u be using that as a basis to exploit ur program, is this really progression i.e. improvement! im also dissapointed in the various jathas that they do not realize this themselves let alone the various other ppl trying to make a name for themselves

Re: broadcast rights being inforced in gurdwara during kirtan

sikh · 13 Aug 2004

i am sorry but i do not believe a word that GSGHKS or any of the other organisers say, in my opinion i think they are just hiding behind this 'disturbing sangat' excuse, as they probably relaised the mistakes they have made for signing these agreements, only way any faith or trust can be restored by the organisers is if they say people can record. dont believe a word u read or hear there is only one truth Dhan Dhan Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji

Re: broadcast rights being inforced in gurdwara during kirtan

Charanpreet Singh · 13 Aug 2004

Waheguru Ji No we havent signed anything that says that ETC have exclusive rights nor have we sold the rights. AS we are paying for ETC to come and film. The rights will be ours, and will be used for the benefit of the sangat The kirtan will be recorded for all 17 days, audio will be downloadable free of charge from www.atamraskirtan.com after the event. and dvds will be made afterwards which will be availabable to the sangat, all proceeds will go to the next programme in 2006 As stated on sikh sangat we are taking this measure to reduce the disruption if people in canada and singapore dont have problems with this then why do you? If anyone has concerns then please ring me 077 939 76746 Etc state that they have rights but they do not for this programme as it is in our agreement that their payment will be split in 2 ways 50% for the two cameramen that will be coming and the other 50% once the dvds arrive. And for everyones information no one has copyrighted gurbani

Re: broadcast rights being inforced in gurdwara during kirtan

UkSingh · 13 Aug 2004

that's great all it takes is communication and clarification thanks for clearign up matters